Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Health visitor

129 replies

ellie2323 · 11/03/2023 15:36

Hi,
so I am a first time mum, and my son was born a week ago. The health visitor has now arranged an appointment to see us at home early next week I believe on day 11.

The HV visited us before he was born. I found her intimidating and to be honest she made me feel uncomfortable.
I felt she was extremely judgey of my situation. Myself and sons dad are in a complicated relationship, we don’t live together or plan to live together permanently. He is known to the police or has been known to the police (not for anything DV related) and she was firing quite uncomfortable questions at me.

  • why don’t you plan to live together?
  • how do you pay your rent ?
  • many questions about his occupation.
  • Was the baby planned?
  • I mentioned that I didn’t have a great relationship with my mother and she pressed me about this.
  • I also mentioned that my sons dad planned to move in to my house for a short time once baby was here to help out (which he has done). She questioned this, and my decision saying this could be difficult.

In all honesty I don’t know if I’m been sensitive because of hormones, I obviously know she has a job to do and a duty of care, but now the thought of her coming again is filling me with complete dread and anxiety.
I believe I can refuse the HV, but I also feel like this makes me look ‘guilty’ or like I have something to hide or be ashamed of which I have not.

Maybe I’m just reading too much into the situation, I don’t know. I was just after some impartial advice.

OP posts:
Moonicorn · 11/03/2023 22:02

What was the baby’s dad convicted of? Can you tell us? That probably changes things somewhat and adds context.

ellie2323 · 11/03/2023 22:02

Sighdeeply · 11/03/2023 20:56

I love the non judgemental tone on here. Has baby with known criminal but the HV is in the wrong. Batshittery mumsnet at its finest.

I definitely didn’t say she was in the wrong, I said it left me feeling anxious.

OP posts:
FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 11/03/2023 21:59

ellie2323 · 11/03/2023 21:55

Well.. unfortunately I cannot control the situation with my mother, and it’s not the relationship I would want with her. I wouldn’t wish the situation on others, but sadly it is what it is.

‘unstable family’ is a strong comment. Life doesn’t always pan out like a fairytale. I love my son very much, and regardless to ‘my situation’ I want to do the right thing for him as at this point he is all that matters.

In my post I said I understand that HV have a duty of care..

Again, no, you can’t change your past, but it does (and clearly has) influenced your family decisions.

Life does not always pan out, no. But you cannot call a family where the parents are not together and the father is involved with the police a stable one.

I don’t doubt you love your son, but it is important that all authorities are on high alert in these situations.

ellie2323 · 11/03/2023 21:55

FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 11/03/2023 21:41

No, we don’t. But our backgrounds influence our choices in later life and those with unstable backgrounds are more likely to a) make poorer choices and b) be unable to create a secure environment for their child(ren).

That is exactly what has happened here. Baby has been born into an unstable family unit where the father is not properly around and is known to the police.

The environment is not the most suitable or secure for baby and so of course the HV and other related services need to keep a close eye.

Well.. unfortunately I cannot control the situation with my mother, and it’s not the relationship I would want with her. I wouldn’t wish the situation on others, but sadly it is what it is.

‘unstable family’ is a strong comment. Life doesn’t always pan out like a fairytale. I love my son very much, and regardless to ‘my situation’ I want to do the right thing for him as at this point he is all that matters.

In my post I said I understand that HV have a duty of care..

OP posts:
FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks · 11/03/2023 21:41

Babooshka1990 · 11/03/2023 20:17

@FoxInSocksSatOnBlocks vile. It isn’t OP’s fault that she doesn’t have what you call an ‘appropriate healthy stable family background’. We don’t choose our parents!

No, we don’t. But our backgrounds influence our choices in later life and those with unstable backgrounds are more likely to a) make poorer choices and b) be unable to create a secure environment for their child(ren).

That is exactly what has happened here. Baby has been born into an unstable family unit where the father is not properly around and is known to the police.

The environment is not the most suitable or secure for baby and so of course the HV and other related services need to keep a close eye.

exwhyzed · 11/03/2023 21:33

The really crap local health visitor who I know vaguely socially through our children's school completely lost her shit with her own child in front of me at an event today. Reminded me that she is just another human being.

she's shit at her job because she's patronising and a bit socially inept with people when she is in work mode - I had first hand experience of that when she went into work mode with me in a social situation.

she's actually a pretty nice person away from work mode - some people are just really bad and unsuited to their jobs, Health Vistors included.

just remember they are human beings and if you came away from her involvement it feeling bad then it's partially on her and her professionalism and not all on you.

