Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this being a hypocrite?

34 replies

againandagain1000 · 11/03/2023 09:22

I'm due to see a friend this weekend. My friend keeps messaging to change the time and venue which is making me quite anxious as it's somewhere I haven't been before so ideally I want to know the plans in advance.
I've said to my partner I'm feeling a bit anxious because the plans keep changing.

Friend has then said they're going to arrive at the venue early and might eat before I get there, which again I am a bit upset about as when I arrive, my friends would have already eaten. (I can't get there earlier due to work so I'll arrive an hour after them).

My partner then said 'your friend is out of order. Are they really that fat that they can't wait for you? (Then paused) No they're not so why can't they wait?'

I told my partner I don't like that comment and there's no need to mention weight at all in this.

Partner is now annoyed with me saying I'm a hypocrite for not calling out my friends behaviour but I'm calling DP out on not liking that comment.

Partner is really upset with me and has said 'now I'm the bad guy in this. Thanks a lot. You're a hypocrite calling me out on what I've said when you won't say anything to your friend about their shitty behaviour'.

Is this me being a hypocrite?

OP posts:
againandagain1000 · 11/03/2023 09:49

@Chickenly
I would have preferred to have been told 'you need to speak to your friend about it and let them know you're bothered'. Etc. It just seemed unnecessary to insult them in that way.
I get that it can be annoying when I'm struggling to tell me friend that their behaviour bothers me but I'll say it to DP.

OP posts:
Jazper · 11/03/2023 09:48

Hypocrisy would be you calling them fat but then having a go at your DH for calling them fat.
You aren't a hypocrite.
Your husband shouldn't have mentioned their weight (though said from a place of attempted solidarity).
They are out of order for messing you around but are they aware of the anxiety it's causing you? From someone who suffers anxiety, I get it but those who don't suffer likely wouldn't relate at all...

DisplayPurposesOnly · 11/03/2023 09:46

Your DP was out of order to bring weight into it. If he wanted to support you, all he had to do was agree with you that her vacillations were annoying and upsetting you.

You aren't being a hypocritic. You are complaining about the behaviour that it upsetting you, without bringing in random irrelevant insults.

againandagain1000 · 11/03/2023 09:42

That's what DP said 'I'm trying to stick up for you'. But I felt upset about it because I didn't like my friend, or anyone being called fat.
I used to have an eating disorder which I've been battling with lately. DP has been supportive and has said I need to help with this etc. which has been good. So hearing DP saying that struck a chord.

I can see what you're all saying, that DP was trying to be supportive in some way.
And I can also see the frustration that I'm not calling my friend out too.

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 11/03/2023 09:41

If he wouldn't have said the same if they were male, then I wouldn't have said anything. However as someone overweight, I would have an issue. It's the greddy pig connotation. It isn't being a hypocrite.

PinkVine · 11/03/2023 09:39

I wouldn't call you hypocrite exactly, but I do understand why he's upset that you won't speak to them about them treating you badly, but will object to him saying something unpleasant about them, especially when it came from a place of supporting you.

I'd cancel and go out for lunch somewhere nice with him.

DinnerThyme · 11/03/2023 09:35

I think he’s probably pissed off by the “I’m too much of a shrinking violet to call people out” attitude that applies to everyone except for him.

Chickenly · 11/03/2023 09:31

I wouldn’t use the term “hypocrite” for this but I do understand his frustration. He has to listen to you whinge about something whilst refusing to stand up for yourself. That must be frustrating for him. Then he says something bad about her and you turn on him, perfectly happy to call him out. His comment, whilst not exactly a work of linguistic beauty, was said in solidarity with you and you took her side! It’s incredibly annoying listening to someone complain about something they’re refusing to do anything about - it’s even more annoying when they make it impossible for you to say anything because they’ll defend the other side to the death.

Would you have preferred he said “FGS strap on a pair and call her out”?

timeforchampagne · 11/03/2023 09:29

He shouldn’t of commented on their weight but he’s correct your friend is out of order to keep messing you about