Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to worry when jobs that sound so important have such a low salary?

110 replies

merrigorownd · 11/03/2023 07:02

I'm currently job hunting, so get a few mailshots, and have an alert set up for analytical jobs in the civil service. I'm often surprised at how low the salaries are for job titles that sound strategically important for the running of our country. This is just a random example.

The range shown is for someone based in Darlington, but I clicked through to the detail and the London range was only £3k higher. I know the cost of living is lower in Darlington than in London, and that £50k is relatively a high wage in that area, but if I was a Darlington-based economist with the required level of competence to lead a team of 15 people in advising Government ministers on national policy, I think I might be well aware of my ability to earn much more with a different employer.

Aibu to worry when jobs that sound so important have such a low salary?
OP posts:
namejump · 12/03/2023 08:49

@TheHateIsNotGood I've not done a personality test (well except for a leadership programme) I've done a situational judgement test a couple of times which was fine, I didn't realise they did personally test on recruitment campaigns, how can they measure them with a score?

TheHateIsNotGood · 12/03/2023 00:02

Having made it through the 1st sift, I'm rather proud that I only got 14% for the CS online 'personality test'. It was such bollocks I'm glad I ain't good at it. Apparently I can practice and learn how to understand bollocks in order to pass....er, no thanks....

Anyone here got a lower score?

viewsoftheshard · 11/03/2023 15:50

Thank you for the link to that auction site, I’m busy planning my bids! The sapphire bracelet would lift all my navy blue outfits nicely.

Ginmonkeyagain · 11/03/2023 15:40

Although SPADs aren't mainstream civil servants, that's kind of the point of them.

They are political appointees.

Notwhatnotwhat · 11/03/2023 15:18

The civil service is such a weird place, it attracts a certain type of person with those salaries. I joined from private sector and was gobsmacked at what I would consider relatively junior, inexperienced people having such responsibility and influence. Then there are spads in their mid 20’s having only worked at think tanks advising the PM on business….

SallyLovesCheese · 11/03/2023 14:40

chocolatepenny89 · 11/03/2023 10:01

Firstly, the CS is massive and it’s difficult to generalise. There will be good and bad teams/departments to join. There will be roles which suit you and roles which don’t.

Secondly, it depends what you’re looking for. Do you care more about flexibility/part-time options than earning a big salary? Is pension important to you? Is job security important? If so, might be a good move. Do you want perks like free tea/coffee, paid-for Christmas parties. Want to be able to earn a decent bonus each year? Want the opportunity of a good pay rise/promotion solely on the basis of your performance? If so, might not be what you’re looking for.

I’m not an ex teacher but I know there are FB groups which are all about teachers looking to career change, as I’ve seen them recommended on here. I bet there would be a few civil servants on there.

Big thank you. Yes, I'm in the big FB group for teachers wanting to leave which is where I've seen lots said about the CS wanting teachers. But here is the first time I've seen the negatives of the CS laid out so I was curious.

Very true about what I want from the job. After teaching, I do want more flexibility at this point in my life (DS about to start school). I'm not bothered about free drinks or parties! So I'll continue to explore CS roles.

Thanks for your thoughts.

brainstories568 · 11/03/2023 12:08

merrigorownd · 11/03/2023 10:10

Have you thought of moving within HE? You'd probably get a higher salary and similar benefits, particularly at some of the London unis

@brainstories568 I'm already at the top of my pay grade at one of the central London unis, but yes, a couple of others that are wealthier institutions are starting to do market supplements so I'm applying. Some CS departments are offering market supplements too, so I'm also applying there. I like my job and lifestyle, so aiming for a horizontal move to somewhere with higher pay and similar/better benefits.

Makes sense... Are you at UoL or non UoL? Without being too outing much, I've generally found that my central London HE institution pays higher than UoL, particularly my department which is how/why we retain so many staff, but yeah, getting to the top of your band is an issue, particularly when there either isn't anywhere obvious to go to and/or the next grade job isn't worth the stress of being paid an extra couple of grand pre tax at the most :)

KILM · 11/03/2023 10:58

BridieConvert · 11/03/2023 09:23

£50k is a low salary for an "important" job? Excuse my ignorance as I don't really know what it entails but is analytics of the treasury seen as an important job?
As a PP has said I place importance on roles that involve caring/teaching/nurturing etc. and those are the important jobs with low salaries. I'd love a salary of £50k but instead I'll keep looking after and teaching your preschoolers for £20k. And my husband will continue caring for your sick relatives for £36k

I think analytics of treasury data is quite important as presumably economic decision making is based on those results. Well, if you had a government that followed logic that is! Your comment made me think of something interesting though - I suppose the ratio of 'important' (like caring and teaching, both woefully underpaid and underappreciated in my view for how critical they are to the economy, never mind people's lives) to 'unimportant' (hate that word but serves its purpose here, not crucial) like, working in a chip shop has tipped over the years with the extensive automation of 'unimportant' jobs that don't need to be done by a human being or are no longer needed due to technology/societal advances. Which means we are left with this sort of 'what's important' in-fighting that tends to be manual labour vs office work. When really we need to recognise that the guy working in cyber security in a comfy 9-5 WFH job making sure no-one can get into military databases by working on his one section of the system he has expertise in, does have importance, just in a different way to a doctor. But it's a relatively new set of circumstances, so it's hard to shore it up against someone working end of life care. (If anyone reading this knows of any further reading on this pls let me know!)

HallucinationQ · 11/03/2023 10:11

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

merrigorownd · 11/03/2023 10:10

Have you thought of moving within HE? You'd probably get a higher salary and similar benefits, particularly at some of the London unis

@brainstories568 I'm already at the top of my pay grade at one of the central London unis, but yes, a couple of others that are wealthier institutions are starting to do market supplements so I'm applying. Some CS departments are offering market supplements too, so I'm also applying there. I like my job and lifestyle, so aiming for a horizontal move to somewhere with higher pay and similar/better benefits.

OP posts:
merrigorownd · 11/03/2023 10:01

Vloader23 · 11/03/2023 07:26

YANBU
Historically public sector has paid less than private markets but this was offset by good conditions, pensions and so on. Now that's not the case and wages have further even further Vs cost of living.

There are significant vacancy & capability gaps across public organisations for this reason. Happily for the Tories, though, it means we can pay £££ above the odds for their contractor and consultancy buddies to fill those gaps. Costing us more than offering a realistic wage in the first place.

And contractors bring their own issues. This article is behind an FT paywall, but worth a read if you have access:

Aibu to worry when jobs that sound so important have such a low salary?
OP posts:
chocolatepenny89 · 11/03/2023 10:01

SallyLovesCheese · 11/03/2023 09:18

I'm applying for CS roles. I'm currently a teacher and have been told the CS value a teacher's skill set. This is interesting what people are saying here about not going into the CS in the first place!

Would it still be a good bridge between my teaching career and something else? Should I just try and find jobs in the private sector? I'm not sure what kind of job title I'd be looking for and I don't have industry experience! It's a nightmare trying to leave teaching, honestly.

Firstly, the CS is massive and it’s difficult to generalise. There will be good and bad teams/departments to join. There will be roles which suit you and roles which don’t.

Secondly, it depends what you’re looking for. Do you care more about flexibility/part-time options than earning a big salary? Is pension important to you? Is job security important? If so, might be a good move. Do you want perks like free tea/coffee, paid-for Christmas parties. Want to be able to earn a decent bonus each year? Want the opportunity of a good pay rise/promotion solely on the basis of your performance? If so, might not be what you’re looking for.

I’m not an ex teacher but I know there are FB groups which are all about teachers looking to career change, as I’ve seen them recommended on here. I bet there would be a few civil servants on there.

brainstories568 · 11/03/2023 09:58

merrigorownd · 11/03/2023 07:47

I currently work in a much less important-sounding senior analytical role in the Higher Education sector, in London, helping to deliver projects. It's a skilled role, but I have no direct reports. I've seen my job title advertised in a variety of civil service departments, sometimes for less than this, sometimes for the same, and sometimes for more (if a market premium is added, and London weighting). It just seems very random.

Have you thought of moving within HE? You'd probably get a higher salary and similar benefits, particularly at some of the London unis...

Duttercup · 11/03/2023 09:45

BridieConvert · 11/03/2023 09:23

£50k is a low salary for an "important" job? Excuse my ignorance as I don't really know what it entails but is analytics of the treasury seen as an important job?
As a PP has said I place importance on roles that involve caring/teaching/nurturing etc. and those are the important jobs with low salaries. I'd love a salary of £50k but instead I'll keep looking after and teaching your preschoolers for £20k. And my husband will continue caring for your sick relatives for £36k

There are many different types of important jobs.

Ginmonkeyagain · 11/03/2023 09:40

I don't work for the CS but for a public body that has a lot of ex industry people. We do get better pay and terms and conditions than the CS, but we do struggle to retain some people who have niche akills that attract a lot more pay in the private sector.

One interesting thing is some private sector recruits don't realise is working for a public body is more complex and involves a lot more soft skills and political judgement. In the private sector essentially your only aim is to make money for your employer, every role ultimately contribites to that aim.

Public sector bodies have to balance lots of statutory requirements, political demands (with a large and a small P) and sometimes being asked to do stuff, not because it makes sense, but because it is demanded either by ministers or the general public.

This can lead to institutional cynicism and inertia, it is true.

Allergictoironing · 11/03/2023 09:38

I've been Civil Service, private sector and now local government, and have family in the Civil Service. When I first left the Civil Service, I got a little over 30% more money, for a job with much more authority and less responsibility. At the same time I may have had to go into a not quite as good pension scheme and lost a couple of days holiday, but I had tea/coffee etc supplied by the company, private health insurance, decent up to date offices, better quality accommodation if I worked away from home etc. Also didn't have to pay for work parties, had decent catering for meetings, ability to occasionally WFH, decent up to date kit & didn't have to justify in triplicate why I wanted a different colour Bic pen.

The salary for the grade I was then, around 25 years ago, has gone up by a total of around £6k. Pay rises for standard Civil Servants have been capped well below those of the private sector for many years, including quite a few years of pay freezes.

Move on 25 years to local government. I am earning maybe £2k more now than the equivalent grade in the Civil Service was earning when I left, though this IS going up £2k this April. The very rare perk of tea & coffee supplies is being taken away at the same time. I get 26 days leave a year which is pretty standard and no extras. The pension scheme isn't too bad, though of course defined benefits (which we contribute a fair bit to) isn't as much of an advantage if your salary is low

Many things are dictated by grade e.g. spending limits are grade dependent even if your job involves having to expend lots of money. But at least we aren't expected to work more than our contracted hours of 37.5 hours per week which is pretty much standard.

So all in all public sector (office based) work pays shit and has virtually no perks any more. The plus side is if you manage to hold out there you have the job satisfaction (role dependent) of value to the community and a half decent pension.

Chocolateydrink · 11/03/2023 09:34

DH works in the civil service, I'm private sector. Our headline salaries are similar but his pension is massively better than mine (and mine is very good for a company pension). The salary looks poor because there's masses going into the pension. There should probably be a change in the law so that jobs have to be advertised with the full pay package including pension contributions and T&Cs. Might make public sector workers realise they are doing OK.

Oh, and 2 people on '£50550 to £57500' will be able to afford a very nice period property (e.g. This) in the nicest part of Darlington in the catchment for the best schools. What a Londoner considers low is double the average salary in the NE.

namejump · 11/03/2023 09:29

Don't forget the overall package is worth more, you can easily add about 25% to try and include the pension value (though this isn't easy to accurately reflect)

You're not wrong, but I will not sit here and be told (by others) I am mediocre, I am fucking good at my job and the CS is lucky to have me, I work where I work because the subject area is fascinating, I would likely have to work in the financial sector to do what I do at a much higher salary, and the thought bores me to to tears. I earn £65k, have an excellent pension, in a cheap area, complete flexibility, and a job I enjoy. Yep I could earn £100k in an insurance firm...but no fucking thank you!

Onebigmistake · 11/03/2023 09:28

In some counties, CS pays MORE than the private sector average. Imagine that

(Cornwall especially!)

ScentOfSawdust · 11/03/2023 09:24

I have worked in the public sector my whole career. Some areas have lacked innovation and been mired in red tape but that’s not the case everywhere. I have worked with some brilliant people on policies and programmes that have made real improvements to people’s lives. Yes, they (and I) could be earning more elsewhere, and yes, it can be frustrating at times but I could never get job satisfaction from a role where my ultimate purpose is to make money for someone.

BridieConvert · 11/03/2023 09:23

£50k is a low salary for an "important" job? Excuse my ignorance as I don't really know what it entails but is analytics of the treasury seen as an important job?
As a PP has said I place importance on roles that involve caring/teaching/nurturing etc. and those are the important jobs with low salaries. I'd love a salary of £50k but instead I'll keep looking after and teaching your preschoolers for £20k. And my husband will continue caring for your sick relatives for £36k

Parsley1234 · 11/03/2023 09:20

I had to get a job in the pandemic after losing my three businesses was recruited as a work coach the first day I was there I could not believe the ineptitude the laziness the lack of innovation the calibre of people there. Sad to say most left all the new fresh people from lots of different industries left because it was so shit ! I was incredulous most days

SallyLovesCheese · 11/03/2023 09:18

I'm applying for CS roles. I'm currently a teacher and have been told the CS value a teacher's skill set. This is interesting what people are saying here about not going into the CS in the first place!

Would it still be a good bridge between my teaching career and something else? Should I just try and find jobs in the private sector? I'm not sure what kind of job title I'd be looking for and I don't have industry experience! It's a nightmare trying to leave teaching, honestly.

PandasAreUseless · 11/03/2023 09:09

Agreed.
I saw a role advertised with GCHQ. It was for something like "Head of Security Analytics".
The salary was £30k! I thought - surely that's missing a '0'!

SlipperyLizard · 11/03/2023 09:09

I applied for a civil service job that would have required a 30% pay cut if I got it, but at my age the value of the pension benefit would have made up the difference.

I agree that public sector salaries look low, but the cost of the pension is massive compared to what the private sector provides.