Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to worry when jobs that sound so important have such a low salary?

110 replies

merrigorownd · 11/03/2023 07:02

I'm currently job hunting, so get a few mailshots, and have an alert set up for analytical jobs in the civil service. I'm often surprised at how low the salaries are for job titles that sound strategically important for the running of our country. This is just a random example.

The range shown is for someone based in Darlington, but I clicked through to the detail and the London range was only £3k higher. I know the cost of living is lower in Darlington than in London, and that £50k is relatively a high wage in that area, but if I was a Darlington-based economist with the required level of competence to lead a team of 15 people in advising Government ministers on national policy, I think I might be well aware of my ability to earn much more with a different employer.

Aibu to worry when jobs that sound so important have such a low salary?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ginmonkeyagain · 01/04/2023 08:41

Yeah, but as people have pointed out abive "Head of" in the CS does not mean the same thing as it does in the private sector.

The very senior grades are Deputy Director and Permanent Secretary. Those will be the ones on the 6 figure salaries.

For context I work for a non CS public body and I am definitely not a "Head of" but I regularly meet with CS "Heads of" and regard them as my peers. My salary is higher than the one advertised but not hugely so.

merrigorownd · 01/04/2023 08:00

... Even the Cyber Security lead at my Higher Education employer earns more then £57k!

OP posts:
merrigorownd · 01/04/2023 07:57

Spotted on Twitter - someone else pointing out another worryingly underpaid CS job!

Aibu to worry when jobs that sound so important have such a low salary?
OP posts:
Jimboscott0115 · 16/03/2023 06:47

Sshiamreading · 14/03/2023 23:56

This is a false conclusion, even if we take what you say as true and agree it’s a slower pace of work or less demanding etc there’s many reasons a talented person might take a job like that on - childcare or other caring responsibilities, stress in other areas of their life, flexible working, not like the atmosphere of the private sector. Money isn’t everything and some people are very talented but not super career driven.

I don't disagree at all and there's clearly a lot of Nuance to this, but if you think about it, the pool of people is narrower and narrower, hence the recruitment issues.

If you're looking for someone who wants a slower pace/flexibility due to the reasons above, but is talented, experienced and is also willing to earn less and work in this kind of environment to do so - it's a significantly smaller pond to fish (recruit) in. It likely excludes a good 80/90% of people in most roles.

For what it's worth, it's certainly something I'll consider in 10 years time if I still want to earn what many would consider a good wage but slow down a little as I head into my 50s. As much as I enjoy what I do, it can be ridiculously stressful in the private sector and I'm not sure this is something I can imagine being able to sustain at 50 and beyond.

Olaftree · 15/03/2023 22:38

And I also do a 9 day fortnight (flexible working) - it’s v difficult for them to decline a FW.

Olaftree · 15/03/2023 22:37

I work for a publicly owned company (not CS). I earn 34k but in the private sector could probably earn around 50k.
I get to WFH majority of the time, 21% pension (they add 12%), 6 months full sick / 6 months half sick, 35 days A/L (I buy a week) plus all bank holidays, performance salary paid up to 10%, 6 months full pay mat leave..

The benefits - annual leave! - for me keep me here for now. But there are definitely reasons why people stay. The red tape is ridiculous though but as stated our purpose as a business isn’t just money, so it’s a balancing act.

milliondollardress · 15/03/2023 22:10

Ah this thread is depressing, I am a civil servant and I started another thread about how overwhelmed I feel at work. And that my “part-time” job isn’t really part-time at all.

I must be a special kind of useless to be feeling like this when CS jobs are so flexible and straightforward and don’t involve any actual work or decisions 😭

Chocolatetadpole · 15/03/2023 08:38

For me the work life balance I have at CS, the high A/L , bank holidays plus 2 extra bank holidays and the general job security puts me off looking outside of where I am, but I am aware that I could do a similar role in the private sector and be paid more than I do in the CS.

CS strike today over pay actually, although it's overshadowed by the Teachers/ Doctor strikes we've had lately.

Ginmonkeyagain · 15/03/2023 08:33

Also the idea there isn't red tape or hierarchy in large private companies is laughable.

I am trying to get some fairly non controversial data from a large, household name company at the moment for a work project. The amount of people that need to check and sign it off is astonishing.

Sshiamreading · 14/03/2023 23:56

Jimboscott0115 · 11/03/2023 08:21

I get it, but the only people I can see being offended are those who are in the kinds of jobs that cause some of the problems, who love hierarchy, red tape and long drawn out processes and a slower pace of work. That's great for them, but they have to accept an outsider's view as to why talented people wouldn't or don't consider working there.

This is a false conclusion, even if we take what you say as true and agree it’s a slower pace of work or less demanding etc there’s many reasons a talented person might take a job like that on - childcare or other caring responsibilities, stress in other areas of their life, flexible working, not like the atmosphere of the private sector. Money isn’t everything and some people are very talented but not super career driven.

csnc · 14/03/2023 23:50

NicolaSturGONE · 13/03/2023 09:25

I just got an email from a someone from HM Treasury with a 'head of' job title. That person was a work experience student at our place of work less than 5 years ago.

I can see why that would be jarring but within Big 4 consultancy and Magic Circle/Silver Circle law firms, you progress and gain titles along a roughly similar timescale as well, but obviously at much, much higher salaries.

csnc · 14/03/2023 23:45

YANBU.

I know people who work as their Minister's right hand man everyday on pathetic pay. Equally I know many who've left for higher pay in the private sector eg consultancy. Most civil servants in policy (at least those I know) are from Oxbridge or Golden Triangle unis and they can clearly command 6 figure sums elsewhere.

