Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Secret Pay Rise

169 replies

Legaleagleplease · 11/03/2023 10:39

Hi All, I am hoping that one of the MN group has some experience they can share on this topic. My company is uber secretive about pay rises and bonuses.
I am suspicious why this is.

You are told that you will be disciplined if you tell anyone else what you earn. I am not sure this is legal or not, it certainly does not sound ethical.

The exact words from the HR Manager are:
You are reminded that information regarding your remuneration is strictly confidential and should not be divulged to colleagues.

AIBU to want clarity on what my peers earn?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Aria999 · 12/03/2023 13:23

It's because they are worried if you tell people you had a pay rise then everyone else will want one.

RainbowBrightside · 12/03/2023 09:20

I take it this is private sector. In the NHS, most people are open about what band they are and once you know how long they’ve been in that band you’ve got a ballpark figure. No big secrets.

Whiteroomjoy · 12/03/2023 09:12

emmathedilemma · 11/03/2023 18:13

It’s also to do with the fact that there are far fewer women engineers entering the business as graduates to get promoted up the ranks!

I don’t dispute that. But I’m talking about where the qualifications of entry level are same. For instance we know overwhelmingly that there are more women nurses at entry level and always have been, but when you look at senior nursing roles they become more male dominated. In my company we employed overhelmingly female science graduates ( pharmacists and biologists, microbio etc) but we ven at next grade up there were already seeing the ratio shifts, and by 2 grades up men were in majority, and at senior level tiny proportions of women.

emmathedilemma · 11/03/2023 18:13

Whiteroomjoy · 11/03/2023 16:50

Ok, ask yourself this, why are lower grades predominantly women and higher grades men? That is half the issue🤦‍♀️
many companies employ more women at lower or the nary grades, even NHS, but as those people rise through ranks with experience it becomes male dominated. That is one of the key points about the gender pay gap
it is human nature to promote people who are like yourself ..and that is the unconscious bias. If the people do g the promoting are all middle aged white males, then that’s who will be promote . Add to that it there is also yet another bunch of research to say that men get promoted INTO jobs whilst women and some ethnic groups have to do the job first before they get promoted to recognise it

It’s also to do with the fact that there are far fewer women engineers entering the business as graduates to get promoted up the ranks!

NowDoYouBelieveMe · 11/03/2023 16:58

An alternate view:

The only people who consider concealing their pay to be a privacy issue are those who want to hide how overpaid they are.

When employers do it, or try to make employees do it, they are being cheap and very possibly discriminatory.

Badgerandfox227 · 11/03/2023 16:56

YANBU. This clause is exactly why women end up earning less than men. Salary bands should be available to staff, and pay review % bands should also be published. Therefore this can be challenged by staff who feel they are not being paid fairly. Companies using this clause are likely to have some unfair practices in place.

NowDoYouBelieveMe · 11/03/2023 16:54

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 14:16

Are you very old?

I don't think I would take advice from someone who writes "renumerate".

Pay privacy is not the same as to "conceal".

It's not illegal in any sector.

Pay bands are not the same as a person's pay.

Disclosure rules are quite limited.

Addressing anyone expecting privacy as "old fashioned" is really quite naive and rude.

There's no pay gap for women aged 40 and under and there hasn't been for some time.

The pay gap for older women is due to detrimental treatment in education and career access at the beginning of our working lives, not unequal pay now.

But yeah, we are just old fashioned.

Ghastly attitude.

"Ghastly" lack of nous.

My "are you very old" comment was an arch response to the poster I quoted, who wrote unhelpfully wrote "is this your first job?". Hope that's clearer now. If it wasn't already clear.

Wrt my spelling:

From the OED:
"Continuously since the mid 16th century renumeration / renumerate have been used with the same meaning as remuneration / remunerate."

In your defence, perhaps if you think my use of 16th century language is incorrect you are in fact very, very old!

Whiteroomjoy · 11/03/2023 16:50

emmathedilemma · 11/03/2023 13:25

I don’t know if ours is written down is any many words but for years we haven’t even had published salary bands by grade so you really have no idea where you stand compared to others doing the same role. The gender pay gap report is so vague it’s not worth the paper it’s written on and I work in a male dominated industry but the lower grades of admin staff are predominantly, if not all, female so that potentially skews it more than if they did the gap at comparable grades and roles,

Ok, ask yourself this, why are lower grades predominantly women and higher grades men? That is half the issue🤦‍♀️
many companies employ more women at lower or the nary grades, even NHS, but as those people rise through ranks with experience it becomes male dominated. That is one of the key points about the gender pay gap
it is human nature to promote people who are like yourself ..and that is the unconscious bias. If the people do g the promoting are all middle aged white males, then that’s who will be promote . Add to that it there is also yet another bunch of research to say that men get promoted INTO jobs whilst women and some ethnic groups have to do the job first before they get promoted to recognise it

CharlotteStreetW1 · 11/03/2023 15:49

We have exactly the same at my firm. There are 14 secretaries (I'm one of them) and I'd bet we're not all on the same money.

I miss the days of "salary dependent on age and experience" as I'm 59 and have been doing this job for 40 years 😂

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 15:48

Littlegoth · 11/03/2023 15:27

@Hepwo I should have read further on as I see now you’ve quoted the ONS. You’ve literally written in your post that the ONS shows a pay gap though! 3.2% is still a gap! It doesn’t matter that this is seen as ‘low’, it shouldn’t be there - not when there are some government bodies who have no pay gap at all (and some running at over 18%).

You still aren't reading my posts

There's no pay gap for women aged 40 and under and there hasn't been for some time.

The pay gap for older women is due to detrimental treatment in education and career access at the beginning of our working lives, not unequal pay now.

But don't worry. Women don't want to believe this. They have been absolutely convinced that they are cheated from the moment they get their first payday and no amount of data is going to permit them to even listen never mind read anything to the contrary. I experience this every day from women who should know better. Women at school and leaving university believe they are going to be offered lower pay.

Women ring me and demand back dated pay rises because the media has told them they are being cheated and I'm a liar if I say that's not that case.

It such a shame that women have been fed this.
Especially when the actual evidence is so clear. I just cringe at all the arts grad women telling people that can actually understand statistics a load of nonsense.

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 15:38

Littlegoth · 11/03/2023 15:22

@Hepwo having just produced my organisation’s gender (and ethnicity) pay gap, and being part of a multi organisation working group, you are mistaken. There is still a pay gap, and what’s worse is it appears to be widening.

Don’t take my word for it though - The ONS has just published this year’s stats.

Why would I take your word for it when I actually posted a link to the ONS data in this thread. The trend is downwards. The latest data has been estimated because of the impact of furlough.

So if you want to tell me I'm mistaken despite not reading my post on the ONS, cool.

PegasusReturns · 11/03/2023 15:36

A lack of transparency hurts employees only.

I have team members doing the same job earning almost 80% more/less.

I’ve always been happy to discuss my salary, in the context of helping women understand what they are worth and how to negotiate.

WestendVBroadway · 11/03/2023 15:35

Years ago my employer gave us a pay rise and we were forbidden from telling anyone what they paid us. So I didn't, however I did tell people what I was paid, ( I know it is essentially the same thing)as IMHO that is my business if I chose to share it.

Littlegoth · 11/03/2023 15:27

@Hepwo I should have read further on as I see now you’ve quoted the ONS. You’ve literally written in your post that the ONS shows a pay gap though! 3.2% is still a gap! It doesn’t matter that this is seen as ‘low’, it shouldn’t be there - not when there are some government bodies who have no pay gap at all (and some running at over 18%).

Littlegoth · 11/03/2023 15:22

@Hepwo having just produced my organisation’s gender (and ethnicity) pay gap, and being part of a multi organisation working group, you are mistaken. There is still a pay gap, and what’s worse is it appears to be widening.

Don’t take my word for it though - The ONS has just published this year’s stats.

JessicaBrassica · 11/03/2023 15:18

When I worked in the private sector somebody (accidentally?) Posted the salary spreadsheet onto the shared drive. One of my colleagues saw it and let me know that he earned more as a senior (with less responsibility, ability to claim overtime etc) than I did as a principal. I knew I was underpaid, but until then I hadn't realized by how much!

Rummikub · 11/03/2023 15:14

I don’t understand the lack of transparency.

Some people wouldn’t ask negotiate a pay rise. Those that can talk themselves up get the pay rise- that’s not fair.

Base it on performance if you want but be transparent about it. Eg what are the indicators, how is it measured

Thisismynamenow · 11/03/2023 15:12

Wow, I'm incredibly glad I've always been in the public sector. I'd be fuming knowing there's a possibility a colleague is on a higher salary than me just because they have more confidence than I do.

