Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is DISGRACEFUL! Massive tax credits overpayment!

355 replies

CrumblingKnees · 11/03/2023 15:57

Just furious that common sense is not prevailing and I am essentially being robbed of money by HMRC!

So, twin DC finished education in summer 2021. Both have a disability, DH works but we were entitled to tax credits as wage not massive and we got the higher rate due to disability. I remember getting a letter saying tax credits would stop from August 31st due to this. Was aware and knew I’d have to find a job to cover the shortfall.

Payments stopped and I then started working in November 2021. I do remember getting some letters from them but ignored as as far as I was concerned claim had ended (stupid I know). Youngest was diagnosed with a serious illness last summer and I’ve been a bit of a mess, not keeping on top of things like I normally am.

Anyway got a letter from them a few weeks ago saying we’d been overpaid almost £2,000! Shocked, rang and basically they’d added on my work income from November onwards to my tax credit claim for that year (it was not closed). I assumed claim had ended in August and if it had been there would be no overpayment!

I’ve explained this and filed a dispute. They’ve come back today and said that as I didn’t dispute before the end of Jan the overpayment stands and we need to pay it!

AIBU to think this is a pisstake and totally wrong for a government agency to take money from families like this?

OP posts:
TomatoSandwiches · 14/03/2023 18:03

No not exempt, but there are grey areas imo.

Rosieposy89 · 14/03/2023 18:02

Tax credits are calculated by assessing income from tax year which runs from April-April over a year. If by starting work in November your average income increased by £2500 or more that Tax year there will be an overpayment.

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 17:59

Which they would have to do

but you think they should be exempt?

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 17:58

If they have inherited such a large sum of money that they are able to accrue a substantial level of interest in a short space of time as to mean they receive more than they are entitled to.
I do not have a problem with them being required to pay it back 😐

Justforlaffs · 14/03/2023 17:58

Pay it back at £5 per month if you are worried about it- tell them that’s all you can afford.

They won’t do anything - they can’t. They’d have to take you to court and provide evidence etc, which they don’t - they send these letters out Willy-nilly and most people ignore them and after about 6 years they stop trying.

People on here will try to scare you and tell you untruths but the fact of the matter is they don’t have the resources to chase people for the money!

TomatoSandwiches · 14/03/2023 17:53

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 17:44

If you have substantial interest from savings and investment… that means you have very substantial savings and investments indeed!!

Well that's quite obvious 😂but it may be that someone inherits a substantial sum to say buy a house but they need time to find and purchase, they stick it in a few accounts and the interest takes them over the threshold.
I can't find myself overly bothered if such a situation occurred especially if they were going from council property/housing benefit payments to a home owner, within a time limit of course.

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 17:44

TomatoSandwiches · 14/03/2023 17:21

Interest from savings and investments is counted as additional income, just not the savings.

If you have substantial interest from savings and investment… that means you have very substantial savings and investments indeed!!

TomatoSandwiches · 14/03/2023 17:21

Babyroobs · 14/03/2023 16:05

Thank goodness it's changed now then. Ridiculous being able to have unlimited savings and claim hundreds in tax credits a month. Who ever thought up that system?

Interest from savings and investments is counted as additional income, just not the savings.

Onnabugeisha · 14/03/2023 16:16

CrumblingKnees · 11/03/2023 16:11

I WAS NOT PAID MORE THAN WE WERE ENTITLED TO.

Payments were correct up to August. They added on my work income FROM NOVEMBER AFTER payments ended and we were no longer entitled to tax credits.

Seriously!

Yes you were overpaid. Your tax credit payments from 5 April to the end of summer would have been based on you being unemployed for the entire tax year of 5 April 20221- 4 April 2022.

The fact you went and got a job in Nov 2021, means your household income went up over what was projected for the tax year 21/22 which meant you were paid more than you were entitled to as the tax credit entitlement is based on annual income for the tax year.

Thats why it’s called a tax credit. Tax. It’s in the name.

Babyroobs · 14/03/2023 16:05

gloriawasright · 14/03/2023 15:21

One of the reasons for reluctance to switch from tax credits to UC is the buzzard difference in savings rule.
UC £6k ( I might be wrong and it is £16k,but money taken off for each £250 or so)
Tax credits have no savings rule .

Thank goodness it's changed now then. Ridiculous being able to have unlimited savings and claim hundreds in tax credits a month. Who ever thought up that system?

Babyroobs · 14/03/2023 16:03

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 07:26

Yes. It is shocking. The government is horrific to families - not least the policy of only laying tax credits for two children since 2017 - I have five kids and three of them born since April 2017 and we get no tax credits for them at all. My sister with older kids gets tc for all four. It’s crazy.