The issue also is when you factor in the costs of staying near/ commuting to/ working in Westminster (not as bad now with WFH and the option to stay further though). Those who can afford such a low salary tend to come from a more privileged background. They were trying to equalise it with Darlington, but from what I hear that's not been going very smoothly.

highstep · 14/03/2023 23:16

What? Genuinely don't understand your issue with women saying they're good at they're jobs, they were provoked being called mediocre so it's not as if it was an uninvited defence.

passthegingordon · 14/03/2023 23:11

@highstep Oh please.

highstep · 14/03/2023 23:07

@passthegingordon what's wrong with saying you're good at your job? Being coy won't get you anywhere. Or is just women who aren't allowed to be confident in their skills? Are we all supposed to whimper in a corner with "imposter" syndrome. Fuck that.

passthegingordon · 14/03/2023 22:51

I see modesty is STRONG in the CS.

MilitantFawcett · 14/03/2023 19:43

Civil servant of 20+ years here. Also bloody good at my job and certainly not waiting for my career to die or whatever that nonsense was. I’ve been approached numerous times by headhunters for the industry I have most contact with but I’m not interested. I’m a grade 7, what I earn is sufficient and the work I do is absolutely fascinating and has changed the world for the better. The options open to me in private sector may pay well but they’re dull as ditchwater by comparison (or ethically questionable). My OH left private consultancy for CS a few years ago and says the same. He won’t go back to private sector.

The CS isn’t monolithic and Departmental culture varies, driven by Ministers. What I’ve seen new people struggle with a lot is the politics. Ministers can be capricious, indecisive and frankly stupid. They are frequently working on issues they know (or care) little about and it’s a fair criticism that the CS doesn’t do much to speak truth to power.

tommika · 14/03/2023 19:18

chocolatepenny89 · 14/03/2023 18:47

Thanks. So…one additional bank holiday then.

That was meant to include the quote from @Overthebow

^^
Overthebow · 11/03/2023 08:37
HikingforScenery · 11/03/2023 08:33
Many departments get the same standard 25 days leave
Show quote history
That’s higher than a lot of private sector jobs, statutory is 20 days and lots get that. Civil service also get additional bank holidays.

Many jobs do only get leave including Bank Holidays which was Overthebows point
But based on a full time 5 day week, 20 days including Bank Holidays is below statutory minimum, and a Civil Service starter at 25 days must legally get 3 bank holidays on top

Arguably from overthebow an entry level civil servant is on 36 days and I’m on 42.5 days
And they

chocolatepenny89 · 14/03/2023 18:47

tommika · 14/03/2023 18:28

Statutory leave is 5.6 weeks, (28 days for workers on a 5 day week) and employers can count Bank Holidays within that

A ‘good’ employer is expected to give leave plus bank holidays - so it would be contradictory for government to discount them

www.gov.uk/holiday-entitlement-rights

Civil Servants are generally on 25 to 30 days (rising over 5 years) annual leave plus bank holidays, and the additional 1 privilege day

Personally I’m on 31.5 days annual leave (as the other 1.5 privilege days were taken away after I was promoted and are in my contract of employment)
If I take promotion then I’ll change contract and lose leave - but I also won’t progress on the pay scale without promotion

Thanks. So…one additional bank holiday then.

tommika · 14/03/2023 18:28

chocolatepenny89 · 11/03/2023 08:39

It’s one additional bank holiday isn’t it?

Statutory leave is 5.6 weeks, (28 days for workers on a 5 day week) and employers can count Bank Holidays within that

A ‘good’ employer is expected to give leave plus bank holidays - so it would be contradictory for government to discount them

www.gov.uk/holiday-entitlement-rights

Civil Servants are generally on 25 to 30 days (rising over 5 years) annual leave plus bank holidays, and the additional 1 privilege day

Personally I’m on 31.5 days annual leave (as the other 1.5 privilege days were taken away after I was promoted and are in my contract of employment)
If I take promotion then I’ll change contract and lose leave - but I also won’t progress on the pay scale without promotion

NicolaSturGONE · 13/03/2023 09:25

I just got an email from a someone from HM Treasury with a 'head of' job title. That person was a work experience student at our place of work less than 5 years ago.

thecatsthecats · 12/03/2023 10:34

Interesting. My husband is a civil servant in a regulatory department. He moved from a big 4 accountant, and is eyeing a role in industry for his next move.

He was astonished by the change in culture when he moved, but I basically refused to try for a baby whilst he was working sixty hours a week minimum.

I was looking at roles in my own field with the civil service, and was surprised that the equivalent Civil Service role ONLY paid the market rate. And for that, I'd be responsible for advising all MP offices, plus Parliament and the HoL.

Schooling a bunch of Tories on an area of law they're determined to fuck up? No thank you.

namejump · 12/03/2023 10:24

@TheHateIsNotGood ah ok, I somehow nail them, I scored higher than 99% of G7s in one campaign, it was about how you handle certain challenging situations as a leader, I just find them to be common sense but can't say I'd give them much weight as a recruiter and have never chosen to add it in any of my campaigns, seems too easy to manipulate if you really wanted to.

Maybe I'm just a mediocre cookie cutter civil servant 😂😂

garlictwist · 12/03/2023 10:18

Is that a low salary? I think that's pretty decent actually.

TheHateIsNotGood · 12/03/2023 10:17

Apologies namejump, i meant situational judgement test, which to me is a personality test. The test had nothing to do with the job but struck me as a bit of gossipy, he said/she said nonsense test, which I tend to ignore in real life. Hence my very poor score.