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 15:06

Terraria · 11/03/2023 13:28

I think it's awful for companies to allow to give massive difference salaries under the same job title. I bet this is the reason why they have this policy because people know it's wrong and will complain.

Why is it wrong? Unless a protected characteristic is the reason for the difference, it's perfectly ok.

Some humans have a greater value to a company than others.

This isn't a communist country.

Why do some clothes cost more than other clothes? Do you go into Selfridges and complain that they sell more expensive stuff than Primark?

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 15:01

OheeOheeOh · 11/03/2023 14:46

I work for the civil service and everyone's pay band is no secret, I couldn't imagine working somewhere where someone doing the exact same role, at the exact same level could be paid more than me and I'd be clueless. Why the secrecy? All it does is allows them to get away with paying some people less than they are worth, more often than not women. It allows wage disparity to go on.

How do you know this? You seem really certain!

The evidence shows the opposite. The difference is occupational, not individual salary level.

The reductions in the UK wide pay gap are due to more women moving into management occupations over 40 and this is tied to the generational discrimination women have experienced.

It's such a shame that the general discourse about gender pay gap reporting has convinced women they are routinely being cheated and deliberately so by the women that work in HR.

ONS data below.
www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwork/earningsandworkinghours/bulletins/genderpaygapintheuk/2022
The clearest insight into the gender pay gap is provided by analysis across age groups. For groups aged under 40 years, the gender pay gap for full-time employees (which is a more homogenous basis than all employees for measuring differences in hourly pay) is low, at 3.2% or below. This has been the case since 2017.

However, for age groups aged 40 to 49 years and older, the gender pay gap for full-time employees is much higher, at over 10.9%. Our 2019 analysis explored the types of occupation that men and women work in, by age group. It flagged a lower incidence of women moving into higher-paid managerial occupations after the age of 39 years, at which point pay in these occupations increases.

JackiePlace · 11/03/2023 15:00

This kind of thinking within a company screams to me that there is going to be vast differences in salaries between people that are essentially doing the same job.
Of course they don't want you to know that Incompetent Sam earns more than you do!
In theory this means that the more productive/skilled people can justifiably be given higher salaries, but in practice the pay rises tend to go to those who are good at talking themselves up.

Pay grades/scales are much more transparent and fairer IMO.

endoftheworldniteclub · 11/03/2023 14:55

NeedToChangeName · 11/03/2023 14:24

Salaries are public knowledge in Sweden, according to this article www.ft.com/content/2a9274be-72aa-11e7-93ff-99f383b09ff9

The article is right, transparency.

pinkbaglady · 11/03/2023 14:51

Dotcheck · 11/03/2023 10:45

How is it your business?

Personally, I think women in particular should be open about what they earn if they want to be.

why? We’re historically paid much less than our male counterparts and we need to start being savvy when negotiating salaries.

i started a new job last year. My friend already worked there and when I told her what I was going to ask for as a salary she encouraged me
to add £10k on to it. I did and they accepted. I’m £10k better off than I would have been if I’d said nothing.

Hepwo · 11/03/2023 14:50

stevalnamechanger · 11/03/2023 14:35

I don't think you understand really .

Strikes have been extremely successful . Look at the increases secured in wages

Striking is part of having a unified ( unionized ) labour force which can act as a collective to get access to the best conditions for its cohort of workers

Extremely successful, apart from all the private sector industries that were destroyed by striking that is? And no longer exist in this country to strike? With the outcome that the only sector still addicted to striking is the public sector that can't actually go bust and has to be funded? Really successful.

I don't understand, I'm too old fashioned. Those of us who lived through the strike shutdowns in the 70s are old fashioned and don't understand how much this improved industry.

DontSetYourselfOnFireToKeepOthersWarm · 11/03/2023 14:50

DontSetYourselfOnFireToKeepOthersWarm · 11/03/2023 14:40

I can only imagine that those people saying that you shouldn't discuss pay with your colleagues are either managers whose life would be made harder if salaries were out in the open or they know full well that they aren't worth as much as they are being paid (and are scared in case everyone else knows it too).

Or rather that should say 'shouldn't be able to discuss pay'.

As I understand it (and I am not a lawyer, so please bear that in mind) it is a slightly grey area in that while an employer can put a clause in your contract saying you should not discuss pay, it is almost certainly unenforceable thanks to the Equality Act of 2010.