Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is DISGRACEFUL! Massive tax credits overpayment!

355 replies

CrumblingKnees · 11/03/2023 15:57

Just furious that common sense is not prevailing and I am essentially being robbed of money by HMRC!

So, twin DC finished education in summer 2021. Both have a disability, DH works but we were entitled to tax credits as wage not massive and we got the higher rate due to disability. I remember getting a letter saying tax credits would stop from August 31st due to this. Was aware and knew I’d have to find a job to cover the shortfall.

Payments stopped and I then started working in November 2021. I do remember getting some letters from them but ignored as as far as I was concerned claim had ended (stupid I know). Youngest was diagnosed with a serious illness last summer and I’ve been a bit of a mess, not keeping on top of things like I normally am.

Anyway got a letter from them a few weeks ago saying we’d been overpaid almost £2,000! Shocked, rang and basically they’d added on my work income from November onwards to my tax credit claim for that year (it was not closed). I assumed claim had ended in August and if it had been there would be no overpayment!

I’ve explained this and filed a dispute. They’ve come back today and said that as I didn’t dispute before the end of Jan the overpayment stands and we need to pay it!

AIBU to think this is a pisstake and totally wrong for a government agency to take money from families like this?

OP posts:
IhearyouClemFandango · 11/03/2023 17:58

loudbatperson · 11/03/2023 16:12

Tax credit entitlement is based on the entire tax years income, so it is quite possible you have been overpaid. It doesn't matter if you got no payments after August, as they work on a yearly total basis.

This. We have been caught out by it in the past. But you started getting paid in the same tax year as the payments were going. Presumably a fair amount if you were overpaid £2k between April and August.

HoldTightandPretenditsaPlan · 11/03/2023 17:58

CrumblingKnees · 11/03/2023 15:57

Just furious that common sense is not prevailing and I am essentially being robbed of money by HMRC!

So, twin DC finished education in summer 2021. Both have a disability, DH works but we were entitled to tax credits as wage not massive and we got the higher rate due to disability. I remember getting a letter saying tax credits would stop from August 31st due to this. Was aware and knew I’d have to find a job to cover the shortfall.

Payments stopped and I then started working in November 2021. I do remember getting some letters from them but ignored as as far as I was concerned claim had ended (stupid I know). Youngest was diagnosed with a serious illness last summer and I’ve been a bit of a mess, not keeping on top of things like I normally am.

Anyway got a letter from them a few weeks ago saying we’d been overpaid almost £2,000! Shocked, rang and basically they’d added on my work income from November onwards to my tax credit claim for that year (it was not closed). I assumed claim had ended in August and if it had been there would be no overpayment!

I’ve explained this and filed a dispute. They’ve come back today and said that as I didn’t dispute before the end of Jan the overpayment stands and we need to pay it!

AIBU to think this is a pisstake and totally wrong for a government agency to take money from families like this?

Your income for the whole year does get taken into account unfortunately. Whether or not a claim is active, they base the payments on you earning 5he same throughout the year - that's one bedmbefit of UC over TC... However, if you think their calculations are wrong I highly recommend contacting the Community Law charity. They4e fantastic and will definitely be able to help... Mention this to HMRC and they should allow you to dispute

smellyflowers · 11/03/2023 17:57

berksandbeyond · 11/03/2023 17:54

YABU for ignoring letters and for not getting a job earlier. You were happy to not work while you were getting benefits but magically could work when they stopped? Funny that

I read it more as they stopped when kids left education so she had to rather than stay home to care for them?

Richhandcream · 11/03/2023 17:56

I got caught out like this years back, but really it was my fault for not reading up properly. My income ended up higher than I'd estimated for the year I claimed them, so I had to repay a sum. In other words - The credits paid were based on the income for the year before I was actually entitled to and paid them, so when they looked at what I actually earned in that year I owed them a refund. You can get really reasonable instalments though, if you're assertive with them.

berksandbeyond · 11/03/2023 17:54

YABU for ignoring letters and for not getting a job earlier. You were happy to not work while you were getting benefits but magically could work when they stopped? Funny that

TryingHard1990 · 11/03/2023 17:54

It’s an odd system… I’m going to have to pay back my tax credits from this year. I also claimed what I was entitled to from April - July as my DP moved in.

ifoundthebread · 11/03/2023 17:53

FamilyLife2point4 · 11/03/2023 17:51

@Whyislifesohardsometimes it does beg the question - why can UC be paid in real time and tax credits not? The systems are there …….

