Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My partner having a lodger

88 replies

Biilie82 · 11/03/2023 20:51

So I don’t live with my partner and that isn’t the plan anytime soon.
he has recently decided to take a lodger in so he can make more money. He is in a very high paying job, money is not an issue to him, just says he might as well make an income from his spare room. His house is small and you can hear everything in the next room.
I don’t feel as comfortable when I go now, it feels like a hotel and not a home, the lodger is fine- nice enough guy, but I don’t particularly want to make convo with him in the morning making a brew.
I know it’s not my place and feel free to tell me IABU, just wondered if it would bother anyone else or if I’m just very antisocial!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Biilie82 · 15/03/2023 13:10

ProbablyDogNappersHunX · 15/03/2023 09:06

Same here!

I've got a lodger at the moment - no sense in leaving a big spare room empty, and having her is building up my savings again after spending £££ doing the house up when I bought it. A friend with a good job in his 40s is going to do the same thing for the same reason. He lives alone and WFH so I think the company will do him good.

No problem with my lodgers bringing home a bf/gf; I just ask they don't bring home one night stands, and they don't try and move anyone in full time.

I quite like the extra life in the house. It also has the bonus that if I'm out then the dog also often gets company / someone to let him out on the garden.

I've had lodgers in the past, but DP was a bit sceptical at first (not his choice though, I own the house) but has come round to the idea and quite likes the lodger.

You'd have to be on a very good income to think that an extra £600 tax free income per month wasn't attractive. You could go on a European holiday every month with that sort of money.

I might have enjoyed this in my early 20’s it’s not really the lifestyle I want in my 40’s. Think money is just more important to some people and that’s ok.

OP posts:
Biilie82 · 15/03/2023 13:08

FellPuck · 15/03/2023 09:22

I think YABU because you said you have kids staying with you part of the time, so your house isn't an ideal situation either.

It's his space, his rules.

Of course it is, doesn’t mean I have to love it tho!!!

OP posts:
FellPuck · 15/03/2023 09:22

I think YABU because you said you have kids staying with you part of the time, so your house isn't an ideal situation either.

It's his space, his rules.

ProbablyDogNappersHunX · 15/03/2023 09:06

Tabitha1960 · 11/03/2023 22:39

Blimey what an unfriendly bunch!

I've had 3 lodgers for 25 years and many have brought their boy or girl friends to stay a night or two. One current lodger's boyfriend stays 2 nights a week.

No problem, everyone is friendly!

I've had several long term boyfriends in that time and none has ever had a problem with me having three lodgers in my house when they have stayed over, for a night, a weekend, a week, etc.

I am bewildered by the OP and the replies on this thread!

Same here!

I've got a lodger at the moment - no sense in leaving a big spare room empty, and having her is building up my savings again after spending £££ doing the house up when I bought it. A friend with a good job in his 40s is going to do the same thing for the same reason. He lives alone and WFH so I think the company will do him good.

No problem with my lodgers bringing home a bf/gf; I just ask they don't bring home one night stands, and they don't try and move anyone in full time.

I quite like the extra life in the house. It also has the bonus that if I'm out then the dog also often gets company / someone to let him out on the garden.

I've had lodgers in the past, but DP was a bit sceptical at first (not his choice though, I own the house) but has come round to the idea and quite likes the lodger.

You'd have to be on a very good income to think that an extra £600 tax free income per month wasn't attractive. You could go on a European holiday every month with that sort of money.

Biilie82 · 12/03/2023 20:43

cordelia16 · 12/03/2023 14:37

I don't think that's a fair comparison. The DP has the opportunity to stay with OP when the kids aren't there, but OP never has a chance to stay with DP because the lodger is always there. So DP gets time away, but OP does not. The same situation would be if OP always had her kids there, but that's not the case.

Thank you, I do try and ensure I protect our time, like occasionally if my kids arnt with their dad I will try find alternative arrangements , so I can honour our time together and make him feel like I prioritise him where I can!

OP posts:
Biilie82 · 12/03/2023 20:41

BCBird · 12/03/2023 16:46

It's his decision but I would feel.uncomfortable going over it will mean he is always at your's which is not good. Perhaps he van pay for a mini break every couple of months? I would not be able to talk freely or want sex if there was someone next door

Yep, the walls are soooo thin and the bedroom is adjourning. Just doesn’t feel very relaxed, he’s not a friend/ family member etc last time I stayed could hear him on his phone, arguing! 🙈 far more than I wanted to hear, early on a Sunday morning 😂

OP posts:
BCBird · 12/03/2023 16:46

It's his decision but I would feel.uncomfortable going over it will mean he is always at your's which is not good. Perhaps he van pay for a mini break every couple of months? I would not be able to talk freely or want sex if there was someone next door

Rewis · 12/03/2023 16:37

I don't think it's that deep. I don't think there is hidden resentment or secret messages. He probably don't mind sharing his space and figured it would be cool to make a bit of extra and decided to get a lodger. Didn't occur to him that it's not for everyone. You can still meet up out and about, him coming for a sleepover at yours, you go to hik to watch a film and then home for the night. No need to pu back (unless you want to) and tell him the truth if he asks. It doesn't have to involve ultimatums or anything. Just changing the set up a bit.

cordelia16 · 12/03/2023 14:37

LouandNala · 12/03/2023 11:02

Not needing the money but wanting extra income are different things IMO.
If you're not planning to live together and he can't be at yours when your kids are there, I don't really blame him for making extra money if he can.
I'm not sure why it would not be an option for him to stay at yours with your kids there so there are times when your house is out of bounds for him but you want complete freedom to enjoy couple time at his house whenever.
Seems a bit unfair to me.

