Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want clothes to be the size they say they are 🤷🏻‍♀️

34 replies

Sparrow80 · 11/03/2023 19:39

I don’t even care any more if they use vanity sizing and say a 34 inch waste is a size 10. But I want the clothes that say they are a 32 inch waist to have a 32 inch waist?! I’ve lost a significant amount of weight in the last year or so and have to order new clothes for a new job but it’s proving impossible.

I’m currently wearing a series of size 8 - 10 clothing. I’m very active but have a BMI of 26 and fit the measurements of a size 14 or 16. I must have tried on hundreds of dresses, tops and jeans recently based on their size charts and every single one is too big. I’ve measured the clothes myself in frustration and they are much bigger than what they say.

I end up re-ordering in a smaller size and again … and again til I’m wearing a size 8 when I’m nowhere near. I wear a 34 E bra and my legs are toned but nowhere near a size 8. What do people who are actually an 8 do?!

Mens clothing does not do this. If I order a medium based on measurements it fits. Meanwhile I just ordered some older clothes on eBay from Boden circa 2013 (haven’t liked anything since) in my actual size and they fit.

Has anyone found any shops that are actually making clothes in the size they say they are? I really don’t care what number it says on the label but am driving myself and the postman mad with all the returns and I can’t live in leggings forever. This is not cheaper clothing either - I’ve had the same from supermarket all the way up to the expensive ranges.

YANBU - sizing should reflect the size chart

YABU - the surprise of the actual size of what arrives is part of the fun

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ReneBumsWombats · 15/03/2023 10:46

Needanewnamebeingwatched · 15/03/2023 09:26

Hey can't women's clothing be sized like mens

Chest size
Waist size
Seat size
Inside leg

In normal measurements rather than a 12, 14 etc what does that even mean?

The sizing numbers are based on archaic methods of scaling.

There is far more variation in women's bodies and in clothing styles than in men's, so the measurement by inches thing is much more complicated. Although some vintage style stores do measure by waist size.

Some of them also make a point of using sizing from the 50s so you will indeed find yourself a couple of sizes larger. So much for vanity sizing...

Mutabiliss · 15/03/2023 09:36

Someone who worked in Bravissimo once told me that black clothes will always fit smaller - it's something to do with the dying process. I've always checked this when trying on different colours of the same garment, and it's always the case.

Mutabiliss · 15/03/2023 09:33

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 14/03/2023 05:59

I ordered the same pair of trousers from Next in its 2 available colours. Both should be the same, just a different colour denim.

Nope - black pair perfect length but tighter waist.

  • blue pair perfect waist but about 4 inches too long.

I checked and double checked and the size labels on them are the same. Clearly a mis-labelling.

I bought a pair of jeans I really liked from Next recently, so ordered another pair - same size, same colour. The waist on the new ones was two inches smaller. The legs fit the same though, so it's not mislabeled - just wrong waist band. Or do mine have the wrong waistband? Who knows. It's so fucking annoying.

Needanewnamebeingwatched · 15/03/2023 09:26

Hey can't women's clothing be sized like mens

Chest size
Waist size
Seat size
Inside leg

In normal measurements rather than a 12, 14 etc what does that even mean?

mrsrobin · 14/03/2023 20:48

I feel for you OP. Nothing ever fits as expected - so sick of shopping for clothes. You simply cannot go by their charts - I should be a 14 according to the chart for the last pair of trousers I bought - but the 10 fits me perfect. So annoying. You end up simply taking a punt!

70sDuvet · 14/03/2023 20:31

Last year I was a bit underweight due to illness, there was nothing in high street stores to buy. (Apart from maybe primark but the v small sizes also were for toned 17 year old who want to show belly and side boob)
In Dunnes XS was falling down while my mum who was 5 stone heavier was in a medium.

Now I'm mainly a 6, but I took a chance on the most amazing shirt maxi dress from coast in an 8, and it won't even button - whereas an m&s 6 still has room for about 6 massive meals back to back.

It's ridiculous

Reddahlias · 14/03/2023 19:51

We're getting fatter and the market is adapting.

But why is a size 10 now much larger than it used to be?

If people gain weight, they can buy larger sizes. Manufacturers don't need to change the sizing?

I have always been a size 10, but for the last 4-5 years or so I've been buying size 6 or 8 and these clothes are as large as my old size 10 clothes!!

Cotswoldmama · 14/03/2023 19:45

I was always a 6-8 now I'm a 4. It's shit. It's really hard to find anything to fit me.

LakieLady · 14/03/2023 19:32

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 14/03/2023 05:59

I ordered the same pair of trousers from Next in its 2 available colours. Both should be the same, just a different colour denim.

Nope - black pair perfect length but tighter waist.

  • blue pair perfect waist but about 4 inches too long.

I checked and double checked and the size labels on them are the same. Clearly a mis-labelling.

I bought 2 pairs of jeans from White Stuff; same size, same style, different colours.

The blue pair fit me perfectly but the black pair are much tighter in the leg and practically cut off the circulation to my knees.

It's fucking infuriating, especially as I didn't bother trying on the black pair for a while, and now it's too late to return them.

BobcatDreams · 14/03/2023 19:25

Just talking about this today as I'd ordered a pair of men's walking trousers and they fit perfectly, I'd say I have five different brands of women's walking trousers in 14 all completely different widths.
I like it on eBay when people put stretched and unstretched width of trousers, it really helps, but yes men's trousers tend to be the width they say they are.
When even manufacturers of technical gear think we want to lie to ourselves then it's a poor do.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/03/2023 19:25

Beds are getting bigger, albeit at a slower rate than clothes. If you look at mattresses from the 1960s you see it. Chairs are bigger too.

We are certainly getting bigger, and so are our clothes to accommodate that. No denying it.

It's just that it's not a conspiracy to prevent fat people from finding out that they're fat. It is nothing to do with vanity. It's to do with adapting to a fast changing market. It would be ridiculous never to update, or we would still be using Victorian patterns.

modgepodge · 14/03/2023 19:07

ReneBumsWombats · 14/03/2023 17:52

If there was some kind of enforcement of absolute uniformity in sizing, only the fit models would get clothes. Shops profile their customers and some demographics are slimmer than others. That's why you're a different size depending on where you shop. Nor is it vanity sizing. They're not trying to kid you into thinking you're slim. It's size inflation. We're getting fatter and the market is adapting. Bed and chair makers do it too but we don't have the same emotions about those.

Size inconsistency is getting insane, though. I'm wondering if it has anything to do with the absolute explosion in fast fashion coming out of dodgy factories. Everyone says they'd rather have a very small number of high quality pieces than a load of cheap rubbish, but the sales don't lie.

The fact we are getting fatter doesn’t explain why I measure myself, look at their size chart and see that makes me a large (for example), then the large doesn’t actually fit, I actually need a small.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 14/03/2023 18:08

ReneBumsWombats · 14/03/2023 17:52

If there was some kind of enforcement of absolute uniformity in sizing, only the fit models would get clothes. Shops profile their customers and some demographics are slimmer than others. That's why you're a different size depending on where you shop. Nor is it vanity sizing. They're not trying to kid you into thinking you're slim. It's size inflation. We're getting fatter and the market is adapting. Bed and chair makers do it too but we don't have the same emotions about those.

Size inconsistency is getting insane, though. I'm wondering if it has anything to do with the absolute explosion in fast fashion coming out of dodgy factories. Everyone says they'd rather have a very small number of high quality pieces than a load of cheap rubbish, but the sales don't lie.

Bed makers? Standard bed sizes haven't changed for years. It is the one thing that annoys me about double beds, they just aren't big enough for 2 people to sleep comfortable ( and I am a skinny minnie). We are just generally bigger all over than say, people in 1900. You only have to visit a museum and see for example, old soldiers' uniforms from the first world war. They're tiny. Young people are really really tall these days! But no, we keep our standard UK single bed size and wonder why our lanky teens have their feet hanging out the end.

Re clothes and sizing variation. I'm more of the opinion that it's just poor, low quality clothes production. You have to spend a lot of money these days to buy, eg a dress that has a decent thickness to the material, and is lined, and hemmed properly with no loose bits of thread. I think they are literally thrown together and that includes in the design too.

ReneBumsWombats · 14/03/2023 17:52

If there was some kind of enforcement of absolute uniformity in sizing, only the fit models would get clothes. Shops profile their customers and some demographics are slimmer than others. That's why you're a different size depending on where you shop. Nor is it vanity sizing. They're not trying to kid you into thinking you're slim. It's size inflation. We're getting fatter and the market is adapting. Bed and chair makers do it too but we don't have the same emotions about those.

Size inconsistency is getting insane, though. I'm wondering if it has anything to do with the absolute explosion in fast fashion coming out of dodgy factories. Everyone says they'd rather have a very small number of high quality pieces than a load of cheap rubbish, but the sales don't lie.

modgepodge · 14/03/2023 17:47

This winds me up too OP. I hate online shopping. They provide a size chart but it’s always nonsense. I generally wear a size 14-16. If I measure my busy, waist and hips, most shops put me at least an 18, if not a 20 or even 22!! Yet if I order the size they tell me I am, I end up with something far too big (and my sister telling me ‘I told you so!’) and have to return it. WHY PRODUCE A SIZE CHART THEN??

literally received a bridesmaids dress yesterday which fits like a glove, despite me being 6 inches bigger than the measurements suggest I should be to fit that size.

Reddahlias · 14/03/2023 17:47

I used to be size 10 for years.

Recently, over the past few years, I've started buying sizes 6 and 8, despite being exactly the same size as before!

Bagzzz · 14/03/2023 17:40

Sparrow80 · 14/03/2023 09:22

@Bagzzz - what I'm finding is they do provide the widths / lengths etc and they're nowhere near what they say they are. I'm currently sat in clothing that claims it's got a 26 inch waist but in fact is fairly loose on my 32 inch waist. It's like vanity sizing got even crazier. Shops must spend so much time and money having stuff returned.

Yeah it would need to be regulated but it’s not really a priority.

Curiosity101 · 14/03/2023 10:08

I use What size am I and have found it to be pretty accurate. If you combine that with a knowledge of your overall shape, how you like clothes to fit and that different styles will vary on their sizing then it's fine.

A pair of size 14 skinny leather trousers (tight and inflexible) to fit the same as a pair of wide leg cotton relaxed fit trousers (probably bigger with a looser waist). A size 14 cropped vest top (tight style) will fit very different to a size 14 slub shirt (very oversized). They will have very different measurements but they are the same 'size'.

Youcunnyfunt · 14/03/2023 10:01

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 14/03/2023 05:59

I ordered the same pair of trousers from Next in its 2 available colours. Both should be the same, just a different colour denim.

Nope - black pair perfect length but tighter waist.

  • blue pair perfect waist but about 4 inches too long.

I checked and double checked and the size labels on them are the same. Clearly a mis-labelling.

This is because a lot of jeans manufacturers do the measurements based off the fabric when it's cut, not the final sewed garment, and it's pre-dye and fabric treatment. Black denim shrinks a lot, which is why you're seeing a massive difference between the blue and black denim. It's a super stupid method of setting the sizes, but that's how they do it. And is why Levis is so irregular with sizes and why the same exact jeans can fit slightly differently even in the exact same wash and measurement (allegedly).

I don't know why manufacturers don't use accurate measurements based on the final garment. But I'm with you - I often just buy an 8 or 10 even though based on measurements I "should" be a 14 or 16. And I'm not squishy, I have an athletic frame, so it's not stretchy clothes squeezing on me!

Sparrow80 · 14/03/2023 09:22

@Bagzzz - what I'm finding is they do provide the widths / lengths etc and they're nowhere near what they say they are. I'm currently sat in clothing that claims it's got a 26 inch waist but in fact is fairly loose on my 32 inch waist. It's like vanity sizing got even crazier. Shops must spend so much time and money having stuff returned.

OP posts:
Bagzzz · 14/03/2023 06:41

Yes should have to provide lengths etc rather than M or 12 at least online. I doubt Councils would have time to enforce but customers and organisations like Which would get onto it.

MoltenLasagne · 14/03/2023 06:39

Drives me insane. I have a size 6 top that I only just don't fit into now at the very end of my pregnancy. It says it's a relaxed fit but it was about 8 inches too big to wear pre-maternity.

Justleaveitblankthen · 14/03/2023 06:34

This drives me mad.

Been the same weight all my adult life.. Circa 1986 I was a size 10...Now bizarrely a size 6-8.
Ridiculous.

M&S are the worst for vanity sizing. For Xmas I was asked my size and gifted a skirt from a friend. Size six was falling down to my knees! I had no receipt and had already taken off the tags.
Managed to take it to the nearest store (10 miles away) and they kindly refunded me..

MintJulia · 14/03/2023 06:24

I feel your pain. I ordered a size 12 tshirt, because I wanted a relaxed fit.

What arrived, I could quite easily have worn at 9 months pregnant so I returned it and ordered the 10 instead. I've just finished taking that in. It's ridiculous.

PandasAreUseless · 14/03/2023 06:18

Yes me too. I've always worn a size 10. I am NOT a size 8. But I order the 10 in amything at the moment and its massive, causing me a load of admin in sending it back. Or I end up thinking "I'll make do" and it never looks as good as I'd hoped.

Swipe left for the next trending thread