Thats why everyone is being moved to UC, so they are on the new systems and reducing the chance of this happening as it has been an ongoing issue for years.

tunamayo81 · 11/03/2023 17:52

arethereanyleftatall · 11/03/2023 17:40

@tunamayo81
I would say because it's absolutely obvious is why you would know that. As demonstrated by the poster after poster detailing how it works on an annual basis after the op shouted that she hadn't been overpaid, when she clearly had.

Is it? My Dad is an accountant that’s the only reason I know about tax years as when I was a kid he he was so busy after January -March doing all his stuff but otherwise I maybe wouldn’t know? I don’t claim anything so I haven’t seen the letters they send but it seems an easy mistake to make to me.

FamilyLife2point4 · 11/03/2023 17:51

@Whyislifesohardsometimes it does beg the question - why can UC be paid in real time and tax credits not? The systems are there …….

Motheranddaughter · 11/03/2023 17:50

If you have been overpaid surely you accept you must pay it back
Ask to pay in instalments

Whyislifesohardsometimes · 11/03/2023 17:50

I'm in the same position, I received a payrise in January which meant my earnings for the current tax year now take me over the threshold, I now have to repay everything paid to me this year. It is what it is. Unfortunately Tax Credits don't work in real time like Universal Credit.

imnotsickbutimnotwell · 11/03/2023 17:46

I had this they calculate it over a year, I stopped receiving payments and changed job. Due to me being paid PILON for 8 weeks and salary for the new job it meant I was over the threshold for the year which meant the entire year payment had to be paid back. OP seems to think it’s calculated on a month by month basis but it’s not.

Tessabelle74 · 11/03/2023 17:46

Your tax credit claim runs April to March. Any payments you received were worked out for a full years benefit. Starting work in November means you have been overpaid as your income for the year is higher than when they worked out your entitlement. Sorry, but your overpayment will be correct

MangoMask · 11/03/2023 17:45

Same thing happened to me. I was fully aware that the payments for my youngest would stop in August, along with child benefits and child maintenance from the ex. No problem at all.

As I was going to be down about £700 per month I started looking for a better paid job. When my boss found out he said they would give me a £7k pay rise. I was over the moon as I love my job. It wasn’t until April the following year I was told this now meant I’d been overpaid in tax credits for April to August.

Money is so tight already I cried down the phone to them and I only have to pay £20 per month back. Will take a few years mind.

But I literally had no idea getting a pay rise would cause this. Yes I understand the ‘logic’ behind it but how the hell was I supposed to know I was getting a rise. Much sympathy to you it’s crap !!

FamilyLife2point4 · 11/03/2023 17:45

@Lovelyveg82 i would argue hmrc systems are wrong. Basing it over a year makes things like this go in their favour (so to speak). If they based it on weekly or monthly income, they probably wouldn’t owe anything.
It does make me question why - when a claim is ‘shut down’ it is still actually active to the following April. Why does income after a claim is shut down still count? I can see why OP is struggling with this - it doesn’t really make sense (even though it’s how they work).
For example:
Family is living on X per month therefore need/entitled to Y amount of credits. X+Y =Z. Credits stop, family really struggling with income X alone.
Family manage to add V income to household. V+X =Z, family can breathe again.
HMRC now say family earned too much that year and owe back N amount, but family have no more money per month than they did do while receiving Y credits. HMRC previously said X wasn’t enough so gave them Y to make Z, but now saying Z is too much (when they’re bursting their arse to make V, to add to X, to make Z again). This isn’t right imo and bamboozling tbh!