I do a very similar job and convey very challenging information to families about things they need to change and 99% of the time I leave having got them to agree to everything I need them to agree to and them feeling like I am on their side.

AnneLovesGilbert · 11/03/2023 21:30

Have this appointment, see how it goes and then decide if you’d like a different HV if possible.

It doesn’t sound like she’s done anything wrong. You feel defensive about your current set up and it’s making you prickly.

Messyhair321 · 11/03/2023 21:24

Those questions aren't all relevant.
I think some professionals are awful, I had someone turn up once on my doorstep when my DC were young. It was unannounced & she came in we had a chat & she left.
Fast forward a few weeks (I was a support worker with Barnardo's at the time) I attended a child protection conference as I was supporting a family who were central to this conference.
This 'health visitor ' was there, & in fact she was actually the social worker. She'd basically lied to get into my house & left realising nothing was wrong. Unbelievable.

In your situation I would ask for another health visitor, be honest & say that you feel intimidated & don't want to feel judged when you're already feeling vulnerable due to having a young baby.
You are well informed that the health visitor is doing their job but there are ways to do that that won't make you feel like you're being pressured or quizzed about your choices & life.
Unless the baby's DD is violent or posed a CP risk I'm not sure how they'd know. Information isn't justice shared unless there's a good reason so it might just be your living situation or family support network. I'd try to reassure them that you have support with reliable friends/ family/ dd's family or whoever is a good solid support for you & your baby.

Makkni88 · 11/03/2023 21:17

ellie2323 · 11/03/2023 15:36

Hi,
so I am a first time mum, and my son was born a week ago. The health visitor has now arranged an appointment to see us at home early next week I believe on day 11.

The HV visited us before he was born. I found her intimidating and to be honest she made me feel uncomfortable.
I felt she was extremely judgey of my situation. Myself and sons dad are in a complicated relationship, we don’t live together or plan to live together permanently. He is known to the police or has been known to the police (not for anything DV related) and she was firing quite uncomfortable questions at me.

  • why don’t you plan to live together?
  • how do you pay your rent ?
  • many questions about his occupation.
  • Was the baby planned?
  • I mentioned that I didn’t have a great relationship with my mother and she pressed me about this.
  • I also mentioned that my sons dad planned to move in to my house for a short time once baby was here to help out (which he has done). She questioned this, and my decision saying this could be difficult.

In all honesty I don’t know if I’m been sensitive because of hormones, I obviously know she has a job to do and a duty of care, but now the thought of her coming again is filling me with complete dread and anxiety.
I believe I can refuse the HV, but I also feel like this makes me look ‘guilty’ or like I have something to hide or be ashamed of which I have not.

Maybe I’m just reading too much into the situation, I don’t know. I was just after some impartial advice.

universal programme of care states HV should make contact with pregnant women after 28 weeks gestation to complete antenatal and commence family health assessment, a holistic piece of work assessing support, parenting knowledge and allowing for a conversation around health promotion topics. There are certain concerns highlighted in your story which suggest vulnerability which needs to be assessed - HV personal skills make a lot of difference as to how this is handled however at the heart of the conversation is not judgement nor “halo shining” but an attempt to understand your situation and help you access any support you might need to be the best mummy possible and promote positive outcomes for your baby. You’re absolutely entitled to decline HV however with a partner who has police involvement it’s very likely to be flagged to social work and they may draw certain conclusions

cadburyegg · 11/03/2023 21:16

Your setup sounds unusual so it's not surprising you were asked about this. And if your partner is known to the police then you will be questioned. What did you expect?

The questions are there to check you have some support.

I've had 2 children whilst married and still been asked if they were planned, it's a standard question

Mavis93 · 11/03/2023 21:13

Maybe they have a terrible reputation due to things like this- clearly identifying a family who need support and yet are still the bad guys and people choose just jump and blame them!

NerrSnerr · 11/03/2023 21:13

She is asking these questions because she wants to make sure you and your baby remain safe. Why is the baby's dad known to the police? Violence? Drugs? Is there a risk that he may end up in prison in the future?

anniz91 · 11/03/2023 21:12

Jadviga · 11/03/2023 15:59

Those questions sound really nosy. She isn't social services, her purview is health. If baby and mom are healthy, that's all she needs to know (unless obviously they are living in absolute squalor but that doesn't seem to be the case).

I'd be tempted to opt out but I've heard that it gets flagged if you do. So I'd either request another one, or politely redirect her nosiness.

"How long is baby's dad staying ? What's his job ? Are you sure this baby was planned ?"

"Actually I'd rather we focus on my baby's health. Has she gained enough weight ?"

If there is a safeguarding issue or a potential one then it is her job to investigate that might seem like she's overstepping.

But it's not just about health...

Emmamoo89 · 11/03/2023 21:12

If you refuse them can guarantee social services will be at your door and you really don't want that.

Makkni88 · 11/03/2023 21:11

They’re not their

Also no such such thing as a RGN anymore

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 11/03/2023 21:09

You can refuse them. Their just polishing their halos anyway thinking their doing good 🙄

How you can give an RGN more training and still have a profession with a terrible reputation inside the NHS always baffled me.

Moonicorn · 11/03/2023 21:05

YABU. Your ‘discomfort’ doesn’t matter. Your child’s safety does. You chose this situation.

TessoftheDubonnet · 11/03/2023 21:03

This HV may be somewhat abrasive and she clearly rubbed you up the wrong way. However, everything about your description of your situation screams VULNERABLE. I would urge you to try and engage with her as she may be able to help you. Whatever you do, don't try to opt out of these visits. I suspect this would definitely result in SW involvement. Although, having said that, having the support of a social worker might potentially be useful, given your circumstances, especially the baby's father and his trouble with the police.

GoAgainstNicki · 11/03/2023 20:59

SnackSizeRaisin · 11/03/2023 20:54

Were you a single parent and was the father of your baby known to the police though? Perhaps this advice isn't the best for someone in the OP's position...

Yes and yes.

Just because someone is known to the police doesn’t mean they’re some woman beater pervert. If the OP doesn’t want a HV then she doesn’t need to have one. It’s really quite simple.

I’m sure SS would be involved if the father proposed any sort of threat

Sighdeeply · 11/03/2023 20:56

I love the non judgemental tone on here. Has baby with known criminal but the HV is in the wrong. Batshittery mumsnet at its finest.

DistantSkye · 11/03/2023 20:56

Congratulations on the birth of your baby! I think the early days are really difficult tbh, and it's hard not to take everything anyone asks you so personally.

I didn't find any contact I had with Health Visitors that useful or remarkable either way but in general they are there to ensure the wellbeing of kids and caregivers. I think the questions do just sound like she was trying to figure out how much support you had. For example I don't have any family close by and when my eldest was born DH worked away a lot so I did get a few questions about support etc. And if there's police involvement with the baby's father and you've got him living with you and the baby for a bit, I think it's fair enough that they'd try and get a bit more information about what's going on. I think in those circumstances I wouldn't refuse Health Visitor intervention.

SnackSizeRaisin · 11/03/2023 20:54

GoAgainstNicki · 11/03/2023 20:46

Just cancel the appointment and say that you don’t want to be under the care of a HV. That’s what I did with my second. I wish I knew I could do that with my first!

Were you a single parent and was the father of your baby known to the police though? Perhaps this advice isn't the best for someone in the OP's position...

SnackSizeRaisin · 11/03/2023 20:52

why don’t you plan to live together?
how do you pay your rent ?
many questions about his occupation.
Was the baby planned?
I mentioned that I didn’t have a great relationship with my mother and she pressed me about this.
I also mentioned that my sons dad planned to move in to my house for a short time once baby was here to help out (which he has done). She questioned this, and my decision saying this could be difficult.

With regard to these questions, the reason you feel defensive is possibly because you don't like the answers yourself. For most people, asked about the baby's fathers occupation, would just say "delivery driver" or "nurse" and the question would be forgotten. I don't think any of the questions are unreasonable or unusual. They are always looking for signs of DV, financial difficulty, PND, as well as the usual baby health things such as feeding, safe sleep, no smoking etc. I think the questions are all relevant to that. They are not targetting you - it does feel a bit patronising but it's standard stuff.

AndTheSurveySays · 11/03/2023 20:50

In your situation (baby with a criminal, "complicated" relationship with the criminal and no relationship with your mother) I wouldn't recommend refusing the visits.
You could request a different HV.
All HV want to do is make sure the baby is safe and cared for.

jigsaw234 · 11/03/2023 20:48

I suspect that you are on the radar of social services and they have asked her to find out a bit more to see if they should get involved. That's kind of what happens when you have a baby with a criminal, sorry. So I would co-operate, make it clear why you think you aren't putting baby at risk. Tell her she can't come any more and you'll find social services at your door.

Swipe left for the next trending thread