Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this isn’t actually the BBC’s fight?

232 replies

notonbodycomparisonsites · 12/03/2023 09:16

Hear me out… I’m not very politically minded. This is my view as a lay person with unlimited access to the news and the internet…

But my personal opinion is that the BBC shouldn’t be held to task like this, not at this time.

They definitely need to assess their policies on who is allowed to say what and when. But the fact is that a public figure disagreed with the government, and the government didn’t want their actions criticised publicly, so they pulled out the ‘we own the BBC card’ and used BBC policy to attempt to shut the matter up. As far as I’m concerned that seems like a misuse of power, and as much as the BBC need to sort themselves out, I’d rather acknowledge that I’m uncomfortable we even got here to begin with!

For what it’s worth, I don’t actually agree with Gary Lineker’s opinion on the immigration matter and the 1930’s Germany blah blah blah… but I’m still glad I live in a society where I got to hear him say it Confused.

So… AIBU for thinking that we should soon be hearing from the government with a little apology for causing such a major fucking mess?

(Please don’t ask me anything about politics)

OP posts:
notonbodycomparisonsites · 12/03/2023 12:42

@LemonSwan I’m of the belief that you can’t correct past mistakes by destroying the past. You can’t only think of the holocaust and ignore all of the policies and the structure that lead to the holocaust. If GL believes this policy is on that slippery slope, that’s his prerogative and opinion, but it doesn’t mean he thinks this new policy IS the holocaust; and I think he would be insulted by anybody that insisted that must be what he meant. He didn’t and it’s important that people use nuance when reading statements online.

OP posts:
LemonSwan · 12/03/2023 12:27

Well personally I think anyone who doesn’t think of the Holocaust when nazi Germany is mentioned is lacking in more than quite a lot of brain cells. And being more than a complete dick by stating that those that do link the two are stupid.

So I will leave it at that and move on with my day because I don’t believe someone who says that wishes to discuss this topic properly in good faith.

MiddleParking · 12/03/2023 12:24

Fairyliz · 12/03/2023 10:06

No you are not.
He also wants the country to let in more asylum seekers who are obviously funded by taxes. At the same time he is fighting HMRC over his legitimate tax bill, so despite being a multi millionaire wants to pay less tax.
Whether you agree or disagree with his policies he is certainly a hypocrite.

“His policies” has made me cackle 😂

notonbodycomparisonsites · 12/03/2023 12:17

DomesticShortHair · 12/03/2023 11:58

The BBC has had it in for Gary Lineker, ever since he took a principled stand against the human rights abuses in Qatar and refused to broadcast during the World Cup.

Poor Alan Shearer was the same, when he walked away from his contract with Al Jazeera almost immediately after ten years due to his discomfort with the regime there.

And Ian Wright’s brave backing of Matt Le Tissier and Phil Neal for expressing their own opinions, completely against the general sentiment of the time, was such a tremendous example of defending free speech, too.

Being beacons of morality sadly makes you a target, as Gary and Alan et al, are finding out. The word hero is often overused today, and MOTD or not, their light shines on.

This is all very true.

GL is an easy target in that respect. As I mentioned before I don’t actually agree that this policy is in any way similar to policies written in Nazi germany. But the nuance is there, he did NOT say that it is the same as the holocaust and in actual fact all the intelligent people that read his tweet most likely understood that quite quickly. And most still thought he was chatting out of his arse, because he’s a bit of a dick.

The fact he’s an easy target probably simply meant that whoever decided to cry to Daddy BBC from no. 10 thought it would be a swift kill and then back to business with heralding the new policy. But as we’ve identified, people aren’t actually that stupid en masse and a lot of people are wondering why GL got hit so hard. I don’t think anyone is wrong for wondering why it’s been blown so out of proportion. A play definitely went wrong somewhere it seems!!

OP posts:
AmusableDragon · 12/03/2023 12:16

'I wonder what GL gets out of having a huge twitter fan base. I guess it must be quite intoxicating'.
There are loads of people on Twitter with huge fan bases, he's not unique by any means, Elon Musk has 131 million followers - what does he get out of it? Some people only have a couple of hundred. What difference how many followers people have make, and why would it be intoxicating (unless you're young, just starting out or find that sort of thing thrilling). I doubt GL really cares who follows him.
Twitter is just another platform to express opinions on, bit like this one. All comes back to freedom of speech, the right to express a view.

