Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that men find it so easy to walk away?

61 replies

IfIseeonemorespaghettihoop · 11/03/2023 13:26

Apologies as this is really long.

My DP told me a few weeks ago that it’s over. We have been together for 5 years and have a toddler.
We have had problems since the birth of our DC, I had quite severe postnatal anxiety which manifested in a few different ways including me having an incessant need for control over everything to do with DC, which obviously caused huge problems for us a couple as he felt I didn’t trust him and that I would nitpick about everything he did. Admittedly I did do these things. He also says I changed as a person, my feeling on this is that you can’t help but change a bit (and probably should) when you have a child but again I think a lot of this was attributable to the PNA.

I am only just now starting to get my old self back and feel normal due to a lot of self reflection and therapy almost 2 years on.

DP has remained completely resolute that there is no hope for our relationship, my behaviour has caused him to feel differently about me and that I’ve made him “the unhappiest man in the world” over the past couple of years.
The thing is though, although there are real elements of truth in all of this, we have had some incredibly happy times as well, we still laugh together and talk and can enjoy spending time together, we have even had sex since the relationship ended (which was completely initiated by him) and it was really great sex, so to me I can’t help but to keep wondering how he doesn’t think there’s anything worth salvaging?

I can’t understand the mindset of just closing the door completely on what used to to a fantastic relationship, we were incredibly happy, especially now that there’s a child involved. Why wouldn’t you want to give it everything in your power to see if it can be saved?
None of this seems hard on him, he has just packed cases to go to stay with his parents and brought them downstairs, I’m doing all I can to hold back tears in front of little one and he appears completely unaffected, just like he’s popping to the shop.

I do wonder whether he hasn’t got the emotional maturity to be in an adult relationship and to navigate the conflict and issues that arise as part of it, I feel like he thinks the honeymoon stage is how a good relationship should be at all times and when real life sets in he’s not interested, he ended his last long term relationship before me very suddenly and without so much as a backward glance or proper explanation to his ex, he cannot process emotions or talk about deep issues without becoming angry and blaming me for everything that’s wrong, but there were two of us in the relationship, I didn’t make it go wrong all by myself.

How is it so easy for (mostly men) to just decide they’re done and walk away, even when kids are involved? What is it about trying hard to work on a relationship that isn’t worth even trying?

I feel so sad, hurt, angry, betrayed. This is fucking hard.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lovelyveg82 · 12/03/2023 08:39

CantAskAnyoneElse · 12/03/2023 08:09

Hey, no reasons for faux caring.
It’s all good, I just have my eyes open and I don’t pretend men are something they are not. I know many women aren’t strong and brave enought to do it, that’s okey.

Misandry isin’t a thing.
HTH

I’m 36.
And nothing, I’ve never been on any kind of a relationship.

so how have you developed such a deep understanding of what “a lot” of men are like? From mumsnet threads? God forbid! 😂

Lovelyveg82 · 12/03/2023 08:33

Ok I read the thread you started @CantAskAnyoneElse and your stance on this thread is now very clear.
If I’d never known love, didn’t have a good childhood, didn’t have children, doubted whether I ever could have relationship because I doubted whether love was ever possible… then I suppose I too may have such a generally and profoundly negative view of around 50% of the population

Lovelyveg82 · 12/03/2023 08:29

@CantAskAnyoneElse

do you have children?

Mummadeze · 12/03/2023 08:19

I think you could do a lot better. I think there is a chance he has made you think this is all your fault when it isn’t. I couldn’t walk away from my five year old easily as a parent, so that is a red flag to me. I am so sorry you are hurting, but I wouldn’t blame yourself for pushing him away. You might have been gaslighted to some extent.

CantAskAnyoneElse · 12/03/2023 08:09

JudgeRudy · 11/03/2023 19:47

I agree. @CantAskAnyoneElse , I'm sorry if this has been your experience but what you describe isnt the male norm. You sound very misandristic.

Hey, no reasons for faux caring.
It’s all good, I just have my eyes open and I don’t pretend men are something they are not. I know many women aren’t strong and brave enought to do it, that’s okey.

Misandry isin’t a thing.
HTH

CantAskAnyoneElse · 12/03/2023 07:56

Moonicorn · 11/03/2023 16:15

That’s life isn’t it? You don’t stay with someone who looks a slob, wants different things to you, does nothing around the house. This ‘love me for who I am’ trope is a load of nonsense. As long as the effort is reciprocal, what’s wrong with that?

Yeah, I guess.
As long as everyone is honest and no one pretends there is any meaning in it.
Let’s chuck the whole ’love’ word out completely, the it’s all good.
And as long as women can do the same for men😉
Would be plenty of divorces soon…

GoldilocksIsALittleSod · 12/03/2023 07:44

It's sounds like he wanted to leave for a while but waited until you were mentally well before he left, hence why no tears at the door. He'd checked out of the relationship a long time ago.
If you had been unwell for around 2 years with PND, that is a long time (especially in a 5 year relationship) for him to 'put up' with your issues and having the rocky start that only leaves a couple of years at most that this relationship was functioning!!
I think perhaps he has no fight left in him, hopefully he intends to do right by his child but as an emotionally mature adult he is allowed to leave you, or to fall out of love with you for any reason (how many times of here are women told to leave their mentally unwell husbands.....)
Stop having sex with him, obviously.

Lovelyveg82 · 12/03/2023 05:45

serious questionable behaviour

right at the beginning of your relationship

I mean it doesn’t sound like you had much of a “honeymoon period” op

Lovelyveg82 · 12/03/2023 05:44

IfIseeonemorespaghettihoop · 11/03/2023 21:51

I said “obviously” because I had alluded to it in the posts.

You hadn’t at all

but ok… out of 5 years you had a couple of happy ones 🤷‍♀️

SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 11/03/2023 22:10

Many facets to this OP.

Unwise of both of you to have a child so early on without a well-established relationship and especially if there were already relationship issues. Hard to judge the severity of those since you've not elaborated.

Sounds like he did try to support you with the PNA and you perhaps did not get help in the timely manner you should have if it's taken this long to fix? When you say "controlling behaviour", what were you doing? Mental health problems are hard and it wasn't your fault you were unwell but you must have known that it was not ok to behave horribly to him.

However, it was irresponsible of him to have a baby with you in the first place if he's the type of person who can't handle that maternal mental health issues are a common effect of having a baby. If he wasn't prepared to weather one of the many "storms" that a baby can bring to life: disability, injuries mental or physical to the mother, etc, he had no business creating a baby at all. If such things happen an adult deals with that at the time, talking, communicating, getting help in place etc, doesn't wait for two years without discussing the issue then suddenly flounce off. People shouldn't have kids if they aren't grown up enough to know they can stick it out if the first few years are tough on them and their relationship as there is a significant likelihood of that being the case. It does reek a bit of manchild. But that depends what you were actually doing when suffering from PNA. If you were actually abusive to him then he's right to leave obviously. If he just found it difficult to cope with you being so anxious and this was out of character for you then that's different.

Awful behaviour from him to tell you it's over and then have sex with you again: this shows huge emotional immaturity and a lack of responsibility or care for his child knowing that you were vulnerable with him just having announced hexis leaving and how having sex with you again would likely cause even more emotional turmoil for you and potentially damage the chances of a good co-parenting relationship. This sounds utterly selfish and very messed up behaviour from him.

Ultimately though it sounds like he's not someone who views relationships the way you do and isn't capable of having the type of relationship with you that you thought you had/ wanted to have together. It doesn't sound like the situation is salvagable so I think you should focus on you and your child now and move on, forget him.

IfIseeonemorespaghettihoop · 11/03/2023 21:51

I said “obviously” because I had alluded to it in the posts.

OP posts:
SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 11/03/2023 21:41

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/03/2023 16:21

@Spanky123

Sad fact is woman can't do it all without men, as much as it sounds like you would like to.

They can't? Says who? I've been doing it all for 12 years....

I was thinking the same! Not surewhat it is we're meant to be incapable of.

ReneBumsWombats · 11/03/2023 21:24

Obviously we have had our struggles in the beginning

Why do you think that's obvious? The beginning is supposed to be the honeymoon period...

Was your baby planned? You say you didn't want to marry too quickly, but having a baby was OK? A baby throws a grenade into even the strongest relationships.

I'm not trying to pull apart your relationship. I just don't think it sounds as if it was ever that strong or that he's shown much change of character. I agree with a PP that it's shitty of him to initiate sex if he's so sure he wants out.

Lovelyveg82 · 11/03/2023 21:14

No op it is not “obvious” to have “struggles at the beginning”. Nor is it “obvious” to “put up with a lot” of “seriously questionable behaviour” at the beginning of a relationship.

It would seem you have had a very limited period of time where you were both happy.

I know it’s hurtful and tough but I suspect your partner has just pulled off a plaster that was inevitably going to fall off anyway

IfIseeonemorespaghettihoop · 11/03/2023 20:27

ReneBumsWombats · 11/03/2023 19:55

I'm sorry you're going through this, OP. I had such terrible PND with my first that I almost didn't have a second so I know it can really change your personality.

How were things before the baby? Is there a reason you didn't marry? Of course you don't have to be married to have a good relationship and there might be good reasons for it, but I'm just wondering if he was never really all in to start with, which would explain him bailing now. I like to think that if a man really loves a woman, he would hold through while she's not herself from having his child and be there when she returns.

Obviously we have had our struggles in the beginning which I won’t go into but things were really genuinely great, we had reached a point in our relationship where we understood each other and were very very happy, many of the same goals, shared interests and similar outlooks on life, same sense of humour etc.

we talked a lot about marriage but I didn’t want to get married too quickly and then when I got pregnant I guess it was a bit of an unspoken thing that we’d wait until after baby was born and settled.

i think the same as you and yes, I wonder the same thing, although I never thought or felt like that until he ended it

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 11/03/2023 19:55

I'm sorry you're going through this, OP. I had such terrible PND with my first that I almost didn't have a second so I know it can really change your personality.

How were things before the baby? Is there a reason you didn't marry? Of course you don't have to be married to have a good relationship and there might be good reasons for it, but I'm just wondering if he was never really all in to start with, which would explain him bailing now. I like to think that if a man really loves a woman, he would hold through while she's not herself from having his child and be there when she returns.

JudgeRudy · 11/03/2023 19:47

Coffeellama · 11/03/2023 14:05

There are plenty of men out there like this, but it’s ridiculous to suggest it’s most men, it’s not. And it’s not a helpful reply to the OP, their relationship has struggled due to really unfortunate mental health, not because he’s just a bastard.

I agree. @CantAskAnyoneElse , I'm sorry if this has been your experience but what you describe isnt the male norm. You sound very misandristic.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 11/03/2023 19:24

Sapphire387 · 11/03/2023 15:10

Harsh.

She had mental health problems after the birth of THEIR child.

Plus he's hardly innocent, fucking with her head by having sex with her after telling her it's 'over'.

Yeah, and however bad my relationship with my partner was, I can’t imagine being completely unaffected while preparing to walk out of the home I share with my child.

tothelefttotheleft · 11/03/2023 17:44

Choconut · 11/03/2023 14:54

He's messing with you OP and I can't believe no one else can see it. He doesn't want you but you're familiar and a safe bet, so he'll have a laugh when he wants it and sex when he wants that and then he'll walk away again.

You need to start putting in boundaries and not allowing him to swan in and out as he pleases. Stop allowing him to use you as it just going to prolong the hurt indefinitely. Now you only talk about your child and only as required. He chose to walk away so now you need to make it clear that he needs to stop muddying the waters and messing you around.

I can't believe no one picked up on the sex issue until you did.

No decent man sleeps with someone they no longer wants to be with. What a user he is.

stuckdownahole · 11/03/2023 17:23

He might be seeing this in a totally pragmatic way. It's possible he fell out of love with you some considerable time ago and has now decided that the time is right to leave the relationship.

He can manage being separated from his child with only routine visits, whereas it sounds like you wouldn't be able to handle that emotionally. Therefore he calculated that if you split up, you would have to have custody.

You were unwell and he didn't want to leave you (and the child) in that situation but now you are better.

He shouldn't be initiating sex with you, that's unfair and selfish. But lots of men and women have fallen into bed with an ex as a previous poster said. It shouldn't happen again and you shouldn't read it as a sign that he is wavering.

Coffeellama · 11/03/2023 16:55

i agree that’s it’s not his responsibility to change my behaviour but as one half of an adult relationship with a child it most certainly was his responsibility to communicate with me about how he was feeling and to suggest solutions.

And as the other half of the adult relationship you could have thought about how your actions were impacting your relationship and how unhappy he must be too. You acknowledge you were controlling and horrible but seem surprised he was unhappy, did you think he enjoyed it? Surely you could tell treating him badly would make him unhappy. You’ve only been together 5 years and you were unhappy at the start and you’ve both been unhappy the last 2 years, it doesn’t sound like you’ve ever had a great relationship. I no it’s hard to accept it’s over but this isn’t all his fault and he has a right to move on and be happy, as do you.

Chickenly · 11/03/2023 16:50

I’m sorry OP, I think (gently) YABU, but obviously you’re going through an awful time.

Firstly, it doesn’t seem like a sensible idea to have had a child so soon in a relationship where you’ve admitted that you were putting up with a lot.

Secondly, it sounds as though he’s put up with a lot. I recognise that PND and PNA are very difficult but that doesn’t actually entitle you to treat him how you chose to treat him. I think you have to take some responsibility for that.

Not to give you false hope but perhaps he would’ve been willing to work on the relationship if you had indicated an acceptance that you did the wrong thing at times and hurt him. It doesn’t sound as though you’re receptive to his needs or emotions, so it’s not surprising he’s not willing to be vulnerable with you.

I am sorry though, I know it’s tough but you will be ok. And, yes, at PP said, stop having sex with him. Neither of you should have allowed that to continue.

Lovelyveg82 · 11/03/2023 16:44

I feel like he thinks the honeymoon stage is how a good relationship should be at all times

but OP yours wasn’t even good in the honeymoon period. You say you “put up with a lot at the beginning”

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 11/03/2023 16:42

I feel like he thinks the honeymoon stage is how a good relationship should be at all times and when real life sets in he’s not interested, he ended his last long term relationship before me very suddenly and without so much as a backward glance or proper explanation to his ex, he cannot process emotions or talk about deep issues without becoming angry and blaming me for everything

Sounds like you're better off without this immature twat in your life.
Once you're over the shock, you'll agree.

RedDirtWildChild · 11/03/2023 16:40

*And STOP having sex with this man.