Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School Refuser

168 replies

VolvicAstronaut · 10/03/2023 20:14

Hello.

First time posting, I’d very happy for any advice given.

My 12 year old has a diagnosis of anxiety and OCD

He has recently started a specialist school, at the moment he is only staying for 1-2 hours per day. He only went once this week (Tuesday) he refused to go the other days, we would never force him.

My partner, I and my other children whom are age 16 and 21 always praise him for going and sometimes come along to offer their support. We always tell him how proud we are of him, I’ve even tried to bribe him with more Lego sets, he is a huge fan of the sets but nothing seems to work.

Staff have said that he needs to start attending regularly, and from Monday he needs to start coming every single day. We fought for an EHCP, school is a well known SEN in London and we all believe once he gets settled; he will do very well academically.

He is very quiet boy, prefers to stay in his own room, He always has been. Will only speak if spoken to, prefers to spend time at home building Lego or on handheld console.

Doesn’t like to attend family events, days out and holidays; which I’m very sad about because we have no choice to leave him behind, with my mum.

He is no trouble; it’s all and it just makes me so sad that he is different from my children, and I’m constantly having to explain myself to family members and friends why he is not with me. I really wish he was like my other kids, although I love him dearly, but it’s almost as if he doesn’t fit in our family as much as we try and encourage and include him in everything.

AIBU for feeling like this?

Would it be unreasonable of me to explain that he needs to start attending school everyday? Even though I know school and even leaving the house makes him very anxious.

OP posts:
FloatingBean · 11/03/2023 19:22

Support in EHCPs is based on needs, not diagnosis, and doesn’t require DD to sit on the normal waiting lists.

@EilonwyWithRedGoldHair You cannot be compelled to organise, facilitate or deliver provision even if that means the LA have to fund someone to do so. It is far more likely to be can’t rather won’t and the provision needs amending and more support given so DS gets to place where he can. Does DS have an EHCP? If so you need an early review. If not you need to apply.

Are you claiming everything you are entitled to?

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 11/03/2023 19:18

DS started school refusing last year, June/July time. Suspected ASD, waiting for assessment, very high anxiety. Now has a place in a special unit, very hard to get him there for 30-40mins twice a week, now we're being asked to get him there 5 days a week for 1.5hrs. Don't know how to do it. Don't know how to work around it if we manage it. It all seems impossible.

He won't do schoolwork at home. DH & I need to work - the only reason we're managing is we both work from home and I have a very understanding and flexible employer. DH just fits in work as best he can with the result he earns very little.

I don't know what to do tbh. Life is a nightmare right now.

CountryParsonPetal · 11/03/2023 19:15

My DS found secondary school very traumatic and became a school avoider. Emotionally Based School Avoidance is very, very common amongst Neurodivergent children.

If you are on Facebook there are a two useful groups that will help you realise you are far from alone. I found a lot of support on Not Fine in School and Missing the Mark.

Sometimeswinning · 11/03/2023 19:15

lifeturnsonadime · 11/03/2023 18:04

And yes to the poster who asked I accessed CAMHS quickly. Yes I did. He was actually diagnosed with autism in 5 months given the severity of the mental health issues he was facing.

There are long waiting lists but if a child is in crisis they can be bi-passed.

He couldn't access formal learning for a period of time but he could and did start to access theraputic assessments and care.

Home and hospital tuition (AP was available very quickly) although my son couldn't access it due to the severity of his mental health needs.

As @FloatingBean said the law says 15 days. LAs do like to break the law, but they are legally obliged to educate when a child can't be in school.

Then you are in a minority. Im seeing children and families falling apart waiting for Cahms. Families spending thousands to have their child diagnosed privately and then paying for medication. This is where I say realistic. This does not happen for every child.

I agree our schooling system does not work. But after seeing so many school refusers I see which families can move heaven and earth (Don't work, have money) and those who have to drop them at the office door and leave (Low income, need to work) I'll be honest, its the parents who drop and run I really feel for. Halfway through the term and we're proud of how our kids spend more time in lessons than out. Maybe I should just be proud that I work at a really supportive school!

lifeturnsonadime · 11/03/2023 18:55

I mentally beat myself up about the things I used to think about her most days.

I think this is common.

I have some serious regrets that I listened to people who told me there was no other way to educate than in school and told me that he'd come to nothing if he didn't go.

But all we can do is do the best now. Society is terrible with children with autism. Schools think that if they do a social story or if they do a visual timetable they can solve the anxiety that comes with school. They just can't. The amount of pressure put on parents to push their kids when it is harming the kids is enormous. We can see it on this thread.

I really hope the EDMR works with your daughter and things slowly improve.

Flowers
JimnJoyce · 11/03/2023 18:17

my child is starting EMDR therapy for PTSD in a few weeks time. Trauma caused by years of trying to get her to school. She was recently diagnosed as autistic too. I had no idea at all she could be autistic, I have no other DC so nothing to compare to. I've been a lone parent since she was 3, ive always worked full time 45 hrs a week. No gp, nursery, carer or teacher has ever said 'could she be autistic'? Until she started refusing to go to school 18 months ago.
She could have had such a different childhood if I'd had any inkling. I mentally beat myself up about the things I used to think about her most days.

lifeturnsonadime · 11/03/2023 18:07

cornflakegeneration · 11/03/2023 18:02

I think that when you've tried for years to get your child to school and they are on a regular basis:

  • crying inconsolably to the point of vomiting
  • begging and pleading with you
  • clinging to the banister/door frame/railings
  • screaming
  • physically shaking
  • unable to speak
  • rocking in a corner
then you have to start to think that there is a problem that will NOT BE SOLVED by continuing to force them to go.

I'd rather sell my house and live in a skip than have to put my child through this again.

And I'm not the only one.

It would be great if posters could just try to listen and learn about what it's like to be in this situation.

Absolutely. .

It would be nice if people would try to listen rather than say we just didn't try hard enough.

I suspect the posters think we are all weak parents of naughty kids tbh.

Drives me nuts.

cornflakegeneration · 11/03/2023 18:06

I'll also never understand why it bothers other people so much if my child/another child is too traumatised to be at school. Why feel the need to say that a child is being indulged when you know nothing about their situation?
How does it actually affect you? It doesn't, so why bother passing comment, knowing that you are going to upset people or cause an argument? That's just being mean for the sake of it.

lifeturnsonadime · 11/03/2023 18:04

And yes to the poster who asked I accessed CAMHS quickly. Yes I did. He was actually diagnosed with autism in 5 months given the severity of the mental health issues he was facing.

There are long waiting lists but if a child is in crisis they can be bi-passed.

He couldn't access formal learning for a period of time but he could and did start to access theraputic assessments and care.

Home and hospital tuition (AP was available very quickly) although my son couldn't access it due to the severity of his mental health needs.

As @FloatingBean said the law says 15 days. LAs do like to break the law, but they are legally obliged to educate when a child can't be in school.

cornflakegeneration · 11/03/2023 18:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

I think that when you've tried for years to get your child to school and they are on a regular basis:

  • crying inconsolably to the point of vomiting
  • begging and pleading with you
  • clinging to the banister/door frame/railings
  • screaming
  • physically shaking
  • unable to speak
  • rocking in a corner
then you have to start to think that there is a problem that will NOT BE SOLVED by continuing to force them to go.

I'd rather sell my house and live in a skip than have to put my child through this again.

And I'm not the only one.

It would be great if posters could just try to listen and learn about what it's like to be in this situation.

FloatingBean · 11/03/2023 18:01

Meeting a child’s needs arising from a disability isn’t indulging them. You wouldn’t say the same about meeting the needs of someone with a physical disability.

What is madness is causing further trauma.

lifeturnsonadime · 11/03/2023 18:00

It’s madness to indulge this stuff but some households are able to and do. Some simply wouldn’t be able to

It is quite clear that you have never, happily for you, been in a position where you haven't got a choice.

I mean how do you think families on low incomes with very sick children cope, or children who have life threatening illnesses?

Sadly part of parenting involves a risk that any of these things could happen.

I think there is a fair amount of ableism going on on this thread.

CAMHS wrote a letter to say it would harm my child to be in school yet you think he should have been sent in?

Others on here have said their child's psychologists have said that sending children to school in this situation would cause the child to experience trauma.

Yet you think, despite all of this, it is a choice?

SalmonKnicks · 11/03/2023 17:53

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

FloatingBean · 11/03/2023 17:52

s.19 provision must be provided as soon as it becomes clear DC will miss 15 days, the days don’t need to have already been missed or consecutive.

Of course EHCP provision takes longer, but that’s not a reason not to pursue it.

Siblings of DC who have EOTAS via an EHCP or s.19 provision still have clothes, shoes, go on school trips, and go to extracurricular activities.

Sometimeswinning · 11/03/2023 17:42

lifeturnsonadime · 11/03/2023 16:56

Dh and I both work full time to afford our home and lifestyle. cars, bills, food etc

So you'd put your lifestyle above your child's welfare.

I see.

We had to make some life style changes to begin with. Otherwise we'd have had a dead son.

I do now work again with the EOTAS arrangement in place for my daughter.

I guess it comes down to priorities in the end.

Nothing to do with realism.

I see. You ignored every other part of that sentence and picked out one thing.

Yes my amazing lifestyle of schoolclubs, football, swimming (All for the kids mind) kids clothes, shoes, schooltrips. Sorry I didnt think anyone would assume a lifestyle would mean holidays, nightsout and takeaways! It doesnt for me and my family. They are treats.

Also when did you recieve these packages? Did you ring up Cahms/LA and they were sorted within a few days?

lifeturnsonadime · 11/03/2023 16:56

Dh and I both work full time to afford our home and lifestyle. cars, bills, food etc

So you'd put your lifestyle above your child's welfare.

I see.

We had to make some life style changes to begin with. Otherwise we'd have had a dead son.

I do now work again with the EOTAS arrangement in place for my daughter.

I guess it comes down to priorities in the end.

Nothing to do with realism.

PreparationPreparationPrep · 11/03/2023 16:55

He only feels safe at home or at my mums house.

OP could your mum attend with him if she has time. And slowly and. gradually reduce her time settling him in.

FloatingBean · 11/03/2023 16:52

No one is saying forget the needs of siblings. No one at all.

FloatingBean · 11/03/2023 16:51

Sometimeswinning · 11/03/2023 16:47

In my situation 3dc. Dh and I both work full time to afford our home and lifestyle. cars, bills, food etc. My 7yo starts refusing to go to school. What do I do? Quit my job? Forget the needs of the other 2. Let my 7yo sit in her room all day with lego and a console? I cant do that. Im not saying some parents with a different situation could facilitate it but there are many who cant.

This is why I say realist.

DC whose parents work can still have EOTAS via EHCP and s.19 provision. Parents can’t be compelled to organise, facilitate or deliver the package even if that means the LA has to fund someone to do so.

But since you mention it many parents of disabled DC do have to give up work or go part time because of their DC’s needs. That applies whether the child goes to school or not.

Sometimeswinning · 11/03/2023 16:47

FloatingBean · 11/03/2023 16:26

Forcing a child to attend school at all costs doesn’t make anyone “a realist”.

Recognising sometimes forcing a child to attend causes further trauma and isn’t the correct response doesn’t make someone not a realist.

OP Dr Naomi Fisher is a well regarded clinical psychologist specialising in SEN (in particular neurodiversity), she talks a fair bit about EBSA, forcing DC to attend and the problems with that, trauma etc.

In my situation 3dc. Dh and I both work full time to afford our home and lifestyle. cars, bills, food etc. My 7yo starts refusing to go to school. What do I do? Quit my job? Forget the needs of the other 2. Let my 7yo sit in her room all day with lego and a console? I cant do that. Im not saying some parents with a different situation could facilitate it but there are many who cant.

This is why I say realist.

Choconut · 11/03/2023 16:45

OP I don't understand how you can say he has never been assessed for autism because he's never shown any signs when your whole post literally describes an autistic person! Apart from the fact that anxiety, OCD and autism are often frequently comorbid you say:

Once he gets settled; he will do very well academically. He is very quiet boy, prefers to stay in his own room, He always has been. Will only speak if spoken to, prefers to spend time at home building Lego or on handheld console.
Doesn’t like to attend family events, days out and holidays; which I’m very sad about because we have no choice to leave him behind, with my mum.
He is no trouble; it’s all and it just makes me so sad that he is different from my children.

That is literally what an autistic 12 year old is like that would have been diagnosed with Asperger's syndrome back when that was a thing. He sounds exactly like my ds (accept he doesn't suffer with OCD or anxiety to such an extent). I can't believe no one, not even his SEN school have suggested it as a possibility.

I'm sorry I don't know what the answer is with school though.

SwankyPants · 11/03/2023 16:40

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Education is compulsary, school is optional.

FloatingBean · 11/03/2023 16:26

Forcing a child to attend school at all costs doesn’t make anyone “a realist”.

Recognising sometimes forcing a child to attend causes further trauma and isn’t the correct response doesn’t make someone not a realist.

OP Dr Naomi Fisher is a well regarded clinical psychologist specialising in SEN (in particular neurodiversity), she talks a fair bit about EBSA, forcing DC to attend and the problems with that, trauma etc.

Sometimeswinning · 11/03/2023 14:57

cornflakegeneration · 11/03/2023 13:49

@Sometimeswinning Are you a mental health professional?

Because my DS's psychologist has said that forcing him into school is traumatising and not to do it.

Nope. A realist.

cornflakegeneration · 11/03/2023 13:49

@Sometimeswinning Are you a mental health professional?

Because my DS's psychologist has said that forcing him into school is traumatising and not to do it.