Notonthestairs · 12/03/2023 12:07

Emotionalstorm · 12/03/2023 12:01

I think it's understandable for the government to do this. If I owned a company and they were talking badly about me I would put my foot down too.

Do the Government own the BBC? It's a public broadcaster not a state owned.

notonbodycomparisonsites · 12/03/2023 12:05

Emotionalstorm · 12/03/2023 12:01

I think it's understandable for the government to do this. If I owned a company and they were talking badly about me I would put my foot down too.

It’s an understandable reaction, but an inadvisable way to run a company.

OP posts:
notonbodycomparisonsites · 12/03/2023 12:04

Can anybody saying that GL should have minded what he said, sincerely declare that they believe the BBC would have taken action following his tweet regardless of No. 10’s response? I don’t think they would have done.

OP posts:
Emotionalstorm · 12/03/2023 12:01

I think it's understandable for the government to do this. If I owned a company and they were talking badly about me I would put my foot down too.

bellac11 · 12/03/2023 12:01

Salverus · 12/03/2023 11:52

The BBC didn't seem too happy and I believe they are one of his bosses in that he is employed by them?

Why arent they happy, they dont have anything to do with government policy do they?

notonbodycomparisonsites · 12/03/2023 12:01

@Salverus im not convinced he did piss off the BBC to this extent though. I don’t think they would have done a damn thing if RS didn’t insist and that’s where I start to feel uncomfortable. Like you, I couldn’t give the shiniest shit what GL’s opinion is. Most of the time, I’ll be honest (and I hope nobody reads this comment) I can’t even give a shit what the new government policy is because I know I can’t do a damn thing about it unless I smear cake over a statue naked, and quite frankly I can’t be arsed with the effort. So I listen, laugh, and turn off the radio or tv or whatever. But I’m not comfortable listening to this right now because it’s gone beyond anybody’s opinion. In my opinion 😉

OP posts:
Forester1 · 12/03/2023 12:00

Salverus · 12/03/2023 11:54

I'm freelance, that doesn't mean you can piss off a client and expect to remain employed by them. Clearly he's pissed off the BBC, whether they were right or wrong is up to them - I agree with the OP that they probably should have just ignored it, but that was the risk he took I guess.

I agree. His profile is such that politically charged comments will reflect on the BBC and he fully understands that. Thousands of people in organisations will limit what they say on social media because their comments will be linked to their organisation. This is not a curb on free speech.

LemonSwan · 12/03/2023 11:59

bellac11 · 12/03/2023 11:48

He didnt say anything about the holocaust

He also didnt bring his company (he is freelance by the way but lets assume the BBC is his employer) into disrepute

When you mention nazi Germany you are by extension referencing the Holocaust.

And the disrepute thing well that’s a grey area isn’t it which is why most people would be careful about what they post around sensitive topics under their real name.

I am not saying he can’t discuss this topic or say this opinion if it’s something he genuinely believes. But a 140 character tweet is not in my opinion a genuine attempt to discuss this topic sensitively and seriously. A tweet of this nature is sensationalist. He should have written an article or blog and could caveat that it’s not to do with the Holocaust etc. If that is what he believes. Because right now it’s reading as basically ‘conservatives are one step away from mass genocide’

Notonthestairs · 12/03/2023 11:59

"DH says it's because most the others are clowns or started out as political pundits or simply didn't suggest "Nazi" connotations."

Sugar tweeted a mocked up picture of Corbyn in a car with Hitler.

DomesticShortHair · 12/03/2023 11:58

The BBC has had it in for Gary Lineker, ever since he took a principled stand against the human rights abuses in Qatar and refused to broadcast during the World Cup.

Poor Alan Shearer was the same, when he walked away from his contract with Al Jazeera almost immediately after ten years due to his discomfort with the regime there.

And Ian Wright’s brave backing of Matt Le Tissier and Phil Neal for expressing their own opinions, completely against the general sentiment of the time, was such a tremendous example of defending free speech, too.

Being beacons of morality sadly makes you a target, as Gary and Alan et al, are finding out. The word hero is often overused today, and MOTD or not, their light shines on.

Notonthestairs · 12/03/2023 11:57

I just can't think why Richard Sharp, Robbie Gibb or Tim Davies would be cross with GL and not Lord Sugar or Andrew Neil or John Humphrey. It's a real head scratcher.

Oblomov23 · 12/03/2023 11:56

@StormInaDcup99

Yes you are unreasonable. The WC being held in Qatar was a disgrace. UEFA corrupt. Hotels not built on time, using cheap Labour. The timing was wrong, didn't suit the premier league timetable. But once it's decided what can you do. You can choose to not watch. I didn't choose that. I knew it was all wrong, but what could I do. I watched. I love it, because I like football.

He voiced his objections. I agreed with him. But he then went. To do a job. Which they did actually need presenters there to present. Was every football pundit in the world supposed to refuse? To go to the World Cup? No!

lljkk · 12/03/2023 11:56

GL has tweeted very strongly antiBrexit stuff for years. Those opinions didn't cause a scandal. I can't understand why this tweet triggered BBC panic when private opinions by A.Neil, Adam Rutherford, Boris Johnson (remember he worked on HIGN4U?), John Humphries, Sandi Toksvig, Peter Allen (openly talked about being member of Tory party), Jeremy Clarkson & a zillion other people didn't cause uproar.

DH says it's because most the others are clowns or started out as political pundits or simply didn't suggest "Nazi" connotations. I'm told problem is that GL is a "serious guy". (yeah, like all sports reporters ??) All of which is cherry-picking who is allowed private opinions. I totally get why other current presenters are standing in solidarity with GL. BBC presenters are NOT Royalty or civil servants, they are allowed to have private opinions on political matters.

Salverus · 12/03/2023 11:54

I'm freelance, that doesn't mean you can piss off a client and expect to remain employed by them. Clearly he's pissed off the BBC, whether they were right or wrong is up to them - I agree with the OP that they probably should have just ignored it, but that was the risk he took I guess.

notonbodycomparisonsites · 12/03/2023 11:52

Salverus · 12/03/2023 11:47

And I didn't say GL "shouldn't be allowed to have an opinion". Of course he is. I just have no interest in knowing what it is.

Well, I mean, nobody can help you there. You need to close your browser. Sincerely. If you want to escape celebrity opinions you need to escape celebrity culture and that won’t happen by hanging out online.

OP posts:
Salverus · 12/03/2023 11:52

bellac11 · 12/03/2023 11:50

How did he 'annoy his boss'?

The BBC didn't seem too happy and I believe they are one of his bosses in that he is employed by them?

Hellocatshome · 12/03/2023 11:51

Salverus · 12/03/2023 11:49

Ugh.

Being gobby on twitter and annoying your boss isn't a human right

Being gobby on twitter i.e free speech is a human right. You can choose to ignore what is said that is your right.

He is freelance so is his own boss

notonbodycomparisonsites · 12/03/2023 11:50

Salverus · 12/03/2023 11:46

Yes I do agree.

I wonder what GL gets out of having a huge twitter fan base. I guess it must be quite intoxicating.

He’s lived his entire adult life in the public eye; everybody has asked him his opinion for most of his life. Psychologically, it doesn’t surprise me that he feels entitled to speak out when he has an opinion. Celebrity actions really shouldn’t surprise most people. None of what has happened after the government intervened has surprised me. It’s simply unsettled me that the government intervened in the first place: the public consensus seems based on some kind of idea that GL actively interfered with government policy. And that is completely ridiculous.

OP posts:
Oblomov23 · 12/03/2023 11:50

The Government, the BBC trying to control what someone says is laughable.
He's not exclusively employed by the BBC. He's not an employee. (Although that's debatable after the recent Uber case, but that's a whole other thread!!). He's a contractor. He has other jobs. Sky. Walkers crisps. Loads of others.

bellac11 · 12/03/2023 11:50

Salverus · 12/03/2023 11:49

Ugh.

Being gobby on twitter and annoying your boss isn't a human right

How did he 'annoy his boss'?