Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Upset at the way my niece & nephew treat my dcs

136 replies

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 13:29

DH & I live in Cardiff with our 3 dc who go to a Welsh speaking school, they love it.
I'm from rural Wales & go back quite often to visit my parents. My brother lives in the village still with his wife & kids. Their dc are similar ages to mine. We met up with them last night & they were so nasty to my dc.

Firstly they were slagging off their school, saying how much they hated the Welsh language & would prefer to jump off a cliff than go to dc's school.

Slagged my dc's off for going to a Welsh language camp during half term saying they spend their holidays relaxing not doing stupid camps.

Anything my dc said they liked they hated eg Harry Styles!

Really annoying, my DH & his wife just smirk. My dc's are a bit crestfallen & confused at how resentful they are... My mum also picked up on it & put it down to hormones.
They also seem to hate Cardiff with a passion even though they've only been their a couple of times..
Aibu to just do our own thing when we visit my parents & try to avoid them. My parents are late 60s, completely self sufficient so no bitterness about us not "helping".
My parents help my brothers kids with childcare etc, are very active. The family just seem to resent us.

OP posts:
Sceptre86 · 11/03/2023 18:21

You don't sound very close to them because if it was me I'd be like, 'wind you're neck in so and so you are being rude'. Then give the parents a pointed look and if they challenge you tell them they are raising brats.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 11/03/2023 18:18

MzHz · 11/03/2023 14:44

So bollock the cousins yourself!

“Excuse me, but enough of your rudeness. If you can be pleasant to my kids then kindly stay silent or remove yourselves before I do it with a boot up your arse. I wouldn’t take this crap from knuckle dragging strangers and I sure as hell won’t take it from family.”

if/when their parents kick off say something like “finally, you ARE able to pull people up on behaviour. If you can’t teach your kids some manners I will.”

then leave.

make the scene. Your kids need to see they are defended and valued.

I missed your post when I wrote mine, @MzHz , and your words are far better than mine!

As a side note, I’m learning Welsh on duolingo, for fun, and today I learned how to say “Owen’s night club sells parsnips”. Is it just me, or is this a phrase that won’t be particularly useful to anyone? It does seem to be a bit of a thing with duolingo - I can also say “The angry old men do not hit the drunk parrots” in Latin. Equally useful, I’m sure you’ll agree. Confused

pattihews · 11/03/2023 18:13

SemperIdem · 11/03/2023 17:42

This is quite true. The Pontcanna area of Cardiff is the hub for this type of Welsh speaker, though many have been priced out and opt for neighbouring Grangetown these days.

My child goes to a Welsh speaking school, though I am not myself a fluent Welsh speaker. The attitude described by the pp is alive and well amongst some of the parents. I personally don’t care in the slightest, but it does rankle others.

I don’t think it’s overly odd for children to be encouraged to be immersed in the secondary language at home, or even have one parent speak to them in English and the other Welsh (or whichever language), it’s an effective way to facilitate bilingualism.

Thank you for confirming, Semperidem. As someone born on the wrong side of the border and used to being put right on anything I say about Wales, it comes as a relief.

RandomMess · 11/03/2023 18:10

I would comment on your DN rudeness tbh

"They don't seem to encourage manners and kindness at these English medium schools do they" Grin

JoanThursday1972 · 11/03/2023 18:01

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 14:06

Welsh is spoken in my region (don't want to out myself too much) but the village school is English speaking,they do learn Welsh but most of the teaching is in English.

It's OK I don't think you're going to out yourself, unless you are Catherine Zeta Jones, or Imogen Thomas.

Nancydrawn · 11/03/2023 17:58

I genuinely don't understand this: why don't you speak to your brother directly? Why is this going through your mother? He's your brother. Talk to him! Don't be passive aggressive and just avoid: talk to him first.

Similarly, when his kids are being rude, you're allowed to say to them, "that's not a nice thing to say. They're your niece/nephew. This isn't a stranger's child, or even a friend's -- this is your relative.

You seem very reluctant to engage. Is there a reason for this?

Stompythedinosaur · 11/03/2023 17:50

I hope you pull them up every time. Not about whether it is fun or not to go to a language camp, but rather, "Come on, that's not a kind way to speak to people." If they don't stop then you need to speak to their parents "could you have a word with dns about putting dc down? It's making the whole meal really uncomfortable".

Don't now to pressure not to rock the boat. It's ok to point out bad behaviour, they are the ones who have caused any scene.

SemperIdem · 11/03/2023 17:43

pattihews · 11/03/2023 16:16

It may actually be about a bit more than having rude relatives.

When I first came to live in Wales back in the 90s a Welsh friend (Barry born and non-Welsh-speaking) took me to a concert at the St David's Centre where at the bar we experienced some Welsh speakers being unpleasant to the barman because he couldn't speak Welsh and couldn't understand their order expressed in Welsh.

These people, my friend explained, was what was laughingly known as the Taffia: a group of middle class Welsh speakers, often influential in politics and education and the law, who send their children to Welsh-medium schools (Cardiff is largely English speaking/ English-medium for education and 20 years ago there were a limited number of them). Not long ago I was introduced to a Cardiff woman whose Welsh-first-language husband insisted that only Welsh was spoken in the home and only Welsh TV and radio were allowed. Their children went to Welsh-medium schools and Welsh camp. It's a kind of Welsh elitism.

Not saying that the OP and her family are like this or are part of that group, but the fact that being a Welsh speaker has brought advantage to her husband in his work does hint at it. Perhaps to their extended family living more rural lives OP and her family descend from the big city speaking Welsh and they seem a bit — well, pretentious. Perhaps the adults have talked about them in this way and the children have picked it up.

Meant to quote this post in my post above!

SemperIdem · 11/03/2023 17:42

This is quite true. The Pontcanna area of Cardiff is the hub for this type of Welsh speaker, though many have been priced out and opt for neighbouring Grangetown these days.

My child goes to a Welsh speaking school, though I am not myself a fluent Welsh speaker. The attitude described by the pp is alive and well amongst some of the parents. I personally don’t care in the slightest, but it does rankle others.

I don’t think it’s overly odd for children to be encouraged to be immersed in the secondary language at home, or even have one parent speak to them in English and the other Welsh (or whichever language), it’s an effective way to facilitate bilingualism.

pattihews · 11/03/2023 17:05

DH is a native Welsh speaker & it has served him very well in his career but he doesn't push it too much with the dc. They watch English TV, read English books etc but their school is all through Welsh. However as other posters suggested above I think he should start speaking to the dc in Welsh whenever we need to be in db's family's company.

Okay, OP. Personally I think if the others aren't confident Welsh speakers it would be really unhelpful for your DH to speak Welsh as a way of winding the family up.

I think the point made by a PP that your nieces and nephews have to learn Welsh as a despised compulsory extra language and are probably as disengaged from it as they are French or Spanish was very pertinent. They just don't see Welsh as important, and you do and they don't get it and they think you and your children are weird and different — which is how most young people feel about people they don't understand.

I hesitate to go there, but if you and your husband are nationalists and the brother and his family aren't, that's probably something else that is discussed — and possibly not very respectfully — in front of the children. I'm not saying that that excuses rudeness, but it may explain some aspects of their behaviour. Obviously the kids ought to be able to get on with each other. So why aren't your BIL and SIL wading in and insisting on politeness?

What do you think they think of you and your husband?

Waitin4snow · 11/03/2023 17:01

They are feeling inferior and they don’t like it OP .

There are many people in life who will be unkind to your kids , some of them family . it’s about getting your kids to realise that most bullying comes from the bullies own inadequacies and to rise above it .. preferably chatting amongst themselves in Welsh

LookItsMeAgain · 11/03/2023 16:46

MzHz · 11/03/2023 14:44

So bollock the cousins yourself!

“Excuse me, but enough of your rudeness. If you can be pleasant to my kids then kindly stay silent or remove yourselves before I do it with a boot up your arse. I wouldn’t take this crap from knuckle dragging strangers and I sure as hell won’t take it from family.”

if/when their parents kick off say something like “finally, you ARE able to pull people up on behaviour. If you can’t teach your kids some manners I will.”

then leave.

make the scene. Your kids need to see they are defended and valued.

100% this.

These are rude teenagers who will grow up to be rude adults. Time for them to see that you stick up for your kids.
Just because they are cousins does not mean that they get to be rude to them.

I'd start by saying "If you've nothing nice to say, I'd rather you keep your mouth shut", even better if you say it first in Welsh! 😉

laroisenoire123 · 11/03/2023 16:42

tell your kids that next time it happens, for your kids to speak to each other in welsh, look at them and laugh....

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 11/03/2023 16:42

We had 3 nephews who were similar. Looked down on all their cousins. I just stopped seeing them, other than about twice a year. Told my dc to rise above it. In adulthood all the cousins are close, apart from these 3.

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 16:36

@JADS I love living in Cardiff, it's a great city. The cousins weren't always like that & I think that's what the most upsetting bit.

OP posts:
JADS · 11/03/2023 16:31

I was born in England, but my Dad is a native Welsh speaker as are my cousins. I have never experienced the unpleasantness that some have on here with regards to Welsh language speakers. However my uncle was very meh about Cardiff and when we lived there temporarily, we had some bloody odd reactions from more rural dwellers (not family members) about the 'big city' and how awful it was. I didn't dare tell them we are actually from London!

I loved Cardiff and probably would have sent ds to a Welsh medium school if we had stayed. Your DN and DN sound nasty and I would agree it probably comes from DB and SIL. I would be tempted to avoid them all.

pictoosh · 11/03/2023 16:26

Yes sounds like your brother and sil’s noses have been put out of joint by your move and Welsh speaking school. Your brother’s nationality is a point of pride and because he’s never left the village he grew up in, he resents that you left and your kids speak better Welsh than theirs do. They have scorned your choices around their kids.

I wouldn’t put my kids through another sneerfest. What’s more I’d be telling my brother why.
“Our kids didn’t enjoy being put down and there’s no need to repeat the experience.”

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 16:21

pattihews · 11/03/2023 16:16

It may actually be about a bit more than having rude relatives.

When I first came to live in Wales back in the 90s a Welsh friend (Barry born and non-Welsh-speaking) took me to a concert at the St David's Centre where at the bar we experienced some Welsh speakers being unpleasant to the barman because he couldn't speak Welsh and couldn't understand their order expressed in Welsh.

These people, my friend explained, was what was laughingly known as the Taffia: a group of middle class Welsh speakers, often influential in politics and education and the law, who send their children to Welsh-medium schools (Cardiff is largely English speaking/ English-medium for education and 20 years ago there were a limited number of them). Not long ago I was introduced to a Cardiff woman whose Welsh-first-language husband insisted that only Welsh was spoken in the home and only Welsh TV and radio were allowed. Their children went to Welsh-medium schools and Welsh camp. It's a kind of Welsh elitism.

Not saying that the OP and her family are like this or are part of that group, but the fact that being a Welsh speaker has brought advantage to her husband in his work does hint at it. Perhaps to their extended family living more rural lives OP and her family descend from the big city speaking Welsh and they seem a bit — well, pretentious. Perhaps the adults have talked about them in this way and the children have picked it up.

DH is a native Welsh speaker & it has served him very well in his career but he doesn't push it too much with the dc. They watch English TV, read English books etc but their school is all through Welsh. However as other posters suggested above I think he should start speaking to the dc in Welsh whenever we need to be in db's family's company.

OP posts:
Lavenderflower · 11/03/2023 16:21

This sounds like something that would have overheard. I would have pulled them up on their prejudiced behaviour. These type of comment could get them in serious trouble in the the future. I surprised the parents didn't say anything

Hotvimto3 · 11/03/2023 16:20

Beautiful3 · 11/03/2023 16:17

I think the kids are voicing what their parents are saying. Next time they slag off the school just say, don't be so rude. Or ask, why would you say that?

Yes. I have started saying to my friends daughter who is like this ' what do you think people might think about you when you say things like that' granted she literally stared me down but i don't care. She has no manners and respect.

NewtoHolland · 11/03/2023 16:18

They sound like they are being raised to be very unpleasant, sneering is such an ugly quality.

Beautiful3 · 11/03/2023 16:17

I think the kids are voicing what their parents are saying. Next time they slag off the school just say, don't be so rude. Or ask, why would you say that?

Justmeandthedog1 · 11/03/2023 16:17

It’s not hormones — it’s children who have not been taught good manners.

Hotvimto3 · 11/03/2023 16:17

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 16:15

Dc3 getting an air up bottle for her birthday.. He was telling me there that he told his cousins last night. His cousin said "yea I got one for Christmas but it's rubbish, it makes me feel sick".. They just seem to want to put my cousins down at every single opportunity even bloody air up bottles & Harry Styles!

My friends daughter is like this. Shes fucking horrible to be around.

Mommymoments · 11/03/2023 16:16

Sorry he not she!

OP posts: