Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Secret Pay Rise

169 replies

Legaleagleplease · 11/03/2023 10:39

Hi All, I am hoping that one of the MN group has some experience they can share on this topic. My company is uber secretive about pay rises and bonuses.
I am suspicious why this is.

You are told that you will be disciplined if you tell anyone else what you earn. I am not sure this is legal or not, it certainly does not sound ethical.

The exact words from the HR Manager are:
You are reminded that information regarding your remuneration is strictly confidential and should not be divulged to colleagues.

AIBU to want clarity on what my peers earn?

OP posts:
daisychain01 · 11/03/2023 12:37

The exact words from the HR Manager are:

You are reminded that information regarding your remuneration is strictly confidential and should not be divulged to colleagues.

if those are the "exact words" they aren't saying you will be disciplined for talking about your remuneration. They need to say something like "discussing your remuneration is subject to disciplinary procedures" or similar.

if I were you I wouldn't discuss you pay with colleagues, it never ends well.

Anniegetyourgun · 11/03/2023 12:35

All the permanent jobs I've done and most of the temporary ones over many decades have been in the public sector, where you know pretty much to the penny how much all your colleagues earn simply by knowing their grade and length of service, barring performance related scale positioning and small bonuses for exceptional (measurable, recorded) achievements. That seems much healthier to me than this secrecy lark. There would otherwise be frequent cases of either positive or negative discrimination, even if subconscious, where remuneration depends on the manager's opinion, or for that matter the performance of the team you've been allocated to whether or not you are responsible for its overall results. I say, if they've got nothing to hide, why hide it? Oh, because then they'd all want a bigger piece of the pie. If the employer can't demonstrate it's been fairly sliced, maybe they should be getting more, eh?

prh47bridge · 11/03/2023 12:32

Such clauses are less common than they used to be. Contrary to what has been said up thread, they can be legally enforceable depending on the circumstances. However, an employer cannot prevent employees disclosing salaries if they are investigating whether there is an equal pay issue. Such disclosures are protected. If an employer penalises someone and they are able to show that they were trying to identify a potential equal pay issue, the employee may be able to make a claim for discrimination.

AllCatsAreBeautiful · 11/03/2023 12:31

Dotcheck · 11/03/2023 10:45

How is it your business?

Secrecy allows gender pay gaps, maternity pay penalties etc to flourish.

rothbury · 11/03/2023 12:31

It’s not illegal to put this dated and nasty clause in a contract, but it’s not legally enforceable.

I work in legal sector and would never work for anyone who put a clause like that in my contract.

This is a contributor to gender pay gap. Disgusting really.

maddiemookins16mum · 11/03/2023 12:31

It can cause issues. We have a team member who is quite frankly useless, she’s an older lady (this is relevant) and simply won’t/can’t do certain tasks (think join a Teams meeting, refuses to use Teams - just shuffles her chair over to peer over someones shoulder instead). She says I’m too old for this new fangled nonsense - she’s 67. Won’t retire as she hates her husband (retired and sits in the chair with the paper all day). We spend hours training her on stuff, simple emails etc, won’t do them, transferring calls, nope - she’ll walk the length of the building to deliver a message in person. She’s been with us years, was employed to deal with paperwork (think filing etc), times have moved on now and it’s now 80% digital. She then forgets what we have shown her by the next day/week. So we repeat…..and repeat. She earns 5K a year more than us.

Whiteroomjoy · 11/03/2023 12:28

Absolutely agree with you. This is pretty outrageous to say that people can’t tell others what their salary is, and definately it’s protecting some pay anomalies they know they have - otherwise why would they be bothered if they could defend it

In reputable companies they will publish pay scales - so at each grade you know the ranges of salary and can therefore judge where you are on scale and query that if you feel you are too low on scale. You can do that without having to know the exact salary of anyone else. But generally you do know what scale others are on and again all jobs should be in defined in terms of relevant pay scales as part of their job description which is available on line to anyone

personally, I don’t think even that goes far enough. Even in my companies that were all pretty relaxed about telling you exactly where on scale you were, and what was needed to get a rise up scale, very few people ever shar3d their exact salary. Whether we like it or not , where there is unfairness in pay it will almost always be people with protected characteristics that are being penalised such as women, ethnic minorities, disabled etc. we see that in pay gaps as a result of even fairly benign “unconscious bias” including the still appalling pay gap for women that opens out once they become mothers or older. We will not get rid of unconscious bias until pay is out in the open. Lots of countries do this- people get used to it. Right now people aren’t comfortable as pay is secret for a reason - becuase it is often unfair.

if your company is telling you to not talk about your own pay then they are covering up that they know there is unfairness and unconscious bias. They will know this as they have to publish gender pay gap- do you know what your companies gender pay gap is? That is first thing to challenge legitimately - ask them to prove that your salary is not impacted by gender pay gap. Ask for data, analysis etc of anonymous salrieries by sex on your pay grade to prove it

bibbybox · 11/03/2023 12:22

@Doyoumind what legal consequences?

Doyoumind · 11/03/2023 12:22

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 11/03/2023 11:18

The company couldn't hold the OP responsible and if they tried to they'd be facing some legal issues of their own.

If colleagues find out someone is earning more than them and decide to ask for an equivalent pay rise it is up to the company to approve or reject the request. If they reject it they need to be able to justify why they feel one person is worth more than others and be prepared to loose that employee.

I didn't say they could take legal action. The result of holding them responsible could be that the person suffers legal if questionable consequences in their role.

bibbybox · 11/03/2023 12:21

Are posters still in the 1970s?

Legaleagleplease · 11/03/2023 12:20

Crazycrazylady · 11/03/2023 10:54

Ah seriously.. how you hold down a job if you're querying why you can't announce your pay rise to all and sundry in the company is beyond me 🙄

Well I have made quite a good career out of it for the last 30+ years 😂

OP posts:
Nevergonnastop · 11/03/2023 12:20

Climbles · 11/03/2023 11:43

What if the company pays women less? Or black people? Would it be her business then?

Why single out woman and black people?

FiddleLeaf · 11/03/2023 12:19

It’s not legally enforceable to discipline someone for discussing their salary but naturally, it’s discouraged. The same way I wouldn’t want someone to go up to our roof and hang off the edge.

You don’t have a right to know your colleagues’ salary or circumstances though and if someone wanted to discuss mine I wouldn’t take it well.

KrisAkabusi · 11/03/2023 12:18

It is normal IN THE UK. In other countries money is not considered a taboo or distasteful subject to discuss. In many European countries your personal payments, taxes etc are all freely available and searchable, so you can see exactly how much your colleagues are earning. Keeping salaries secret is a race to the bottom. Why is it acceptable in private industry, but not the public service?

Legaleagleplease · 11/03/2023 12:17

I am not complaining about how much I earn or how much my salary is. I have been working over 30 years and earn well into six figures.
I also do not think that everybody should be paid the same. Different people deserve different pay, commensurate with responsibility and experience.
My issue is the thought police controlling what I say to my peers. Chances are they would gain more than me from it as they may just blindly accept whatever is given. If there is nothing sinister and pay awards are defendable why hide it?

OP posts:
Fairyliz · 11/03/2023 12:17

I’m actually really surprised about some of these comments, surely transparency will only help women, who lets face it generally earn less.

TheChosenTwo · 11/03/2023 12:12

Where I work everyone is working on a totally transparent payscale. It’s a good way to work from my perspective as I know everyone who does my job earns the same. Not exactly because for the first three years it rises in £1,000 increments each year and after 3 years you are on the top of that pay scale. The only way to earn more would be to apply for a role in the next banding.

Aweebitpainful · 11/03/2023 12:10

To me it tells me the company have a lot of people earning vastly different salaries. If it was a standard amount and equal there would be no need for it to be a secret.

ohdoleavemealoneplease · 11/03/2023 12:09

It's not unusual to have this clause in a contract.

I don't disagree with it either.

Some people are better at a job than someone else. They may get more work done or bring in my business.

You may not went to lose them so pay them more!

Thesinisterdiagram · 11/03/2023 12:07

Lack of wage transparency is one of the many reasons women are still being paid less than men. Not to mention the fact that women who try to negotiate pay rises and higher salaries are viewed much less favourably than men who do the same thing.

Mxflamingnoravera · 11/03/2023 12:06

It's only in the public sector that pay is strictly banded and public, the private sector have very different approaches to pay because they can.

drpet49 · 11/03/2023 12:03

theemmadilemma · 11/03/2023 11:05

Those clauses are legally unenforceable. You have every right to discuss it.

We should be more open. Culturally my team in Manila are far more open about discussing salary and benefits than the UK team who seem to believe a punishment worse than death will be passed down if they dare mention it. Employers don't want you to of course!

I agree.

Crumpetdisappointment · 11/03/2023 12:02

my ds has an appraisal and a yearly payrise
i work for the nhs, enough said,
top of my band.
i can only increase my pay by working more or going up a band.

Chowtime · 11/03/2023 12:00

It's aim is to pay women less money than men.

Why the fuck should anyone get paid more just because they have negotiating skills. So what? Most jobs don't need their employees to negotiate with anyone. I've got embroidery skills, why don't they pay me more than the others because i'm good at embroidery?

Rewis · 11/03/2023 11:57

IANAL but to to my understanding companies can't legally forbid you from discussing your salary and you can't be reprimanded for doing so. While it's common, I don't think it's OK for HR to put out statements like that. I think it's sketchy AF. While people can choose to keep their salary private the company should not be enforcing it like this. Company must have reasons why A got a raise but B didn't. While specifics shouldn't be discussed they should be able to present what B should in order to get a raise.