Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH not responding to my Dad

84 replies

sjxoxo · 12/03/2023 10:53

DH and I are going through a bit of a rough patch since having DS who is 12 months. Just exhaustion and struggling to balance everything plus a few big changes - new job, big house renovations.. lots of change in a year. My parents are very supportive 1 we live far away so not ‘present’ support but financially they are very generous and often gift us quite large chunks of money and take all the family on holiday etc etc. We visit often and all generally have a good relationship.

My DH is quite a different personality to my Dad who is very social and likes to keep strong close family relationships.
DH’s parents are divorced and his family is quite a quiet/independent dynamic but also all friendly and we have good relationships with them. I speak to my MIL on video call on at least a weekly basis and we get on fine.

My dad knows we are having a tough time and has offered us a three figure sun to stay at a fancy hotel, whilst he and my mum look after our DS for the night. He sent this offer by message to DH.

He showed me the message and we had a brief chat but didn’t really decide either way to take it or not. DH has not even bothered to reply to my dads message.. I think that’s really rude and he could’ve had the decency to reply and at least say thanks for the kind offer…

I feel if tables were turned I would have at least replied with acknowledgment of the thought???

I suppose I am already miffed because I feel I maintain our family relationships and he rarely makes the effort. He doesn’t even really calm his mum unless she calls several times and then I ask if he’s called her back. I get the general feeling he can’t be arsed with either of our families.. if I said that to him he would say it’s not true.

I often think that men are free passengers in family groups where women maintain all the relationships.. present buying.. preparing, organising trips… Sometimes I think how nice it would be to be married to someone who is enthusiastic about our families and would enjoy a relationship with my Dad who is really active and social still. I suppose my original AIBU is just about DH responding to the text?? Am I being too demanding do you think wise women of MN.

Sorry for the rambling post! X

OP posts:
sjxoxo · 12/03/2023 14:55

Wow wasn’t expecting so many replies.
I suppose I am a daddy’s girl in that we are close. I wouldn’t say he ‘fixes all my problems’ but equally I know the support is there if I want it or needed it. The money that comes our way is mainly just generosity from my parents’, they are happy to offer us security for the long term and have recently inherited a large estate which they want to share with me/us/siblings for various reasons. DH has no issue accepting that.. or so he says/appears. I wouldn’t say they fix our problems though as one poster politely put and we certainly don’t rely on any money from them and we don’t ‘need’ it. Interesting those saying that there’s no obligation on my part to maintain relationships eg with his family - I actually do see that as a bit of an obligation, mostly one I’m happy to make. I feel that a family unit is based on relationships and I would be sad if my family didn’t have that element. I think I also feel guilty re my MIL - I can see she is desperate to be close to her son and his effort is s*. He didn’t even buy her an Xmas gift.. I did it all. I wouldn’t want to see her upset at the thought he hadn’t got her anything.. I think it really saddens her that they aren’t closer. I say I think, I know is the truth because she says so in an indirect way. I think she’d be sad if I withdrew from her because I couldn’t be bothered and I can see the happiness my DS brings her when we chat on video etc. I think it’s polite and the decent thing to do, to maintain a good relationship with her and DH’s family in general. Agree with the pp who suggested we have different ideas of what constitutes ‘normal family ties’. I will have a think if there’s any way we can bridge the gap and how I could improve the dynamic. Thanks all for your input & interesting perspectives x

OP posts:
Believeitornot · 12/03/2023 14:40

Just tell your DH bluntly that he should reply please, even if it’s a no thanks

My DH is terrible for not replying to his own parents, so I always have to remind him - I don’t tell him what to say, just tell him to reply.

and let this be an opener to discussing your rough patch, making time for yourself as a couple etc?

lazycats · 12/03/2023 14:38

*male egotism

lazycats · 12/03/2023 14:37

Hmm. I can understand someone being uncomfortable at feeling like a charity case. Especially when the dynamics of make egotism are thrown into the mix.

But he should have replied anyway.

Sleepless1096 · 12/03/2023 14:31

Not what you asked, but in your situation, I'd take your parents up on the offer of babysitting and book a solo trip away just for you to recharge your batteries.

No reason why you should miss out on the treat because your "D"H is a rude, miserable git. And he might think twice about failing to make any effort next time.

Tiredmum100 · 12/03/2023 14:16

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 12/03/2023 13:04

I'm on the fence here.

On the one hand, your DH shouldn't have ignored the message - even if he just said "That's a lovely gesture, thank you! I'll speak to SJ about."

On the other hand, I think your dad has put your DH in a bit of an awkward position and I suspect he's been made to feel a bit inadequate by your dad's gesture, however well-meaning it was. Your dad should have spoken to you about the idea instead of going to your DH about it - it comes across as a bit interfering and like he thinks your DH isn't doing enough for his daughter, iyswim.

Yes, I agree with this. I feel a bit sorry for your dh to be honest. You sound like a daddys girl, and he fixes all your problems for you. Maybe your husband has had enough of it all, and them interfering. I think its strange your father didn't text you, asking about the hotel. Speak to.your dh and ask him how he's feeling. And yes, I do think he should have replied to you father, even it was a "thanks for the offer I'll speak to OP"

pinkyredrose · 12/03/2023 13:57

If you talk to your parents about your marriage problems I'm not surprised your husband doesn't want to accept the money.

Put your husband first, try and understand his point of view if your marriage has any chance of succeeding .

Your husband probably feels like he's married to them aswell.

Awrite · 12/03/2023 13:52

DH deals with his family, I deal with mine. No free passengers that way.

I'm not a fan of unsolicited gifts. This puts your DH into a position of having to be thankful to your Dad. Perhaps he doesn't want to. He didn't ask for this gift after all.

DoristheDuchess · 12/03/2023 13:48

Aurorabored · 12/03/2023 13:12

’DH and I are going through a bit of a rough patch … My dad knows we are having a tough time and has offered us a three figure sun to stay at a fancy hotel, whilst he and my mum look after our DS for the night. He sent this offer by message to DH.’

I would find that so intrusive and inappropriate. If you want to talk to your parents about your relationship with your DH that’s your call but for your father to then unilaterally arrange a ‘date night’ for you and your DH that he intends to pay for??? Does the man have no boundaries? I think you should be very grateful that your DH didn’t respond by telling your father exactly what he thought of the suggestion.

I agree with this.

You are being infantised by your parents and I suspect your DH is getting fed up with it.

Stop accepting handouts and work out your issues between the two of you.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 12/03/2023 13:40

Dh is rude not to reply, but generally he should be communicating with his family and you with yours. I don't necessarily agree with the whole he has to buy his family presents and I get mine type thing. I am happy to pick up things for his family and he happily points out things for mine and if I say yes he will get it but the ringing, texting and visiting arrangements are dealt with by whichever family is involved

FiveHundredDucksWentOutOneDay · 12/03/2023 13:35

Why did he message your husband, not you?

I want to say that I’d reply and thank them regardless; but I often don’t reply to my MIL. She’s not a good MIL and she has no boundaries at all.

Perhaps DH is uncomfortable with your parents knowing that you’re having a tough time, but messaging him basically saying he’ll fund a date and hotel for you, and has organised childcare… it’s a bit of an overstep, even if he meant it nicely.

You seem to have accepted that you’ll be a point of contact for MIL and regularly talk to her as a result; and expect DH to do the same, when surely the more logical position is that you communicate with your own parents?

billy1966 · 12/03/2023 13:30

Lots of interesting advice.

First off, yes it is rude of him not to reply.

However, you need to leave his family to him. Back off.
If he doesn't respond to his mother, thats on him.

Is he very aware that your family are very aware of your marital challenges?

If so that could be very embarrassing.

I think you should thank your father and ask him to hold off on any money gifts going forward, however generous.

It really doesn't sound like he wants to be around your family so keep them close to you and leave him off.
Stop swooping into his relationship with his mother, it really is none of your business.

Are you happily married?
It doesn't really sound it.

I complete agree with @thecatsmeows on not taking up the family organiser role that so many men think they are entitled to hand over, like complete CF's.

Some women naively think its a great idea and are oblivious to the absolute PITA job they have signed up for.

Aurorabored · 12/03/2023 13:12

’DH and I are going through a bit of a rough patch … My dad knows we are having a tough time and has offered us a three figure sun to stay at a fancy hotel, whilst he and my mum look after our DS for the night. He sent this offer by message to DH.’

I would find that so intrusive and inappropriate. If you want to talk to your parents about your relationship with your DH that’s your call but for your father to then unilaterally arrange a ‘date night’ for you and your DH that he intends to pay for??? Does the man have no boundaries? I think you should be very grateful that your DH didn’t respond by telling your father exactly what he thought of the suggestion.

whumpthereitis · 12/03/2023 13:11

determinedtomakethiswork · 12/03/2023 12:27

I'm sure if your husband was offended by this generous offer that he would've said something to you. It sounds to me as though you both want a different kind of family. I'm on your side here. He sounds really miserable actually. I would be tempted to say to my dad, if he was ever going to give me any money, to put it in premium bonds or other savings because I think in the future you might want that money in order to separate.

Depends if he thinks she’d be receptive to him saying anything. You wouldn’t necessarily say something to someone you know is going to dismiss it.

He may very well be miserable, because what OP feels is normal is to him overbearing and suffocating. It does sound like they want different types of families, but I’m not sure ‘taking sides’ is helpful, because it’s framing it as a battle to be won (and lost), rather than respecting, and working with, two different but valid perspectives.

UseOfWeapons · 12/03/2023 13:10

pinkyredrose · 12/03/2023 11:39

Why do you keep accepting money off your parents? Maybe your husband is embarrassed by them constantly throwing their cash around.

Yes, I wonder about this.
You don’t have to accept every handout, and whilst I agree that your OH should have replied, maybe he’s trying to come up with a non-inflammatory way to say no.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 12/03/2023 13:04

I'm on the fence here.

On the one hand, your DH shouldn't have ignored the message - even if he just said "That's a lovely gesture, thank you! I'll speak to SJ about."

On the other hand, I think your dad has put your DH in a bit of an awkward position and I suspect he's been made to feel a bit inadequate by your dad's gesture, however well-meaning it was. Your dad should have spoken to you about the idea instead of going to your DH about it - it comes across as a bit interfering and like he thinks your DH isn't doing enough for his daughter, iyswim.

KalvinPhillipsBoots · 12/03/2023 13:02

How's about you stand on your own two feet and talk to your husband instead of daddy throwing money at you to fix your problems.

Mortimercat · 12/03/2023 12:56

Your dad should have offered the money to you not your husband. Your husband should have replied, but you say you hadn’t decided whether to take it or not, so maybe he was waiting until you had clarity on that before answering?

That aside you do you and let him do him. He doesn’t have to fall into your pattern of maintaining family relationships and likewise you don’t have to do it for him.

Norriscolesbag · 12/03/2023 12:49

It is very rude of your husband but maybe he feels a bit embarrassed to take him up on his offer or that your dad has felt compelled to offer this at all? They aren’t his family and it’s almost like your dad is suggesting he can’t support you adequately as your husband. It’s not on to not respond though, that’s basic manners.

Asummersday · 12/03/2023 12:43

parietal · 12/03/2023 11:08

your DH should reply. but this kind of thing should not be done solely by text message - it is a conversation that needs a bit of nuance, especially if you haven't decided if you want to accept the offer or not.

phone your Dad and then pass the phone to DH for DH to thank your Dad for the kind offer in a conversation.

REALLY?! Pass the phone to DH so he can thank her dad? He’s not a toddler or child.

Asummersday · 12/03/2023 12:41

I feel like your dad needs to back off - that text would seem really emasculating to a man in my opinion

SallyWD · 12/03/2023 12:35

I think your dad should have made the offer to you. If my parents were offering favours or money, they'd speak to me, not DH. Then I'd discuss it with DH.
But yes, I agree that your husband is being very rude. I couldn't bear to ignore someone's kindness like that! How can he? Even if he doesn't want it he should thank them.
It sounds like he can't be bothered in general with maintaining family relations. I don't think all men are like this. My own DH communicates a lot with his family and mine. He really cares about family. My 2 brothers are also very attentive with my parents and friendly to their inlaws.

determinedtomakethiswork · 12/03/2023 12:27

I'm sure if your husband was offended by this generous offer that he would've said something to you. It sounds to me as though you both want a different kind of family. I'm on your side here. He sounds really miserable actually. I would be tempted to say to my dad, if he was ever going to give me any money, to put it in premium bonds or other savings because I think in the future you might want that money in order to separate.

Thisisformathilda · 12/03/2023 12:08

Extremely rude.

roarfeckingroarr · 12/03/2023 12:02

I don't think you're being demanding at all and I agree with what you're saying about men being passengers. It's very rude of your husband to not respond to your dad. Is this rudeness and lack of care a symptom of why you're going through a rough patch?