Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this isn’t actually the BBC’s fight?

232 replies

notonbodycomparisonsites · 12/03/2023 09:16

Hear me out… I’m not very politically minded. This is my view as a lay person with unlimited access to the news and the internet…

But my personal opinion is that the BBC shouldn’t be held to task like this, not at this time.

They definitely need to assess their policies on who is allowed to say what and when. But the fact is that a public figure disagreed with the government, and the government didn’t want their actions criticised publicly, so they pulled out the ‘we own the BBC card’ and used BBC policy to attempt to shut the matter up. As far as I’m concerned that seems like a misuse of power, and as much as the BBC need to sort themselves out, I’d rather acknowledge that I’m uncomfortable we even got here to begin with!

For what it’s worth, I don’t actually agree with Gary Lineker’s opinion on the immigration matter and the 1930’s Germany blah blah blah… but I’m still glad I live in a society where I got to hear him say it Confused.

So… AIBU for thinking that we should soon be hearing from the government with a little apology for causing such a major fucking mess?

(Please don’t ask me anything about politics)

OP posts:
Florenz · 12/03/2023 17:10

Roussette · 12/03/2023 16:58

Which is why he didn't do that.

Have you read and understood the tweet? He is talking about language used in the 1930s.

The language used by the Government now is not dissimilar to that which was used in 1930s Germany. It started in the dehumanisation of vulnerable and minority groups by language back then. Lineker called no one a nazi

If you compare language used by the government to language used by the German government of the 1930s, you're comparing the government to the Nazis.

Blossomtoes · 12/03/2023 17:02

Florenz · 12/03/2023 16:31

Lineker's been critical of the Tories for ages but it was comparing them to the Nazis that got him suspended.

Except he didn’t. 🙄

FinallyHere · 12/03/2023 17:02

Still don't understand what is thought to have changed. It can't surely just be that his opinion is critical of His Majesty's esteemed government policy.

Say it isn't so.

To think this isn’t actually the BBC’s fight?
Roussette · 12/03/2023 16:58

Florenz · 12/03/2023 16:31

Lineker's been critical of the Tories for ages but it was comparing them to the Nazis that got him suspended.

Which is why he didn't do that.

Have you read and understood the tweet? He is talking about language used in the 1930s.

The language used by the Government now is not dissimilar to that which was used in 1930s Germany. It started in the dehumanisation of vulnerable and minority groups by language back then. Lineker called no one a nazi

pointythings · 12/03/2023 16:58

@Florenz but he didn't. He (correctly) pointed out similarities in use of language and expressed concerns. Concerns very many people have been expressing for much longer. If the BBC and the Toris hadn't made a stupid fuss, all of this would have been barely more than a ripple.

Florenz · 12/03/2023 16:31

Lineker's been critical of the Tories for ages but it was comparing them to the Nazis that got him suspended.

TooBigForMyBoots · 12/03/2023 16:21

Typical of the authoritarian, snowflake nature of the Tories.

"He criticised me. Cancel him."😭😭😭

Ifailed · 12/03/2023 16:09

The BBC have messed up big time as they appear to be 'cancelling' someone who does work for them (not an employee) for criticising the Tory party, whilst allowing people in a similar position to praise the Tory party.

I'd bet they won't try and 'cancel' Ian Hislop, who also works for the BBC, criticises the Tory Party (& others), but also edits Private Eye.

CremeEggThief · 12/03/2023 15:43

Ttwinkletoes you're the one implying he should keep his mouth shut because he's a celebrity!😆

My point to you is that so what if he is? Celebrities and anyone else in any position of privilege have the same right to express an opinion as anyone else. Similarly, Musicians get a lot of flak especially in America for beinging politics into music when they are just as entitled as anyone else to choose to be political.

luckylavender · 12/03/2023 15:36

RandomMess · 12/03/2023 09:35

Start paying their presenters far far far less and remove the issue Wink

They get paid the going rate. Lineker would earn a lot more if he left the BBC.

luckylavender · 12/03/2023 15:35

Fairyliz · 12/03/2023 09:29

The thing is if you were say a comedian you can say what you like about the government. However the whole point of the BBC is that they are supposed to be impartial, so report on the news not comment on it.
I know everyone will say GL is only a sports presenter, but everyone knows he is their biggest paid star so he is seen as a face of the BBC.

And that could be ok if everyone were treated the same. Alan Sugar is a prominent BBC employee, says terrible things about eg Corbyn & Mick Lynch. Never sanctioned. Deborah Meaden is a prominent BBC employee & regularly criticises this government. Never sanctioned. Andrew Neil when a BBC employee was editor of The Spectator & very vocal. Never sanctioned.

Saschka · 12/03/2023 15:29

LemonSwan · 12/03/2023 12:27

Well personally I think anyone who doesn’t think of the Holocaust when nazi Germany is mentioned is lacking in more than quite a lot of brain cells. And being more than a complete dick by stating that those that do link the two are stupid.

So I will leave it at that and move on with my day because I don’t believe someone who says that wishes to discuss this topic properly in good faith.

And anyone who is offended by somebody else mentioning the interwar period, because that reminds you that the Second World War happened a decade later and you can’t cope with that, is also lacking a few brain cells.

Saschka · 12/03/2023 15:20

Salverus · 12/03/2023 11:46

Yes I do agree.

I wonder what GL gets out of having a huge twitter fan base. I guess it must be quite intoxicating.

Same reason every celeb has a social media presence these days - branding/publicity.

He makes a lot of money from his podcast production business; having a thriving Twitter following probably sends a lot of subscribers to the podcasts.

Notonthestairs · 12/03/2023 15:17

Robbie Gibb was appointed to the BBC board on 29/04/21

Just over a month later he was liking tweets from Tory MPs saying how desperate they are to kick out the SNP

twitter.com/writesbright/status/1562570519097982978?s=46&t=Uw4lJNwxFZFnX0Xs3doHYg

Roussette · 12/03/2023 15:10

Deborah Meaden (BBC Dragons Den every Thursday) and Richard Osman (every day BBC2) give political opinions.

Why aren't they suspended too?

Ttwinkletoes · 12/03/2023 15:05

CremeEggThief · 12/03/2023 14:57

Salverus, stating you would be happy with the erosion of free speech, for any reason at all, is a very strange position and not one I can ever fathom!

And people of privilege have the same right to express an opinion as anyone else! Ttwinkletoes.

Surely only GL gave an opinion

CremeEggThief · 12/03/2023 14:57

Salverus, stating you would be happy with the erosion of free speech, for any reason at all, is a very strange position and not one I can ever fathom!

And people of privilege have the same right to express an opinion as anyone else! Ttwinkletoes.

Roussette · 12/03/2023 14:56

LakeTiticaca · 12/03/2023 10:09

Gary is entitled to free speech just as the rest of us are entitled not to pay the wages of a mansion dwelling, tax dodging millionaire virtue signaller who will never be affected by uncapped immigration.
The BBC is an outdated concept and nobody should be criminalised because they don't wish to be lectured by the liked GL and his comrades.

You do know do you, that he has taken in two refugees... into his 'mansion'.

He didn't lecture you. He expressed an opinion. He's entitled to do that, like it or not.

Ttwinkletoes · 12/03/2023 14:49

These former footballers are so overpriviliged, rich I wish the bbc would sack them all. Obviously so confident of their vitally important role for the bbc/ society that they can chuck their toys out of the pram and assume someone will grovel and pick them up.

notonbodycomparisonsites · 12/03/2023 13:00

@Fluffyslippersohyes exactly. For some reason somebody thought this would be an easy win but the facts don’t make sense, whether you agree with his statement or not. And even if people are upset at the BBC caving under the pressure, I really do wonder what the alternative would have been in that situation if no. 10 really was ‘insistent’. Did they have a choice really?

OP posts:
Fluffyslippersohyes · 12/03/2023 12:55

Firstly I agree with GL.

Secondly I think the problem is plenty of other BBC people tweet and write political stuff as mentioned before - not a problem apparently.

MPs have tab gigs and second jobs - again not a problem apparently.

But GL is in trouble because it was against gov policy he was tweeting? From his own account - not the MOTD account, not saying it on MOTD. It’s just not very consistent.

bellac11 · 12/03/2023 12:55

LemonSwan · 12/03/2023 12:27

Well personally I think anyone who doesn’t think of the Holocaust when nazi Germany is mentioned is lacking in more than quite a lot of brain cells. And being more than a complete dick by stating that those that do link the two are stupid.

So I will leave it at that and move on with my day because I don’t believe someone who says that wishes to discuss this topic properly in good faith.

Stop trying to gaslight people

He said, which is clear enough, that he has a problem with the language used about migrants and that its not disimilar from the language used in 1930s Germany

The German government of the day worked really really hard to dehumanise the Jews (and other groups) with their language and propaganda.

Most intelligent and decent people recoil at similarities of language to those times.

Blossomtoes · 12/03/2023 12:51

I think anyone who doesn’t think of the Holocaust when nazi Germany is mentioned is lacking in more than quite a lot of brain cells.

He didn’t mention Nazi Germany.

Grantanow · 12/03/2023 12:49

The BBC has caved in to Tory pressure. If Lineker had agreed with the Tory policy nothing would have happened! How can a Tory Director General working under a Tory Chairman claim to interpret impartiality rules fairly? It's disgraceful.

Blossomtoes · 12/03/2023 12:45

shouldhavetakenmorenotice · 12/03/2023 10:23

This!

One person should not have so much power.

Gary seems to have forgotten that we are his bosses.

We’re not his bosses and he has zero power. After this debacle he has significant influence and I’m delighted.