Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that having a child inevitably spoils your marriage/relationship?

142 replies

ShangriLaLaLaLa · 10/03/2023 13:27

I'm in my 30s and have always been chronically on the fence about having children. Been with DH 12 years and we are very happy, lucky enough to have a lovely life, great careers, lots of holidays, meals out, etc etc.

I have come to realise that a major reason for my fence sitting has been my parents. They had a life of fun, parties etc (or so it seemed) before having me when my mum was 37. My mum threw herself into motherhood, it was her life's ambition, she was a fantastic mother. But her relationship with my dad suffered as a result and especially in my teens in hindsight it was a bit me & her vs him.

I've realised that, subconsciously, I've always felt that to have children you have to sacrifice a degree of happiness in your relationship with your partner. And - given I don't know my potential child(ren) - it's felt like an impossible decision to give up how good things are with DH in exchange for that?

I see a mix with some friends marriages suffering a fair bit after kids but some less so.

Can anyone relate or has my upbringing really coloured this for me? AIBU to think you can't have a fully happy marriage/relationship with children?

OP posts:
girlmumsince2021 · 10/03/2023 20:02

Having our daughter has made our marriage stronger and us alot closer. We obviously put DD first but we also try make time for us & our marriage. I have a friend whos marriage has ended and fell apart since having their child. Probably depends how much effort you put into each other. Marriage needs worked at alot more when kids come along. For us it's definitely made us happier😊

Yazo · 10/03/2023 19:31

Not at all, my relationship with my husband is better than ever after nearly 20 years and two kids under 10. My parents divorced too, might be worth having a bit of counselling as they're really good at helping you understand family dynamics. Having kids also helps understand societal dynamics too and how powerful they are, it makes a big difference on work and social life after kids but it's a bit different these days, for older generations it restricted women a lot more and they were trying to manage pleasing generations above i.e grandmother too.

AnotherEmma · 10/03/2023 19:27

HeadNorth · 10/03/2023 13:50

The early years are tough on your relationship, no doubt about that. But my goodness, the long term rewards. One of the wonderful things about my long marriage is the shared pride, love and care for our adult children. It has undoubtedly strengthened and added depth to our relationship.

This is lovely to read (from a parent struggling in the earlier stages!)

summerfinn · 10/03/2023 18:01

Snoopystick · 10/03/2023 13:51

I’d only been with my partner for 3 months when I got pregnant 🥴 but 18 years later and we’re still going strong. Having kids isn’t always easy of course but there is nothing better than all the firsts they have and all those incredibly proud moments you have and can share together.

Same as me except our son is only 3 😭🙈. It's tough going

Moonicorn · 10/03/2023 17:47

I think marriages fail after having kids because having kids tests the strength of the relationship but often it's because the people were mismatched in the first place.

I agree. It seems random in the couples who I know - some who had a baby quicklyish (within a few years) have stayed together, other couples together for 10+ years split. And of course the reverse. It’s all a bit ‘suck it and see’ although of course there are red flags which can give you an indicator.

Crabo · 10/03/2023 17:37

Things changed tremendously when you have children but then you have children to love. If you want to be self-centred in your relationship and going about your pleasure and your employment and whatever then that is a choice and there is nothing wrong in that but then you miss out on the dimension of parenthood with all the stresses and trials and all the joys it brings. You have to be mad to be a parent but then most of us are mad because of the rewards.

WonderingWanda · 10/03/2023 17:34

No not at all. I think marriages fail after having kids because having kids tests the strength of the relationship but often it's because the people were mismatched in the first place. It sounds like your parents wanted different things, as did my parents. I made sure my dh was on the same page before we married. Was always upfront about the kind of life I wanted and luckily he wanted the same. Having kids had made us stronger and closer and we have supported each other through the tough bits.

Roxie99 · 10/03/2023 17:24

Yeah it changes. I always say it changes your lives ...both partner and you.we have had ups and downs when they were small but they are growing and we are good. But I think our relationship was better before kids.

Spoldge45 · 10/03/2023 17:02

I think this very much depends on your support network, if you have family & friends who show an interest in your children and are happy to babysit for then you can still have date nights etc...maybe even weekends away if you are really lucky!!

My DH's & I relationship has suffered but I think that mainly because both our families had no interest in our daughter & so therefore didn't offer to babysit etc..

Our DD is now 14 so its different now & we can go out for the odd coffee, maybe even lunch, but still even now going out in the evening or for the wknd is a no/no.

It totally depends on your situation.

For the first year or so you are tired & just getting used to everything so you don't get that craving to go out as much & plus there is the fact that you don't have as much disposable income post baby to be able to go out etc...

NeedToChangeName · 10/03/2023 16:58

ItsaMetalBand · 10/03/2023 16:52

How did you feel transitioning from being a couple to being a family?

For us, brilliant. It felt like there had been a DS shaped gap in our lives that we didn't know was there until it was filled. Seeing DH as a dad I fell in love with him all over again.

Like others, our lives didn't really need much adjusting. We didn't go out much pre-kids and preferred to hang out at home, and didn't have a lot of holidays or hobbies that having a kid interfered with.

However, DH is the least selfish man I know and he was all-in from the start as an equal hands on parent with me. It never felt it was all on me. Many will tell you that you can't really know what your DH will turn out to be like as a dad but I think that often, the signs can be very subtle, but they are there.

Even if it's small things like using up all the hot water for a massive bath without checking with you, knowing that you like to have a shower every night. Or using up the last of something like the last of the milk in a big bowl of cereal when he could have easily spared enough for your morning coffee. Hogging the remote /prioritising his mates over you, leaving his shoes in the hall instead of putting them on the rack right beside it, knowing that it drives you cracked... all those things point to someone who only considers others after themselves. Some men will step up when they become a father but some wont but it's a hell of a gamble.

@ItsaMetalBand Similar for us. My relationship was happy already, and has only been enhanced further by seeing my DH as such a great father, as well as great DH

ItsaMetalBand · 10/03/2023 16:52

How did you feel transitioning from being a couple to being a family?

For us, brilliant. It felt like there had been a DS shaped gap in our lives that we didn't know was there until it was filled. Seeing DH as a dad I fell in love with him all over again.

Like others, our lives didn't really need much adjusting. We didn't go out much pre-kids and preferred to hang out at home, and didn't have a lot of holidays or hobbies that having a kid interfered with.

However, DH is the least selfish man I know and he was all-in from the start as an equal hands on parent with me. It never felt it was all on me. Many will tell you that you can't really know what your DH will turn out to be like as a dad but I think that often, the signs can be very subtle, but they are there.

Even if it's small things like using up all the hot water for a massive bath without checking with you, knowing that you like to have a shower every night. Or using up the last of something like the last of the milk in a big bowl of cereal when he could have easily spared enough for your morning coffee. Hogging the remote /prioritising his mates over you, leaving his shoes in the hall instead of putting them on the rack right beside it, knowing that it drives you cracked... all those things point to someone who only considers others after themselves. Some men will step up when they become a father but some wont but it's a hell of a gamble.

Sleepless1096 · 10/03/2023 16:48

If you share the load, you'll have tough times but you'll grow together.

Unfortunately, many men don't. They cast themselves in the role of grown-up manchild and expect their partner to do everything and "mother" them too. Unsurprisingly, these relationships struggle.

It's difficult to predict what your OH will be like tbh. Many unbalanced relationships are fairly equal until children come along.

mydogisthebest · 10/03/2023 15:50

Me and DH chose not to have children and one of the reasons (there were a few) was that we were very happy and didn't want that to change.

Before we married a friend's mum said to us "if you want to stay as happy as you are now don't have children" and I couldn't really get that out of my mind.

Most of our friends who have children are divorced and most of them say their marriage broke down when they had children/because they had children.

BertieBotts · 10/03/2023 15:38

I think if you're a team with your OH and you both have desire for children, rather than it being led by one person only, you're OK with there being a change in the pace of life for several years and you approach it as a joint venture then it can be great and bring your relationship to new highs.

Where I've seen it place more of a strain on relationships is when one partner (commonly the man) kind of checks out and doesn't see it as their resposibility, or is willing for it only to have minimal effects on their life. Raising children is rewarding but exhausting, so if you genuinely support each other and hold each other up you can delight in the rewards and not completely burn out, but if it's just you who is shouldering 90% of the work it causes resentment on both sides. The parent who is fully in ends up resentful because of how much work it is, and the parent who isn't fully in ends up resentful because their partner doesn't have time/energy/brainspace for what they used to.

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/03/2023 15:34

It's hard to avoid the fact that you will have less sex, less romance, less adventure and be able to go out a lot less after you have children. That's the case for almost all couples, unless you are multi-millionaires.

Depending on what your DH is like, having kids may or may not also trigger the dormant lazy misogynist gene which for a lot of men only really comes out when their partners have children. It's surprisingly common for men to be basically fine until they have children and then to decide they can't be arsed with any of it and expect the wife to do it all and get resentful that their "needs are not being met". Only you know how likely it is that your DH will turn into one of those men. It's not always necessarily possible to tell from their pre-child persona either and you seem to have a good relationship now but that isn't a guarantee.

That's the key swing factor really. If your DH is a decent bloke and prepared to share the load and the relationship is otherwise strong it will be tough for a few years but you will come through it. If not, not so much.

lazycats · 10/03/2023 15:31

*wasted 20 years!

FGS Mumsnet it's 2023, get an edit button.

lazycats · 10/03/2023 15:30

"If I'm still the same man at 50 I was at 30, I've wated 20 years" - Mohammad Ali.

Whether you have kids or not, you'll change anyway as you get older. It's a compromise either way.

Echobelly · 10/03/2023 15:26

I think in inevitably changes it, but doesn't spoil it. I don't feel it did with DH and I - and not because our relationship is perfect or was before kids, it's different but not worse and probably better ultimately, I think it's given us a lot to learn together. But - caveat - we have been lucky to have not had kids who have (so far at 11 and 14 now) given us any profound challenges so far, which is not to say there haven't been some difficult things to deal with. But nothing relationship challenging, let's put it that way.

If you have a relationship based on spontaneity and loads of passionate sex then, yes, kids will probably spoil it.

Or if one or both of you thrive on routine and me-time but you end up with babies/small children that just don't sleep and have high needs, that would be enough to do in a lot of relationships.

It helps a lot to be on the same page before you embark on a family - I'm glad DH and I went on a course for soon-to-be-parents recommended by a friend that was about setting expectations and thinking about how you'll manage.

Toffeeappler · 10/03/2023 15:25

Having kids and all the work that entails was definitely one of the stress points that contributed to the end of my marriage. I love them and wouldn’t be without them but, yeah, it’s undeniable for me.

Chimna · 10/03/2023 15:22

I think it can be hard if you don't have any support to spend time as a couple. But you make it work and they're not little forever.

With regards to another person in your house seeming wierd, by the time they find a voice and seem like an actual person they're already part of the furniture!

thecatsthecats · 10/03/2023 15:17

It can also depend on what sort of lifestyle you have before you have kids.

We have a very sedate lifestyle as it is. There aren't big nights out to give up. Our hobbies are both home based, and our excursions are kid friendly too.

It must naturally be harder if your free time involves wine bars and playing football with your mates in the week.

saraclara · 10/03/2023 15:17

I can only speak for myself of course, but I think having kids brought us even closer. Our shared love for them and enjoyment of them was an extra connection that we had. He loved me even more for the mother I was, and I loved him even more for the way he was with our children. I know it sounds a bit soppy, but hey...

But we were on the same page. My DH was a hands on parent, he shared the housework and child work, and was around, unlike my friends whose partners had big jobs with long hours and business trips, or others I knew whose partners just didn't see themselves as equally responsible for their children.

So basically, it depends.

WalkingThroughTreacle · 10/03/2023 15:08

Life obviously changes significantly when you have kids. How your marriage adapts to that change, and whether it's for the better or worse, depends very much on the father IME. If your DH is the sort of man who buys into the mentality that the day his first child is born is the end of him being the centre of his own universe then you should be fine. If he is the sort of man who puts himself and his own wants first then you might well grow to resent him and rightfully so.

ShangriLaLaLaLa · 10/03/2023 15:07

Reading everyone's experiences and views is really helpful thank you

OP posts:
ShangriLaLaLaLa · 10/03/2023 15:07

Moonicorn · 10/03/2023 14:18

If everything is so great as it is why are you contemplating kids at all?

Great question!

I guess most people of child-bearing age consider if they want kids or not at some point.

But why start this thread with this question - it was actually a comment I read on another thread by someone saying the best bit of advice they'd had before having kids with someone was "consider if you'd want them if you were on your own" (ie, the guy leaves you). And I had a realisation that, if I was single, I probably would want kids, as naive as that must sound as being a single mum is clearly hard AF. But with DH if feel like I have to weigh up happy relationship vs child. And therefore I lean more towards no, because that feels like a lot to give up.

Interesting the PP who said it's another person in your home - that's another thought I've had, I suppose it doesn’t feel strange when it's your own DC. But having someone else present all the time in your home which you previously only shared the two of you feels....strange?

How did you feel transitioning from being a couple to being a family?

OP posts: