Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Secret Pay Rise

169 replies

Legaleagleplease · 11/03/2023 10:39

Hi All, I am hoping that one of the MN group has some experience they can share on this topic. My company is uber secretive about pay rises and bonuses.
I am suspicious why this is.

You are told that you will be disciplined if you tell anyone else what you earn. I am not sure this is legal or not, it certainly does not sound ethical.

The exact words from the HR Manager are:
You are reminded that information regarding your remuneration is strictly confidential and should not be divulged to colleagues.

AIBU to want clarity on what my peers earn?

OP posts:
Maray1967 · 11/03/2023 11:52

Bigmirrorssmallrooms · 11/03/2023 11:00

Is this your first job op?

I’ve been working for 30 plus years but if I was told not to disclose my salary to colleagues I would question that as well. All my team know I am at the top of a particular band. Pay scales are published and so all my team know exactly how much I earn. I think that’s exactly how it should be.

Summerhouse2013 · 11/03/2023 11:50

There is nothing in that HR statement that says you would actually be disciplined for discussing your salary.

category12 · 11/03/2023 11:47

SpottyLip · 11/03/2023 11:44

"Hey Frank, I got a 10% pay rise this year, what did you get?"
"2%. Now fuck off. Who did you sleep with to get 10?"

Or if you were the one with the lower raise, how does it help you to know that? You can't go back to the bosses and demand an increase.

Yes you can. If it's unfair, you certainly can go back and negotiate.

And if it's based on something discriminatory, you can take them to a tribunal.

ememem84 · 11/03/2023 11:45

I went into my appraisal recently and asked for between a 10-15k pay rise. Apparently I’m the only one who did this

whether I get it or not is another matter. But I did my research and made my case.

nc1013 · 11/03/2023 11:45

I think it's common for employers to not want you to discuss it. The wording you've quoted is fair enough.

I doubt they'd legally be able to do anything if you did tell someone

SpottyLip · 11/03/2023 11:44

Legaleagleplease · 11/03/2023 10:51

Wow - quick response! I think I was unclear in my original post.

Just for the record I do not think everyone's salary should be on the intranet. I meant more that I cannot discuss with a colleague that I have had a % pay rise.

"Hey Frank, I got a 10% pay rise this year, what did you get?"
"2%. Now fuck off. Who did you sleep with to get 10?"

Or if you were the one with the lower raise, how does it help you to know that? You can't go back to the bosses and demand an increase.

Climbles · 11/03/2023 11:43

Nevergonnastop · 11/03/2023 10:42

It's normal. It's none of your business what anyone else earns.

What if the company pays women less? Or black people? Would it be her business then?

Brefugee · 11/03/2023 11:43

a company i worked for was like this, and one of the men i worked with (same level but i had more seniority in years, which was one criteria for pay) and he was so keen to let me know how much he earned in the mistaken belief it was more than me.

Such a lemon-sucking expression when i told him i wouldn't stand being paid so little (not actually that much less than me, but i made my point)

to get back on topic - i hate these rules, but i can see why companies do it. I prefer transparency.

HMTheQueenMuffin · 11/03/2023 11:43

Organisations keep pay confidential when they are trying to reduce the remuneration people get. IMO.

I discovered by accident that my male colleague with less experience and who reported to me for some things was earning circa 30% more than me.

Tinkerbyebye · 11/03/2023 11:42

It’s normal, and yes you are being unreasonable to expect to know what your peers earn, it has nothing to do with you

category12 · 11/03/2023 11:40

Found this: "under the Equality Act 2010 it is unlawful to prevent an employee from disclosing a difference in salary if the purpose of doing so is to try to understand whether an equal pay issue exists. As such, whilst salary confidentiality clauses can be very useful, employers should take care to understand the circumstances of a particular disclosure before seeking to enforce them."

Chocolatefreak · 11/03/2023 11:35

I think the secrecy and lack of transparency is there for a reason - so that HR departments does not have to justify a lack of consistency in their salaries. This is often demonstrated in a lack of wage equality between men and women, seniority, qualifications etc. This secrrecy also makes the system open to abuse. When details are accidentally let slip it can be very damaging for individuals and organisations. As an example, I had just started working for a very small organisation. Shortly before I arrived, the Executive Director and another manager had negotiated, with the board, a 10% pay rise for themselves but not for the two existing admin members of staff. This was not announced but recorded in the board meeting minutes, which of course the admin officer saw. This resulted in a huge amount of resentment and was one of the factors that led to the departure of the ED and the other manager.

Other countries make transparency around salaries a legal requirement e.g. in Finland, so even if you don't know exactly what your colleagues salary is you can see it through clear salary scales available in the public domain. There is also a far smaller gap between basic salaries and the top of the scale compared to the UK.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 11/03/2023 11:18

Doyoumind · 11/03/2023 10:58

The point is they are unlikely to ever do anything or even know if you tell your colleague as a friend. But if said colleague then went and told a dozen people in the same role and they all got together and demanded an equivalent rise, the company would hold you responsible.

The company couldn't hold the OP responsible and if they tried to they'd be facing some legal issues of their own.

If colleagues find out someone is earning more than them and decide to ask for an equivalent pay rise it is up to the company to approve or reject the request. If they reject it they need to be able to justify why they feel one person is worth more than others and be prepared to loose that employee.

AdInfinitum12 · 11/03/2023 11:14

UpperLowerMiddleClass · 11/03/2023 11:11

Just because something is common or the norm doesn’t mean it’s acceptable. I think the more open people are about their pay the better.

In the sector I work in you always know the band someone’s pay is within eg £25-30k or £40-48k but not their exact pay. Which I think is a good compromise between transparency while also allowing some discretion for hiring managers to eg offer the top of the band salary to an outstanding candidate.

My employer does the same. Our band 2 is 33-39k, band 3 is 39k-45k and so on.
It means everyone with the same qualifications are in the same band but a manager can reward a stand-out candidate by promoting to the top of the band or providing small rises as and when. The top of the bands increase by a certain % each year so even if you reach the top of your band one year there's room for a further pay rise the next year.

ZiriForEver · 11/03/2023 11:12

Wow, this thread....

Privacy about salaries is one of the reasons of pay gaps. How is an individual supposed to learn about salaries, when noone is allowed to share theirs?

In EU it will be compulsory to share ranges for job advertisements, plus some statistics.

UpperLowerMiddleClass · 11/03/2023 11:11

Just because something is common or the norm doesn’t mean it’s acceptable. I think the more open people are about their pay the better.

In the sector I work in you always know the band someone’s pay is within eg £25-30k or £40-48k but not their exact pay. Which I think is a good compromise between transparency while also allowing some discretion for hiring managers to eg offer the top of the band salary to an outstanding candidate.

TheGenerousGardener · 11/03/2023 11:11

Secrecy surroundings salaries is very old fashioned.

Boomboom22 · 11/03/2023 11:10

It's unethical and legally unenforceable. The comments on here are nuts and just try to justify the pay gap. How anti feminist by default.

Zhougzhoug · 11/03/2023 11:10

This used to be more common when I was just starting out (I'm 41) and still happens quite a bit but it is my understanding that it is considered bad practice these days, on a par with not publishing a salary range. Employers who have those "we're a good employer" type kitemarks won't do it.

Masterofcats · 11/03/2023 11:10

I do find it odd that it's so secret. I was brought up not to discuss money publicly ( rude apparently). But my pay is common knowledge and you can Google NHS pay scales.
So yes what are they hiding if you can't talk about pay?

EstherHazy · 11/03/2023 11:10

I work in a finance department and see everyones pay. There are a lot of people are on a lot more than I think they probably should be, and a fair number on less. But maybe I think that because I'm in the lower echelons of pay and wouldn't think that if I joined the higher earners - I'd think I deserved it.

I also realise - who am I to really know! But I do know, working in finance, if everyone got the same raises as those who got the biggest, we'd be bankrupt, so we do NOT want those with bigger raises telling people who will go on to demand it themselves. There's a reason they've been selected for a raise based on performance which is meant to motivate them and recognise additional responsibilities/experience. But it will demotivate those who don't get the raise if they know this, and we can't afford to give them more.

I can also say after you get over the initial 'ooo' of knowing it all, it's actually not that interesting and is never a subject of conversation internally in the group who have access to this info (except occasionally if someone takes a massive redundancy pay out we'll be like 'oh they did well!' and just quickly move on).

But it's probably the danger of starting an uprising where everyone demands the highest raise given that's behind the confidentiality clause.

theemmadilemma · 11/03/2023 11:09

Crazycrazylady · 11/03/2023 10:54

Ah seriously.. how you hold down a job if you're querying why you can't announce your pay rise to all and sundry in the company is beyond me 🙄

But she has every legal right? And this is how employers get away with huge wage disparities in this country.

We SHOULD discuss.

macncheeeesey · 11/03/2023 11:08

It's so staff don't get disgruntled over how little they get paid compared to colleagues. At my last job, I realised one of my colleagues was getting paid double the amount I was, it was a shock and I left shortly after because when I started the role, they haggled me down by £10,000K, saying they couldn't afford anymore.

I love the role I thought, so I took the job anyway..

In my current role, recently someone left and we had a discussion about wages and pay, turns out again I am the lowest paid person in the company, it's a small start-up . I'm disgruntled once again as a pay rise doesn't seem like it will happen.

Doyoumind · 11/03/2023 11:08

I once managed a team of people who all had the same job title and role in theory, where the highest earner's salary was over 50% more than the lowest. When woman on the lowest salary got a rise she was thrilled but had she known how much others were earning she wouldn't have been quite so happy. It's not that people were being paid unfairly, but rather that their salaries matched their experience rather than the job title. I did push for levels to be introduced but wasn't backed by senior management.

edwinbear · 11/03/2023 11:07

Completely normal in my sector too. When I was younger, we’d discuss salary/bonuses with each other anyway, it never ended well.