You surely knew you wouldn't get them for five after the rules changed? Your sister clearly had hers before the rules changed.

BeavisMcTavish · 14/03/2023 15:41

Of course you should use savings before State intervention 🤦‍♂️

gloriawasright · 14/03/2023 15:21

Buzzard?? Bizzare I mean

gloriawasright · 14/03/2023 15:21

gogohmm · 11/03/2023 16:17

Tax credits are annual award. An increase later in the tax year can result in you needing to repay your credits from earlier. Uc has ironed out this anomaly. It was one of the reasons for needing to reform tax credits but those on historic awards were reluctant to switch across.

One of the reasons for reluctance to switch from tax credits to UC is the buzzard difference in savings rule.
UC £6k ( I might be wrong and it is £16k,but money taken off for each £250 or so)
Tax credits have no savings rule .

gloriawasright · 14/03/2023 15:18

Tax credits are calculated on your forecasted income for the year ahead.your income projection was what you were being paid for.
When you started working that changed your income for that whole year,you were being paid monthly based on your estimated or actual income would be up until April 2023.
Which would entitle you to the monthly payments you were getting.
But your monthly payments would have been lower had you been able to foresee the job that you started.

It's a horrible system which actually pays you what you estimate you will earn for the year ahead .and none of us are fortune tellers,so many many households end up owing back payments .

Amispringy · 14/03/2023 15:06

berksandbeyond · 14/03/2023 08:29

All mums are full time mums. I’m not no longer a mum when I’m at work.

People just like to say ‘full time mum’ because it sounds better than ‘unemployed’

This

BeavisMcTavish · 14/03/2023 14:45

I have no words for how bonkers this is - that a child’s validity has any link to what handouts you can get for them.

Government shouldn’t be providing anyone with anything other than a leg up in times of need.

un-means tested child benefit shouldn’t exist at all for any number of kids (said as a parent of kids).

CMO · 14/03/2023 10:34

You ignored the letters. Your fault.

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 10:27

Whereas I had two and I thought “a third would be lovely but…. Nope, can’t afford a third without sacrifices I do not think would benefit my current two”. So I didn’t.

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 10:26

So presumably @thismamayogi after your second child and knowing no additional benefits you and your partner thought… yes, we can afford a third and provide a good standard of living to all three without additional support.

and then you thought the same about a 4th.

and then you thought the same about a 5th

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 10:24

More than 2

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 10:24

I like the two child benefit policy because it means people have to think about their financial situation before having more than 3. Essentially makes people have skin in the game.

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 10:21

A two child benefits policy makes the other children “less valid”???

I don’t regard the validity of my children based on whether I am eligible to receive benefits for them

Lovelyveg82 · 14/03/2023 10:19

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 08:19

@CrumblingKnees
So only those who are affluent should be “allowed” to have lots of kids? Or a Chinese style ban on more than one/two is to be welcomed? This is dangerous ground. You have to follow that through.
if full time mothers were not penalised for making a choice to raise their own kids full time, perhaps the poverty of the same wouldn’t be an issue.

They can have as many as they heck they like.

But thankfully we don’t all need to pay for them.

thismamayogi · 14/03/2023 10:13

I’m not asking others to pay for them - I’m talking government policy. If we’re going to get into that - I deeply object to the government still spending millions on trident, sending arms to Ukraine, paying ministers for dubious duties that serve no one - squandering millions on those nightingale hospitals that never got used once - I was not talking generally about what the government does with tax - if you have a problem with benefits in general and think I’m a freeloader for using them where they are due - that’s another matter. I was making a point about government policy to pay a “benefit” for raising children, but only for a set amount of children - clearly indicating that more is therefore less socially acceptable, according to the logic. That is all. I was using this premise to illustrate the point that government policy rarely puts families front and centre but instead squanders resources on areas that do not benefit families. I believe that supporting families in any way ends up being beneficial in general because robust families make society stronger. That’s it. The systems are so opaque - as OP pointed out - she made a call and there was all sorts of nonsense about cut off periods and confusing criteria - she was overpaid because of confusion and error and then the waters were further muddied. This is typical of the opacity of simply claiming a benefit that is supposed to be made fairly universally available. OP was not trying to commit fraud, but found the impact of having to pay back for this error would be huge - whereas in all honesty the government would barely notice if they let it go.

basically, these policies end up hindering as much as helping and it should all be simpler and clearer, and, yes, fairer. There is little enough to make raising a family in today’s hostile climate anything less than a superhuman endeavour.