Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Secret Pay Rise

169 replies

Legaleagleplease · 11/03/2023 10:39

Hi All, I am hoping that one of the MN group has some experience they can share on this topic. My company is uber secretive about pay rises and bonuses.
I am suspicious why this is.

You are told that you will be disciplined if you tell anyone else what you earn. I am not sure this is legal or not, it certainly does not sound ethical.

The exact words from the HR Manager are:
You are reminded that information regarding your remuneration is strictly confidential and should not be divulged to colleagues.

AIBU to want clarity on what my peers earn?

OP posts:
xJoy · 11/03/2023 13:58

Bigmirrorssmallrooms · 11/03/2023 11:00

Is this your first job op?

How is that a reasonable question?

I've had ten jobs approx and I hated this lack of transparency in previous private sector jobs. It never serves people like me well. If you're confident at negotiating raises you might get a raise at somebody more timid's expense. 25 years ago I was told "you're worth what we are prepared to pay you" and they paid me a pittance. Outrageous abuse of secrecy. Somebody better at demanding raises in that company was overpaid so I was underpaid to make up for that.

Thank goodness for transparency in civil service in ireland. I prefer this so much. I dont have to work knowing my time is worth less than somebody else at my grade.

Purplecatshopaholic · 11/03/2023 13:57

Very common in the private sector. Only the company wins with this culture in my view. I’m in the public sector where pay grades and scales are published and it’s all transparent - quite right too!

BishopRock · 11/03/2023 13:51

moneyhouse · 11/03/2023 11:01

Normal in my business too. It creates ill will when your colleagues find out you earn more for example

Oh boy doesn't it! I once got a job with a qualification bar. I had the qualification so was straight in at 11 of 12 on the pay scale. Somehow others on the same Grade found out, and they had started at 1, and they took it out on me. I left after a year.

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 13:51

Company level "pay gap" data is nonsense as anyone with half a brain has worked out by now.

Figgygal · 11/03/2023 13:49

Theyve gone about it in the wrong way and now created a culture of suspicion but talking salaries is crass and frankly none of your business.
People's salaries are determined by lots of things and without context it's too easy to yell discrimination

PhillySub · 11/03/2023 13:48

Strange, I was in the armed forces and everybody in the world knew how much I earned.

funeraletiquette1 · 11/03/2023 13:47

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 13:42

In commercial/corporate settings, the asymmetry of information is a tactic used by HR departments to keep employees in the dark. The only reason for this is to make their life easier when having performance reviews, and to perpetuate situations where some people are grossly underpaid. Often those people are women.

So HR, which is a mainly female occupation, go to work everyday with the intention of keeping women in the dark in order to grossly underpay them. Really?

You are ridiculous.

Yes, it's well known that only companies without HR managers have pay gaps, or get taken to employment tribunals for managing women out while they're on maternity leave.

Natty13 · 11/03/2023 13:46

Crazycrazylady · 11/03/2023 10:54

Ah seriously.. how you hold down a job if you're querying why you can't announce your pay rise to all and sundry in the company is beyond me 🙄

Very arr9w minded response. It's normal in some workplaces to discuss pay, especially those where take home is variable.

category12 · 11/03/2023 13:45

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 13:43

Yeah of course they are free after you have told them you need to be told otherwise they are colluding in cheating you out of money. There's no pressure!

Quite dramatic, aren't you?

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 13:43

category12 · 11/03/2023 13:41

It's not pressure to simply ask. Colleagues are free to answer or not.

Yeah of course they are free after you have told them you need to be told otherwise they are colluding in cheating you out of money. There's no pressure!

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 13:42

In commercial/corporate settings, the asymmetry of information is a tactic used by HR departments to keep employees in the dark. The only reason for this is to make their life easier when having performance reviews, and to perpetuate situations where some people are grossly underpaid. Often those people are women.

So HR, which is a mainly female occupation, go to work everyday with the intention of keeping women in the dark in order to grossly underpay them. Really?

You are ridiculous.

category12 · 11/03/2023 13:41

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 13:37

You may be be legally ENTITLED to pressure other staff to reveal their personal information to you but why don't you think respecting their privacy should take preference over what you want?

It's not pressure to simply ask. Colleagues are free to answer or not.

Littlegoth · 11/03/2023 13:40

HR manager should know better than to send reminders like this. These clauses can’t be enforced under the Equality Act 2010.

I’m in HR. Not an HR manager, but I still know that.

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 13:37

eloquent · 11/03/2023 13:30

'in the UK, these pay secrecy clauses are legally unenforceable. Under the Equality Act 2010, an employer cannot enforce a pay secrecy clause if the employee was discussing their pay for the purpose of finding out whether they were being paid differently to a colleague on the grounds of discrimination.'

From a solicitor's page

And see here: www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/notes/division/3/5/3/14

You may be be legally ENTITLED to pressure other staff to reveal their personal information to you but why don't you think respecting their privacy should take preference over what you want?

endoftheworldniteclub · 11/03/2023 13:36

I’m not in the UK, but here you can look up how much anyone in the country earns.

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 13:35

Overall only the companies win if you keep it to yourself.

Win what though? What is it we want to win?

Pay is a big source of grievances which sucks up a lot of time. Suggesting that publishing everyone's pay will mean less grievances is a fantasy.

Everyone will be queuing up for a meeting about why they aren't paid more than all the people they hate. It would never end.

The FT did recently write about a tech company rowing back on transparency as they can no longer increase pay for anyone. The entire company including the poorest performer lines up for a whinge over every increase given to anyone.

Many of you aren't nice respectful people at work, you don't behave well with sensitive information. This is why you are asked to respect confidentiality, because it gets nasty, time consuming and unresolvable grievances are created otherwise.

eloquent · 11/03/2023 13:30

'in the UK, these pay secrecy clauses are legally unenforceable. Under the Equality Act 2010, an employer cannot enforce a pay secrecy clause if the employee was discussing their pay for the purpose of finding out whether they were being paid differently to a colleague on the grounds of discrimination.'

From a solicitor's page

And see here: www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/notes/division/3/5/3/14

Terraria · 11/03/2023 13:28

I think it's awful for companies to allow to give massive difference salaries under the same job title. I bet this is the reason why they have this policy because people know it's wrong and will complain.

ForestDad · 11/03/2023 13:27

I have worked in the public sector where everyone was on the same pay scales. Interesting that in the military a manager with a lot of responsibility is paid the same as someone in the same rank with a lot less responsibility in their current job.
Now in private sector but salaries are union negotiated and published. So I'm getting paid the same as someone else doing the same job.
Overall only the companies win if you keep it to yourself.

emmathedilemma · 11/03/2023 13:25

I don’t know if ours is written down is any many words but for years we haven’t even had published salary bands by grade so you really have no idea where you stand compared to others doing the same role. The gender pay gap report is so vague it’s not worth the paper it’s written on and I work in a male dominated industry but the lower grades of admin staff are predominantly, if not all, female so that potentially skews it more than if they did the gap at comparable grades and roles,

RosaBonheur · 11/03/2023 13:22

Whiteroomjoy · 11/03/2023 12:53

You do know that men will nearly always negotiate higher salary rises , even when women and men go after the same amount. Lots of research to prove this.
if it was down to just experience, skills, talent then fair dos. It isn’t . Unconscious bias, at the least, has a lot to do with it, particularly at hire stage when the candidate is not well known to the company and it’s all based on impression during interviews. Men particularly generally big themselves up, tell more “mistruths” and exaggeration, and even the language they use is more aligned to the language looked for by the predominantly male recruiters. Agian look at research on this about how male leadership style dominates recruitment language and penalises women and disabled.

There's a lot of truth in this.

In some jobs in the private sector, such as law, there are set pay scales at junior levels and you can look up what individual firms pay, e.g. a first year trainee, a second year trainee, a newly qualified solicitor, a NQ+1 etc. for the first few years. After that it's "dependent on performance" and there's no more transparency. I'm guessing that's the moment where the men start to pull ahead significantly, especially since it coincides with the time a lot of women start taking maternity leaves.

Where I work (in law but not in a law firm and not in the UK) we don't tend to discuss our salaries in detail but there is no general rule about it. My manager told me that he knows how much his female counterpart owns and vice versa, so clearly it would be OK for me to discuss my own salary with other team members.

A few years ago a guy joined my team from a well known company in a high paying sector. My manager told me that my salary was higher than this guy's, but I have no way of knowing whether that was true or not. My manager probably thought he could rely on me not asking the other guy because we hated each other. And I thought there was no point in asking him because he would definitely have lied and told me he was on more than he was actually on. He lied about everything, including on his CV. Amazingly, he put on his CV that he speaks fluent Spanish, which he definitely doesn't, and got away with it despite the fact that our boss is half Spanish and could have tested him at any time. He's now left, and is earning megabucks somewhere else, but frankly I'm just glad he's gone.

Last year my manager and his female counterpart did a benchmarking exercise and went to senior management with a business case for our entire team getting a fairly substantial pay rise, due to the fact that our salaries were already lagging a little bit below the market and with inflation it was only going to get worse. We were told that everyone in the team would be getting a percentage rise based on our level of seniority, with the more junior members getting a higher percentage pay rise because they were on lower salaries. We were told not to discuss it with anyone outside the team, or with people in our sister companies, because the company couldn't afford to do the same for everyone.

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 13:22

Boomboom22 · 11/03/2023 11:10

It's unethical and legally unenforceable. The comments on here are nuts and just try to justify the pay gap. How anti feminist by default.

People are entitled to privacy about what they are paid.

Where I work there's a small group of women who are utterly convinced that the "management" are underpaying them deliberately because they are women.

This has been going on for the five years I've worked there.

They ask people what they earn. Great, you might say, but to me that just shows a complete lack of respect for a person's right to privacy. Of course people can say they don't want to share but these women are loud grievance mongers and I expect many don't want to risk their ire as they are nasty and never let their grievances go. After meetings with them, their peers do tell me that their behaviour is disgraceful but stay absolutely silent whilst they are making accusations. They write emails saying I trust my manager but unless I'm told what everyone else is earning I will assume you are not being truthful about paying equally.

So am I in favour of secrecy to cover up ? No, I think people should have their privacy respected.

And am I am manager who deliberately lies to cheat women?

No, I am literally the person doing the Equal pay audits.

Its me you think goes to work every day, chats to senior managers and says, pay her less and we'll keep it secret. We have a secret conspiracy to do this. We meet secretly to approve men's pay rises. All companies have secret "cheat the women" policies.

It all top secret. Woops, I just let slip.

Climbles · 11/03/2023 13:19

Nevergonnastop · 11/03/2023 12:20

Why single out woman and black people?

They are two marginalised groups who are often underpaid. What should I have written?

HikingforScenery · 11/03/2023 13:18

Companies who are so secretive about their pay are likely to have massive discrepancies, most likely at a disadvantage to women

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 13:06

Luredbyapomegranate · 11/03/2023 10:48

Take some proper legal advice but I THINK any clause that tells you you cannot discuss your salary isn’t legal - ie it has no basis in law, so they can write it in a contract all they like, but no court would uphold it.

And while you can write all sorts of things in a contract I also think (check) that this clause is frowned upon for the above reasons.

The sooner salaries are completely transparent the better obviously. I bet at least some of the PPs upholding confidentiality above are being paid less than their male colleagues because of it.

What's your reason for saying this? I don't think it's obvious why this is better. Can you clarify?

The sooner salaries are completely transparent the better obviously.