Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To evict my tenants

254 replies

Landlordbyaccident · 12/03/2023 15:35

Name change due to personal info possibly given.

I brought my first home in my 20’s and quickly paid off the mortgage on a 2 up, 2 down terrace in Birmingham. Nothing special and it always needed a new kitchen. I invested very little money in this house as I was so unhappy there.

I brought my current home in 2018 and we are paying a manageable mortgage although other outgoings has become a strain in the current financial climate. We owe around £75k on a house worth around £250 (not sure if this is relevant). My previous house has been rented out to a friends friend for around 2 years before this it remained empty.

They are paying £475 per month, other rentals in the area go for around £800. Some months they pay late or come up short. I know they are struggling. They are from a Caribbean island so I am not sure what benefits they are entitled to to help them.

Anyway my husband would like to ‘evict’ them. Ideally I would like them to increase the rent and remain in the house as they are no trouble and really nice people. I am going to be transparent in saying the house could do with some work being carried out but they never complain as I assume it’s because I am in a position of power and they fear I would evict them if I do.

After writing this I am not sure what I am asking? Would I be heartless in evicting them (goes against my core values) or raising their rent ? Should I just continue with the current contract and seek to cut costs in other areas.

what would you do?

OP posts:
ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 12/03/2023 17:37

yoghurtflavours · 12/03/2023 17:02

The vast majority of landlords provide overpriced, undermaintained homes for people who are too scared to speak up. Just because you provide somebody with a home, doesn't automatically make you a good or ethical person.

And if the tenants don't like it they can jog on. Find someplace better at a lower price, and good luck with that.

WilsonMilson · 12/03/2023 17:35

You won’t get a balanced view on mumsnet, as for some reason it’s very pro tenant and anti landlord.

For me it’s quite simple, you’re not running a charity here, you’re running a business and you need to think of it that way.

An important factor is how much the property is worth in its current state, that will enable anyone to work out what the rental should be, ie what sort of yield you will have on your investment. Ie, if it’s worth 200k and you get 6k a year rent, that is a 3% yield. At the moment you could get a higher rate of interest with that money in the bank in a fixed rate bond. That is because bank interest rates are currently high. Usually you would try to aim for at least a 6% yield on your property.

I am of the opinion that good long term tenants are worth their weight in gold, so I wouldn’t knee jerk to evict just yet, but not paying the rent cannot continue.

If you evict these tenants you will have to spend money on the property to rent it out again. That may be worth it if you can achieve a much higher rent.

If you sell you may have capital gains tax to pay, so take that into account.

I think you need to take emotions out of this and make the decision that’s best for you.

sqirrelfriends · 12/03/2023 17:34

IMO, you should try to bring it closer to market rate but still keep it fair if they’re good tenants.

Good ones can be hard to come by and I could never deal of the stress of a bad one.

PuzzledObserver · 12/03/2023 17:33

@yoghurtflavours

Landlords - like tenants - vary massively. I was a landlord for 13 years, while we lived in job-related accommodation.

We sold our barn conversion and bought a new build, so as to have a house which was in good condition and easily maintainable, rather than an older property with significant maintenance needs.

We used a fully managed service, and all faults reported by the tenant were fixed.

We had a total of five tenants. Two were fine - kept the property clean and tidy and paid the rent on time. Three defaulted on the rent (just stopped paying) and were eventually evicted after due process. One of those basically trashed the place and left owing us 6 months rent, plus we had to refurbish and pay the legal costs.

A few times there were negotiations over rent at renewal time, we usually ended up accepting a lower increase than the agent suggested in return for a longer contract. The rent at the end was barely any higher than at the start.

We eventually sold the house to the last tenant, who has been in it for 8 years. The fact we were negotiating the sale did not prevent us replacing the boiler when it failed.

So for 13 years we provided a comfortable well-maintained home to five families who needed one - three of which didn’t keep their end of the bargain by actually paying the rent.

But yeah, all landlords are the scum of the earth.

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 12/03/2023 17:32

Sshiamreading · 12/03/2023 17:31

I don’t know statistics on this but most flats I’ve stayed in (about 12 in total) were indeed overpriced and under maintained. The exceptions were mainly when I had a live-in landlord. Funny that, people will always make sure their own living space is nice and comfortable.

I stated in one quite nice flat in London years ago and when it came to renew the yearly contract I asked for the mould problem to be looked at as my incoming flatmate said she was asthmatic the landlord got annoyed and said I was always asking him to fix things ( the other two times the washing machine had broken down) so he decided not to renew the contract and I had to find somewhere else with little notice

Totally anecdotal and irrelevant then.

GoAgainstNicki · 12/03/2023 17:32

They are from a Caribbean island so I am not sure what benefits they are entitled to to help them.

What does this have to do with anything? If you want to evict them then just evict them. If they know their rights they may say they’re not going anywhere without a section 21 notice anyway

Sshiamreading · 12/03/2023 17:31

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 12/03/2023 17:11

Well that’s clearly not true. The “vast majority”? Source?

I don’t know statistics on this but most flats I’ve stayed in (about 12 in total) were indeed overpriced and under maintained. The exceptions were mainly when I had a live-in landlord. Funny that, people will always make sure their own living space is nice and comfortable.

I stated in one quite nice flat in London years ago and when it came to renew the yearly contract I asked for the mould problem to be looked at as my incoming flatmate said she was asthmatic the landlord got annoyed and said I was always asking him to fix things ( the other two times the washing machine had broken down) so he decided not to renew the contract and I had to find somewhere else with little notice

Shelefttheweb · 12/03/2023 17:31

Landlordbyaccident · 12/03/2023 15:49

@welshdaisy

This was the initial plan, however due to a number of reasons I never put it on the market. Now I think it’s better to sell it in the future when my children need help with university and mortgages.

You are paying interest on your mortgage, think carefully whether appreciation of asset value minus depreciation would actually be higher than your mortgage interest.

WhereYouLeftIt · 12/03/2023 17:30

Landlordbyaccident · 12/03/2023 16:59

There is a lot of misconceptions.

The first one is that I can’t comprehend basic English!

Followed by those who are assuming that the house is a complete wreck and needs lots of work. There has been suggestions that it is inhabitable and needs £1000s spending on it.
This is not the case. It will benefit from a new boiler but this is all. The boiler is in working order. The tenants have never complained about the kitchen or front door. These are things which I had always planned on replacing.

I am not sure whether stating I have no choice but to accept the rent from the tenant is fair. LLs raise rents all the time. If I did do this, I would not charge market value although despite assumptions made I would get it. It’s in a nice enough area where homes are of short supply.

The homes which have a rent of £800 are very similar to mine. It would not have been helpful to make comparisons with homes which are of a much higher standard. It’s not rocket science to look at what’s on the market for rent and compare the rent of these houses to the rent, type and condition of mine.

I think I will increase the rent and I am aware of the risks associated with this such as losing good tenants, a long court case and or difficult future tenants.

Thanks all for those who have responded and if there are any other grammatical mistakes in my posts I can live with it!

"My previous house has been rented out to a friends friend for around 2 years before this it remained empty.

They are paying £475 per month, other rentals in the area go for around £800. Some months they pay late or come up short. I know they are struggling."

OP, do you feel restricted by the fact that your tenants are friends with a friend of yours? Do you feel that 'connection' might be why they "pay late or come up short"? And when they pay late or underpay - what do you do? Have you discussed this with them? How do you know they're struggling? Are they telling you, or your mutual friend?

Sorry, bit of a 20 questions, but I suspect you'd have acted differently if this connection didn't exist.

Justforlaffs · 12/03/2023 17:30

yoghurtflavours · 12/03/2023 17:14

@Justforlaffs As I already said back on page 3, we want tenants to be able to live in properly-maintained properties, at a fair rent, with much more heavily regulated landlords who are made to do their jobs properly. The current system has a huge imbalance of power, with tenants scared to speak up for fear of revenge eviction. The OP has even acknowledged this, yet still wants to increase the rent apparently without fixing anything. It's shitty to become a landlord in the current climate when landlords have far more rights than tenants.

So you are not a landlord then? You haven’t the first clue what you’re talking about.

It currently takes around 18 months to evict a tenant - even if they haven’t been paying rent during this time. I’m not sure where you get the idea that the law is on the landlords side?

Do you understand the first thing about why LL’s are getting out in droves, causing rents to spiral massively - partly to do with the many arbitrary rules brought in along with the staggering rise in interest rates and it simply not being a viable option for most people to own a couple of rental properties any more.

With the enormous shortage in social housing and ZERO plans for building any where near enough in the future, I ask you again:

If all the smallerLL’s get out of the buy to let market (news flash: it’s happening now!) where will people like the Op’s tenants live??

There is a national housing shortage. Where are people going to live?

Do you and people like salmon think that the people who manage, for instance, Asda are scum because they are profiting from selling food to people?

If not, why not?

PixieLaLa · 12/03/2023 17:30

I am going to be transparent in saying the house could do with some work being carried out but they never complain as I assume it’s because I am in a position of power and they fear I would evict them if I do

Wow very telling sentence here. You have been taking advantage of people in need by not paying for work to be carried out knowing they won’t speak up and now you want to kick them out to get more money. Are you planning on paying for these repairs? Or just going to find another desperate family willing to pay the rent to live in this state?

aloris · 12/03/2023 17:26

Unfortunately you have gotten yourself into a bit of a pickle by charging so far below market rate that you are unable to fund the upkeep of the property from the rental income. I think that the longer you allow that to continue, the farther you will fall behind with maintenance, until you may have difficulty keeping the unit in sufficiently good condition as to be legal for tenancy. I understand why people think that "landlords are scum" but the reality is that rents need to be set so that upkeep of the property can be performed on a reasonable basis. If you need to go into debt you can't afford to do necessary maintenance like replacing the boiler (which you may not have to do today but sounds like you will have to do fairly soon and how will you fund that?), then you have probably set the rent too low.

For those who think landlords are scum, it may be helpful to remember that if someone owns their own home, they have to replace their broken boiler themselves, with all the cost that entails. It's not on the landlord to gift you a free boiler out of the goodness of his/her heart. The way it works is that the cost of the boiler goes into your rent, either on the front end or the back end.

Sshiamreading · 12/03/2023 17:24

Mummyoflittledragon · 12/03/2023 16:30

I should have added, I have a long term tenant, who can only just about pay his rent by himself. He split up from his wife maybe 5 years ago and I agreed for him to stay on even though he failed credit checks by a few pounds and left the rental amount the same. He’s been a tenant for maybe 7 years now and didn’t increase in all that time.

His ds is working now and has been for a while. In that time, I’ve redecorated and changed the bathroom. The kitchen was brand new. I paid for a week in a furnished apartment for the work to be carried out, which cost the same as a months rent. Until a couple of weeks ago that meant he was paying £255 below market rent. I increased it by £105, which equates to 15% below market rent. A dad and his ds in his 20s should be able to work that rental amount out imo.

He is from a Western African country and travels home for a month every year. I decided in the end, his need to travel home shouldn’t impinge on my right to charge a rental figure, which represents the current situation. If rents decrease 10% or even 15%, he still won’t be paying over the odds.

This seems like a reasonable approach.

OP, I feel you shouldn’t be asking for the full market value of £800 until it’s refurbished.

How many adults are in the house and do they work? I’m wondering why they’re struggling to pay £470 between them.

BearLeft · 12/03/2023 17:22

Nowhere for £475 pcm. But typical market rent is considerably higher than monthly mortgage payments. Which makes saving for a deposit nigh on impossible. If you’re from a nice seaside place in Devon (for example), even if mum and dad stumped up a deposit for you, all the property has been swallowed up by second home owners. The OP isn’t a social landlord. The LHA rate for a two bed in Brum is about £630 pcm. It is reasonable that she charges that. As long as the state of repairs isn’t below standard.

Btjdkfnn · 12/03/2023 17:22

I would hand the entire situation over to a letting agent and tell the tenants that this is the plan.

Market rent, formal contract, all money collected by letting agent. Letting agent will of course take a fee, but all this nonsense will then be out of your hands.

If repairs are needed, tenants tell letting agent and letting agent arranges it and charges you.

Fair to all.

FlowerArranger · 12/03/2023 17:21

TheGoogleMum · 12/03/2023 17:13

I think you should just sell it, you'll probably get enough to pay off the rest of your current mortgage and then it won't matter about not having money for repairs

"Just sell it"? It's not that simple.

The market for selling rental properties with tenants in situ is very difficult at the moment. She could try, but many existing landlords are selling up, and this is unlikely to change any time soon.

If she wanted to sell with vacant possession, see my post above. It would almost certainly be a long drawn out and expensive process.

yoghurtflavours · 12/03/2023 17:19

Being anti-landlord doesn't mean we want them to all disappear. It means we want more rights for tenants, and we want more people to take our side during disputes. The tenancy deposit scheme was one major piece of progress but it's just the beginning, we need way more protection.

Justforlaffs · 12/03/2023 17:18

Yes, why would you 'evict' if not causing any problems?

Because if they can’t afford to pay the rent that op needs to charge in line with her costs, why in earth would she keep them as tenants?

Im presuming Op isn’t doing this for shits & giggles?

It’s a business the same as any other.

Increase the rent op, giving them sufficient notice. If they can’t afford it you will need to serve a section 21. As nice as you sound, it isn’t your job to house people at the detriment to yourself.

FatimaHatima · 12/03/2023 17:16

Landlordbyaccident · 12/03/2023 15:45

@FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks

Thanks. I definitely brought it!

From where?

yoghurtflavours · 12/03/2023 17:14

@Justforlaffs As I already said back on page 3, we want tenants to be able to live in properly-maintained properties, at a fair rent, with much more heavily regulated landlords who are made to do their jobs properly. The current system has a huge imbalance of power, with tenants scared to speak up for fear of revenge eviction. The OP has even acknowledged this, yet still wants to increase the rent apparently without fixing anything. It's shitty to become a landlord in the current climate when landlords have far more rights than tenants.

TheGoogleMum · 12/03/2023 17:13

I think you should just sell it, you'll probably get enough to pay off the rest of your current mortgage and then it won't matter about not having money for repairs

HikingforScenery · 12/03/2023 17:12

HollyFern1110 · 12/03/2023 16:32

Unless it's in a very rough area, £475 does seem cheap for a privately rented 2 bed house in Birmingham.

You say it needs a new boiler, kitchen & front door - but are these more wants than needs? If so, maybe increase the rent half way between the current rent & market value and use the extra money to complete the work?

Anyone legally living & working in the UK should be able to get help with housing costs shouldn't they?

Many people have to have been living here for over 5years before they can get help from the govt

viques · 12/03/2023 17:12

Landlordbyaccident · 12/03/2023 15:45

@FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks

Thanks. I definitely brought it!

You bought it. Unless you moved your house from one location to another in which case yes, you brought it from a former location to its present location.

If you bought your present house five years ago you have had five years worth of rental income , which even allowing for landlords insurance, appliance testing and registration, and tax paid on the income would surely have given you enough money to do some basic repairs since you have nor been paying a mortgage on it.

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 12/03/2023 17:11

yoghurtflavours · 12/03/2023 17:02

The vast majority of landlords provide overpriced, undermaintained homes for people who are too scared to speak up. Just because you provide somebody with a home, doesn't automatically make you a good or ethical person.

Well that’s clearly not true. The “vast majority”? Source?

Plodstop · 12/03/2023 17:11

Yes, why would you 'evict' if not causing any problems?

When the children's father wanted to sell his rented out property we sat down and had a proper discussion with them. We felt awful and apologised to them and helped them to find somewhere new. They were nice tenants and always paid on time but we also couldn't afford to keep the property at the time.

Just be honest. Give them notice and try to help them find alternative accommodation if you have the time.

The other option might be to sell with tenants in situ.

I'd never want to be in that position again or be a landlord.