Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cannot lose weight. AIBU to not know where I’m going wrong?

135 replies

Firehouse1 · 10/03/2023 09:43

For the last two weeks I’ve eaten less than 1200 calories (tracked in my fitness pal). Food is weighed or in defined portions.

typical day:
-breakfast: low fat yogurt or cereal bar
-lunch: ryvita and extra light Philly x4 and a piece of fruit/yogurt
-dinner: ham salad or a weight watchers ready meal or pasta/veg/chopped tomatoes or steamed cod/broccoli and rice or salmon/mixed green salad/rice

no snacks/a banana if I feel really hungry/one square of chocolate a few times which I added to my food tracker

zero alcohol and no fizzy drinks. I’ve just been a couple of teas and water. I’m pretty bad at drinking water though and it’s one area I’m working on.

exercise; I’ve just hired a personal trainer so just getting started with that. Only find a few sessions. I also cycle. At the weekend I walked over 10k steps each day.

I’ve lost a grand total of 1.5lb. Honestly I’ve had more weight loss after a poo 🤣

what the hell? What am I doing wrong? Too much carbs? Not enough protein?

Im 39 and hate that I just cannot get out of the obese category. I’m very short and weigh 78kg.

OP posts:
Karcher · 10/03/2023 10:59

@maddening I also have PCOS so was insulin resistant. I went through crazy cravings when I ate my old way, often eating an entire sharing size chocolate bar, then followed by a bag of crisps because I then craved something salty. This was just in the drive home from the supermarket or in front of the TV after dinner. Confused

The sugar and carbs for me were the issue. I followed the calories and protein recommendations from that calculator, but then ensured by carbs did not go over 20g and I made the rest up with fats from the sources I mentioned previously. I was very skeptical at first, but honestly I've never felt better and it definitely worked Smile

Reclining · 10/03/2023 10:59

YABU to expect results in 2 weeks when you've not even started working out yet. If you have that mindset you'll give up.

Vegetablesupreme · 10/03/2023 10:55

I'm another who agrees that it takes time for your body to lose the weight and for it to register on the scales. It's the same gaining. I can binge eat crap for a couple of weeks yet stay the same weight and then suddenly I get on the scales and I'm half a stone heavier!
I think if you gave yourself 2 more weeks of eating how you are you would definitely get that whoosh of half a stone gone.
I do though agree that your meal plan sounds a little boring/strict and could mean you throw in the towel quite soon. Calories from protein are important as they keep you fuller for longer and help maintain your muscle plus I read somewhere (it may or may not be true) that your body burns a third of it during digestion processes so a third of protein calories are not absorbed by the body apparently!

BIWI · 10/03/2023 10:53

I'd really recommend that you read this book, which explains why calorie counting doesn't work.

I also agree with PP that your diet is way too heavy in carbs. And, don't expect exercise to result in weight loss - unless you're doing A LOT of it, every day. Your diet is much more important.

Karcher · 10/03/2023 10:53

I should also say that it is important to revisit the macro calculator every time you lose 5lbs to get an updated calorie count and macros based on your new weight. Otherwise if you lose weight and continue eating the initial number of calories you calculated for your original weight you won't lose any more weight because you'll essentially be over eating.

To put things into perspective, I basically started out eating on the same calories and macros I just shared with you for yourself. Since I have lost such a significant amount of weight my calories and macros needed to MAINTAIN my current weight of 52.6kg are 1521cals and 79g protein. If I wanted to continue to LOSE weight (I do not) at my current weight then my calories would be 1293 and 79g protein.

So currently you are under eating causing your body to hold onto the fat storage because it's essentially in 'starvation' mode. You're eating less calories than I am and I'm pretty small now.

Also your body is trained to burn carbohydrates for energy which cause insulin spikes and once they go back down you're hungry again. With keto your body will learn how to burn its own fat storage for energy and you will have no cravings anymore. Seriously Smile

smooththecat · 10/03/2023 10:53

“-breakfast: low fat yogurt or cereal bar
-lunch: ryvita and extra light Philly x4 and a piece of fruit/yogurt
-dinner: ham salad or a weight watchers ready meal or pasta/veg/chopped tomatoes or steamed cod/broccoli and rice or salmon/mixed green salad/rice”

Get rid of cereal bars, they are v. high in sugar. Replace low fat yoghurts with regular 10% fat plain Greek yoghurt. Ditch ready meals unless an emergency. Dial down pasta and rice and up the protein and veg. 1200 is v. v. low unless you are totally inactive.

Firehouse1 · 10/03/2023 10:51

That’s great @AutisticLegoLover just gotta keep going and be patient.

it feels different this time because being nearly 40 has scared me. My mates are started to get sick and it got me thinking… do I really want diabetes or a stroke?! Because of my lifestyle?!

I am doing this for different reasons this time. Nothing to do with looks/slimming into a wedding dress/slimming for a holiday but more to do with health.

at the end of the day, I’m OBESE. And that is an issue health wise.

OP posts:
EnthENd · 10/03/2023 10:50

Weight naturally fluctuates by plus or minus 2 pounds or so. So two weeks isn't enough to get any proof a diet is "not working".

maddening · 10/03/2023 10:49

Karcher · 10/03/2023 10:16

Your diet isn't the greatest OP. It's very carb heavy and you're not getting enough protein. What weight are you currently? 1200 cals likely isn't enough unless you're quite short.

As a PP mentioned, keto / very low carb will get you results. I have lost (in less than a year) and kept off (for 2+ years) 3.5st with ZERO exercise thanks to Keto. Do keep in mind that as with any 'diet', once you stop doing it and revert back to old eating habits the weight will come back. After all, it's the old eating habits that got you there in the first place.

If you really want to lose weight and choose Keto, you'll need to go all in and embrace it as a lifestyle change and not a diet.

I based my macros and calorie intake on the James Smith macro calculator here: www.jamessmithacademy.com/macro-calculator/

Then tracked everything in my fitness pal making sure my carbs did not exceed 20g per day and my protein intake made up roughly 40% of my calories (I think?). I don't track anymore and just eat what I want because I know what to consume in order to stick within a keto diet now. But I'm eating things like chicken, fish, pork, eggs and beef, and other sources high protein with every meal, along with full fat dairy (cheese, full fat cream, butter, etc), green veg, cauliflower and fresh berries.

It's all delicious and keeps me very satisfied. I'm never hungry (carbs cause hunger!).

But in short, your diet is the issue here, not your activity levels.

Interesting but the calculator says I should be eating 1944 cals a day with 143g of protein- I would balloon on that - over 1200 calories i put weight on - so will it be my health issues (pcos and hashimoto) do you think that mean that this doesn't look right for me?

Firehouse1 · 10/03/2023 10:48

Well here’s a wake up call… so I looked at MFP and my tracker and my daily average is as follows
54g of protein
150g of carbs

OP posts:
AutisticLegoLover · 10/03/2023 10:47

I'm 46 so older than you and also had 3 children.

AutisticLegoLover · 10/03/2023 10:46

@Firehouse1 come over to the LOSE IT thread. I've dropped 10.5lbs in 2 months eating 1600-1700 calories. I'm 5'3" too and weight 58.2kg. My goal is 55kg. I was 68kg last summer. I walk a lot. 50 miles so far this week. I eat normal food. Greek yogurt, berries, chia seeds, porridge, pasta, chips, homemade veggie soup, homemade veggie lasagne and homemade chips done in the air fryer. Normal food, smaller portions, everything tracked on my fitness pal and keep moving.

Firehouse1 · 10/03/2023 10:45

Thanks all! It’s 100% my crap diet. Just need to try to find some interesting ways to eat protein now.

Ive always been very drawn to carbs (obviously) but I realise that isn’t the best.

OP posts:
Hydrangeatea · 10/03/2023 10:41

Karcher · 10/03/2023 10:40

@Firehouse1

I input your stats into the calculator I mentioned and according to that you should be consuming 1772cals with at least 117g protein. Limiting carbs to 20g and making up the rest of your macros with fats (from all sources including nuts, avocado, olive oil, coconut oil, and full fat dairy such as butter, cheese, double cream, as well as your meat / protein sources).

This right here!

I lost 3 stone on 1800-1900 calories a day with 2-3 hours of movement a day.

RiceOnABike · 10/03/2023 10:41

I'm struggling too, OP. I calorie counted the same as you for 6 weeks and lost nothing. I then started Slimming World, and 6 weeks in I've lost 7lbs. So it is moving now, but just feels so slow! People who started after me have lost far more, some can lose 7lbs in the first 2 weeks. It's so disheartening! I am happy with SW though, can eat loads and seems to be working better than restricting myself and feeling miserable all the time.

Hydrangeatea · 10/03/2023 10:41

TheSoapyFrog · 10/03/2023 10:32

Have you figured out your BMR which tells you how many calories you need per day based on height, weight, and how active you are? 1200 calories might not be enough, and this can prevent you from losing weight.

1200 calories won't prevent you from losing weight, that theory has been blown out of the water many times. Starvation mode does not exist.

But 1200 calories will be unsustainable in the long term, will leave you feeling unfulfilled and you are likely to cave at some point and then over eat or binge.

Karcher · 10/03/2023 10:40

@Firehouse1

I input your stats into the calculator I mentioned and according to that you should be consuming 1772cals with at least 117g protein. Limiting carbs to 20g and making up the rest of your macros with fats (from all sources including nuts, avocado, olive oil, coconut oil, and full fat dairy such as butter, cheese, double cream, as well as your meat / protein sources).

Cannot lose weight. AIBU to not know where I’m going wrong?
PandasAreUseless · 10/03/2023 10:40

I don't know anything about dieting, but I do know about being slim. And there's a lot of processed and/or unsatisfying junk in your diet.

Low fat yogurt, cereal bars, ryvita, extra light Philly, ham (if it's the crap kind) and weight watchers ready meals all fall into this category.

I would switch to full fat yoghurt and full fat cream cheese and cut out the junk. Good fats and protein are much better for you, and so much more satisfying so you need less of them and they keep you full for longer.

To me your current diet screams "faddy dieter who's going to go off the rails in....3, 2, 1".

Firehouse1 · 10/03/2023 10:40

@TheSoapyFrog

i just worked out my BMR using an online calculator. 1495 was the answer.

OP posts:
Hydrangeatea · 10/03/2023 10:38

IT JUST TAKES TIME

People expect weight loss to be immediate but sometimes you just have to be patient. My body loses fat every 10-14 days.

1200 calories sounds far too low to be sustainable long term and you are likely to cave and give up on that amount.

Be patient, up your calories to a reasonable amount - probably your BMR number would be good and try to get a couple of hours of movement each day and be patient.

ArseMenagerie · 10/03/2023 10:37

Firehouse1 · 10/03/2023 10:34

@humpty74 i had a recent blood test and all seemed good. I have no other symptoms.

Im probably just perimenopausal. That won’t be helping me right now. Most women in my family start around 40. I’m due on and feel a little bloated this week.

im going to share my food diary with my PT this week yikes! I think he will say the same about carbs.

so on my shopping list this week I have:
protein yogurts
more vegetables (broccoli/cauliflower/carrots/green beans/spinach)
ham
chicken/turkey
beans/pulses
fish (tinned tuna and fresh fish)
more salad items(rocket/lettuce/tomato/spring onion/cucumber)

Sounds brilliant I think.
Maybe lose the ham but otherwise I reckon you’ll feel better with more nutrients and still lose weight - good luck! Perimenopause is a bitch x

wasacasa · 10/03/2023 10:35

You have lost weight just keep going.

AuntieStella · 10/03/2023 10:35

fruitstick · 10/03/2023 09:45

I am no expert (ah the irony) but when I have tried to lose weight in the past I found I lost nothing for the first few weeks. Then there was a drop. Almost like the fat was clinging on for dear life.

I would say you need a little less carb and a bit more fat and protein though. Full fat yoghurt is great and still healthy.

I agree with this!

When I was going through my big weight loss about 7 years ago, I was on a MN thread where we talked about the "whoosh" and the "lag" and it was a common phenomenon.

So you'd be eating in a way that meant you should be seeing a nice steady pattern of losses, but noting happens. That's the lag. Then bizarrely, out of nowhere, and on same eating pattern, you'd get a week when 4-5lbs just vanish. That's the whoosh.

Bodies are funny things - they're not like internal combustion engines that use fuel in a predictable way, yes it's about fuel in v fuel used, but it's more complex than a machine and there's much more variety in rates for a whole host of reasons.

They key part is sticking with it. Even in the really boring bits when nothing seems to be happening and target seems to be miles away.

Firehouse1 · 10/03/2023 10:34

@humpty74 i had a recent blood test and all seemed good. I have no other symptoms.

Im probably just perimenopausal. That won’t be helping me right now. Most women in my family start around 40. I’m due on and feel a little bloated this week.

im going to share my food diary with my PT this week yikes! I think he will say the same about carbs.

so on my shopping list this week I have:
protein yogurts
more vegetables (broccoli/cauliflower/carrots/green beans/spinach)
ham
chicken/turkey
beans/pulses
fish (tinned tuna and fresh fish)
more salad items(rocket/lettuce/tomato/spring onion/cucumber)

OP posts:
fishonabicycle · 10/03/2023 10:34

If you are new to exercise a very common thing is that your muscles will hold onto water to repair themselves for a bit. This gives a temporary bit of extra weight. Just keep on and you will get results.