Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this isn’t actually the BBC’s fight?

232 replies

notonbodycomparisonsites · 12/03/2023 09:16

Hear me out… I’m not very politically minded. This is my view as a lay person with unlimited access to the news and the internet…

But my personal opinion is that the BBC shouldn’t be held to task like this, not at this time.

They definitely need to assess their policies on who is allowed to say what and when. But the fact is that a public figure disagreed with the government, and the government didn’t want their actions criticised publicly, so they pulled out the ‘we own the BBC card’ and used BBC policy to attempt to shut the matter up. As far as I’m concerned that seems like a misuse of power, and as much as the BBC need to sort themselves out, I’d rather acknowledge that I’m uncomfortable we even got here to begin with!

For what it’s worth, I don’t actually agree with Gary Lineker’s opinion on the immigration matter and the 1930’s Germany blah blah blah… but I’m still glad I live in a society where I got to hear him say it Confused.

So… AIBU for thinking that we should soon be hearing from the government with a little apology for causing such a major fucking mess?

(Please don’t ask me anything about politics)

OP posts:
pointythings · 14/03/2023 10:35

@notonbodycomparisonsites I agree with you. I grew up in the Netherlands where every content provider/service has ads and always has had. The broadcasters absolutely do have a platform - some are religiously based (KRO/EO), some are libertarian (AVRO), some are socialist (VARA) and so on. Viewers choose what and who to watch. It's mostly based on content these days, not so much on politics, and there is a national news service which absolutely is unbiased. There isn't however a sacred cow of broadcasting.

The BBC either needs to live up to being that sacred cow or just be another broadcaster like Channel 4 or ITV. They can then decide where they want to stand politically and viewers can choose. I'd prefer that.

notonbodycomparisonsites · 14/03/2023 10:26

The BBC work directly with Netflix to produce shows, and also the fact that they outsource roles to freelance celebrities is, in my opinion, evidence enough that they weren’t impartial for a long time prior to any of this crap.

If they want to have true control over their impartiality, I think they have to stop trying to find sneaky ways around the ‘no advertising clause’ to make extra money and keep up with other broadcasters; and start fixing the damage in their company structure before it collapses.

Or; soon they really are just going to have to accept that they are just another broadcaster like ITV and Channel 4, and they should be regarded as such by the public; not held in any special regard or trusted any more.

OP posts:
pointythings · 14/03/2023 08:44

@TodayInahurry GL has in fact criticised FIFA and the fact that it chose to give Qatar the World Cup. He did it on air. The BBC allowed it.

Blossomtoes · 14/03/2023 08:14

TodayInahurry · 14/03/2023 08:02

Linker is selective, football and FIFA is totally corrupt, why are so many clubs owned by foreign nationals, like Abramovich? He does not criticise that!

FIFA didn’t design the country’s policies the last time I looked. Nor does the ownership of football clubs have any effect on them.

Roussette · 14/03/2023 08:04

Notonthestairs · 14/03/2023 07:56

In which case I'd like to be able to vote on whether any seat on the board should be a politically appointment.
If the argument is that the anyone who works for the BBC for the period of their employment must be wholly impartial and independent then its about time we removed any Government (of any flavour) influence over the appointments process.

Yep.

And sack a BBC Chair who quite obviously has helped a PM with finances. And also not employ an ex Comms Director of an ex PM on the Board. And who helped set up the most rightwing news channel we have (GBNews). And who surprise surprise forgot to disclose all of this before being appointed!

TodayInahurry · 14/03/2023 08:02

Linker is selective, football and FIFA is totally corrupt, why are so many clubs owned by foreign nationals, like Abramovich? He does not criticise that!

Notonthestairs · 14/03/2023 07:56

In which case I'd like to be able to vote on whether any seat on the board should be a politically appointment.
If the argument is that the anyone who works for the BBC for the period of their employment must be wholly impartial and independent then its about time we removed any Government (of any flavour) influence over the appointments process.

MarshaBradyo · 14/03/2023 07:40

Notonthestairs · 14/03/2023 07:37

Im not arguing against a review of guidelines at all.
I'm arguing that there isn't a link between the guidelines and the licence fee.

How can you know for certain unless you ask people?

Better to check imo

PerfectYear321 · 14/03/2023 07:38

MarshaBradyo · 14/03/2023 06:07

Do you think BBC presenters should have free reign on SM from now on?

Fine to think so but you’ll just as likely get views from left and right. Plus impartially will be harder to claim.

It’s up to the BBC as they’re reviewing atm but it could be trickier to maintain argument for license fee

How do you explain Andrew Neil being able to be editor of the Spectator while being the face of the BBC's main politics show and all the other countless examples? It's blatantly obvious that they're only unhappy when the partiality is towards the Tories. The BBC board is packed with Tories so by this logic they should all resign?

Notonthestairs · 14/03/2023 07:37

Im not arguing against a review of guidelines at all.
I'm arguing that there isn't a link between the guidelines and the licence fee.

MarshaBradyo · 14/03/2023 07:34

Always with typical responses.

I don’t think it’s unwise to consider how the public feel or underestimate what those feelings lead to - see Brexit.

I like the BBC, I rely on radio a lot and losing it would damage the music scene in U.K. and other good things.

I don’t know what the review entails but if it does actually ask people what the impact would be I don’t think that’s a bad idea. It could be no change in perception or something. Much better for an organisation to be aware of what people who pay think.

They’ve been on the back foot on this and insights helps to change that.

If you’re right then no issue. If not, better to know.

Notonthestairs · 14/03/2023 07:29

I think you & Jacob Rees Mogg do viewers a disservice.

I think viewers are quite able to understand why an actor or presenter might have differing views from the Government of the day and make up their own minds.

It's why I can watch Portillo zipping around on trains and simultaneously ignore his political ponderings on other media.

MarshaBradyo · 14/03/2023 07:19

Notonthestairs · 14/03/2023 07:02

"It’s up to the BBC as they’re reviewing atm but it could be trickier to maintain argument for license fee"

Can you explain why it should be linked to the licence fee?

Are viewers considered so silly as to not understand that actors & presenters might have opinions that differ from the Government of the day?

It's public broadcasting not state.

‘Silly’ no

Impacting public perception who knows. The review of the guidelines could be taking that into account when deciding what to do.

Notonthestairs · 14/03/2023 07:02

"It’s up to the BBC as they’re reviewing atm but it could be trickier to maintain argument for license fee"

Can you explain why it should be linked to the licence fee?

Are viewers considered so silly as to not understand that actors & presenters might have opinions that differ from the Government of the day?

It's public broadcasting not state.

Roussette · 14/03/2023 06:43

MarshaBradyo · 14/03/2023 06:07

Do you think BBC presenters should have free reign on SM from now on?

Fine to think so but you’ll just as likely get views from left and right. Plus impartially will be harder to claim.

It’s up to the BBC as they’re reviewing atm but it could be trickier to maintain argument for license fee

It's the inconsistency that's a problem. I follow Deborah Meaden, and Richard Osman on Twitter. They both have daily/weekly BBC programmes. They are not backward in coming forward on political matters!
Then there's Alan Sugar. Why should they be able to express opinions but GL wasn't?

Some people just don't want to sell their souls to their employer.

MarshaBradyo · 14/03/2023 06:07

PerfectYear321 · 14/03/2023 00:52

If this had happened in China or Russia we would be turning, or perhaps smirking at how at least we have freedom of speech

Do you think BBC presenters should have free reign on SM from now on?

Fine to think so but you’ll just as likely get views from left and right. Plus impartially will be harder to claim.

It’s up to the BBC as they’re reviewing atm but it could be trickier to maintain argument for license fee

Zuffe · 14/03/2023 05:44

DdraigGoch · 14/03/2023 00:40

Just type "Gary Lineker tax" into Google and you'll find pretty much every news site, plus specialist accountancy news sites summarising the dispute which revolves around whether IR35 should apply to him.

It’s not just IR35. There are companies he owns in Barbados and BVI. It’s in the Paradise Papers.

PerfectYear321 · 14/03/2023 00:52

If this had happened in China or Russia we would be turning, or perhaps smirking at how at least we have freedom of speech

DdraigGoch · 14/03/2023 00:40

Ttwinkletoes · 13/03/2023 06:55

Where do you get your info on GL’s tax

Just type "Gary Lineker tax" into Google and you'll find pretty much every news site, plus specialist accountancy news sites summarising the dispute which revolves around whether IR35 should apply to him.

pointythings · 13/03/2023 22:06

Yeah, the Times and the Spectator having a go at Gary Lineker - colour me sooooo surprised!

Got anything juicy from the Mail, Clav?

TooBigForMyBoots · 13/03/2023 21:35

Oh dear, are the Tories circling the wagons @Clavinova? They must be rattled.🤣🤣🤣

notonbodycomparisonsites · 13/03/2023 20:41

And for those that disagree with Gary please remember that I do too. I’m not convinced that this policy is that drastic. But I don’t think he was wrong to air his concerns if that’s honestly how he feels; and clearly a large section of our population feel similarly, so I don’t understand why they need to be silenced. If those are the “vibes” people are getting then surely the bloody thing might at least need a look over 🙄

OP posts:
Clavinova · 13/03/2023 20:36

Notonthestairs
Was that in the Opinion/Comment section?

Leading Articles
The Times view on the BBC’s dilemma: The Gary Lineker Show
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/the-times-view-on-the-bbcs-dilemma-the-gary-lineker-show-kr8096mpl

Just looked at the Spectator, mentioned up thread;
Gary Lineker’s offensive Nazi Germany comparison
www.spectator.co.uk/article/gary-linekers-offensive-nazi-germany-comparison/

notonbodycomparisonsites · 13/03/2023 20:31

“A grotesque analogy”

I admired Germany when they were having a moral battle with themselves over sending the tanks to Ukraine. Nobody recoiled in horror when past atrocities were mentioned: they straightened up and did what they had to do, which was asses their position before moving forward. Regardless of what individuals felt, as a nation we got one message from them. And they were actually responsible for “1930’s Germany”

I’m actually embarrassed right now that our country can’t have an open discussion about potential missteps based on history, without our leading print media calling it heinous.

OP posts:
Roussette · 13/03/2023 20:31

Here

Swipe left for the next trending thread