Diedre44 · 11/03/2023 17:45

Same thing happened to me OP. I got a full time job in October 2010, informed them, payments stopped. March 2012 got a letter saying I had been overpaid £2600ish. Rang, rang, rang and rang them never got to speak to anyone on the phone, sent a letter asking them for a breakdown and got a letter by return saying "we will respond in xyz weeks" (don't recall exactly) and then heard no more. Life went on and I forgot all about it.
Fast forward to March 2019 and I get a letter from them informing me they had applied for an attachment of earnings to recover. Was a nightmare again trying to speak to someone to sort it out and in the end I just gave up. It's paid off now thankfully. They take a percentage of whatever you earn, so the more you earn the higher the percentage, think it's between 5% up to 60% without checking.

TomatoSandwiches · 11/03/2023 17:43

tunamayo81 · 11/03/2023 17:38

I feel sad for you, i think this was an easy mistake for you to make, they base it on the whole tax years earnings April-April but why would you know that? bastards don’t tell you so they get money out of you through things like this It’s completely understandable you thought as you’d stopped being paid in August that was the end of it. so now you’re getting less benefits and you have a debt to repay 😢 Unfortunately, by the official rules you do have to pay it back, but I totally see how you got here.

It has the dates for calculation on the award letters they send you, so it actually is very clear, so long as you read them.

Honestly it is no ones fault but the ops.

Densol57 · 11/03/2023 17:42

YOU WERE PAID MORE THAN ENTITLED. I cant be bothered to read all the replies but tax credits are worked out on the YEARLY income April to April.
Tax credits were calculated on you not working.
when you got a job in that tax year, the yearly income was recalculated at the end of the tax year and created an over payment unfortunately.

arethereanyleftatall · 11/03/2023 17:40

@tunamayo81
I would say because it's absolutely obvious is why you would know that. As demonstrated by the poster after poster detailing how it works on an annual basis after the op shouted that she hadn't been overpaid, when she clearly had.

tunamayo81 · 11/03/2023 17:38

CrumblingKnees · 11/03/2023 16:11

I WAS NOT PAID MORE THAN WE WERE ENTITLED TO.

Payments were correct up to August. They added on my work income FROM NOVEMBER AFTER payments ended and we were no longer entitled to tax credits.

Seriously!

I feel sad for you, i think this was an easy mistake for you to make, they base it on the whole tax years earnings April-April but why would you know that? bastards don’t tell you so they get money out of you through things like this It’s completely understandable you thought as you’d stopped being paid in August that was the end of it. so now you’re getting less benefits and you have a debt to repay 😢 Unfortunately, by the official rules you do have to pay it back, but I totally see how you got here.

arethereanyleftatall · 11/03/2023 17:37

Vloader23 · 11/03/2023 17:32

Oof it does sound a bit unfair.
But on the other hand if you were able to work to support your family, it seems morally wrong not to have been doing that in the first place?

This was my tangent thought too when I first read the op. 'Our benefits stopped so I found a job' . Implying that the op was capable of getting a job before then but chose not to bother because the tax payer was footing it.

TomatoSandwiches · 11/03/2023 17:33

It's actually quite shocking how many people claim tax credits and are completely oblivious to how they work.
You should always read up on any benefit you are getting not only to get exactly what you are entitled to but to protect yourself from situations such as these, especially if you know yourself well enough to admit you ignore mail from the HMRC.

Lovelyveg82 · 11/03/2023 17:33

letthemalldoone · 11/03/2023 17:31

Sometimes people who are a poor mindspace make errors of judgement like this. Obviously the OP should have read and dealt with the letters but I guess she knows that now without having to be told?!

But she still thinks the HMRC are wrong when very obviously - they aren’t

Vloader23 · 11/03/2023 17:32

Oof it does sound a bit unfair.
But on the other hand if you were able to work to support your family, it seems morally wrong not to have been doing that in the first place?

letthemalldoone · 11/03/2023 17:31

Lovelyveg82 · 11/03/2023 17:28

I love the way the op is trying to convince us HMRC are wrong

OP, you didn’t bother to read multiple letters from HMRC. You’re not exactly someone people will take what they say regarding finances very seriously 😂

Sometimes people who are a poor mindspace make errors of judgement like this. Obviously the OP should have read and dealt with the letters but I guess she knows that now without having to be told?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread