Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to worry when jobs that sound so important have such a low salary?

110 replies

merrigorownd · 11/03/2023 07:02

I'm currently job hunting, so get a few mailshots, and have an alert set up for analytical jobs in the civil service. I'm often surprised at how low the salaries are for job titles that sound strategically important for the running of our country. This is just a random example.

The range shown is for someone based in Darlington, but I clicked through to the detail and the London range was only £3k higher. I know the cost of living is lower in Darlington than in London, and that £50k is relatively a high wage in that area, but if I was a Darlington-based economist with the required level of competence to lead a team of 15 people in advising Government ministers on national policy, I think I might be well aware of my ability to earn much more with a different employer.

Aibu to worry when jobs that sound so important have such a low salary?
OP posts:
MissyB1 · 11/03/2023 09:03

Vloader23 · 11/03/2023 07:26

YANBU
Historically public sector has paid less than private markets but this was offset by good conditions, pensions and so on. Now that's not the case and wages have further even further Vs cost of living.

There are significant vacancy & capability gaps across public organisations for this reason. Happily for the Tories, though, it means we can pay £££ above the odds for their contractor and consultancy buddies to fill those gaps. Costing us more than offering a realistic wage in the first place.

Absolutely this! It’s worth repeating this a million times! And it’s why we have massive amounts of Vacancies in the public sector, particularly NHS of course.

ObamaLlamas · 11/03/2023 09:00

Didn't the civil service strike recently? What's happened with that? Their pay is stupidly low, I know as I've applied for a role but I want the flexibility.

Autocadelite · 11/03/2023 08:59

If you want to see public money being spaffed - check out Healthwatch.

mrspinkhat · 11/03/2023 08:59

Why do you think so many civil servants are going on strike? There are so many depts now that the media aren't reporting- you only hear teachers, nurses, paramedics. The wages are dire, they are extending the hours and we suspect before too long they will be trying to reduce our holidays. I would not join the CS now, and I'm actively looking to leave.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 11/03/2023 08:58

Spaffing

Theeyeballsinthesky · 11/03/2023 08:57

I don’t work for the civil service but I work a lot with civil servants on shared projects. It’s partly as well the nature of the problems we’re asked to solve. We know that falls in older people cost the NHS and social care several billion a year. If we could reduce falls in older people we would both save money & improve older peoples quality of life. We know what works, we’ve known for years - exercise, reducing polypoharmacy, improving pavements, regular sight tests & proper glasses, timely adaptations to people’s homes.

however there’s not the money to do all that so the problem can’t be solved. It’s no wonder civil servants get demoralised and leave. When you have all the evidence of what works but know it will never be implemented cos money while seeing the government slagging millions and millions on projects for their mates, I’d leave too

BeautifulWar · 11/03/2023 08:55

I was looking for a WFH remote job recently and came across a job requiring lots of experience and an MBA. The salary was £28k in the South East. I was amazed because that was lower than starting salaries when I finished my MBA 20 odd years ago.

I've noticed this with WFH jobs posted - the pay is significantly lower.

Autocadelite · 11/03/2023 08:49

largely due to an outdated culture and ridiculous red tape.

Oh mega cross post. PPs said the same

Autocadelite · 11/03/2023 08:45

I was also warned not to work for CS.

Our university (RG) warned us that it was full of people who are so hell bent on following rules from the 1970s that they don't have initiative or independent thinking skills.

And we were told its where your skills and talents end up fading into the ether.

😳

mincedtart · 11/03/2023 08:44

MissTrip82 · 11/03/2023 07:36

Wow I thought the important job title was going to be intensive care nurse or similar.

Oh for goodness sake, what is the obsession with hospital staff on MN. You’re right everyone else is unimportant.

chocolatepenny89 · 11/03/2023 08:44

Autocadelite · 11/03/2023 08:41

YANBU

I saw a data analyst job advertised last week for £21,000 - private sector for an insurance company.

5+ experience required. As was degree and preferably Masters.

Local Authority same job is £30k +

Never in a million years is the 21k job going to recruit a suitable candidate then, in this market. They are living in a dream world.

CornedBeef451 · 11/03/2023 08:44

I work in local government and it is dire.

The red tape and many, many, many levels of management seem designed to stop anything actually changing or improving.

Quick turnover of high level jobs, each one sets off some new way of designing the council and then disappears without anything actually changing and while the rest of us just get on with our jobs.

It has been incredibly flexible over the years though, I have gone part time, returned to full time, excellent maternity pay, sick pay, annual leave, flexi time, but I do worry that it has sapped my will and enthusiasm and I now might never leave. Not sure I could manage elsewhere!

Snowjokes · 11/03/2023 08:43

I’m civil service middle management and I largely (not totally) agree with @Jimboscott0115 unfortunately. You can’t achieve much in most roles because all decisions rest with ministers - if they want it to happen you have to make it happen and if they don’t care or have an opinion, nothing will happen. There are a lot of civil servants who are fairly useless and have managed to drift under the radar, scraping promotions, for many years. The red tape and hierarchy is ridiculous. Getting on and up is not about capability, it’s about how you manage relationships.

Also, I’m this grade, and I’d agree it’s not really as senior as it might sound on paper. It’s a grade where everyone wants a job title that makes them sound more important than they are.

On one level I’d love to leave the civil service. But a) I’m actively job hunting and finding similar T&Cs (part time, 33 days leave + bank hols, flexi hours) is very tough, and b) as someone who considers myself fairly capable, I feel a real guilt at adding to the “brain drain” that I’ve seen hit our department very hard over the last few years.

mynameiscalypso · 11/03/2023 08:42

I'm not a civil servant but work a lot with HMT. Everyone I deal with is 'Head of' something. It doesn't correlate at all with either any kind of experience or any kind of decision making power.

Blurpy · 11/03/2023 08:41

Jimboscott0115 · 11/03/2023 07:20

Several issues with the civil service which pays about 50% of the going rate for my role.

The first is, noone worth their salt in a professional field wants to work for the civil service. It's full of red tape, processes designed to do nothing but cover arses and ridiculous hierarchical attitudes that ultimately means nothing of value gets done. If you have a problem in a project that needs escalation it can take a week for it to feed up the chain through official channels and a week to come back down again. In the private sector I can pick up the phone to whoever makes the decision and solve it in an hour.

Every person I know who's moved from private sector to public has given it up in 12-18 months because it's where you go to die and plod along while nodding away at a bunch of idiots. Yes the pension etc might be tempting but the complete death of your career, ambitions and ability to think for yourself and create solutions isn't quite worth it.

Back to the questions raised in the OP, these roles pay lowly because they're shopping for talent below the midpoint - the mediocre - because that's the only people they can attract due to culture, processes and the way they do things.

"it's where you go to die" sounds pretty accurate. I moved from private to public sector six months ago. There ARE some really good people in my department, but they have no space to grow because they're forced to spend all their time on pointless, menial tasks. The people who could change things have no impetus to, as they're just waiting for retirement.

A lot of people I work with are very underqualified for their roles and would never be able to find work in the private sector due to their low level of skill, despite having worked for 10+ years. The expectation of what will be achieved each day is minimal. Projects that I would complete by myself in a couple of weeks in the private sector now drag on for months, due to staff inefficiency but also the need to make every decision by committee.

I was warned off by other people in my field, but in my naivety thought 'surely it can't be THAT bad'. 😑

Autocadelite · 11/03/2023 08:41

YANBU

I saw a data analyst job advertised last week for £21,000 - private sector for an insurance company.

5+ experience required. As was degree and preferably Masters.

Local Authority same job is £30k +

chocolatepenny89 · 11/03/2023 08:39

Overthebow · 11/03/2023 08:37

That’s higher than a lot of private sector jobs, statutory is 20 days and lots get that. Civil service also get additional bank holidays.

It’s one additional bank holiday isn’t it?

Conkersinautumn · 11/03/2023 08:37

My mum used to be at Horseguards. I'm actually shocked that whilst those might be low to you they've obviously been keeping up with pay rises reasonably well compared to some other public sector work. No wonder there are so many strikes and these come with reasonable hours and breaks. Cushy indeed.

Overthebow · 11/03/2023 08:37

HikingforScenery · 11/03/2023 08:33

Many departments get the same standard 25 days leave

That’s higher than a lot of private sector jobs, statutory is 20 days and lots get that. Civil service also get additional bank holidays.

HikingforScenery · 11/03/2023 08:33

FrenchFancie · 11/03/2023 07:05

We’ll yes, but the civil service still work shorter hours and with more holidays than the private sector, so the overall package is better.

at least that’s the theory….

Many departments get the same standard 25 days leave

DanceToTheMusicInMyHead · 11/03/2023 08:30

I work in the public sector in a similar role. I am well aware that I could earn 50% extra in the private sector given my qualifications, skills and experience. The 'package' here is slightly better, but no longer such a huge gulf to private sector (especially as maternity is no longer an issue for me). What keeps me here is the value of the work - working for public benefit.

However, it can be soul destroying! The hierarchy, bureaucracy and inefficiency drive me to tears of frustration. I am trying to change this in our area, but it is so culturally embedded that this will take time. Meanwhile, our salaries are so out of step that we can't recruit good people- we get the lower end of the talent pool. Or, if we do by chance get someone good, they leave because they can't take the frustration. So this exacerbates the issue - high turnover or poor staff stifles progress and innovation.

Increasing salaries would offer much better public value - an investment in doing better. With salaries that could attract the top of market candidates, so much more could be achieved. But then the same is true across the public sector, and can you justify raising the salaries in these roles Vs raising NHS and education sector salaries. Basically the public sector is broken.

DipsyLaLaPo · 11/03/2023 08:30

I have worked in government for nearly 15 years and have been reflecting on salaries recently. Last year we had a pay award across the board for all grades set at 2k. This year proposing similar. Quite progressive compared to % increase.

It occurred to me though, that colleagues in the role I was in 10 years ago pays exactly the same salary. Despite payrises after the worst of the austerity years.

What I realised is they are recruiting to those roles at lower grades when people leave, or they restructure. I have seen people accept lower grading, but the salary protected for a certain period, and there's little they can do to fight it. Then they leave after a year or two. New people join on the lower grade.

This is how in 10 or 15 years you see people being paid the same amount despite celebrating pay rises, since few people are in the same role for long as restructures are common and people move sideways or out to escape toxic teams.

So whether you are a head of service on about 60-70k, a senior manager on about 50-60k, a senior analyst on about 45k, a junior analyst on 35-40k, scaling down to the most junior entry roles on 19k - how can an admin role still be 19k after 15 years of pay rises?

Interestingly director salaries only ever go up, up up. I saw one for 170k this week. Directors 10 years ago were on around 100 and chief execs around 120 depending on size of authority.... chiefs are now on 250k+

It's a bloody scam.

Ginmonkeyagain · 11/03/2023 08:28

TBH I think tne job title is misleading uou. This is not a senior civil service job.

"Head of" doesn't mean you are particularly senior in the civil service, it just means you are a lead in a particular subject area and a grade 7. There are a fuck ton of grade 7 staff in the civil service.

It's a lower tier middle management job at most, if that.

Overthebow · 11/03/2023 08:25

Much prefer not ouch

Overthebow · 11/03/2023 08:25

Jimboscott0115 · 11/03/2023 07:20

Several issues with the civil service which pays about 50% of the going rate for my role.

The first is, noone worth their salt in a professional field wants to work for the civil service. It's full of red tape, processes designed to do nothing but cover arses and ridiculous hierarchical attitudes that ultimately means nothing of value gets done. If you have a problem in a project that needs escalation it can take a week for it to feed up the chain through official channels and a week to come back down again. In the private sector I can pick up the phone to whoever makes the decision and solve it in an hour.

Every person I know who's moved from private sector to public has given it up in 12-18 months because it's where you go to die and plod along while nodding away at a bunch of idiots. Yes the pension etc might be tempting but the complete death of your career, ambitions and ability to think for yourself and create solutions isn't quite worth it.

Back to the questions raised in the OP, these roles pay lowly because they're shopping for talent below the midpoint - the mediocre - because that's the only people they can attract due to culture, processes and the way they do things.

This is one of the reasons I left the civil service. Hat and the slow nature of the work compared to jobs in the private sector. Of course there are people who like working like that and that is great for them, but I ouch prefer the fast pace of the private sector.

Swipe left for the next trending thread