Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that men find it so easy to walk away?

61 replies

IfIseeonemorespaghettihoop · 11/03/2023 13:26

Apologies as this is really long.

My DP told me a few weeks ago that it’s over. We have been together for 5 years and have a toddler.
We have had problems since the birth of our DC, I had quite severe postnatal anxiety which manifested in a few different ways including me having an incessant need for control over everything to do with DC, which obviously caused huge problems for us a couple as he felt I didn’t trust him and that I would nitpick about everything he did. Admittedly I did do these things. He also says I changed as a person, my feeling on this is that you can’t help but change a bit (and probably should) when you have a child but again I think a lot of this was attributable to the PNA.

I am only just now starting to get my old self back and feel normal due to a lot of self reflection and therapy almost 2 years on.

DP has remained completely resolute that there is no hope for our relationship, my behaviour has caused him to feel differently about me and that I’ve made him “the unhappiest man in the world” over the past couple of years.
The thing is though, although there are real elements of truth in all of this, we have had some incredibly happy times as well, we still laugh together and talk and can enjoy spending time together, we have even had sex since the relationship ended (which was completely initiated by him) and it was really great sex, so to me I can’t help but to keep wondering how he doesn’t think there’s anything worth salvaging?

I can’t understand the mindset of just closing the door completely on what used to to a fantastic relationship, we were incredibly happy, especially now that there’s a child involved. Why wouldn’t you want to give it everything in your power to see if it can be saved?
None of this seems hard on him, he has just packed cases to go to stay with his parents and brought them downstairs, I’m doing all I can to hold back tears in front of little one and he appears completely unaffected, just like he’s popping to the shop.

I do wonder whether he hasn’t got the emotional maturity to be in an adult relationship and to navigate the conflict and issues that arise as part of it, I feel like he thinks the honeymoon stage is how a good relationship should be at all times and when real life sets in he’s not interested, he ended his last long term relationship before me very suddenly and without so much as a backward glance or proper explanation to his ex, he cannot process emotions or talk about deep issues without becoming angry and blaming me for everything that’s wrong, but there were two of us in the relationship, I didn’t make it go wrong all by myself.

How is it so easy for (mostly men) to just decide they’re done and walk away, even when kids are involved? What is it about trying hard to work on a relationship that isn’t worth even trying?

I feel so sad, hurt, angry, betrayed. This is fucking hard.

OP posts:
RedDirtWildChild · 11/03/2023 16:39

The thing is though, you’ve said the relationship had issues from early on and that you put up with a lot. Yet if you’ve only been with him 5 years and have already been pregnant and have a toddler, that means that you rushed into having a child with someone that you were not in a solid relationship with. It’s no surprise that when things get hard, the relationship breaks down. When the relationship isn’t built on solid foundations and a deep love and respect, of course he’s not going to find it that difficult to walk away.

It’s done now though. Learn from it. And having sex this man.

Throwncrumbs · 11/03/2023 16:39

Choconut · 11/03/2023 14:54

He's messing with you OP and I can't believe no one else can see it. He doesn't want you but you're familiar and a safe bet, so he'll have a laugh when he wants it and sex when he wants that and then he'll walk away again.

You need to start putting in boundaries and not allowing him to swan in and out as he pleases. Stop allowing him to use you as it just going to prolong the hurt indefinitely. Now you only talk about your child and only as required. He chose to walk away so now you need to make it clear that he needs to stop muddying the waters and messing you around.

My thoughts exactly, stop having sex with this guy, he’s using you, and is giving you false hope. Not good for your emotional well being!

IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 11/03/2023 16:38

I think there is a grain of truth in this tbf. I don't think its all men by any stretch but a substantial number of men have a "template" for a woman and as long as she ticks enough of the boxes (attractive, looks acceptable and scrubs up OK, gets on with friends and parents, cooks, cleans, looks after kids) they are more or less interchangeable. While the first one is working well and still under warranty they will play nice but if she malfunctions it's on to the next. It can't come as a shock to any of you that some men are like this.

Even women have some idea what they are looking for in men and should her wants and needs not be met she leaves...
We have "templates". Everyone does.

We don't just lie down next to first guy who picks us with absolutely no agency over our lives (well I would bloody hope so though it does sound on here that many simply do)...

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 11/03/2023 16:25

Sorry you're going thru such a tough time, OP.

From everything you've said it sounds like you've both spent a fair amount of time unhappy in your relatively short 5 year relationship. You at the beginning and clearly he's been very unhappy for the past two years. So roughly half your relationship (give or take).

He has ended things and apparently is not interested in trying to work things out. You are understandably very hurt.

We have no way of knowing if he has found walking away "easy". It could be that somewhere over the past two years when he was unhappy he just accepted that the relationship couldn't be saved. So perhaps not easy, it's just that he's further along in the process than you.

As for the sex...many people (both men and women) continue to have sex with people they no longer love, for various reasons. Convenience, familiarity or just because that's who happens to be available. Only you can decide if continuing with that is benefiting you. To be clear though - you're not a victim, you are a willing participant.

You won't always be this sad. I sincerely hope this man lives up to his responsibilities as a father. You will find happiness again, but not with this man. Good luck.

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/03/2023 16:25

CantAskAnyoneElse · 11/03/2023 14:01

A lot, A LOT, of men just see women as a means to an end. And objects.

Women are supposed to just look good for them, have sex with them, build a life/home/family around them. Cook and clean and remind them to see a doctor for them.

As long as women do these for men, they will ’love’ you (love what these women do for them).

And once that it’s over, they leave.
Kind of like if you washing machine don’t work - you just throw it away and get a new one.

It’s not deeper than this for most of them, that’s why it’s so easy for them to leave.
They never actually cared in the first place.

Sad, but true.

I think there is a grain of truth in this tbf. I don't think its all men by any stretch but a substantial number of men have a "template" for a woman and as long as she ticks enough of the boxes (attractive, looks acceptable and scrubs up OK, gets on with friends and parents, cooks, cleans, looks after kids) they are more or less interchangeable. While the first one is working well and still under warranty they will play nice but if she malfunctions it's on to the next. It can't come as a shock to any of you that some men are like this.

On the other hand it's by no means clear that this bloke has been like this. He may have been but by your own admission OP you have not been much fun to live with. He may have really struggled for a long time and just run out of road.

Doesn't make it any easier for you and obviously very painful but I don't think there's much to be gained from trying to change his mind or continuing to sleep with him. That ship has sailed.

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/03/2023 16:21

@Spanky123

Sad fact is woman can't do it all without men, as much as it sounds like you would like to.

They can't? Says who? I've been doing it all for 12 years....

Moonicorn · 11/03/2023 16:15

CantAskAnyoneElse · 11/03/2023 14:01

A lot, A LOT, of men just see women as a means to an end. And objects.

Women are supposed to just look good for them, have sex with them, build a life/home/family around them. Cook and clean and remind them to see a doctor for them.

As long as women do these for men, they will ’love’ you (love what these women do for them).

And once that it’s over, they leave.
Kind of like if you washing machine don’t work - you just throw it away and get a new one.

It’s not deeper than this for most of them, that’s why it’s so easy for them to leave.
They never actually cared in the first place.

Sad, but true.

That’s life isn’t it? You don’t stay with someone who looks a slob, wants different things to you, does nothing around the house. This ‘love me for who I am’ trope is a load of nonsense. As long as the effort is reciprocal, what’s wrong with that?

ComtesseDeSpair · 11/03/2023 16:11

How much of your relationship has actually been any good? You’ve only been together for five years yet there were problems with his behaviour at the start serious enough for lots of talk around expectations and boundaries; problems for the last two years with the effects of your poor mental health and controlling behaviour. It doesn’t sound like it’s been much fun for either of you for very much of it at all. It sounds like he’s finally got to the point where he can admit that to himself. Perhaps you need to do the same, however hard that currently feels, and evaluate whether the relationship has ever been what you want it to be.

Spanky123 · 11/03/2023 15:55

CantAskAnyoneElse · 11/03/2023 14:01

A lot, A LOT, of men just see women as a means to an end. And objects.

Women are supposed to just look good for them, have sex with them, build a life/home/family around them. Cook and clean and remind them to see a doctor for them.

As long as women do these for men, they will ’love’ you (love what these women do for them).

And once that it’s over, they leave.
Kind of like if you washing machine don’t work - you just throw it away and get a new one.

It’s not deeper than this for most of them, that’s why it’s so easy for them to leave.
They never actually cared in the first place.

Sad, but true.

WOW! True colours here...
Sad fact is woman can't do it all without men, as much as it sounds like you would like to.

Lovelyveg82 · 11/03/2023 15:54

CantAskAnyoneElse · 11/03/2023 14:22

Where did I say majority?

And it’s not bullshit.
If you don’t want to see it, then don’t. But it’s true.

Yes it is true

in. YOUR. Experience.

sure as heck not mine

Lovelyveg82 · 11/03/2023 15:53

on what used to to a fantastic relationship,

but you say say

”I put up with a lot” even at the very start of the relationship

you have been together just 5 years and a good proportion of that has been highly troubled by the sounds of it

it really doesn’t sound like this really ever had long term legs op

Moonicorn · 11/03/2023 15:38

You don’t need to ‘accept responsibility’ OP, you weren’t well, and he has exercised his right to leave a relationship he felt he couldn’t cope with. Neither of you are to blame. There doesn’t need to be a villain. But I do agree with this:

I think men are generally much better at compartmentalising their emotional lives than women. This has its downsides but it also means that once they decide something isn't working for them they are able to shut the emotions which related to that relationship down more easily than women.

Just don’t have sex with him again the last thing you need is to end up a FWB or pregnant.

IfIseeonemorespaghettihoop · 11/03/2023 15:33

I would just like to clarify for anyone that has misinterpreted the situation, I have wholly and unreservedly accepted responsibility for how my actions and behaviour have contributed to the ultimate demise of our relationship, that’s why I finally sought the help I needed and have been nothing other than honest when describing the way I have been.
On the other hand, he has accepted no responsibility at all, he is just happy to go with the “It’s all your fault because you made me so unhappy” narrative, but at no point did he seriously sit me down and communicate with me and tell me how desperately unhappy I was making him and talk about ways we could’ve changed things. He doesn’t think it was his responsibility to do that, he said it’s not his responsibility to change my behaviour. i agree that’s it’s not his responsibility to change my behaviour but as one half of an adult relationship with a child it most certainly was his responsibility to communicate with me about how he was feeling and to suggest solutions. Especially when I was at a point where the fog was so thick I couldn’t see that I was doing anything wrong.
When we were first together I put up with a lot from him (not cheating or anything like that) but seriously questionable behaviour but I loved him and I knew that we would be happy if he were to address these behaviours so I stuck with it, had countless conversations about my expectations and boundaries and made him see the impact he was having, I just don’t understand not doing this when you love someone.

OP posts:
Lovelyveg82 · 11/03/2023 15:32

”Easy” when

a) you have completely un judgemental parent; and
b) likely to have a love Interest that is serious or becoming increasingly serious; and
c) a twat

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 11/03/2023 15:30

So the relationship is over and you are still letting him shag you all on his terms?. Over is over. Draw a line and stop letting him have his cake and eat it. You deserve better.

TedMullins · 11/03/2023 15:27

I’m sorry you’re hurting, break ups are horrible but I’m afraid I don’t agree. I used to think like you - that love should conquer all and the good times should outweigh the bad and mean it’s worth fighting for, even if the bad times are in reality overshadowing the good. I no longer think that’s the correct approach.

Love is not enough, not on its own. You can love someone but come to realise, as painful as it is, that being with them hurts you. It sounds like this is what’s happened here. I’ve had MH issues myself and they’ve contributed to past breakups because frankly I was a fucking nightmare and I’d have dumped me had the roles been reversed. MH isn’t a green card to treat people badly and push them to their limit. The fact it’s bad enough for him to leave suggests the effect on him has been profound. Have you had any help with your anxiety?

all that said, he shouldn’t be messing you about by having sex with you, and he still has responsibilities to your child as a co parent so how he behaves there will show how decent he really is. But all in all I think more women should up and leave when things are bad. “Real life” doesn’t mean misery and being ground down, relationships don’t have to be hard work.

IWinMN · 11/03/2023 15:15

You made him miserable and he felt like he couldn't leave while you were unwell, otherwise he'd have gone sooner.

Honestly think you need to accept your part in it, and move on - even the way you're saying 'oh he's not mature enough to be in an adult relarionship' is ridiculous. He didn't deserve to be treated the way you treated him, and he's finally had enough.

Sapphire387 · 11/03/2023 15:10

CalistoNoSolo · 11/03/2023 14:25

It sounds like he's been through absolute hell and I can't blame him for falling out of love with you. I would have walked after the first few months and we would be separated co-parents now. You need to own your behaviour, however it was caused. There may be hope for your relationship beyond friendly co-parenting, but you're going to have to give him space, trust him with your child and keel a lid on your feelings of anger and betrayal.

Harsh.

She had mental health problems after the birth of THEIR child.

Plus he's hardly innocent, fucking with her head by having sex with her after telling her it's 'over'.

Choconut · 11/03/2023 14:54

He's messing with you OP and I can't believe no one else can see it. He doesn't want you but you're familiar and a safe bet, so he'll have a laugh when he wants it and sex when he wants that and then he'll walk away again.

You need to start putting in boundaries and not allowing him to swan in and out as he pleases. Stop allowing him to use you as it just going to prolong the hurt indefinitely. Now you only talk about your child and only as required. He chose to walk away so now you need to make it clear that he needs to stop muddying the waters and messing you around.

CalistoNoSolo · 11/03/2023 14:25

It sounds like he's been through absolute hell and I can't blame him for falling out of love with you. I would have walked after the first few months and we would be separated co-parents now. You need to own your behaviour, however it was caused. There may be hope for your relationship beyond friendly co-parenting, but you're going to have to give him space, trust him with your child and keel a lid on your feelings of anger and betrayal.

Coffeellama · 11/03/2023 14:23

CantAskAnyoneElse · 11/03/2023 14:22

Where did I say majority?

And it’s not bullshit.
If you don’t want to see it, then don’t. But it’s true.

You said A LOT and most of them. Most of = majority.

Livinghappy · 11/03/2023 14:22

Op, I agree with you. However you seem to be taking on the blame for the relationship ending but he can't have been perfect.

I think what is closer to the truth is that he can't live outside of the honeymoon phase. Call me cynical but I also think you might get surprised by someone else appearing. It sounds fairly classic to me.

Are you back at work yet?

CantAskAnyoneElse · 11/03/2023 14:22

Sporty2022 · 11/03/2023 14:08

Absolute bullshit. Some men yes, but not the majority.

Where did I say majority?

And it’s not bullshit.
If you don’t want to see it, then don’t. But it’s true.

Companyofwolves · 11/03/2023 14:12

Sounds painful OP. I think because they don’t physically or hormonally change in the way we do through having a child, they can be much more removed. And you’ve gone through a tumultuous post natal experience, and it’s been tough on you both. I feel for you because the anxiety you experienced isn’t your fault & you’d hope he could have been more forgiving maybe. However emotional & mental distress & controlling behaviours are tough on any relationship & he sadly sounds like he can’t deal with it any more.

If you were married I suppose you could say a partner is supposed to be there in sickness and in health. And regardless of a marital contract you do hope having a partner is about having that support that is not conditional. It’s a hard one & heartbreaking that he can’t get over it now that you’re back to your old self more. I would feel the same & as though he was abandoning you & your son as well to a degree - couldn’t he try to save the relationship given you have your son together & are much better now? He should not be sleeping with you however & I can understand you hoping that if you can have sex & want each other maybe it will mean /prove to him that there’s a chance still. Given you can get on well etc as well & enjoy each other’s company still.
I don’t know what your relationship was like before you had your DC & how invested he was in this to start with? I would feel resentful at how fairweather some people can be, when essentially they have helped create the thing that brought about your PND /anxiety. Maybe you need someone who is able to be there through thick & thin & that he has shown that for whatever reason he isn’t that. Him saying that it’s all down to your mental health is pretty harsh & will be hard to move on from OP. But it can be extremely hard on relationships & I suppose if anything the experience has taught you more about yourself & how these aspects of yourself can impact on your relationships & also maybe a realisation of the kind of person you want to be with in the future, who will have your back during the tough times 💐

DrManhattan · 11/03/2023 14:10

@CantAskAnyoneElse that may be your experience but nearly all the men I know are decent human beings.