Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Secret Pay Rise

169 replies

Legaleagleplease · 11/03/2023 10:39

Hi All, I am hoping that one of the MN group has some experience they can share on this topic. My company is uber secretive about pay rises and bonuses.
I am suspicious why this is.

You are told that you will be disciplined if you tell anyone else what you earn. I am not sure this is legal or not, it certainly does not sound ethical.

The exact words from the HR Manager are:
You are reminded that information regarding your remuneration is strictly confidential and should not be divulged to colleagues.

AIBU to want clarity on what my peers earn?

OP posts:
Bangolads · 11/03/2023 13:00

It’s amazing how I indoctrinated people are to in the UK to secret salaries. Whilst it’s not black and white the open salary trend is far better at protecting you and your interests. Hiding salaries protects the company. Read more in link:
openwage.com/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-pay-transparency/

KrisAkabusi · 11/03/2023 13:00

PinkVine · 11/03/2023 12:47

I agree it's normal, but also that it's used to hide pay disparities which almost always favour men.

I wonder if you could make a FOI request asking for actual salaries of everyone in your role (without names) ? You definitely can ask for breakdown of male/female pay.

No, because FOI only applies to government bodies, not private companies!

YukoandHiro · 11/03/2023 12:59

They don't want people to work out the women are earning 30 per cent less or more for the same job.
They can't tell you what to do with personal information. Share away and see how colleagues react

Bigmirrorssmallrooms · 11/03/2023 12:57

Legaleagleplease · 11/03/2023 12:17

I am not complaining about how much I earn or how much my salary is. I have been working over 30 years and earn well into six figures.
I also do not think that everybody should be paid the same. Different people deserve different pay, commensurate with responsibility and experience.
My issue is the thought police controlling what I say to my peers. Chances are they would gain more than me from it as they may just blindly accept whatever is given. If there is nothing sinister and pay awards are defendable why hide it?

But that’s not what you said, your very specific last line was you wished to know what your peers earn, and there is nothing in that statement you quoted that said disciplinary if disclosed

PinkVine · 11/03/2023 12:53

It was definitely a requirement when I last worked in the private sector (left 2011) but I found this

"Since the introduction of the Equality Act in 2010, you have the right as an employee to discuss salary. This means that your employer has no legal standing to stop you talking about what you earn, with anyone you work with."

Whiteroomjoy · 11/03/2023 12:53

HelpMeGetThrough · 11/03/2023 12:41

We have the policy of not being able to discuss pay.

Simple reason is, everyone's pay is different depending on what they negotiated when they were offered the job.

Some do say what they earn and aren't happy. I'm keeping my mouth shut.

You do know that men will nearly always negotiate higher salary rises , even when women and men go after the same amount. Lots of research to prove this.
if it was down to just experience, skills, talent then fair dos. It isn’t . Unconscious bias, at the least, has a lot to do with it, particularly at hire stage when the candidate is not well known to the company and it’s all based on impression during interviews. Men particularly generally big themselves up, tell more “mistruths” and exaggeration, and even the language they use is more aligned to the language looked for by the predominantly male recruiters. Agian look at research on this about how male leadership style dominates recruitment language and penalises women and disabled.

Mark19735 · 11/03/2023 12:52

Most people in the country work in an organisation where you can look up pay rates online. Some people work in organisations where their specific seniority/rank is part of their uniform, so you can tell what they earn by looking at them.

What this does is make evaluations person's contribution more relevant. Instead of asking "I wonder what they earn?" people ask "Are they worth the money?" which is actually healthier.

In commercial/corporate settings, the asymmetry of information is a tactic used by HR departments to keep employees in the dark. The only reason for this is to make their life easier when having performance reviews, and to perpetuate situations where some people are grossly underpaid. Often those people are women.

There is no excuse for it. It is lazy and anti-competitive. That is why Glassdoor is so popular. It is also why working in commercial/corporate settings is so miserable for so many people. I'd venture that lack of pay transparency actually means that on balance, companies have to pay more overall ... so it's a self-defeating policy to boot.

funeraletiquette1 · 11/03/2023 12:50

Doyoumind · 11/03/2023 10:46

Completely normal. What's not normal is to expect to be paid exactly the same as someone else in the same role whatever the circumstances as there are valid reasons why that might be the case. Firms have to manage their costs and it doesn't help if someone expects equal pay when all things aren't equal. As long as any differences aren't legally discriminatory it's fine.

How do you know you aren't being illegally discriminated against if you don't even know how much you earn compared to your colleagues?

Nevergonnastop · 11/03/2023 12:49

Maedan · 11/03/2023 12:45

Because they're usually the lower earners who get shafted which is why there are special protections in law to protect these groups. Have you heard of the equality act, what rock do you live under 🙄

Course I've heard of it. The list is endless what it covers. Just wondered why this poster singled out women and black people.

category12 · 11/03/2023 12:48

Maedan · 11/03/2023 12:42

If this is the UK it's not legal to have this policy in place, employees are allowed to share pay details. Companies try this when they know they have an unfair system.

I think it's legal to have the confidentiality clause, but would be hard if not impossible to make it stick due to the Equality Act. As most employees won't be discussing salaries for shits and giggles but to work out if they're being paid fairly.

So it's just a culture of private companies discouraging it and making it seem a risky thing to do for their own purposes.

UpperLowerMiddleClass · 11/03/2023 12:48

Thesinisterdiagram · 11/03/2023 12:07

Lack of wage transparency is one of the many reasons women are still being paid less than men. Not to mention the fact that women who try to negotiate pay rises and higher salaries are viewed much less favourably than men who do the same thing.

Also, when people are negotiating wage and other factors (eg flexible or home working) they only have a certain number of bargaining ‘chips’ to use.

And so people who need to negotiate flexible working (yep, mainly the mothers of young children) will have less bargaining chips available to negotiate pay. As will eg disabled people who need some home working days etc.

Plus as already said rewarding someone solely for their negotiating skills seems odd when you think about it. In my twenty years of working those with the ‘best’ negotiating skills are those who are the best bullshitters and spend their endlessly pontificating and holding meetings, without getting much actual work done.

Willthisusernamework1 · 11/03/2023 12:48

I would be suspicious that they are paying some people VERY high salaries that do not reflect the value they bring to the table. It looks bad, and kills morale.

PinkVine · 11/03/2023 12:47

I agree it's normal, but also that it's used to hide pay disparities which almost always favour men.

I wonder if you could make a FOI request asking for actual salaries of everyone in your role (without names) ? You definitely can ask for breakdown of male/female pay.

Whiteroomjoy · 11/03/2023 12:46

Nevergonnastop · 11/03/2023 12:20

Why single out woman and black people?

Er, because that what research into pay gaps show as 2 of the biggest groups of pay injustice. Afro- Caribbean/ black decent get penalised more than Asian decent apparently- that’s the good old unconscious bias coming into play .

Maedan · 11/03/2023 12:45

Nevergonnastop · 11/03/2023 12:20

Why single out woman and black people?

Because they're usually the lower earners who get shafted which is why there are special protections in law to protect these groups. Have you heard of the equality act, what rock do you live under 🙄

JocelynBurnell · 11/03/2023 12:44

Crazycrazylady · 11/03/2023 10:54

Ah seriously.. how you hold down a job if you're querying why you can't announce your pay rise to all and sundry in the company is beyond me 🙄

Organisations depend on employees being foolish enough not to discuss salaries as otherwise the organisation would come under pressure to rectify pay disparities.

Whiteroomjoy · 11/03/2023 12:42

Mxflamingnoravera · 11/03/2023 12:06

It's only in the public sector that pay is strictly banded and public, the private sector have very different approaches to pay because they can.

Bollocks. All the private companies I worked for throughout my 40 year career had this, going back to the 1980s.
almost all private companies that are large, trying to at least be ethical, have been doing this for years

Maedan · 11/03/2023 12:42

If this is the UK it's not legal to have this policy in place, employees are allowed to share pay details. Companies try this when they know they have an unfair system.

Nevergonnastop · 11/03/2023 12:41

CascaChan · 11/03/2023 12:37

And allows the company to keep you and your colleagues on a low wage for years with tiny pay increases and then have new hires on a much higher starting wage then the long term employees earn after years of loyalty. True story.

If you allow yourself to be kept on a low wage then you're the problem. True story.

HelpMeGetThrough · 11/03/2023 12:41

We have the policy of not being able to discuss pay.

Simple reason is, everyone's pay is different depending on what they negotiated when they were offered the job.

Some do say what they earn and aren't happy. I'm keeping my mouth shut.

Whiteroomjoy · 11/03/2023 12:40

SpottyLip · 11/03/2023 11:44

"Hey Frank, I got a 10% pay rise this year, what did you get?"
"2%. Now fuck off. Who did you sleep with to get 10?"

Or if you were the one with the lower raise, how does it help you to know that? You can't go back to the bosses and demand an increase.

🤦‍♀️yes . You can. That’s exactly why they’re stopping it- they cannot justify the pay inequalities.
when you’ve informed yourself about the gender pay gap and other pay gaps as a result of unconscious bias , maybe you’ll realise that your attitude is laying you right open to someone taking the piss over what you’re paid
other people want to ensure they’re paid fairly, and not subject to unconscious bias. As most women will, at some point in their career, experience this , it is a very naive attitude to have

AngryAndUnapologetic · 11/03/2023 12:40

I'm surprised by how many people think we shouldn't discuss salaries. The more open we are about it, the more employers are held to account for fairness and equality. In many countries it is absolutely normal to discuss salaries. An employer should be able to justify any differences e.g. two people with the same title but one has more experience, or has led bigger projects, so their salary reflects that. In reality, the secrecy around pay means some people are unaware how much less they are being paid than colleagues and therefore do not realise their own value. They don't negotiate for more pay because they simply don't know that their role might be worth more. And we all know that (generally) it is women who get the short end of the stick on this.

OP is not saying that the employer should reveal details of individual staff pay; she is querying the clause in her contract that forbids her from discussing her salary, bonus etc with others. As a PP said, I'm pretty sure this is not legal in the UK.

daisychain01 · 11/03/2023 12:38

"They would need to say..." I mean

Whiteroomjoy · 11/03/2023 12:37

maddiemookins16mum · 11/03/2023 12:31

It can cause issues. We have a team member who is quite frankly useless, she’s an older lady (this is relevant) and simply won’t/can’t do certain tasks (think join a Teams meeting, refuses to use Teams - just shuffles her chair over to peer over someones shoulder instead). She says I’m too old for this new fangled nonsense - she’s 67. Won’t retire as she hates her husband (retired and sits in the chair with the paper all day). We spend hours training her on stuff, simple emails etc, won’t do them, transferring calls, nope - she’ll walk the length of the building to deliver a message in person. She’s been with us years, was employed to deal with paperwork (think filing etc), times have moved on now and it’s now 80% digital. She then forgets what we have shown her by the next day/week. So we repeat…..and repeat. She earns 5K a year more than us.

This has to do with poor management, not pay secrecy (especially as you know her pay🤷🏼‍♀️)
in any company that doesn’t have formal performance reviews and performance improvement programmes then this will happen. Nowt to do with her being old- I’m retired and mix in groups of 80 plus year old women doing team meetings, whatapp groups etc. many managers will not address poor performance. Many companies don’t have formal systems to guide a manager through how to address poor performance from one of their reports. And many more companies don’t have a culture of all employee feedback , where (within a certain framework like “STARs”) any team member can provide specific defined feedback to another team member and their manager which will ensure these sort of performance issues are identified and addressed.

CascaChan · 11/03/2023 12:37

moneyhouse · 11/03/2023 11:01

Normal in my business too. It creates ill will when your colleagues find out you earn more for example

And allows the company to keep you and your colleagues on a low wage for years with tiny pay increases and then have new hires on a much higher starting wage then the long term employees earn after years of loyalty. True story.

Swipe left for the next trending thread