Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

What stops you voting Labour? #2

105 replies

SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 10/03/2023 19:41

Just tried to post on that thread but it had run to 1k responses already, so here is a continuation one and my answer to the OP's question.

Rachel Reeves in her recent Mumsnet interview made it clear that she's not interested in dealing with the anomalies and unfairnesses in the tax system. One example given and that she was asked about in that interview was the way single parent households/ single income households lose child benefit at half of the household income. But there are many, many more such issues creating disincentives to work across the economy.

The role of Chancellor, if the country is to improve in terms of services or living standards, is more important than that of Prime Minister. And I found her response on this critical issue very poor.

Her day one job in role should be to address the things that she can fix immediately, that ARE within her power to sort out with immediate effect. Most economic reforms will take far longer to bear fruit but the tax system, as Chancellor, she would be able to sort out, if she had the will. Yet she made it clear that she has no intention to do so.

Bizarrely for someone who I had high hopes for as a potential Chancellor - as someone who for a change does actually understand economics - she appeared to be unwilling to accept or engage with, let alone address, the massively damaging effect our tax system has on families but also on productivity, at all levels of earnings. And particularly on single mothers and childhood poverty, given that most one parent households (over 90%) are headed by women, and much of child poverty is in those households. And yet she's quite happy for them to be taxed more than other households with the same income, and have child benefit withdrawn at half the income, etc.

So, despite her protestations about wanting to address productivity - which is the only way our economy can grow so that living standards rise and public services can be funded properly - I don't believe she's serious about doing it. Even if there are big infrastructure products and jobs in green energy etc as Labour claim there would be, if the tax system isn't fixed, it won't fix the problem.

The tax system needs fixing at every level of earnings:

amp.theguardian.com/business/2023/feb/13/full-time-part-time-work-no-longer-pays-uk-economy

I am hugely disappointed in her response to even the partial question on this that Mumsnet asked her in that interview in relation to child benefit. And they didn't even bother to ask her about the wider question about how she should obviously remove the disincentives at every level of the tax system: double the tax-free allowance for single people, double all the tax/ benefit thresholds for them, get rid of the absurd tax rate of 60%+ at £100k. Remove the bottlenecks that stop, at various earning thresholds, it being worthwhile for many households of any composition to work more or seek promotions etc.

The way she responded shows me she's not willing to make rational, evidence based, fair policy and is instead - depressingly - yet another politician who will pander to optics instead of doing what works and what needs to be done, for everyone.

So I can't vote for them unless their policies on this change.

OP posts:
kagerou · 10/03/2023 20:49

These threads just make me stronger in my conviction to vote for Labour

YES there are some genuine issues and things I don't agree with

But none of them seem as bad when compared to what the Conservatives have done and are continuing to do to this country

Labour have a lot of good policies to me they outweigh the bad

Over all I think they'd be an obvious improvement on what we have now and I really don't get how anyone can look at the last 10 years and think otherwise

SueVineer · 10/03/2023 20:31

I agree particularly on the single parents and child benefit issue. It would be really easy to fix this for single parents (vast majority women). It’s currently an “honesty” system that requires you to self assess if you earn more than 50k. All they need to do is change it to 100k for single mums.

But they don’t give a f*ck about women. They don’t even know what women are or they pretend they don’t. Jess Philips even sabotaged reading out a list of murdered women by adding a male. I won’t be voting for them till they fix this.

FlameGrilledSquirrel · 10/03/2023 20:21

Very much doubt any politician in opposition is going to give specific policy details at this stage of the game. Gives too much ammunition.

Very much doubt any party would double the tax-free allowance for single people and/or double all the tax/ benefit thresholds for them. It's a great idea on paper but by Christ it would get abused. Be a hell of a lot of new cohabiting but separated parents if you could save ££££ per year.

As for child benefit, does anyone know just how many households fall into the both partners earn just less than the £50k bracket? I'm hazarding a guess here but the cost of paying those households child benefit is probably a lot less than the cost of administering the means tested system.

Fully agree though that Labour need to come out with actual policies rather than the vague soundbites they are doing.

SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 10/03/2023 20:07

@winniethepoohandtiggertoo

OP posts:
SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 10/03/2023 20:06

The discussion of childcare as well that focused almost entirely around mainstream wraparound care and involved no comment whasoever on provision of funding to parents who have children with SEN and can't attend those settings was also shocking, and shows they have no proper awareness of the problems for disabled children and their families.

OP posts: