Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH not responding to my Dad

84 replies

sjxoxo · 12/03/2023 10:53

DH and I are going through a bit of a rough patch since having DS who is 12 months. Just exhaustion and struggling to balance everything plus a few big changes - new job, big house renovations.. lots of change in a year. My parents are very supportive 1 we live far away so not ‘present’ support but financially they are very generous and often gift us quite large chunks of money and take all the family on holiday etc etc. We visit often and all generally have a good relationship.

My DH is quite a different personality to my Dad who is very social and likes to keep strong close family relationships.
DH’s parents are divorced and his family is quite a quiet/independent dynamic but also all friendly and we have good relationships with them. I speak to my MIL on video call on at least a weekly basis and we get on fine.

My dad knows we are having a tough time and has offered us a three figure sun to stay at a fancy hotel, whilst he and my mum look after our DS for the night. He sent this offer by message to DH.

He showed me the message and we had a brief chat but didn’t really decide either way to take it or not. DH has not even bothered to reply to my dads message.. I think that’s really rude and he could’ve had the decency to reply and at least say thanks for the kind offer…

I feel if tables were turned I would have at least replied with acknowledgment of the thought???

I suppose I am already miffed because I feel I maintain our family relationships and he rarely makes the effort. He doesn’t even really calm his mum unless she calls several times and then I ask if he’s called her back. I get the general feeling he can’t be arsed with either of our families.. if I said that to him he would say it’s not true.

I often think that men are free passengers in family groups where women maintain all the relationships.. present buying.. preparing, organising trips… Sometimes I think how nice it would be to be married to someone who is enthusiastic about our families and would enjoy a relationship with my Dad who is really active and social still. I suppose my original AIBU is just about DH responding to the text?? Am I being too demanding do you think wise women of MN.

Sorry for the rambling post! X

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DowntownRegret1 · 13/03/2023 16:17

I think it was rude of him to not respond to the offer, but overall it sounds like you're very different in terms of family relationships and he probably feels a bit suffocated. Similar to me and DH, he comes from a big close family that all like to be in touch daily on a whatsapp group, hug a lot in person, whereas I have a more 'formal', kinda distant in his eyes relationship with my dad. We talk weekly and see one another every few months and that's absolutely fine. But we respect one another's ways, I have zero issue of course with how he relates to his family and nor would he try and make me have more contact with his family. I would feel quite offended and suffocated tbh if DH tried to step in and tell me when to respond to messages from people, regardless of who they are.

The gift thing though... yeah, rude not to acknowledge it. But can equally see how sometimes you just think 'oh I'll respond to that later' and don't get around to it. And if being given money is a regular thing it probably does become a bit taken for granted rather than some huge wow, amazing thing. Maybe DH doesn't want that much financial exchange between families?

Weallgottachangesometime · 13/03/2023 15:49

“I often think that men are free passengers in family groups where women maintain all the relationships.”
^
this is so true in lots of relationships/families. I stopped buying gifts for in-laws and just accept that left to my husbands it means they often get nothing or get something late.

It was rude for him not to reply to your father after being offered a nice gift. Could he have thought you would reply. Probably best just to ask him to acknowledge the texts.

As for the wider relationships. I’d maintain the ones you get value from and leave anything else.if that means the relationships with some people drifts then so be it. Some people just aren’t in to family as much as others. So it’s also reasonable to think maybe he wouldn’t went to see family as much as you. I certainly don’t want to speak to my family weekly.

cptartapp · 13/03/2023 15:38

sjxoxo being too involved doesn't just mean living in close proximity or seeing each other often. You can be over involved from a distance. I'm not the only one to think so.

Snoken · 13/03/2023 13:48

ChangedmynameagainforChristmas · 13/03/2023 11:49

"Your DF has offered you over a hundred thousand pounds if you and your DH agree to stay in a hotel for a night so they can babysit your child? I'm sorry OP but this sounds dodgy as hell! I'm not surprised your DH hasn't responded."

A three figure sum is anything between 100 and 999 pounds !

It would have been a pretty epic hotel stay though!

ChangedmynameagainforChristmas · 13/03/2023 11:49

"Your DF has offered you over a hundred thousand pounds if you and your DH agree to stay in a hotel for a night so they can babysit your child? I'm sorry OP but this sounds dodgy as hell! I'm not surprised your DH hasn't responded."

A three figure sum is anything between 100 and 999 pounds !

gannett · 13/03/2023 10:43

There's an obvious reason your DH hasn't replied that most posters haven't picked up on - you haven't decided whether to accept the offer or not yet.

Yes, I know some people are very prompt messagers and will text back "thanks, need to discuss it first" immediately but others (like me) don't really like to sent waffly non-answers to offers/invites - I wait til I can say yes or no. Which ideally shouldn't be long but as I'm sure you know these things can slip.

Make up your mind about what your answer is, then he can and should actually answer!

(I do also think the underlying stuff about your husband wanting your dad to back off a bit could be accurate as well, so it's certainly worth having a chat about that.)

SchoolTripDrama · 13/03/2023 10:35

Your DF has offered you over a hundred thousand pounds if you and your DH agree to stay in a hotel for a night so they can babysit your child? I'm sorry OP but this sounds dodgy as hell! I'm not surprised your DH hasn't responded.

SallyWD · 13/03/2023 09:42

I did wonder if this was a clash of male egos. You say you've accepted generous cash donations from your parents before. Maybe your husband is feeling slightly uncomfortable about this and a like less of a man for having to accept this money. Then your dad goes to him, not you, to offer yet another gift. I can see why your DH might feel awkward. I'd question your dad's motives in approaching your DH rather than you. Is it possible he was trying to be the "big man"?
Money is a very sensitive issue and your dad should have gone to you.
Equally it's very rude indeed to ignore the message! But I can see how the whole situation is rubbing your DH up the wrong way.

billy1966 · 13/03/2023 08:25

So you live a considerable distance from your family.

OP, are you happily married?

Do you really think your marriage is going to last the dustance?

If you had your time over and knew what you know now, would you choose him?

Because if you have even the slightest hesitation, it would be far better your father hold on to any gifts that will be come marital property.

You sound possibly mismatched.

Your father may have been a bit over enthusiastic and your husband may feel intimidated by that, but your family are not close by and having a supportive family IS a wonderful thing.

I would have a tactful chat with your father about stepping back a bit with offers of any further money, but I think you should keep your family close to in a quieter way.

You may well need them for support.

Johnisafckface · 12/03/2023 23:05

Comedycook · 12/03/2023 11:06

Your dh sounds unbelievably rude

This. How hard is it to at least acknowledge the text? So very rude. But it seems he’s like this with almost everyone. So it’s not personal. I’d just tell your dad not to bother with him anymore as he’s not good with texting.

bluegreygreen · 12/03/2023 23:02

My dad might offer money but he would do so to me, his daughter, i.e. his own family member.
He would never offer money as part of interfering in my relationship - and if he did we would both wonder what was wrong.

If my husband received a text offering something that we hadn't decided to accept, he would respond gratefully and appropriately but only when we'd actually decided whether to accept it - he wouldn't see the point in replying before that.

You say your MIL really wants to be close to your husband but imply he'd rather have some distance. Why do you think you know better than he does about his relationships with his own family?

SheSaidHummingbird · 12/03/2023 22:46

'Hun' as in MLM?

labamba007 · 12/03/2023 22:24

Have you asked your dh why he didn't respond?

Undisclosedlocation · 12/03/2023 16:47

I would view your dads offer as meddling in my relationship and sticking his oar in if I were your OH.
if his mum had made a similar offer based on your relationship difficulties wouldn’t you think she was over stepping?

sjxoxo · 12/03/2023 15:58

cptartapp · 12/03/2023 15:44

Do you always accept these 'large chunks of cash?' Do you need them?
Too involved nevertheless. Put some boundaries in place.

No we don’t always accept them. Some larger ones are planned well in advance which we do discuss & organise. We don’t live in the UK (DH & I) so some planning is required to declare as required. My parents’ know we can manage without. My Dad grew up with very very little and had a hard life up until probably his 50s, and I think as a result now he is very generous. Also maybe because we are far away they want to give some support. That said I have two younger siblings much closer to home who also have the same financial support time to time. Possibly slightly more actually as one of them is in a bit of difficulty. It’s ironic really to say they are too involved when we see them probably every couple of months for short periods x

OP posts:
sjxoxo · 12/03/2023 15:52

Snowflake2023 · 12/03/2023 15:10

Off topic, but why do you keep putting a kiss at the bottom of your posts?

Just curious. Might just be me but it undermines what you are saying.

Haha!! Habit I guess. You’re obvs not a hun 🤣🤣🤣🤣 X

OP posts:
winningeasy · 12/03/2023 15:50

@Snowflake2023 why are you being so pedantic? Just curious.

winningeasy · 12/03/2023 15:48

Why don't you tell him to get back to your dad asap please??

Aquamarine1029 · 12/03/2023 15:45

Snowflake2023 · 12/03/2023 15:10

Off topic, but why do you keep putting a kiss at the bottom of your posts?

Just curious. Might just be me but it undermines what you are saying.

It's not just you.

cptartapp · 12/03/2023 15:44

Do you always accept these 'large chunks of cash?' Do you need them?
Too involved nevertheless. Put some boundaries in place.

JudgeRudy · 12/03/2023 15:16

I just think you have very different expectations. I think it's odd that your dad chose to message your husband about staying in the hotel. Its a kind offer but it also has connentations that he's suggesting it would be 'romantic' and a solution to your marital problems. I must be honest, I'd be inclined to show it to you then get you to sort it.....or accept that he's not going to.
You said
"I often think that men are free passengers in family groups where women maintain all the relationships.. present buying.. preparing, organising trips…"

I'm perhaps one of the 'free passengers' but I often feel a 'hijacked passenger'. I would genuinely opt out of lots of things. Xmas day is one. I don't necessarily think people are looking for a free ride, they just don't care in the way you do. Your husband hasn't gold you simply because he can't be bothered to 'sort thing' with your dad. He's giving you the option of sorting it thecway you want because he's declined to follow your rules. How would you feel if he just texted back No Thanks. I've done that and other people expect more.Hes giving you some choice.
As for relationships with his family....stop if you don't want to but don't expect him to take up the slack. He's really notvss bothered by these details as you are.

Snowflake2023 · 12/03/2023 15:10

Off topic, but why do you keep putting a kiss at the bottom of your posts?

Just curious. Might just be me but it undermines what you are saying.

whumpthereitis · 12/03/2023 15:08

Interesting those saying that there’s no obligation on my part to maintain relationships eg with his family - I actually do see that as a bit of an obligation, mostly one I’m happy to make

Then that’s something you’re choosing to take on. You’re complaining that it’s left to you as a woman, but in reality you’re actively choosing to pick it up as a duty despite the fact you don’t have to, and aren’t actually expected to 🤷🏻‍♀️

Aquamarine1029 · 12/03/2023 15:00

Your husband should have responded, but your dad is weird and is massively overstepping. I think it's really inappropriate he went to your husband with this offer, honestly. I think your dad likes to one-up your husband and it boarders on creepy.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 12/03/2023 14:56

pinkyredrose · 12/03/2023 11:39

Why do you keep accepting money off your parents? Maybe your husband is embarrassed by them constantly throwing their cash around.

Yeah op. Stop accepting help and support from your loving family. If your dh doesn’t think you deserve treats then you and your dc should just go without like a good family. Your dh’s pride is far more important than maintaining good family relations. That’ll be why he hasn’t bothered to thank your df. This is all his fault for trying to do something nice and making your poor dh feel bad.🙄

Honestly op, this isn’t about different family expectations. Embarrassed or not he’s behaving like a twat. My dmil drives me batty at times and my dh definitely had his moments with my dm (she was so generous but could be a touch interfering and never missed an opportunity to express an opinion). But neither of us have ever been rude to our in-laws as we know they love us and mean well. My dm often offered us money but my dh would thank her for her lovely offer, tell her there was no need and make a joke of it. He didn’t see it as an insult or an affront to his pride, he realised it was normal family generosity.

I couldn’t be with anyone who didn’t demonstrate a basic level of respect to my dm and your dh behaviour is disgusting. He doesn’t have to accept but he should at least have the grace to respond. He doesn’t sound like a quality person.