Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reincarnation and multiple lives - if you believe this what does it mean

131 replies

Pleasekeepmycoffeehot · 10/03/2023 20:40

Just for fun really, as I don't believe in reincarnation. The idea of it is so fucking tiring! When I'm dead I want peace and quiet and a rest Grin the thoughts of starting the whole thing again is quite draining...

But, if you have an interest in this stuff, what do our hardships mean in the present life? Is it all something to do with karma and about lessons we need to learn this time round?

Is it like - we start off with 'easy' lives to begin with, and build our experience, and our lives get progressively harder until we reach enlightenment?

Or the opposite! Do we start off with 'harder' lives - and then they get easier the more we work our way through multiple lives? Kind of like a career pathway where you get really experienced and do more challenging things later on lol. And get to enlightenment that way?

And then is there something about karma biting us on the ass/ bad stuff happening as punishment in this life for stuff we fucked up last time round? Hmmm, that seems a bit victim-blamey.

What way does it work? Who has read about this or has any thoughts?

OP posts:
JoonT · 11/03/2023 16:23

I really hope people like Richard Dawkins are right. I hope that death is the end. Life has its good bits, but it’s mostly suffering. Frankly, there are times when I feel guilty for bringing a child into the world. I certainly wouldn’t want to live my life over again, and reincarnation is just about the worst thing I can imagine.

Some people cannot bear the thought eternal nothingness. I mean the thought that you could be walking along the street then bang, a car hits you, and its instant nothingness forever. I’m terrified of dying (I mean the hideous process - the death rattle, the struggle for breath, etc), but the thought of not existing at all makes me happy. Some people find it unbearable. For me it’s a comfort. If we just disappeared, instantly and painlessly, at 85 - like a hologram that is switched off - I’d never worry about anything again.

When you undergo regression therapy, I suspect you re-live the experiences of your ancestors rather than something you went through yourself. I’ve got a feeling we somehow inherit our ancestor’s memories. Maybe they are stored in the DNA somehow. Jung called it the collective unconscious. But the idea of an individual soul - some solid, persistent thing that is reincarnated - no, that seems unlikely. We aren’t made of anything that persists. We’re a collection of atoms and cells and bacteria, which is constantly being replaced. You’re not even made of the same cells and atoms and bacteria as you were 30 years ago.

OMG12 · 11/03/2023 15:25

I believe in reincarnation. I’m not a big follower of Eastern philosophy so can’t really answer your questions about Karma etc.

I believe we contain an energy/soul which is part of the divine. The purpose of creation and therefore out purpose within time and space is to experience being. Something that is everything cannot experience itself, each of our souls has a purpose to fulfil within that need to experience. It’s not about becoming objectively perfect. It’s about finding our true purpose - once we have fulfilled that purpose or will then we will return to the source. We all have different purpose to enable the source to experience every aspect of itself. Part of the journey is finding out what that purpose is and fulfilling it.

IME “past life regression” should be done by the individual being guided into the right alternative state of consciousness and discovering their own past life rather than someone else telling them what it is.,

whether this is indeed past lives is of course open to debate but it’s largely irrelevant

it could be reliving a past life

it could be recognition of a life you’re living simultaneously

it could be your imagination creating a back story to understand something in the present

amylou8 · 11/03/2023 15:25

I hope not. I want to die, be gone and know nothing about it. If I do come back though I'd like to be my cat.

blebbleb · 11/03/2023 15:06

I used to be terrified of no longer existing, went through a real existential crisis recently. Perhaps there's more after death but I think consciousness happens in the brain. It's almost a comfort to think it ends one day, even though I'm happy in this life. Many beliefs like reincarnation stem from a fear of the unknown and fear of no longer existing. But then I'm just another person so I have no clue really!

blobby10 · 11/03/2023 15:02

SharonKaren · 11/03/2023 14:53

Do you think people who are very empathetic have lived through many lives before and can therefore empathise with different human conditions?

That's a good point - I hadn't thought of it like that before! I do believe in reincarnation mainly because I don't want to believe a being as complex as a human can just stop existing. We are so much more than blood and emotions - I don't want to believe a soul ever dies and it gives me comfort to think this. I don't think we are 'supposed' to remember past lives but the memories are there until our brains become too cluttered with this life stuff but I'm not going to say I'm right and you're wrong to anyone!

My DS between the ages of 2 and 5 related in great detail his life when he was 'big', life with his grandparents, his drowning(s), food he ate, his grandparents bicycles, their clothes, their faces. He was very attached to his grandfather and sobbed several times because he missed him . We were careful never to put words in his mouth or ideas in his head or to encourage elaboration. The words he said were quite matter of fact and there was no way he could have got any of the descriptions from photographs or endless watching of Thomas the Tank engine videos.

SharonKaren · 11/03/2023 14:53

Do you think people who are very empathetic have lived through many lives before and can therefore empathise with different human conditions?

blebbleb · 11/03/2023 14:50

I would choose nothingness rather than be born over and over!

blebbleb · 11/03/2023 14:48

@Itdoesnthavetobejusrol I personally don't believe it. Yes I wouldn't know if I lived before but that's sad to me. Your whole past lives just erased from your memory until you die again. You could be born into a life of slavery, suffering and abuse next time. It's as plausible as any theory but like a previous poster said where do all these new souls come from? I certainly hope it's not true and would opt out if that's a thing. Perhaps I'm just attached to this life!

Itdoesnthavetobejusrol · 11/03/2023 14:45

*shoes

Itdoesnthavetobejusrol · 11/03/2023 14:38

blebbleb · 11/03/2023 03:00

I really hope reincarnation isn't a thing. I don't want to be someone else or be born into a life of suffering. Once is enough.

You won't know. Just like you don't know now. You might be on your 123rd life!

When (usually older) people look at a baby and say 'he's been here before' it makes me feel warm inside. I don't know why really. I don't necessarily believe in it but I do find it comforting. Old souls, and all that.

I lean more towards believing this than in any particular religion or god. It just feels like it makes more sense. I have no idea how on earth the process would work though! Someone asked earlier at what moment in time does the soul transfer into a new body - perhaps the point of your earliest memory? So for me it would have been whilst I was trailing my should on the floor in my buggy and my mum kept putting them back on the plastic foot belt thing. Then I'd trail them again cause I liked the vibration through my shoes.

Like I said, I don't wholeheartedly believe in it but it's my favourite spiritual theory by far and I love speculating about it.

frozenyoghurtyurt · 11/03/2023 12:20

Yes, I do. I don't have any real reasoning for it. I just don't feel that our souls, our spirits, disappear with our physical bodies. The essence of who we are.

I can fully believe that I knew my mum in a previous life, but with roles reversed. I have always been the adult more than she has. I really hope I get something easier next time. This life has been traumatic.

stardustpixy · 11/03/2023 09:04

RollerCoaster2020 · 10/03/2023 23:58

I found this thought-provoking, having Buddhist tendencies.

"The egg" on kyrzygsdadt (sic?) (which means in a nutshell)

Christ my worst nightmare.. living everyone's lives. Living all those horrific deaths in auschwitz etc no thanks this video is very disturbing

Sunriseinwonderland · 11/03/2023 08:39

reincarnation is a core belief in my religion but I can't even think about it I am totally exhausted with this life.

queenMab99 · 11/03/2023 08:36

I believe we are here to learn, and improve, so, to me, it doesn't matter whether we come back in another life. If you look at every situation as a chance to learn and improve, it makes it easier to bear when things are bad.
If we all try to raise our level of consciousness, the over all level will increase, and the world will be a better place to live.

Craftycorvid · 11/03/2023 08:25

When very young children spontaneously start talking about when they were here ‘before’ and can be precise with details, I find that fascinating. I don’t know if it’s evidence in support of past lives or not, but it feels more convincing than the results of adult past life regression experiences. Mature adults have forgotten and filed away hundreds of impressions from books, conversations, films etc, so any ‘recall’ is liable to be more like a dreaming and altered memory state than anything more significant. We may think it’s amazing and that we must have been that person in another time and place because we have so much detail to supply, but we might have read or otherwise found out about that and lost the conscious memory of doing so.

follyfoot37 · 11/03/2023 08:17

OnlyFannys · 10/03/2023 20:45

I would like to believe in reincarnation because the idea of death and nothingness terrifies me but sadly I dont

but you won't be aware of being dead or the nothingness. That's the point; it's not like you are in an empty, silent room, you have no conscious awareness

TuesdayJulyNever · 11/03/2023 08:07

The problem I have with most schools of religious thought is that you start with an improbable but deeply attractive idea like reincarnation or heaven, etc, and then apply logic and reason after the fact and inevitably end up with dulled compassion.

Suffering, whether it’s in this world or the next, can be brushed off as karma, or the wages of sin; ultimately the fault of the victim.

I’d rather believe that our efforts to alleviate suffering and right injustice in this life matter.

I quite like the idea of reincarnation - I feel like I’ve known my dh and ds in other lives. I just don’t want to think too much about it.

Fuwari · 11/03/2023 07:43

When my son was a toddler and started talking he told me he was meant to go to someone else but “chose” me instead. He never really said much more than that about it, but was adamant that was the case. He forgot about it as he got older though.

I wouldn’t say I believe anything. There are multiple theories which could be true, we can’t know. I suppose I am open minded to what happens when we die. I had a horrible childhood, so the idea of having another go with a nice childhood is somewhat appealing. But if I got that I’d have no memory of the past awful one so I guess I’d just take it for granted!

Wooooooo · 11/03/2023 06:58

Quote fail.
The above was to this…
SisyphusDad · Yesterday 23:17
It means you lack critical faculties.

Wooooooo · 11/03/2023 06:57

How so?

Why should we be so arrogant to assume we know all? That humans have acquired as much knowledge as they ever will?
We all, for whatever reason, have our own beliefs, I would not insult those whose beliefs are different to mine, so please, respect goes both ways.

blebbleb · 11/03/2023 03:00

I really hope reincarnation isn't a thing. I don't want to be someone else or be born into a life of suffering. Once is enough.

Crunched · 11/03/2023 02:39

I couldn't really say I believe in reincarnation or multiple lives, but I do imagine that when we die, the atoms that made up our body will somehow rejoin the life of this planet and be part of other life.

User8646382 · 11/03/2023 01:24

NotSoBigCrocodile · 10/03/2023 22:23

I’ve named changed for this because it doesn’t sound very believable, but…

I had a past life regression session done years ago and it was recorded and given to me on disc.

It was incredibly vivid and I gave many details during the session - my name, where I lived, when I was born, my spouse’s name, what lessons I had learned during this lifetime etc. I gave descriptions of my home and what clothing I was wearing. I was no one of importance.

I listened back to the recording and done some research. There was a person by the name I had given, who was born on the date I gave, in the place I was living. The clothing and house I described were typical of those from that period in time. My spouse’s name was the same.

I’ve never really thought about it again until now. I don’t really know what to make of it.

I watched a TV documentary about this. The people claiming to have had past lives were strikingly physically similar to the people they allegedly were in those past lives. They basically had the same faces - it was fascinating.

Did you find a photo of this past person to compare, or was it too far back, ie pre-photography?

PlateBilledDuckyPerson · 11/03/2023 00:04

I'm interested to know at what point the reincarnation takes place. Is it:

  • When sperm meets egg
  • At a specific point in the development of the foetus or pre-sentient infant
  • At the moment of birth
  • At a random point between conception and the infant becoming fully sentient

Also, what is the time lapse? If looking for past incarnations, should you focus on people who died around the time you were conceived/born - or could there be a time lapse so your year of conception/birth is irrelevant?

RollerCoaster2020 · 11/03/2023 00:00

Itdoesnthavetobejusrol · 10/03/2023 23:52

I read the Bhagavad Gita many years ago and my remembering of it is that the dehin (embodied being) needs to experience every possible human condition before it transcends. This takes many lifetimes playing many different roles.

I like this theory a lot because when I'm going through extreme life events I just think it's my soul learning about the human condition. It always makes me feel better, like I'm the vessel for the experience rather than 'woe is me', 'why is this happening'.
I don't particularly believe that this is definitely what is happening but the thought of it stops me going under, helps me stay rational and reminds me that people are going through a million different scenarios simultaneously and life is up and down, ebbing and flowing, constantly in flux.

Fantastic perspective. 🥰

Swipe left for the next trending thread