Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Upset at the way my niece & nephew treat my dcs

136 replies

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 13:29

DH & I live in Cardiff with our 3 dc who go to a Welsh speaking school, they love it.
I'm from rural Wales & go back quite often to visit my parents. My brother lives in the village still with his wife & kids. Their dc are similar ages to mine. We met up with them last night & they were so nasty to my dc.

Firstly they were slagging off their school, saying how much they hated the Welsh language & would prefer to jump off a cliff than go to dc's school.

Slagged my dc's off for going to a Welsh language camp during half term saying they spend their holidays relaxing not doing stupid camps.

Anything my dc said they liked they hated eg Harry Styles!

Really annoying, my DH & his wife just smirk. My dc's are a bit crestfallen & confused at how resentful they are... My mum also picked up on it & put it down to hormones.
They also seem to hate Cardiff with a passion even though they've only been their a couple of times..
Aibu to just do our own thing when we visit my parents & try to avoid them. My parents are late 60s, completely self sufficient so no bitterness about us not "helping".
My parents help my brothers kids with childcare etc, are very active. The family just seem to resent us.

OP posts:
pattihews · 11/03/2023 16:16

It may actually be about a bit more than having rude relatives.

When I first came to live in Wales back in the 90s a Welsh friend (Barry born and non-Welsh-speaking) took me to a concert at the St David's Centre where at the bar we experienced some Welsh speakers being unpleasant to the barman because he couldn't speak Welsh and couldn't understand their order expressed in Welsh.

These people, my friend explained, was what was laughingly known as the Taffia: a group of middle class Welsh speakers, often influential in politics and education and the law, who send their children to Welsh-medium schools (Cardiff is largely English speaking/ English-medium for education and 20 years ago there were a limited number of them). Not long ago I was introduced to a Cardiff woman whose Welsh-first-language husband insisted that only Welsh was spoken in the home and only Welsh TV and radio were allowed. Their children went to Welsh-medium schools and Welsh camp. It's a kind of Welsh elitism.

Not saying that the OP and her family are like this or are part of that group, but the fact that being a Welsh speaker has brought advantage to her husband in his work does hint at it. Perhaps to their extended family living more rural lives OP and her family descend from the big city speaking Welsh and they seem a bit — well, pretentious. Perhaps the adults have talked about them in this way and the children have picked it up.

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 16:15

Dc3 getting an air up bottle for her birthday.. He was telling me there that he told his cousins last night. His cousin said "yea I got one for Christmas but it's rubbish, it makes me feel sick".. They just seem to want to put my cousins down at every single opportunity even bloody air up bottles & Harry Styles!

OP posts:
Strawberrydelight78 · 11/03/2023 16:10

Jealousy is an ugly trate. Wouldn't anyone living in Wales love to speak the Welsh language?

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 16:05

Thanks @Bigmirrorssmallrooms. Yes will be keeping them apart. Glad my mum was there to witness.

OP posts:
Bigmirrorssmallrooms · 11/03/2023 16:01

alittleprivacy · 11/03/2023 15:39

Well there you go. They resent having to do Welsh in school. I'm Irish and I HATED doing Irish in school with every fibre of my being from around age seven onwards. When I met kids who went to Irish language schools I felt a mixture of deep pity for them while also thinking they were weird as all hell if they didn't hate it. Obviously as an adult, I understand that once they are immersed in the language they had a different relationship with it. But as a child all I knew was that I, and almost every single person I knew, adult and child, resented being forced to learn a language we felt no connection to.

I suspect this nails it, and likely the parents feel the same. They are all looking down on your families choices.

i don’t think the right term is inverted snobbery and I don’t think it’s envy, I think it’s condescension or disdaining and due to this they are belittling your kids.

inverted snobbery is when you look down on those who you think are superior. And envy is that it’s something want for themselves. I don’t think either is the case, I think it’s condescension and disdain.

its completely different view points on the language importance, and they shouldn’t be looking down on your children for it. But more importantly neither should the adults. who appear to be looking down on you and your husbands choices here, which is then coming down to the kids.

I do think this is sadly a major differentiator between your families and as they seem unable to cease being condescending and disdainful of your perfectly valid choice, so staying apart is the only option.

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 16:00

@Yoshithegreen i suspect it's coming from their parents too.

OP posts:
Justalittlebitduckling · 11/03/2023 15:59

Cardiff is great. I think it’s a classic case of tall
poppy syndrome, resenting the sibling who’s moved to the big city, assuming you think you are “better than them” and over compensating with nastiness. You can’t fix it, you can only distance yourself and your DC unfortunately.

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 15:58

@Lunde they were talking about the midterm last month & asked dc why they didn't come down. My dc said they did a Welsh camp & that's how it started.. Cousins"Oh we prefer to relax on our hols than do silly camps"..

OP posts:
Yoshithegreen · 11/03/2023 15:52

The apple doesn’t fall far from the tree. It’s a brother and SIL issue they have instilled this in them with the smirks. They probably slag you off when not around would be my bet.

Protect your kids i wouldn’t force them to be around those kids if they aren’t very nice

Lunde · 11/03/2023 15:50

How did the whole subject of education systems come up? Did the adults start prompting the kids to talk about this?

I remember some very uncomfortable discussions in my family - private school v grammar school v comprehensive and tbh the kids didn't start it but it was all to do with undercurrents among the adults who wanted to defend their own choices and prejudices by proxy

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 15:49

@MyopicBunny my brother is a very proud Welsh man, appears to throw himself into any local cultural events 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Hotvimto3 · 11/03/2023 15:47

I love the soeaking welsh infront of them comment... i would do this ha

MyopicBunny · 11/03/2023 15:42

Cardiff is an amazing city - my dd is there for uni and I studied there too.

One thing that I have noticed is that some welsh people do seem to have internalised a dislike of welsh speaking culture which really is such a shame. My ex husband is Welsh and his family were like this.

Zarqon · 11/03/2023 15:41

Either call them on it or avoid the family (or both).

On the rare occasions our cousins are rude to my DC and the parents don’t intervene, I say “Don’t be rude.” Or something like “Goodness, you do need some help with your manners don’t you, it’s not polite to insult others hobbies you know, I hope your teacher doesn’t let you talk to your classmates at school like that.”

coconutpie · 11/03/2023 15:41

OP, would you be able to say the MN classic each time they are rude - "did you mean to be so rude?" each time they say something to insult your DC.

justasking111 · 11/03/2023 15:39

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 15:17

No it's not particularly rural rural! I don't want to out myself by being too specific but the cousins go to an English speaking school.

We're in north Wales, at secondary level some of DS Fri went to Welsh medium school, some a mixed bag. No-one thinks anyone else is superior

The children are bloody rude and ignorant. You right to vent.

alittleprivacy · 11/03/2023 15:39

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 15:15

The cousins do a bit of Welsh in school it's compulsory but all the subjects are in English.
Mine are Welsh immersion & all subjects are through Welsh. I'll say this to DH (Welsh is his first language) he'd relish in it🤣

Well there you go. They resent having to do Welsh in school. I'm Irish and I HATED doing Irish in school with every fibre of my being from around age seven onwards. When I met kids who went to Irish language schools I felt a mixture of deep pity for them while also thinking they were weird as all hell if they didn't hate it. Obviously as an adult, I understand that once they are immersed in the language they had a different relationship with it. But as a child all I knew was that I, and almost every single person I knew, adult and child, resented being forced to learn a language we felt no connection to.

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 15:39

Thanks everyone. Appreciate your comments & will be giving them a wide berth now.

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 11/03/2023 15:38

I doubt it’s about speaking welsh, and more to do with the fact that you left your hometown and made a life elsewhere.

It’s designed to knock you down to the size they think you should be. I expect their attitudes are along the lines of ‘thinks she’s too good for where she came from!’, ‘thinks she’s better than us!’, ‘her and her kids think they’re something special’ etc. Some people take it very personally indeed if you make different choices to them.

Thekirit · 11/03/2023 15:38

Phonemonkey2023 · 11/03/2023 13:32

Abounds like there’s a bit of ‘they think they are better’ which must have come from your brother and SIL and they are trying to bring you all down a peg or 2. Jealously is a terrible thing.

I agree with this.
We had the same with my db second wife and child
Hated us I think before they walked in the door. Nasty comments from kids and parents. Including really slagging off our school choices. When she had two more kids the three of them decided to beat up one of mine, kicking and punching him on the ground.
No apology…nothing…nasty little shits
We still send Christmas cards,( I don’t really know why ) db down to a text 🤣. Luckily db first wife and son are amazing.
Try not to let it affect the way you live,
They are the problem,
Good luck

billy1966 · 11/03/2023 15:38

OP, I'm with @N7 there is no way you should be standing around allowing this behaviour.

Start speaking welsh to them and explain that unfortunately they clearly don't know any better.

Correct your mother firmly that you will not have your children being treated badly and avoid visiting your brother in his home.

If they come to your mothers, first sign of rudeness have your children warned that they can head to their rooms or head out for a walk..

Very important IMO to say very openly to your children that their cousins are rude and we don't have to spend time with rude people.

Avoid them and their nastiness.

Or the next hint of rudeness ask what their problem is? Why are they being so rude....to your brother....maybe with a MN head tilt!

This is NOT normal behaviour so make no effort to normalise it by accepting it.

BrutusMcDogface · 11/03/2023 15:36

They sound bitter and jealous. It might have come from their parents, or it might just be pure and simple jealousy that they’re stuck in rural wales (no offence; I bloody love wales!) while your dc live in the city with lots to see and do; shopping etc (I’m thinking mainly the 12 year old, here).

you’re right to challenge them on their behaviour and I would continue to do so!

Foxglove22 · 11/03/2023 15:35

I think your brother and his wife have an inferiority complex for some reason because your children go to a Welsh school - who knows why that may be the case - and they have voiced it in front of their children, who now feel they have the freedom to be rude to your children too. They sound childish and mean, and are a really bad example to their children and I would certainly limit the amount of time your children spend with all of them as it could be really demoralising for them.

Nanny0gg · 11/03/2023 15:34

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 13:40

It definitely came from somewhere, even my mum picked up on it. DH has brought them swimming & I'm here fumimg.

Then stamp on it when you hear it

MemyselfandI2019 · 11/03/2023 15:34

LAMPS1 · 11/03/2023 15:31

Very strange that their parents smirk especially if your DB is a patriotic Welshman. Surely he realises that to be truly bilingual is a bonus your children have that his don’t have. What does he have to smirk about. If he’s smirking because his children feel superior, looking down on yours for loving their interesting and full lives in Cardiff and enjoying two languages, then he’s ignorant and I would avoid him and his family as far as possible. I would also talk frankly to your children about their cousins’ small-minded attitudes so that realise it isn’t normal to be so very unsociable and snooty.
Just wondering …….Isn’t it rather unusual that a rural village school in Wales is teaching through the medium of English ?

Rural villages are only Welsh medium, a few towns do have English medium schools though but not many.