I don't think that's a fair comparison. The DP has the opportunity to stay with OP when the kids aren't there, but OP never has a chance to stay with DP because the lodger is always there. So DP gets time away, but OP does not. The same situation would be if OP always had her kids there, but that's not the case.

Biilie82 · 12/03/2023 12:23

Whatdayisitalexa · 12/03/2023 12:19

I think you need to have a frank discussion including the future after 2 years as partners. It's nice when you're not a materialistic person, but skipping through life without having any thoughts about bills and keeping a roof over your head (especially with kids) is another matter. It does sound as if it's more of a bf/gf situation rather than partners at the moment, and mutually enjoyable up until now.

Having a secure home is not to be underestimated, and gives you many more options. If you did move in together for a trial it would make perfect sense that your bf could go back if it didn't work out for example, while the rent paid his bills at his and he could contribute to your household.

Assuming you have an assured tenancy or own your property (maybe your ex is paying towards the bills) so you don't feel financial pressure, this could change once the kids are grown up though. A small 2 bedroom terrace doesn't sound like a rich persons home to me, but either way you should be thinking about the future..together or not

Good luck with that chat 🙂

I do wonder if he feels I have this attitude of ‘skipping through life’ and I know I’m lucky not to worry about my housing. My ex doesn’t pay anything but we are comfortable in terms of housing costs. I don’t think he wants to move in with me, think the kids might be too much, I’m assuming this, he hasn’t actually said it! Think I need a grown up conversation!

OP posts:
Biilie82 · 12/03/2023 12:19

HaveTheDayOff · 12/03/2023 12:09

Yeah you do. How would you react if he was rude to you?

I havnt found him rude at all, think we both just feel a little awkward. I wouldn’t be rude or off with him, that would be awful!

OP posts:
Whatdayisitalexa · 12/03/2023 12:19

I think you need to have a frank discussion including the future after 2 years as partners. It's nice when you're not a materialistic person, but skipping through life without having any thoughts about bills and keeping a roof over your head (especially with kids) is another matter. It does sound as if it's more of a bf/gf situation rather than partners at the moment, and mutually enjoyable up until now.

Having a secure home is not to be underestimated, and gives you many more options. If you did move in together for a trial it would make perfect sense that your bf could go back if it didn't work out for example, while the rent paid his bills at his and he could contribute to your household.

Assuming you have an assured tenancy or own your property (maybe your ex is paying towards the bills) so you don't feel financial pressure, this could change once the kids are grown up though. A small 2 bedroom terrace doesn't sound like a rich persons home to me, but either way you should be thinking about the future..together or not

Good luck with that chat 🙂

billy1966 · 12/03/2023 12:11

OP,

He stays at yours when your house is child free?

And you stayed in his and things balanced out?

He now has a lodger which has understandably made you feel a lot less comfortable at his?

So if you are not careful, he will end up at yours.

So you socialise at yours and he has a paying lodger?

Double win for him.

Red flag for me that he is very very astute and your comfort does not figure in his thoughts.

I would take it that he is very much suiting himself and isn't particularly committed long term.

I would be focused on protecting yourself as you are not on the same page at all.

Do not allow yourself or your home to be used.

HaveTheDayOff · 12/03/2023 12:09

Biilie82 · 12/03/2023 12:06

No, I was introduced and from then I’ve bumped into him in the mornings etc. I feel I have to be polite when we are both in the kitchen etc

Yeah you do. How would you react if he was rude to you?

Biilie82 · 12/03/2023 12:06

HaveTheDayOff · 12/03/2023 12:02

Was it explained to the lodger BEFORE he moved in that his landlords girlfriend doesn’t want to make small talk with him??????

No, I was introduced and from then I’ve bumped into him in the mornings etc. I feel I have to be polite when we are both in the kitchen etc

OP posts:
PaleGreenFrontDoor · 12/03/2023 12:05

HaveTheDayOff · 12/03/2023 12:02

Was it explained to the lodger BEFORE he moved in that his landlords girlfriend doesn’t want to make small talk with him??????

Do you always ask such weird questions?

HaveTheDayOff · 12/03/2023 12:02

Was it explained to the lodger BEFORE he moved in that his landlords girlfriend doesn’t want to make small talk with him??????

DaisyBoop · 12/03/2023 11:59

We’ve got two lodgers and I hate it. We’re only doing it for another 2-3 years until our debts are gone then the house will be ours again. The house has too much of a student vibe which I loathe.

Biilie82 · 12/03/2023 11:57

NewNameNigel · 12/03/2023 11:21

Oh for gods sake don't do this. You're not 15 years old.
Gradually getting more distant without explanation can really mess with people's heads.

If I was in your partners situation and a man thought he should have any say in who lived in my house I would see it as a red flag. A double red flag as getting rid of the lodger would be reducing my income.

Point taken. It’s not my place to say anything to him

OP posts:
Biilie82 · 12/03/2023 11:51

LouandNala · 12/03/2023 11:40

I get it. BUT he isn't saying there are times you can be here and not, as OP is.
He hasn't said at all that OP cannot be at his home, it's that she feels uncomfortable and he clearly doesn't.
So OP has set limits on her home, he hasn't set any on his. OP being uncomfortable isn't really his problem if he isn't and you look at it that way.

I think I'm just seeing it from the BF point of view, that OP sets limits on when he can stay at hers, he sets no limits on when she can stay at his but she feels she'd prefer to have his place to themselves so he's the one having to make compromises and lose income.

I don't think it's as simple as he is prioritising his relationship with the OP when she is prioritising her relationship with him, because she has children. That's completely understandable. She is not wrong. But in them not being able to live together, he is essentially a single person in terms of finances.

And the 'doesn't need the money' argument I keep seeing isn't that valid IMO. Since covid, the Ukraine war etc, millions of people are realising that the money they have or had planned for retirement is subject to unexpected events.

My retired Dad who's in his mid 60s has realised that the savings he thought would see him to the end of his life is likely not to as although his mortgage is paid, his energy bills and food costs have skyrocketed.

I think anyone making as much money as they can through legitimate means whether they seem to currently 'need it' or not are sensible to be honest.

Yes. this is very balanced, he’s probably being sensible about money and I’m maybe not as good at short term compromise for long term gain.

OP posts:
Biilie82 · 12/03/2023 11:49

Barnstormaway787 · 12/03/2023 11:18

Yes that sounds reasonable but the difference is the lodger is there all the time! At least there are SOME times at the op’s house when they can be alone without the dc.

By having a lodger, he has just made their relationship more difficult, which is absolutely his prerogative, but it sounds like he hadn’t given the relationship side much thought.

If op’s dc were there all the time then this couple would never be alone except when out of the house which is the sort of relationship you have in your teens.

I think you’ve hit the nail on the head, it feels a bit teenageish!

OP posts:
LouandNala · 12/03/2023 11:40

Barnstormaway787 · 12/03/2023 11:18

Yes that sounds reasonable but the difference is the lodger is there all the time! At least there are SOME times at the op’s house when they can be alone without the dc.

By having a lodger, he has just made their relationship more difficult, which is absolutely his prerogative, but it sounds like he hadn’t given the relationship side much thought.

If op’s dc were there all the time then this couple would never be alone except when out of the house which is the sort of relationship you have in your teens.

I get it. BUT he isn't saying there are times you can be here and not, as OP is.
He hasn't said at all that OP cannot be at his home, it's that she feels uncomfortable and he clearly doesn't.
So OP has set limits on her home, he hasn't set any on his. OP being uncomfortable isn't really his problem if he isn't and you look at it that way.

I think I'm just seeing it from the BF point of view, that OP sets limits on when he can stay at hers, he sets no limits on when she can stay at his but she feels she'd prefer to have his place to themselves so he's the one having to make compromises and lose income.

I don't think it's as simple as he is prioritising his relationship with the OP when she is prioritising her relationship with him, because she has children. That's completely understandable. She is not wrong. But in them not being able to live together, he is essentially a single person in terms of finances.

And the 'doesn't need the money' argument I keep seeing isn't that valid IMO. Since covid, the Ukraine war etc, millions of people are realising that the money they have or had planned for retirement is subject to unexpected events.

My retired Dad who's in his mid 60s has realised that the savings he thought would see him to the end of his life is likely not to as although his mortgage is paid, his energy bills and food costs have skyrocketed.

I think anyone making as much money as they can through legitimate means whether they seem to currently 'need it' or not are sensible to be honest.

Barnstormaway787 · 12/03/2023 11:29

Biilie82 · 12/03/2023 11:13

He is probably more financially astute than me, I’ve lived with plenty money and also not as much and it doesn’t bother me too much either way. As long as we have a roof and the basics I am happy. People, not things matter more to me. He likes more expensive things. I’m probably scared to have the future talk tbh!

Why not tell him that op? Say you weren’t planning on having the future talk right now but the lodger issue has led to you think about it. Maybe tell him it’s giving you signals that he’s not that serious and is that a correct assumption? Far better to find out now than several years down the line.

It all depends on how old your dc are and whose idea it was not to live together “any time soon”? If it was your idea then you can’t really blame him for having a side hustle until you become more available. In his shoes though I would have tried to find a lodger who’s there mid-week but not every weekend.

Whatdayisitalexa · 12/03/2023 11:23

Financial security is more important to some more than others for sure. Making hay while the sun shines gives you a cushion if things change, and they can do as we've seen over the last few years. Life is much shorter than you think too.

Shelby2010 · 12/03/2023 11:22

It would make me uncomfortable too. Especially if it means he spends more time at your house & costing you more whilst he has extra income coming in.

It would be different if he already had lodgers before you met or was struggling for money.