Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to worry when jobs that sound so important have such a low salary?

110 replies

merrigorownd · 11/03/2023 07:02

I'm currently job hunting, so get a few mailshots, and have an alert set up for analytical jobs in the civil service. I'm often surprised at how low the salaries are for job titles that sound strategically important for the running of our country. This is just a random example.

The range shown is for someone based in Darlington, but I clicked through to the detail and the London range was only £3k higher. I know the cost of living is lower in Darlington than in London, and that £50k is relatively a high wage in that area, but if I was a Darlington-based economist with the required level of competence to lead a team of 15 people in advising Government ministers on national policy, I think I might be well aware of my ability to earn much more with a different employer.

Aibu to worry when jobs that sound so important have such a low salary?
OP posts:
Jimboscott0115 · 11/03/2023 08:21

doingitforyorkshire · 11/03/2023 08:12

Whilst I can completely understand how Civil Service workers could be insulted by your post, unfortunately, I can fully understand your view and be inclined to agree with you.
I considered the Civil Service and was put off it because of everything you said, it would drive me insane with all the red tape, rigid job roles, and hoop-jumping just to get things done. I have talked to some who work there and they confirm it, they are happy with it though it works for them, I just couldn't work like that. It just doesn't seem effective at all.

I get it, but the only people I can see being offended are those who are in the kinds of jobs that cause some of the problems, who love hierarchy, red tape and long drawn out processes and a slower pace of work. That's great for them, but they have to accept an outsider's view as to why talented people wouldn't or don't consider working there.

Overthebow · 11/03/2023 08:21

I used to work for the civil service years ago and their pay has hardly gone up since. I used to think it was a good salary but with inflation over the last 10 years or so it isn’t so good now, especially in London.

Saying that, grade 7 isn’t particularly high, you can reach it in 5 years or so of your career if you are a good graduate. The civil service also works less hours than lots of private sector jobs, has more holidays, bank holidays and better pension.

RattlewhenIwalk · 11/03/2023 08:17

Jimboscott0115 · 11/03/2023 07:20

Several issues with the civil service which pays about 50% of the going rate for my role.

The first is, noone worth their salt in a professional field wants to work for the civil service. It's full of red tape, processes designed to do nothing but cover arses and ridiculous hierarchical attitudes that ultimately means nothing of value gets done. If you have a problem in a project that needs escalation it can take a week for it to feed up the chain through official channels and a week to come back down again. In the private sector I can pick up the phone to whoever makes the decision and solve it in an hour.

Every person I know who's moved from private sector to public has given it up in 12-18 months because it's where you go to die and plod along while nodding away at a bunch of idiots. Yes the pension etc might be tempting but the complete death of your career, ambitions and ability to think for yourself and create solutions isn't quite worth it.

Back to the questions raised in the OP, these roles pay lowly because they're shopping for talent below the midpoint - the mediocre - because that's the only people they can attract due to culture, processes and the way they do things.

The kind of attitude from consultants that really gets up civil servants' noses even if there is some truth in it.

MrsHughesPinny · 11/03/2023 08:15

*stated

MrsHughesPinny · 11/03/2023 08:15

I’m relatively senior in the public sector but every time I apply for a private sector job I don’t even get through the sift despite having 20 years experience and many transferable skills. I’d love to do more in my career for all the reasons stayed. It’s hard to get in when all your experience is in the public and third sector.

Jimboscott0115 · 11/03/2023 08:14

PelicanWings · 11/03/2023 08:02

I doubt @Jimboscott0115 has had a well paying job in their life. What a clown.

Making personal digs is all well and good but doesn't refute any of my points, there's a reason why most of us wouldn't even consider a wage drop to achieve very little in the civil service and it's largely due to an outdated culture and ridiculous red tape.

I've just looked at roles in my field and the civil service is literally offering less than half what I'm on in the private sector - therefore they're chasing very junior people or those absolutely mired in mediocrity.

doingitforyorkshire · 11/03/2023 08:12

Jimboscott0115 · 11/03/2023 07:50

I know of well over a dozen people who have taken the step into public sector/civil service work from private in a variety of roles and generally all pretty senior & every single one without fail has said the same thing and escaped when they could before they lost the will to achieve anything in their careers.

I've dealt with government on private/public collaboration projects and have seen it - the lack of innovative thinking, problem handling and the volume of people who's job is essentially only in existence because of 'processes' and red tape is unreal. Introductions were hilarious in meetings when half the people there were there because they were part of some sort of chain of command/governance but would add zero value to the project (or any project).

If anywhere is paying 40k for a role that can comfortably get 80k then it's clear they aren't looking for the best, or even the average - but the mediocre.

Whilst I can completely understand how Civil Service workers could be insulted by your post, unfortunately, I can fully understand your view and be inclined to agree with you.
I considered the Civil Service and was put off it because of everything you said, it would drive me insane with all the red tape, rigid job roles, and hoop-jumping just to get things done. I have talked to some who work there and they confirm it, they are happy with it though it works for them, I just couldn't work like that. It just doesn't seem effective at all.

Greenfairydust · 11/03/2023 08:11

What planet do you live on?

The average full time salary in the UK is something like £33,000.

£50k and over is a high salary.

This is tax payer money and this type of salary seems perfectly fine to me.

I would be more concerned about the rubbish salaries that nurses, care workers and so on are being paid. That is the real scandal.

Duttercup · 11/03/2023 08:10

Are the benefits better though? I work in the private sector, earn in this range with no line management responsibility and a very low pressure job ('professional non- managerial'). 35 hours contracted, fully flexible hours - I stopped work at 1 on Thursday because I wanted to hang out with my DD - pension is good enough and I top mine up with my bonus, private healthcare etc. My employer is also nice, positive atmosphere, general sense that we do good work and should be proud.

Public sector jobs always look a lot of bother for very little reward in a grumpy environment.

PelicanWings · 11/03/2023 08:02

Thisismynamenow · 11/03/2023 07:41

@Jimboscott0115 wow, what an insult to all the civil servant on here.

I doubt @Jimboscott0115 has had a well paying job in their life. What a clown.

EsmeSusanOgg · 11/03/2023 08:01

FrenchFancie · 11/03/2023 07:05

We’ll yes, but the civil service still work shorter hours and with more holidays than the private sector, so the overall package is better.

at least that’s the theory….

Pay freezes, below inflation raises etc. mean that many Civil Service salaries are substantially lower than they should be. This has lead to recruitment and retentional issues. I know someone who has contractors working for her than are on double her salary.

crisscross101 · 11/03/2023 07:58

It's also a complete myth that public sector workers get amazing holiday entitlements or work less hours. The pensions are good but not the old final salary schemes and you can't retire at 60 anymore...

adulthumanfemalemum · 11/03/2023 07:57

"important"

adulthumanfemalemum · 11/03/2023 07:57

When you said "import" jobs I thought you meant the scandal that is how poorly paid nurses and nursery workers are. 99% of people would say their children and their health are the most important things in the world to them. Yet those who care for our children and us and our families when they are ill are paid less than supermarket staff.

Zarqon · 11/03/2023 07:55

Jimboscott0115 · 11/03/2023 07:20

Several issues with the civil service which pays about 50% of the going rate for my role.

The first is, noone worth their salt in a professional field wants to work for the civil service. It's full of red tape, processes designed to do nothing but cover arses and ridiculous hierarchical attitudes that ultimately means nothing of value gets done. If you have a problem in a project that needs escalation it can take a week for it to feed up the chain through official channels and a week to come back down again. In the private sector I can pick up the phone to whoever makes the decision and solve it in an hour.

Every person I know who's moved from private sector to public has given it up in 12-18 months because it's where you go to die and plod along while nodding away at a bunch of idiots. Yes the pension etc might be tempting but the complete death of your career, ambitions and ability to think for yourself and create solutions isn't quite worth it.

Back to the questions raised in the OP, these roles pay lowly because they're shopping for talent below the midpoint - the mediocre - because that's the only people they can attract due to culture, processes and the way they do things.

This.

I took a massive pay cut to work for the civil service because the job advert sounded awesome.

It was basically fiction: the ad was what someone wished the job was, not what it was. Colleagues were lazy and obsessed with career progression, no one cared if the actual job got done. Perhaps my department was just poor but I knew very quickly that I’d made an awful mistake, and left when I could.

If the money is low, it means you aren’t valued.

merrigorownd · 11/03/2023 07:55

MissTrip82 · 11/03/2023 07:36

Wow I thought the important job title was going to be intensive care nurse or similar.

Senior nurses can and do earn more than this (see www.nurses.co.uk/careers-hub/nursing-pay-guide/) and deserve every penny and more. But we onviously need a thriving economy in order to be able to afford to pay the nurses more.

OP posts:
BelindaBears · 11/03/2023 07:52

Public sector pay lags massively behind private sector in the professions/higher level. It’s one of the reasons there’s such a massive recruitment problem at the moment.

Folklore9074 · 11/03/2023 07:51

Job hunting at the moment and yes salaries are certainly going down not up. That said £50k is a bigish salary in that part of the country.

Jimboscott0115 · 11/03/2023 07:50

Thisismynamenow · 11/03/2023 07:41

@Jimboscott0115 wow, what an insult to all the civil servant on here.

I know of well over a dozen people who have taken the step into public sector/civil service work from private in a variety of roles and generally all pretty senior & every single one without fail has said the same thing and escaped when they could before they lost the will to achieve anything in their careers.

I've dealt with government on private/public collaboration projects and have seen it - the lack of innovative thinking, problem handling and the volume of people who's job is essentially only in existence because of 'processes' and red tape is unreal. Introductions were hilarious in meetings when half the people there were there because they were part of some sort of chain of command/governance but would add zero value to the project (or any project).

If anywhere is paying 40k for a role that can comfortably get 80k then it's clear they aren't looking for the best, or even the average - but the mediocre.

merrigorownd · 11/03/2023 07:47

I currently work in a much less important-sounding senior analytical role in the Higher Education sector, in London, helping to deliver projects. It's a skilled role, but I have no direct reports. I've seen my job title advertised in a variety of civil service departments, sometimes for less than this, sometimes for the same, and sometimes for more (if a market premium is added, and London weighting). It just seems very random.

OP posts:
Thisismynamenow · 11/03/2023 07:41

Jimboscott0115 · 11/03/2023 07:20

Several issues with the civil service which pays about 50% of the going rate for my role.

The first is, noone worth their salt in a professional field wants to work for the civil service. It's full of red tape, processes designed to do nothing but cover arses and ridiculous hierarchical attitudes that ultimately means nothing of value gets done. If you have a problem in a project that needs escalation it can take a week for it to feed up the chain through official channels and a week to come back down again. In the private sector I can pick up the phone to whoever makes the decision and solve it in an hour.

Every person I know who's moved from private sector to public has given it up in 12-18 months because it's where you go to die and plod along while nodding away at a bunch of idiots. Yes the pension etc might be tempting but the complete death of your career, ambitions and ability to think for yourself and create solutions isn't quite worth it.

Back to the questions raised in the OP, these roles pay lowly because they're shopping for talent below the midpoint - the mediocre - because that's the only people they can attract due to culture, processes and the way they do things.

@Jimboscott0115 wow, what an insult to all the civil servant on here.

chocolatepenny89 · 11/03/2023 07:38

In practice what happens is those jobs are taken by very young, ambitious graduates who are maybe 4-8 years into their career and either use them as a stepping stone to promotion (where the salaries are better, although still low for the level of responsibility) or to a much better paying job in the private sector.

I don’t think it’s the kind of civil service job which attracts applicants because of the work/life balance and pension, although there are plenty of those too.

HMT is known to be a very young department which attracts a certain type.

Makegoodchoices · 11/03/2023 07:36

sandgrown · 11/03/2023 07:20

Civil Service wages are lagging behind. Average wage rises are 6% . In the CS it is 1-2% after years of low or no pay rise . Except MPs of course .

My jaw dropped at this. I’ve been at my company (private sector) for a long time and I don’t think it’s ever gone over 3%

Maybe I should enter the civil service and at least get a good pension 😂

MissTrip82 · 11/03/2023 07:36

Wow I thought the important job title was going to be intensive care nurse or similar.

Rollersea · 11/03/2023 07:35

I have no idea now nurses manage to work in any London hospital on a significantly less amount than this