Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how big families have time for their DC?

206 replies

changethenarm · 10/03/2023 14:49

I have a DS, and a DD.

I run a tight ship. DS does 1 activity and DD does 2.

But even without that, it isn't easy to fit in 1-1 time with them, and giving them my attention equally is a juggle but doable

I love kids but having a 3rd would negatively impact the attention and time I have to meet my current childrens needs properly

How do people do it with 4+ kids?!

Seriously. How? Surely other DC must be missing out?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheBigWangTheory · 13/03/2023 12:34

namejump · 12/03/2023 19:15

@TheBigWangTheory no I got your point, you patronisingly tried to explain how a bigger family could have more time for children than a smaller family if the parents were less busy, groundbreaking stuff really, I never could have realised that without you. My point was just that we can't beat working mums with a stick, try as we might, in this thread because it's not that black and white as that either.

OBVIOUSLY the point was not to beat working mums, it was to point out that if you aren't beating working mums, why the fuck do you feel ok to beat up parents of more children? You can't have it both ways.
If you are actually so thick as to think effective parenting is just a matter of available time, you have to think that working parents are worse than non working. And since you don;t, you can't actually think that parents of 4 are automatically worse than parents of two.
So why are so many saying they are?

alanabennett · 13/03/2023 12:27

H12345 · 13/03/2023 05:35

I’m 1 of 3 and thankful to this day to come from a bigger family as we are all very close and my children are so well loved by grandparents, aunties, uncles and countless cousins.
I have 3 children and 121 time is something never overly thought about as it just happens so naturally in our household. My kids all get on well so spend time together or with husband and I whatever they want to do.
We have days out as a family or 121 time but I’m lucky as it’s all balanced out my different interest and my children aren’t bitter people thinking one got more then the other.
I find posts like this so interesting as I think it’s trying to start a war between the small families and big and everyone so judgemental.
All I will say on the matter is a LOVE the fact I’ve had 3 children and my kids will always have family around them. We have an amazing life and I wouldn’t change a moment of it.

I feel the same way. My three children wouldn't change having their siblings for all the 121 time and money in the world. I rather envy them their little "gang" 😀

I was the younger of two with quite the age gap so I didn't have the same kind of childhood. Now that we are adults, my sibling and I know we can depend on each other. It's priceless.

MrsMikeDrop · 13/03/2023 09:44

They probably don't

H12345 · 13/03/2023 05:35

I’m 1 of 3 and thankful to this day to come from a bigger family as we are all very close and my children are so well loved by grandparents, aunties, uncles and countless cousins.
I have 3 children and 121 time is something never overly thought about as it just happens so naturally in our household. My kids all get on well so spend time together or with husband and I whatever they want to do.
We have days out as a family or 121 time but I’m lucky as it’s all balanced out my different interest and my children aren’t bitter people thinking one got more then the other.
I find posts like this so interesting as I think it’s trying to start a war between the small families and big and everyone so judgemental.
All I will say on the matter is a LOVE the fact I’ve had 3 children and my kids will always have family around them. We have an amazing life and I wouldn’t change a moment of it.

namejump · 12/03/2023 19:15

@TheBigWangTheory no I got your point, you patronisingly tried to explain how a bigger family could have more time for children than a smaller family if the parents were less busy, groundbreaking stuff really, I never could have realised that without you. My point was just that we can't beat working mums with a stick, try as we might, in this thread because it's not that black and white as that either.

TheBigWangTheory · 12/03/2023 19:02

namejump · 12/03/2023 18:41

@TheBigWangTheory if you read my post again you will see I was talking about myself I did not compare myself to other 4 children families and I literally said MY circumstances, I don't have an elderly parent and I work very flexibly meaning I am home nearly all the time my kids are at home, so even if I was to not work I could not feasibly give 4 kids the same amount of time as I give 2 now (once they are all at school) because they are out the house the same time I am, because I would be dividing the time at home by 4 not 2.

My point is just that I don't think the SAHP "benefit" automatically justifies a large number of children for the bulk of a child's childhood in terms of time per child, the pre school years are a 1/3 of a childhood and they don't even remember them! So it is a point and a fair one that was made, but I don't think it has that much weight behind it, and I very much agree it is circumstantial. I haven't put hard numbers on any other family but my own.

yeah you could not have missed the point more. It was perfectly obviously a hypothetical, and you didn't understand a word of it!

FourTeaFallOut · 12/03/2023 18:41

I do think there is an upper limit to how much attention is good for you. I was the first in my family and had two sets of doting grandparents for six whole years until thankfully my db came along and then my sister in short order and unshackled me from the constant gaze of expectation.

namejump · 12/03/2023 18:41

@TheBigWangTheory if you read my post again you will see I was talking about myself I did not compare myself to other 4 children families and I literally said MY circumstances, I don't have an elderly parent and I work very flexibly meaning I am home nearly all the time my kids are at home, so even if I was to not work I could not feasibly give 4 kids the same amount of time as I give 2 now (once they are all at school) because they are out the house the same time I am, because I would be dividing the time at home by 4 not 2.

My point is just that I don't think the SAHP "benefit" automatically justifies a large number of children for the bulk of a child's childhood in terms of time per child, the pre school years are a 1/3 of a childhood and they don't even remember them! So it is a point and a fair one that was made, but I don't think it has that much weight behind it, and I very much agree it is circumstantial. I haven't put hard numbers on any other family but my own.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 12/03/2023 18:26

It's not a time divided by children equation. It's idiotic to suggest it is.

I said that earlier and got a charming message that I was “blatantly” delirious.

I’m a SAHP. DH works two weeks on two weeks off. We also have good family support.

our 6 (though 3 are at Uni now) get/got far more time than 2 I know with both parents working two jobs and little support (both parents wfh while juggling childcare as well as working out of home).

Its not about being better, we just simply have more time than they do despite four more children.

conversely my DN has a SAHP and a parent who does two-on-two-off so he gets more time than any other child I know.

TheBigWangTheory · 12/03/2023 18:19

namejump · 12/03/2023 17:51

@FatimaHatima it's a fair comment, but not as simple as that I don't think, SAHP (in my opinion at least) has most of its benefits for a short period of time pre school. I think it's the pre-teen/teen years where parents underestimate the value of parental time (be that spending time together or just needing to ferry them around!) and considering the amount of time kids spend in school I think that is manageable in a working household, but gets harder the more kids you have (and absolutely by correlation the more hours worked, can't deny that) My personal threshold for my own circumstances is 2 kids, I could see 3 being manageable if I worked a bit less, but even as a SAHP I really don't see how I could feasibly spend the time I spend with my 2 kids now if I had 4 kids, there are only so many hours outside of school (unless you homeschool like one of the PPs!)

Ok that's a swerve that completely ignores the important early years, but say I work part time and have lots and lots of free time for my 4 kids, and you work full time and look after an aging parent as well, and have 2. And you're a single parent but I have an involved spouse.

My 4 would have much much more parental time than your two would have, wouldn't they? But I would never dream of telling you that you must be neglecting your children, as so many here have blithely done to those who have more children.

It's not a time divided by children equation. It's idiotic to suggest it is.

namejump · 12/03/2023 17:51

@FatimaHatima it's a fair comment, but not as simple as that I don't think, SAHP (in my opinion at least) has most of its benefits for a short period of time pre school. I think it's the pre-teen/teen years where parents underestimate the value of parental time (be that spending time together or just needing to ferry them around!) and considering the amount of time kids spend in school I think that is manageable in a working household, but gets harder the more kids you have (and absolutely by correlation the more hours worked, can't deny that) My personal threshold for my own circumstances is 2 kids, I could see 3 being manageable if I worked a bit less, but even as a SAHP I really don't see how I could feasibly spend the time I spend with my 2 kids now if I had 4 kids, there are only so many hours outside of school (unless you homeschool like one of the PPs!)

FourTeaFallOut · 12/03/2023 17:27

FatimaHatima · 12/03/2023 17:21

I'm still waiting for someone to explain how it is that, if someone can't possibly be a good parent to four or more kids, because there isn't enough time for quality attention, how it is that SAHP aren't automatically better parents than working ones?

Because if you are adamant about one, you have to be adamant about the other. Strangely, no-one will come out and say that.

I wonder why?

Oh man, get your hard hat on.

FatimaHatima · 12/03/2023 17:21

I'm still waiting for someone to explain how it is that, if someone can't possibly be a good parent to four or more kids, because there isn't enough time for quality attention, how it is that SAHP aren't automatically better parents than working ones?

Because if you are adamant about one, you have to be adamant about the other. Strangely, no-one will come out and say that.

I wonder why?

Zippidydoda · 12/03/2023 14:38

namejump · 12/03/2023 11:05

I'm still surprised at people considering they have a large family because they have three kids and are considering a fourth! Four kids is just barely getting into "large family" category.

4 is double of 2, that's enormous to me!!

Me too. 3-4, especially spaced out it is easy to see how people manage that (though I wouldn’t ). 6/7/8+ kids is what I count as BIG families.

all relative though I suppose isn’t it. My mum was 1 of 10 and most my aunts/uncles had at least 4. Someone from a family where everyone has 2 kids probably 4 seems big.

namejump · 12/03/2023 11:05

I'm still surprised at people considering they have a large family because they have three kids and are considering a fourth! Four kids is just barely getting into "large family" category.

4 is double of 2, that's enormous to me!!

Lwrenagain · 12/03/2023 11:02

I fucking hated being an OC and my kids adore our family dynamic.

I did discuss the 1:1 kiddos get earlier but I thought I'd share my time with DP.

My favourite thing to do with my DP when my kids are in bed, (besides getting knocked up) especially summer, is set out the picnic blankets and cushions in our garden, make us a smorgasbord of our favourites, mocktail as we're not drinkers, and we just have a nice sunset.
We equally get up early and I bung us some pastries in the oven and fresh oj and coffee with sunrise. In the winter we have hot chocolate around the fire once kids are asleep.
We have partied, done gigs and festivals, eaten in some beautiful places, now we do things such as play games etc as our quality time, so we're not just binging Netflix.
I think relationships would be a bit boring if those efforts aren't made, regardless of family size.
We love cooking for each other also, so once a week one of us does something fancy, or if we're being lazy, it's a Thai and film. When kids are in school we do lunch and mooching around places like markets etc, both love a good second hand bookshop and record store.
We aren't glamorous or exciting, but we're happy.

Devoutspoken · 12/03/2023 11:01

Everything is relative, how do two full time working parents, both working long hours, have time for their kids

Coffeetree · 12/03/2023 10:56

I'm still surprised at people considering they have a large family because they have three kids and are considering a fourth! Four kids is just barely getting into "large family" category.

Coffeetree · 12/03/2023 10:51

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 12/03/2023 06:33

My kids all do, even when the ones at Uni were still at home, activities. Just as any other family.

so many random generalisations on this thread

Okay, fair enough and nice to hear! In my experience you're the exception that proves the rule.

Sceptre86 · 12/03/2023 10:14

It depends on your definition of quality time. I have 3 and would like a fourth. I work 2 days a week. Mine go to after school clubs rather than other clubs so there is no extra ferrying them about cutting into family time. They do go to swimming on a Sunday morning with their dad but it's a 30 minute walk from the house or less than 5 minutes in the car. I have their dinner cooked before I collect them from school unless it's something that you would eat straight out of the oven but even then all prep would be done beforehand. I listen to my older two read every night and read to the baby. I do 10 minutes of maths and English with both kids 3x a week sometimes more at the weekend. They have Arabic lessons twice a week for 20 minutes each and I sit with them whilst they have them. I have my chores done before they come home from school and cleaning after the evening meal is a quick wipe down of surfaces, brush the kitchen floor and using the dishwasher. Baby and I go to two groups a week and they are nearby the house. Dh does homework with one child and I do it with the other, we sometimes change it up so we both know how they are getting on. I worked a half day on Saturday then took the older two to the cinema giving my dh an afternoon with baby.

I don't micromanage every hour of my kid's days. They get bored and come up with things to do. I can start them off with an activity and they will carry on. When we spend time together I put my phone away and give them my attention.

We don't have any family support and have always worked things around each other. It helps that dh can work from home two days a week and goes in early. You have to have child friendly jobs when having multiple children unless you have great childcare or family support. Parents of multiple children also get really good at time management.

peppermintzero · 12/03/2023 09:45

If you have 2 kids, that is the perfect MN number. Literally any other number and you are fair game for criticism from somewhere.

I don't have a very large family so no personal skin in the game, but know a lot who do. One very basic factor is that it's much, much more normal for larger families to have a FT SAHP. Decades ago people would have been hand-wringing about smaller families with 2 working parents and how would they have enough time for the children. Now it's more usual to do that about larger families. As a society we just don't seem very imaginative or good at accepting people who do things differently from whatever the prevailing cultural norm of the moment happens to be.

(FWIW I grew up as one of those "ideal" 2 child households and was very lonely and frequently longed for more siblings. There is no perfect number or perfect family.)

ProposedWarning · 12/03/2023 09:39

Bloopsie · 12/03/2023 09:15

Yes they go to Beavers and cubs, horse riding, pony care days, swimming, gymnastics, make friends with other kids on holidays, etc.

They get to choose who they can socialize with and when,not forced socialization like at school/nursery setting.

Ok. You just said they don’t go to school or nursery and you all ‘hang around’ each other all day.

It sounds like my idea of hell but if it works for you, great.

Do you work btw? My separate point unrelated to the thread (not aimed just at you) is that large families are terrible for the gender pay gap. It’s usually the women who stay at home looking after large families and that’s not good in my eyes.

Bloopsie · 12/03/2023 09:25

FourFour · 12/03/2023 06:52

Maybe it's this but that I don't agree with. Having so many kids, where is the time for you? I can't think of a more miserable life to live than being spread so thin, having no time to spend with your partner or just not running yourself rugged trying to balance everything. I have 2 and that's enough for me.

Some mums dont want “my” time, i love time spent with my kids, there is plenty of time for my time when they hit teens and have other interests than hanging around with mum and dad.

Bloopsie · 12/03/2023 09:22

Bloopsie · 12/03/2023 09:15

Yes they go to Beavers and cubs, horse riding, pony care days, swimming, gymnastics, make friends with other kids on holidays, etc.

They get to choose who they can socialize with and when,not forced socialization like at school/nursery setting.

I forgot they also like to visit grabdparents who live on the same street, go to the allotment with their dad/uncle and granddad.

It is a really bizarre opinion for some reason if you are home ed family your kids are locked in the house when reality is quite opposite, we are free to do what we like when we like, if the weather is nice on monday and we think of a place to visit we go for it, if weather is rubbish we do little more educational work at home to cover for the days when we are out and get back home knackered.

Bloopsie · 12/03/2023 09:15

ProposedWarning · 12/03/2023 06:51

This sounds incredibly claustrophobic to me. I am all for one to one time but do your kids properly socialise with anyone else other than each other? Hanging round each other all day, sleeping in bed together; that’s quite unusual.

Yes they go to Beavers and cubs, horse riding, pony care days, swimming, gymnastics, make friends with other kids on holidays, etc.

They get to choose who they can socialize with and when,not forced socialization like at school/nursery setting.