Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL suggesting a mum who loved her kids wouldn’t go back to work

85 replies

Allthesweets · 11/03/2023 20:45

This conversation with my SIL really niggled at me and upset me at the time. My SIL has a habit of making indirect digs at people which I’ve never called her out on. I also absolutely disagree with her.

I am on maternity leave, and she is 8 months pregnant with her much longed for first via IVF.

We were chatting about Mat leave and she asked what I would be doing after Mat leave. I replied that I would be going back to work 4 days a week (financial reasons and I’m also looking forward to going back to a job I love). I didn’t get much response, but she replied with she only wanted to go back part time after her Mat leave and eventually stop work altogether.

I then asked what a mutual friend of ours would be doing, who has a 7 month old baby girl. Her reply was that she believed said friend would be leaving her career to stay at home with her baby. I was surprised to which my SIL said ‘well yeah, she loves her baby.’

Personally I feel like this was a dig at me. I also feel the sentiment that if you love your baby then you’ll quit your job or won’t work is way off the mark.

Aibu?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
lightisnotwhite · 12/03/2023 19:33

Botw1 · 12/03/2023 10:32

@lightisnotwhite

You don't think saying parents aren't willing to put the graft in on a thread about working parents not loving their kids as much as sahms is an insult?

Im not sure how else you could interpret that tbh.

I don't stay at home with my kids because I don't want to.

It doesn't mean I don't love them or that I don't put the graft in.

It just means I don't want to be a sahm. It's not an ideal I aspire to.

Some parents clearly don’t. I have worked with parents that have literally said “ I don’t do young children”. Nothing to do with love or work or anything else.

InsertMoniker · 12/03/2023 16:02

You said you expressed surprise that another woman was giving up work. Perhaps your SIL found your words offensive?

Quite. I was a sahm and had this reaction often enough for it to be irritating.
Why be surprised? We can afford it, and I love being home with my children.

I can't understand why that's so hard to believe. I really, really enjoyed being home with my children and was grateful that I was in a position to do so.

DrCoconut · 12/03/2023 15:40

I bet she has an opinion about mums on benefits too. You can see a lot of people's cogs turning when they realise that you work because you have to and that they themselves have said universal credit claimants should be forced to work etc.

AbsoluteYawns · 12/03/2023 15:39

Obviously your SIL is an idiot!
Each woman makes their own choice which is born after considering many things.
There is no 'one rule fits all'

Reallybadidea · 12/03/2023 15:33

You will not be doing your children any favours by not earning money and not putting money aside for your pension

This. It is slightly terrifying how many women are financially disadvantaging themselves by giving up work or going very part time. Even if you're happily married to a high earner it's a massive risk IMHO. I think we've been brainwashed by society to think that it's what good mothers do.

shattered25 · 12/03/2023 15:31

I found you just can't win 😂 your a SAHM and your an entitlement mum who can't provide and a scrounger...you go to work and you don't love or care for your children and palming them off.

When family member ask me what my plan is I honestly don't know what to say haha what ever I think is best will somehow be wrong and turn me into a horrible woman.

She might be being opinionated and judgemental, or it could be she feels defensive about the topic :( just know that what ever you do or decide, your thinking of the needs of your family. They are all irrelevant x

Ladydinosaur · 12/03/2023 15:31

Years ago,I was a single mum,on benefits and never had a penny from their sperm doner

i took so much shit from family for ‘being a sponger’,‘I have to be up at six to pay for benefit scroungers-they rely on me’,‘I can’t bear people who beg for money from the state’,’must be nice to have the government feed your kids’ etc

then,tax credits kicked in and I could afford to work-for money,my sanity,to show my kids you have to work to be able to live,to feed/clothe them

The shit I got from the same family members was just as unreal

’why have kids if your not going to look after them’,’women should have kids or work-they shouldn’t do both’,’money more important than them?’,’you never see them’ (I worked 16 hours a week-I work full time now) and horrid comments about ‘career women’

honest to god,I couldn’t win-still got sniffy comments about ‘being on benefits’ as I claimed tax credits

best bit was-my mother was the worst for the comments!

(she had me in a world where there was no maternity leave and women didn’t work-if she’d had me now,I’d have been in full time nursery without a hint of guilt)

the irony isn’t lost on me at all

jemimapuddlepluck · 12/03/2023 15:17

Fucking hell, the reaching some posters will do to make it all op's fault 😂
OP, shes a dick. If she says something similar again ask what she means by that. People say shit like that cos no one dares pull them on it. Bet she stutters if you actually ask her to clarify what she means.

SeemsSoUnfair · 12/03/2023 15:14

I was surprised to which my SIL said ‘well yeah, she loves her baby.’

Too much to unwrap as it will all come down to tone and context.

Why were you "surprised" many women choose to be SAHM, especially in the early years it is not unusual.

Did your "surprise" or did you say it in a way that implied judgement and your SIL felt she had to defend her friend and meant she loves spending time with her baby and is prioritising, and is fortunate enough to have the choice to, it over her career.

If she was truly having a go at your for being a WOHM then I would have replied with either - yeah I obviously hate mine, or remind her she also works, albeit part time so does that mean she not love hers enough!

billy1966 · 12/03/2023 14:42

MrsTerryPratchett · 11/03/2023 21:02

I can't actually think of a way that comment wasn't really shitty. Can you?

Agree.

A very nasty comment.

However, she's giving you a valuable heads up as to what a PITA she is likely to be as a new mother, so I would be very wary.

Someone so dim and obtuse is likely to be a competitive mother and IMO the very last person you will want to spend time with on Mat leave.

Have your excuses ready and pull back now in preparation for avoiding her and her stupidity.

bluegreygreen · 12/03/2023 14:36

So...

OP is going back to work part time
OP's SIL is going back to work part time, though would like to stop work at some point
Mutual friend is staying at home
OP expresses surprise, SIL says 'she loves her baby'.

It sounds to me like OP was the one who made the judgemental comment - and I don't see how SIL is making a dig at OP for doing what she herself is doing ...

Tinkerbyebye · 12/03/2023 12:29

I don’t understand, she said she is going back part time so the same applies to her

Goldie2021 · 12/03/2023 11:52

I feel like you’re reading too much into her reply.

LindorDoubleChoc · 12/03/2023 10:47

Oh so what if it was a "dig"? Stop brooding on it. Lots of people feel the same way as your SIL and you'll just have to tough it out unfortunately. Or find your voice and say something!

Conkersinautumn · 12/03/2023 10:42

sheis going back to work and doesn't want to and you immediately go to her making a dig at you. Does dhe often make digs at you or do you feel generally everyone is making digs at you. It sounds as though she is struggling with where she's at

LouandNala · 12/03/2023 10:40

It likely wasn't a dig at you.

custardbear · 12/03/2023 10:38

I bloody hate this mindset! Sone people want to be mums and housewives like yesteryear, but many women have careers and finances being as they are need to work. She's being a bitch and trying to look down at you. I'd remind her about her views being just as ok as yours, and everyone (well there are exceptions!) loves their baby /ies

Botw1 · 12/03/2023 10:32

@lightisnotwhite

You don't think saying parents aren't willing to put the graft in on a thread about working parents not loving their kids as much as sahms is an insult?

Im not sure how else you could interpret that tbh.

I don't stay at home with my kids because I don't want to.

It doesn't mean I don't love them or that I don't put the graft in.

It just means I don't want to be a sahm. It's not an ideal I aspire to.

HistoryFanatic · 12/03/2023 10:30

She will probably be desperate to return to work at the end of her maternity leave!

Beaniesmumsie · 12/03/2023 10:26

She’s an arsehole. I’ve had comments like that too… ‘oh I don’t know how you can go back to work full time and leave your one year old, I miss mine too much so I quit to spend time with mine’

um…. I have an established career and I don’t want to compromise our current lifestyle. Also my husband is not a high earner (earns ok but not mega bucks)

next time just ask her if she means to imply that you don’t love your kid?

lightisnotwhite · 12/03/2023 10:22

Botw1 · 11/03/2023 23:13

@lightisnotwhite

How many hours to parents need to parent to be putting the graft in?

You appear to be dissing people who keep you in employment?

People are saying they need to work therefore not being at home isn’t an option. I’m throwing it out there that other people don’t stay at home with the kids for other reasons.

Youre saying I’m dissing my previous employers for using a nanny for non work purposes. I haven’t. That’s your judgement of the situation.

VivX · 11/03/2023 23:36

Don't over think this. Do what is right for your family, let your friend do what is right for hers and let your SIL discover what choices she'll have to make as a parent.

Returning or not returning to work is only one of the many decisions a parent has to make and that other people will have give their (unsolicited) opinion on. Give yourself a break and let it all wash over you.
Congratulations on your baby

whiteroseredrose · 11/03/2023 23:23

DarkShade · 11/03/2023 22:30

It's very hard. If she's making a dig at you, then obviosuly not acceptable. How did you express your suprise? It you said something like "Fucking hell, really?" maybe it was automatic. I had to send my child to nursery for financial reasons earlier than I wanted to, and I hated it. Still now that they're 3 I wish I could spend more time with them, it makes me sad every single day, I feel like I am wasting the best days of my life in a stupid office, days that will be over and gone in a blink of an eye. If I was being unthinking and someone asked me why, I probably wouldn't spew all of that at them, an easy way to verbalise how I feel is to say 'I love him, I miss him, I like spending time with him'. I do not at all think that women who choose differently don't also love their children.

It's sad isn't it. I felt the same with DS.

vdbfamily · 11/03/2023 23:23

I think YABU because she had just told you she was going back to work part- time, so presumably was not suggesting that mothers who work so not love their children

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 11/03/2023 23:22

Lastnamedidntstick · 11/03/2023 21:01

My mum actually said “people shouldn’t have children if they aren’t going to stay at home and look after them”.

some people are odd.

My mum said this too.

My mum used to be a childminder Confused. She also said this to me when my kids were about 10 and 13, knowing full well the older two were in full time nursery for a while!