Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is DISGRACEFUL! Massive tax credits overpayment!

355 replies

CrumblingKnees · 11/03/2023 15:57

Just furious that common sense is not prevailing and I am essentially being robbed of money by HMRC!

So, twin DC finished education in summer 2021. Both have a disability, DH works but we were entitled to tax credits as wage not massive and we got the higher rate due to disability. I remember getting a letter saying tax credits would stop from August 31st due to this. Was aware and knew I’d have to find a job to cover the shortfall.

Payments stopped and I then started working in November 2021. I do remember getting some letters from them but ignored as as far as I was concerned claim had ended (stupid I know). Youngest was diagnosed with a serious illness last summer and I’ve been a bit of a mess, not keeping on top of things like I normally am.

Anyway got a letter from them a few weeks ago saying we’d been overpaid almost £2,000! Shocked, rang and basically they’d added on my work income from November onwards to my tax credit claim for that year (it was not closed). I assumed claim had ended in August and if it had been there would be no overpayment!

I’ve explained this and filed a dispute. They’ve come back today and said that as I didn’t dispute before the end of Jan the overpayment stands and we need to pay it!

AIBU to think this is a pisstake and totally wrong for a government agency to take money from families like this?

OP posts:
TomatoSandwiches · 14/03/2023 10:06

The lack of financial literacy and personal accountability on here is extremely depressing.

Glitteratitar · 14/03/2023 09:48

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 08:54

Sorry @CrumblingKnees i mentioned you in wrong context previously - I was answering another commentator. I think you have been sorely treated as you tried to do the right thing and got caught up in bureaucracy that isn’t fair.

@Lovelyveg82 , @Glitteratitar and @berksandbeyond

Wow check out the judgement.
I didn’t say I can’t afford my kids - though sudden rent and cost of living increases have made times tough - I merely think a “tax credits for two children only” policy makes the other kids seem less valid. Do you all agree that some kids are less valid than others? really? Some people matter more?

I am a number six of six myself and grew up with the constant comments, in front of me to my parents, indicating I was basically superfluous to requirements. These attitudes shock me - it’s so damn judgemental and mean. I think OP is right to find the system mean and inconsistent - I also find it so. That’s all. I love and care for my kids.
It’s stupid to suggest paying tax credits encourages people to have more and more children - in my experience people make those decisions for very different reasons - as I have pointed out - and it remains true that the vast majority of people in our culture prefer smaller families for a host of reasons - all are valid choices - why attack me for mine? And please - don’t you dare with the unemployed bullshit. My DH and I both work our arses off, I just don’t happen to be paid for it. We made a decision for me to work as a mum at home - I home educate my kids and my eldest has severe special needs for which I get no practical support as she is deemed “too complex”. Yes - mums who go out to work (as both my sisters do) also work extremely hard and are full time mums - I only use the phrase because “housewife” is very out of vogue.
I am not attacking anyone’s choices - I am pointing out government does little to help families - and families remain the bedrock of society.
I think it’s so sad to see these attitudes - because it ends up affecting the way we treat children. All my kids are so loved and well provided for. But people let these views affect how they act - I have a sister in law who makes it quite clear she thinks my youngest two shouldn’t really be here - it’s appalling.

No one is criticising your decision to have several children…we’re criticising your expectation that other people should pay for them.

IhearyouClemFandango · 14/03/2023 09:35

But everyone decides how many kids they can afford surely, that isn't a benefits question but a matter of common sense.

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 08:54

Sorry @CrumblingKnees i mentioned you in wrong context previously - I was answering another commentator. I think you have been sorely treated as you tried to do the right thing and got caught up in bureaucracy that isn’t fair.

@Lovelyveg82 , @Glitteratitar and @berksandbeyond

Wow check out the judgement.
I didn’t say I can’t afford my kids - though sudden rent and cost of living increases have made times tough - I merely think a “tax credits for two children only” policy makes the other kids seem less valid. Do you all agree that some kids are less valid than others? really? Some people matter more?

I am a number six of six myself and grew up with the constant comments, in front of me to my parents, indicating I was basically superfluous to requirements. These attitudes shock me - it’s so damn judgemental and mean. I think OP is right to find the system mean and inconsistent - I also find it so. That’s all. I love and care for my kids.
It’s stupid to suggest paying tax credits encourages people to have more and more children - in my experience people make those decisions for very different reasons - as I have pointed out - and it remains true that the vast majority of people in our culture prefer smaller families for a host of reasons - all are valid choices - why attack me for mine? And please - don’t you dare with the unemployed bullshit. My DH and I both work our arses off, I just don’t happen to be paid for it. We made a decision for me to work as a mum at home - I home educate my kids and my eldest has severe special needs for which I get no practical support as she is deemed “too complex”. Yes - mums who go out to work (as both my sisters do) also work extremely hard and are full time mums - I only use the phrase because “housewife” is very out of vogue.
I am not attacking anyone’s choices - I am pointing out government does little to help families - and families remain the bedrock of society.
I think it’s so sad to see these attitudes - because it ends up affecting the way we treat children. All my kids are so loved and well provided for. But people let these views affect how they act - I have a sister in law who makes it quite clear she thinks my youngest two shouldn’t really be here - it’s appalling.

blumppump · 14/03/2023 08:45

@thismamayogi how long were you pregnant for?

In the 2015 Summer Budget, the Government announced that the child element of child tax credit (CTC) would be limited to two children for those born after 6 April 2017 unless certain exceptions apply

berksandbeyond · 14/03/2023 08:29

All mums are full time mums. I’m not no longer a mum when I’m at work.

People just like to say ‘full time mum’ because it sounds better than ‘unemployed’

Glitteratitar · 14/03/2023 08:26

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 08:19

@CrumblingKnees
So only those who are affluent should be “allowed” to have lots of kids? Or a Chinese style ban on more than one/two is to be welcomed? This is dangerous ground. You have to follow that through.
if full time mothers were not penalised for making a choice to raise their own kids full time, perhaps the poverty of the same wouldn’t be an issue.

Yes…let’s encourage a system where people have more and more children that they can’t afford and expect those who have made a conscious decision to limit their family because of what they can afford pay for them instead. Great idea!

Amispringy · 14/03/2023 08:24

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 07:26

Yes. It is shocking. The government is horrific to families - not least the policy of only laying tax credits for two children since 2017 - I have five kids and three of them born since April 2017 and we get no tax credits for them at all. My sister with older kids gets tc for all four. It’s crazy.

Why is it crazy? You knew before having the last 3

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 08:24

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 08:23

Actually I was already pregnant with number three when the loo T was brought in. We then made the shocking decision not to let the government decide how many kids we wanted.

Too right

So you shouldn’t be “horrified” by the government implementing parameters around benefits

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 08:23

policy

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 08:23

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 08:17

So since 2017 you’ve had three further children.

You knew the policy. And went on to have a further 3 children 🤷‍♀️ .

Actually I was already pregnant with number three when the loo T was brought in. We then made the shocking decision not to let the government decide how many kids we wanted.

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 08:19

@CrumblingKnees
So only those who are affluent should be “allowed” to have lots of kids? Or a Chinese style ban on more than one/two is to be welcomed? This is dangerous ground. You have to follow that through.
if full time mothers were not penalised for making a choice to raise their own kids full time, perhaps the poverty of the same wouldn’t be an issue.

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 08:17

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 07:26

Yes. It is shocking. The government is horrific to families - not least the policy of only laying tax credits for two children since 2017 - I have five kids and three of them born since April 2017 and we get no tax credits for them at all. My sister with older kids gets tc for all four. It’s crazy.

So since 2017 you’ve had three further children.

You knew the policy. And went on to have a further 3 children 🤷‍♀️ .

whowhatwerewhy · 14/03/2023 08:05

@thismamayogi
Well yes the government woke up to the fact the number of children you have is a lifestyle choice ( multiple births exempted) and you choose to have them you pay for them

MissHoneysHappyEnding · 14/03/2023 07:39

DWP need to take more accountability for the impact this has on mental health. I work, have always worked FT, so did ex-dp. We claimed for childcare as we had two under two (twins) and were both in minimum wage jobs. We weren't entitled as soon as they got their free hours.
Last year (they are both 6) we had a letter saying that we had been overpaid in the year 2018 and we needed to repay the full amount (1200) in a months time. No explanation. My ex was in the house on his own and has MH issues, he thought they were going to repossess the house. He actually self harmed because he was in such a bad place and the letter just sent him into a spiral of anxiety.
I had been making repayments all of that time out of my salary and there was no mention of that in the letter. No mention of a repayment plan at all. When I raised it with them via my local MP they took no responsibility for how the letters were worded, no accountability fir not putting any context on the letters, nothing! This is despite there being numerous news stories of people committing suicide after receiving debt letters and that this letter was sent to him and not me, who received the payments and was also the one paying the repayments.

IhearyouClemFandango · 14/03/2023 07:29

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 07:26

Yes. It is shocking. The government is horrific to families - not least the policy of only laying tax credits for two children since 2017 - I have five kids and three of them born since April 2017 and we get no tax credits for them at all. My sister with older kids gets tc for all four. It’s crazy.

Which you knew, before having them though?

Florissant · 14/03/2023 07:28

berksandbeyond · 14/03/2023 07:27

You chose to have five children, why should anyone else pay for them?

That's a good question.

Florissant · 14/03/2023 07:28

Hellocatshome · 13/03/2023 07:57

MPs are not there to try to fiddle the system. No mistake has been made this is how the Tax Credits system works.

I am sure the HMRC teams are recruited on the basis of lacking empathy or pragmatism.

HMRC are being very pragmatic about money owed. (It's always a good idea to know what a word means before using it.)

berksandbeyond · 14/03/2023 07:27

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 07:26

Yes. It is shocking. The government is horrific to families - not least the policy of only laying tax credits for two children since 2017 - I have five kids and three of them born since April 2017 and we get no tax credits for them at all. My sister with older kids gets tc for all four. It’s crazy.

You chose to have five children, why should anyone else pay for them?

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 07:26

Yes. It is shocking. The government is horrific to families - not least the policy of only laying tax credits for two children since 2017 - I have five kids and three of them born since April 2017 and we get no tax credits for them at all. My sister with older kids gets tc for all four. It’s crazy.

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 07:15

Glitteratitar · 14/03/2023 06:18

I mean countless people have tried to explain it on this thread yet OP denies she was overpaid. So that, combined with her ignoring letters, suggests there does seem to be some deliberate ignorance on the part of OP

Either why… she will get no where with any daft appeal. She WILL have to pay it back, which is a good thing.

Aganta · 14/03/2023 07:15

She wasn't overpaid at the time she received the money though. That's why it's a really horrible system to deal with.

She did what she was supposed to in that she kept her information with them up to date. So it wasn't an overpayment in the sense that she got too much money.

It still isn't really - she needed the money because her income was low. When she received it, I guarantee that it did not come with a letter saying 'we will claw this back off you if you start work before next April ' and without that information it doesn't matter a damn which letters you do or don't read.

Glitteratitar · 14/03/2023 06:18

whowhatwerewhy · 14/03/2023 05:46

@Aganta
If she had understood that tax credits were a yearly assessment it would not of come as a shock to her that her wages for that year were taken into account.

I mean countless people have tried to explain it on this thread yet OP denies she was overpaid. So that, combined with her ignoring letters, suggests there does seem to be some deliberate ignorance on the part of OP

whowhatwerewhy · 14/03/2023 05:46

@Aganta
If she had understood that tax credits were a yearly assessment it would not of come as a shock to her that her wages for that year were taken into account.

Aganta · 13/03/2023 22:44

whowhatwerewhy · 13/03/2023 07:53

No op it's not disgraceful that there has been financial support for you and your family, it's not disgraceful that your children ( adults) will now have access to financial support that's appropriate to there disability. What is disgraceful is your inability to open your own post and understand the system that has supported you over the years .

It wouldn't have mattered how many letters she opened. OP would have been categorised as being overpaid regardless of the fact that she was entitled to the money at the time she received it. Because that's how tax credits work.