Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people are very quick to forget the pandemic

304 replies

BelleMarionette · 12/03/2023 19:19

Myself, and other junior doctors, worked hard on the covid wards, in appalling conditions. We didn't have decent PPE, and often had little to no relevant experience or training, as many were redeployed with little notice (in my case, 36 hours). Almost all of of us became sick, some very seriously so, and some even died. Many more were left struggling with our own mental health, suffering from PTSD, anxiety and depression.

We are now striking, due to pay erosion over the past 15 years. In real terms its around a 30% pay cut. It's difficult to live on what we are be being paid, especially with families to support.

I have seen an awful lot of negative comments about junior doctors on another thread. Aibu to think the public has been very quick to forget our contribution during the pandemic?

I would dearly love to be wrong and see support

OP posts:
Crikeyalmighty · 13/03/2023 22:45

For those saying about other workers, yes supermarket workers did a brilliant job in keeping things ticking over as did many other workers and I know most people are very aware of this, but health workers were in a pretty unique position (and I include care workers in this too) of having to deal with very sick people of all ages and horrendous emotional stresses of no family around , conversations on iPad , large amounts of things not normally seen such as ventilation , far more deaths in hospital than normally dealt with- that's a unique situation and I find it offensive that people speak in such a derogatory way on here. I'm not a health worker/medic - but I did 18 months nursing training in the 80s and the few deaths I witnessed played on my mind for weeks - I can only imagine going in day in and out under these circumstances.

Tandora · 13/03/2023 22:33

BelleMarionette · 13/03/2023 22:10

There is a very clear definition: a bed without a patent.

All our beds were full. First with covid patients, then with medical patients as the covid patients lessened. There was a constant juggling act of converting wards to covid wards, then back again to medical wards.

Clearly you don't have a source, but are relying on the testimony of 'a friend'.

Once again, the NHS was open throughout covid. Hospital beds were never empty.

a bed without a patient
well, for example , I recently gave birth and was kept on labour delivery on the grounds there were no “beds” in postnatal. When I was finally moved there were rooms full of empty beds with no patients.
presumably , the issue was the lack of staff to manage them..?
I have many times been in hospital and witnessed the presence of beds with no patients in them, so either your initial statement is wrong, or the definition isn’t as clear as you make out.
I’m not denying your experience at your particular hospital.
I know my friend’s experience , because I was there, and he is a close friend. It is also the experience of many , many other healthcare professionals.
The reasons are clear. Health services were shut down / cancelled and directed to the pandemic, yet there were extensive periods of time during the pandemic when Covid cases were very low. Do you deny this is the case? It is also the case that people stopped attending hospitals etc , partly out of fear and partly because they believed they would be turned away. Do you deny this too?

BelleMarionette · 13/03/2023 22:10

Tandora · 13/03/2023 21:56

It depends how you define “empty beds” doesn’t it.

One of my closest friends is a doctor who was working on Covid wards throughout the pandemic. For much of the time through the pandemic and lockdown , it was the least busy time of his career, he regularly left work several hours early because there was nothing to do- his normal experience is having to stay extra hours- never copping off early like he could then.

I have been told the same from paramedics, ER staff, from paediatricians. People were afraid to call ambulances or turn up to hospital. Meanwhile, There were many many months during lockdowns, where Covid cases were very low, but other health services remained closed.

There is a very clear definition: a bed without a patent.

All our beds were full. First with covid patients, then with medical patients as the covid patients lessened. There was a constant juggling act of converting wards to covid wards, then back again to medical wards.

Clearly you don't have a source, but are relying on the testimony of 'a friend'.

Once again, the NHS was open throughout covid. Hospital beds were never empty.

OP posts:
Tandora · 13/03/2023 21:56

BelleMarionette · 13/03/2023 20:05

Can you provide any source for these wild claims?

We never had any empty beds whatsoever. As patients died, their beds were filled straight away. As the number of covid patients fell, the wards were turned back into general medical wards. This happened overnight in many cases. The NHS simply does not have the capacity for empty beds.

It depends how you define “empty beds” doesn’t it.

One of my closest friends is a doctor who was working on Covid wards throughout the pandemic. For much of the time through the pandemic and lockdown , it was the least busy time of his career, he regularly left work several hours early because there was nothing to do- his normal experience is having to stay extra hours- never copping off early like he could then.

I have been told the same from paramedics, ER staff, from paediatricians. People were afraid to call ambulances or turn up to hospital. Meanwhile, There were many many months during lockdowns, where Covid cases were very low, but other health services remained closed.

30swith3 · 13/03/2023 20:24

Unfortunately the NHS seems to be massively mismanaged, and too many people don’t acknowledge this when talking about the money it gets or ‘needs’. My partner works in the NHS, and have heard first hand of the poor management including costs. The people at the very top need to focus on all the necessities first, paying better for frontline, better systems that are mirrored across trusts etc. NHS appears to pay astronomical costs in long term sick pay (not all will be genuine), mutual agreements & roles that should come after the frontline and day to day management is efficient and effective.

It also cannot be denied that our economy would not be in the state it’s in if we hadn’t shut it down for covid and paid furlough. That’s not rocket science and sadly we’re all paying the price now - which was always obvious.

If we’d protected the vulnerable and allowed everyone else to support the economy we’d no doubt be in better shape.

BelleMarionette · 13/03/2023 20:05

Tandora · 13/03/2023 17:15

That’s not true though. Entire hospital were turned into Covid wards, and then for months and months of the pandemic there were only a handful of patients, meanwhile so much else had been cancelled in preparation- hospital planners massively overshot in their projections for a huge proportion of the pandemic This is not conspiracy, it’s what happened.

Can you provide any source for these wild claims?

We never had any empty beds whatsoever. As patients died, their beds were filled straight away. As the number of covid patients fell, the wards were turned back into general medical wards. This happened overnight in many cases. The NHS simply does not have the capacity for empty beds.

OP posts:
Emma2023 · 13/03/2023 19:52

Theluggage15 · 12/03/2023 19:55

Loads of people did difficult jobs for less praise and less pay and with less protection. Care workers for one.And many people in the NHS weren’t working in covid wards anyway. Stop putting yourself above everyone else.

This!! If you deserve a rise then so do lots of people- I don’t remember shop workers choreographing tik tok dances or getting clapped on a Thursday night 🤷🏼‍♀️

Toothfairy88 · 13/03/2023 19:50

As a nurse myself working in appalling conditions in the NHS, I for one support junior doctors wholeheartedly!! My mental health is in the toilet, directly due to my working conditions. This country is a shambles

brews · 13/03/2023 18:23

I fully support the junior Doctors strike action and believe you should all get paid a great deal more. Thank you for your service 🙏.

flumposie · 13/03/2023 18:18

I support you. I will never forget the treatment of some sectors by the government and people in general.

Lifedonttalktomeaboutlife · 13/03/2023 18:06

I support you.

I refused to clap during the pandemic because it felt like such an empty gesture. Instead I followed all the rules and generally tried to avoid catching/spreading covid (like a mug considering what the gov was up to).

I wonder what proportion of clappers aren’t supportive now. Hypocrites.

5128gap · 13/03/2023 18:01

Yes they have. The fear and drama of covid are in the past and people are now more worried about their cancelled operations.
I support you fully but I think trying to ride public sympathy for your covid contribution is not a winning pitch.
Your pay is unfair, your conditions are appalling and unless those things change, the public are at risk from staffing shortages in our hospitals.
Your support depends on the public understanding the risk to them. When people are struggling financially themselves, it's a hard sell, and you need to appeal to their self interest not hope for their gratitude.

NalafromtheLionKing · 13/03/2023 17:45

YANBU.

Like many others, I really didn’t appreciate just what you have to go through as a junior doctor until I read Adam Kay’s ‘This is Going to Hurt’. Even the parking meter earns more than you and you had to work really hard to get the best grades before putting in 5/6 years of medical school followed by ridiculous levels of responsibility and seriously punishing working hours.

If junior doctors (and nurses) aren’t paid more, no-one will agree to do the job, at least not in the U.K. (Australia OTOH is doing everything it can to poach you all). We are then all screwed.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 13/03/2023 17:31

I support you and everyone else who is striking or who cannot strike.

This government is running the NHS and the country into the ground while lining their own pockets and looking after their cronies. Imagine if all the money wasted on useless PPE contracts, apps that didn't work, test and trace was spent on improving the NHS?

Tandora · 13/03/2023 17:15

BelleMarionette · 13/03/2023 16:42

Did you go onto the covid wards? Of course not, as they didn't allow visitors. Empty outpatient clinics (because doctors are redeployed onto the wards) are not representative. To say that hospitals were empty is just misinformation spread by certain tabloids and conspiracy theorists.

That’s not true though. Entire hospital were turned into Covid wards, and then for months and months of the pandemic there were only a handful of patients, meanwhile so much else had been cancelled in preparation- hospital planners massively overshot in their projections for a huge proportion of the pandemic This is not conspiracy, it’s what happened.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 13/03/2023 17:00

I support the junior doctors strike.

The starting salary is, shit, for the training, experience and working conditions. You can get similar in a graduate (3 year degree) job that doesn't require the personal expenses (from moving frequently, from student debt, from paying for exams, from out of hours childcare) or personal sacrifices (relationship breakdowns, PTSD from covid etc)

The fact that they 'knew that before they got a job' doesn't negate the fact it's a. Still shit and b. Objectively (in real terms salary etc, understanding levels etc etc) getting worse.

And that doesnt mean that other jobs dont deserve more money as well. But the people doing the profession are leaving because the pay doesnt make up for the shit conditions. The NHS can either sort out the conditions (which isn't going to happen) or sort out salary...but doing nothing will cause staff to vote with their feet.

Judijudi · 13/03/2023 16:59

I support you!
and I currently have Covid so I’ve definitely not forgotten the pandemic

Theluggage15 · 13/03/2023 16:56

BelleMarionette · 13/03/2023 13:19

You are misinterpreting this. Childcare out of hours (weekends, nights, evenings and early mornings) is so much more expensive, as nurseries and childminders are closed. The only option is a nanny. It's very expensive to source, and finding a reliable person is very difficult.

The parking fees for hospital staff are also prohibitive, not uncommonly around £100/month. Everyone I know in the private sector has free parking.

The constant moving around, or travelling large distances, is also exhausting and very expensive.

Are you actually just trolling now? Yes of course only NHS staff do shift work don’t they? no one else has childcare issues!

Everyone I know in the private sector pays for their parking, if it’s free it’s considered a benefit in kind and taxed. £100 per month is a bargain. A fiver per day over 20 days. You’re totally out of touch.

BelleMarionette · 13/03/2023 16:42

Tandora · 13/03/2023 15:43

This is absolutely not universally characteristic of the health system during much of the pandemic. It’s just false. We all saw the empty hospitals and health centres. We are not daft. One of my closest friends is a doctor who was working on Covid wards , he was busy for a few weeks, then for months on end said it was the least hard he’d ever needed to work in his career. He copped off at 3pm most days there was so little to do.

Did you go onto the covid wards? Of course not, as they didn't allow visitors. Empty outpatient clinics (because doctors are redeployed onto the wards) are not representative. To say that hospitals were empty is just misinformation spread by certain tabloids and conspiracy theorists.

OP posts:
JenniferBooth · 13/03/2023 15:54

Has anyone else noticed the spectacular own goal by the BMJ If they wanted to drum up support for the doctors strikes it would have been prudent not to minimize the sacrifices and suffering much of the public went through because of the lockdowns

www.bmj.com/content/380/bmj.p588

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4759256-no-real-mental-health-crisis-from-pandemic?page=1

Tandora · 13/03/2023 15:43

BelleMarionette · 13/03/2023 13:06

Do you believe in conspiracy theories?

Hospitals were not empty. We increased our capacity by over 100% in medicine. Every spare space was made into a ward. Our ITU capacity was increased by 300%.

We worked 70 hour weeks on covid wards, and worked bloody hard in appalling conditions.

And no, we didn't have adequate PPE either. That is another misconception that was spread. I helped to intubate a covid positive patient with only a surgical mask, telling older colleagues who wanted to help not to come in as they were more at risk, should they contract covid.

This is absolutely not universally characteristic of the health system during much of the pandemic. It’s just false. We all saw the empty hospitals and health centres. We are not daft. One of my closest friends is a doctor who was working on Covid wards , he was busy for a few weeks, then for months on end said it was the least hard he’d ever needed to work in his career. He copped off at 3pm most days there was so little to do.

BelleMarionette · 13/03/2023 13:19

Theluggage15 · 13/03/2023 07:13

That’s such a typically arrogant comment. We have to pay for parking and childcare blah blah. Yes like millions of other people. So out of touch and sneering at everyone else.

You are misinterpreting this. Childcare out of hours (weekends, nights, evenings and early mornings) is so much more expensive, as nurseries and childminders are closed. The only option is a nanny. It's very expensive to source, and finding a reliable person is very difficult.

The parking fees for hospital staff are also prohibitive, not uncommonly around £100/month. Everyone I know in the private sector has free parking.

The constant moving around, or travelling large distances, is also exhausting and very expensive.

OP posts:
BelleMarionette · 13/03/2023 13:14

Igmum · 13/03/2023 13:10

Thank you for all you and your colleagues are doing OP. I support the strike - how heartbreaking you have been pushed into this. Good luck

Thank you for this and all the other supportive messages.

OP posts:
Igmum · 13/03/2023 13:10

Thank you for all you and your colleagues are doing OP. I support the strike - how heartbreaking you have been pushed into this. Good luck

BelleMarionette · 13/03/2023 13:06

Forfrigz · 13/03/2023 07:17

Other than the properly furloughed, medical staff on the whole were probably the most pampered of all during the pandemic. First access to and best PPE, empty hospitals, and now everyone had to battle for a face to face appointment as phone calls are replacing them, to the pantients' detriment.

Do you believe in conspiracy theories?

Hospitals were not empty. We increased our capacity by over 100% in medicine. Every spare space was made into a ward. Our ITU capacity was increased by 300%.

We worked 70 hour weeks on covid wards, and worked bloody hard in appalling conditions.

And no, we didn't have adequate PPE either. That is another misconception that was spread. I helped to intubate a covid positive patient with only a surgical mask, telling older colleagues who wanted to help not to come in as they were more at risk, should they contract covid.

OP posts: