Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that having a child inevitably spoils your marriage/relationship?

142 replies

ShangriLaLaLaLa · 10/03/2023 13:27

I'm in my 30s and have always been chronically on the fence about having children. Been with DH 12 years and we are very happy, lucky enough to have a lovely life, great careers, lots of holidays, meals out, etc etc.

I have come to realise that a major reason for my fence sitting has been my parents. They had a life of fun, parties etc (or so it seemed) before having me when my mum was 37. My mum threw herself into motherhood, it was her life's ambition, she was a fantastic mother. But her relationship with my dad suffered as a result and especially in my teens in hindsight it was a bit me & her vs him.

I've realised that, subconsciously, I've always felt that to have children you have to sacrifice a degree of happiness in your relationship with your partner. And - given I don't know my potential child(ren) - it's felt like an impossible decision to give up how good things are with DH in exchange for that?

I see a mix with some friends marriages suffering a fair bit after kids but some less so.

Can anyone relate or has my upbringing really coloured this for me? AIBU to think you can't have a fully happy marriage/relationship with children?

OP posts:
AviMav · 11/03/2023 18:45

mightymam · 10/03/2023 14:05

YANBU. Our marriage is a tiny percent of what it was previously. Some marriages just don't survive children sadly.

I think its not the children ultimately though because the tough stages whatever that may have been for you weening, sleepless nights or the teen stages many people make it work.

Children are not the problem per say and there is no guarantee you will remain with that person even if you are both childless. It's all a risk.

AviMav · 11/03/2023 18:41

lazycats · 10/03/2023 15:30

"If I'm still the same man at 50 I was at 30, I've wated 20 years" - Mohammad Ali.

Whether you have kids or not, you'll change anyway as you get older. It's a compromise either way.

Excellent saying.

AviMav · 11/03/2023 18:33

Obviously there's some truth to what you are saying but there's so many factors OP. Do you not see any positives?

journeyofsanity · 11/03/2023 18:25

I think it's pretty weird to assume having kids would have a negative effect on ALL couples. Just very very egocentric thinking there OP. One thing successful parenting does do is help one develop an understanding that your experience is not the same as everyone else's.

PlantPotato · 11/03/2023 18:11

But I think if you have 1 child, no SEN, and family support, it won't change your lifestyle/the demands in your time that much once the early years are over. So it depends.

PlantPotato · 11/03/2023 18:10

It's relentless having kids, especially if you don't have much family support and they have SEN. I wouldn't say our relationship is worse for it, overall we have just as good a connection, probably even deeper, but we barely get any time together anymore. When we do it tends to be right at the end of the day when we are exhausted.

TMess · 11/03/2023 18:09

Not for me. I’m pregnant with our fifth and I think our relationship has become better and stronger with each one. He is such a good dad and partner. We have a lot of mutual appreciation for the work each puts in and he’s still my best friend. I know that sounds maudlin but it’s the facts.

Changeforachange · 11/03/2023 17:24

YABU - of course you can be happy having kids, BUT not everyone will be. Some people have been very honest on MN threads saying they regret becoming a parent.

Anyone chronically on the fence about having children - IMO, should not have children.

Parenting should be something you really, really, wholeheartedly want to do.

Noodles1234 · 11/03/2023 17:05

I do see where you’re coming from, and I think it’s a very good viewpoint some could / should consider also.

I couldn’t wait to not be out every weekend, to sit on the sofa contently having a cool glass of wine with DH while they slept upstairs. I will admit it’s not always like this, sometimes we have friends over or we are too tired and chill out (or go out and have a babysitter over).

it is what you make it, I wouldn’t want to be who I was before, and I love every minute even if I’m inside for the tenth weekend seeing them grow, develop, laugh, learn something new, find their own opinions and hopefully turn out to be decent people.

bridgetreilly · 11/03/2023 16:09

Children always change things, but not necessarily for the worse.

Mew2 · 11/03/2023 15:57

Again we have grown closer since having DD
However we had been through the rough before she came into the world- seeing your other half in ITU for a couple of weeks brings the little things into perspective
We also have both sets of parents who have been married for 30 plus years each with 3 kids and all that it brings- giving us advice.
Our DD is a toddler- so we take half days off work when she is in nursery to prioritise us, have date evenings at home weekly and every other month she has a night away. All of this helps to keep us grounded. If we are starting to bicker we realise we haven't spent enough time prioritising connecting with each other and go back to basics.... we also keep accountable with other couples going through similar which helps massively. But seeing DH interacting, and DD loving her dad so much makes it all worth it

XelaM · 11/03/2023 15:57

Manthide · 11/03/2023 12:34

So do mine after 60 years of marriage. They have a great time together and my dad in particular has always been an amazing dad. His gc call him super grandad and his ggs adores him. At 81 he is still very much hands on. Dm always said she had children for him, not that she was/is a bad mum but she feels she missed out on a career because of having children.

Awww so lovely to hear! Maybe having kids with good men is the secret trick to a happy post-kids relationship. 😃 My dad sounds very similar to yours. He's great fun, but also the epitome of a family man who would literally do anything for my mum and his kids/grandkids. My mum is also great, but less maternal than my dad. 😂

Nothing is any trouble for him when it comes to his family. From small things like pop out to the shop any time of night if my mum said she fancied a snack to big things like the time ai called him up (from UK) to cry to him that my husband was an arse and he immediately got in his car and drove (from Germany) to help me and my daughter leave him. He's truly amazing 🤩

Mondayblues23 · 11/03/2023 15:15

I think it can certainly test your relationship. For us it was the chronic sleep deprivation. It kind of takes over for a while and you don't feel like the same person (well for us). We were snappy, tired, irritable.

But on the flip side, seeing my DH being an amazing dad is so attractive and makes me love him so much

We now have a little someone we both adore and can have adventures with too so that makes the relationship strong I think.

Mummyof4Ireland · 11/03/2023 15:11

Its a personal journey and not everyone will have the same experiences!! Having children is hard work. As babies unless everything is done 50/50 you will be resentful that your shouldering most of the responsibility after just getting them earthside all by yourself too. As toddlers you will more than likely have different parenting styles which can lead to friction. Pre teens and early teenage years is the same. Unless on the same page there will be problems. With all that being said you will look at your husband as he holds your baby, reads your toddler a story or does something nice for your preteen and your heart will soar. You will remember exactly what you fell in love with them even if they are an arse who leaves all the shitty stuff to you deal with lol Ultimately I think very few people regret having a family in the end

Manthide · 11/03/2023 13:01

Aquamarine1029 · 10/03/2023 14:07

If having children ruins your marriage, it's because there were already significant cracks, even if you didn't realise it. Many things/behaviours are very, very easy to overlook/push aside until children are in the mix.

So true! I used to revolve around dh and his needs without really realising it. We lived in his country and in the beginning I didn't speak the language. When we had dc he just carried on as before!

threepeat · 11/03/2023 12:38

For me things eased significantly after the kids were at school.

Manthide · 11/03/2023 12:34

XelaM · 10/03/2023 14:04

My parents still have a great marriage 45 years on and me and my brother (now adults) haven't wrecked it 🤷‍♀️ They love each other's company and love spending time together. They've always been best friends and on the same wave length. But my dad is the nicest man you can possibly meet and really great company and he totally adores my mum.

So do mine after 60 years of marriage. They have a great time together and my dad in particular has always been an amazing dad. His gc call him super grandad and his ggs adores him. At 81 he is still very much hands on. Dm always said she had children for him, not that she was/is a bad mum but she feels she missed out on a career because of having children.

Runningoncoffeealone · 11/03/2023 12:33

I've experienced both sides.
With my ex, having a child together changed us a lot. Neither of us coped with lack of sleep at first, we argued daily, we stopped going on dates, stopped putting effort in etc. We were miserable for years and I admit, I often thought back to our child free life and wondered if we made the wrong choice.
We divorced, and I met someone lovely. We both have children from previous relationships and have made the decision to have one together as we absolutely love family life. One day a week is focused on the kids primarily and another day is focused on us as a couple. We make sure to check in with each other about how we feel, things we want to do, anything we stress about and this works really well for us. Even on bad days when the kids are really testing us and every little thing goes wrong, we tag team, work together, give each other breaks etc. And on the days when we're both not coping well, we cry together and then laugh about it together after.
So from my experience, it depends on who you have a family with.

moonpixel · 11/03/2023 11:30

Children changed our lives but they certainly didn't ruin the marriage or in fact any part of the relationship.

threepeat · 11/03/2023 11:27

It's definitely testing. If it spoils it really comes down to the couple.

CornishGem1975 · 11/03/2023 11:26

Would our marriage be happier and content without children, 100 per cent, but we made the decision to have children so now we have to suck it up!

Kittycat37uk · 11/03/2023 11:17

I think we need to stop making ppl who don't want kids feel selfish as sometimes I think if I didn't have kids I'd have more money and me and my partner could be doing more fun things like holidays days out etc and ppl that want all this they are not selfish by not wanting kids and giving up their fun lifestyles. Wouldn't ppl rather kids be born to ppl who actually want them?

Stompythedinosaur · 11/03/2023 11:13

Having kids definitely puts pressure on your relationship. My experience was that dp and I discovered that we can stick together and treat each other well even when things are very hard, so it brought us closer together.

JudgeRudy · 10/03/2023 20:15

Silly as this sounds I think it might be useful to share some AIBU posts with your OH as a kind of discussion starter. There are so many 'family' related issues where each person believes they're reasonable....and oftenwhenno ones unreasonable but the views don't align.
Eg if your OH wanted to go the gym 3 eves a week would that be OK. If yes do you get 3 nights? Seem fair right? But what if you feel he should want to spend weekends with you and kids...so Saturday life admin,Sunday visit to woods/beach. When do you go football? Do you think parents should ferry the kids back and forth to 'activities' or do you think cubs once a week is fine. So many unknown variables.
I do think if you're on the fence it's a no.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 10/03/2023 20:10

For me, it absolutely would be ruinous for any relationship, and it's one of the reasons why I've always known I would never have children. I go into a relationship with one other individual. I have no desire to start adding 3rd and 4th parties to it because it so drastically alters the dynamic that it entirely ceases to be the relationship I consented to.

I also think this is a largely unacknowledged reason why so many marriages and long-term relationships break down. One party absolutely desperately wants kids, the other is ambivalent but acquiesces in order to keep their partner sweet, the one desperate for kids then can't fathom why the other isn't particularly interested in parenting or loses interest entirely in their relationship, and of course, the one who is left feeling they are into something they never really wanted cops the 'blame'. People should be more honest and strident about saying no to partners who want kids. That would undoubtedly destroy relationships in itself, but at least that would be at a point before there are kids on the scene.