Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cannot lose weight. AIBU to not know where I’m going wrong?

135 replies

Firehouse1 · 10/03/2023 09:43

For the last two weeks I’ve eaten less than 1200 calories (tracked in my fitness pal). Food is weighed or in defined portions.

typical day:
-breakfast: low fat yogurt or cereal bar
-lunch: ryvita and extra light Philly x4 and a piece of fruit/yogurt
-dinner: ham salad or a weight watchers ready meal or pasta/veg/chopped tomatoes or steamed cod/broccoli and rice or salmon/mixed green salad/rice

no snacks/a banana if I feel really hungry/one square of chocolate a few times which I added to my food tracker

zero alcohol and no fizzy drinks. I’ve just been a couple of teas and water. I’m pretty bad at drinking water though and it’s one area I’m working on.

exercise; I’ve just hired a personal trainer so just getting started with that. Only find a few sessions. I also cycle. At the weekend I walked over 10k steps each day.

I’ve lost a grand total of 1.5lb. Honestly I’ve had more weight loss after a poo 🤣

what the hell? What am I doing wrong? Too much carbs? Not enough protein?

Im 39 and hate that I just cannot get out of the obese category. I’m very short and weigh 78kg.

OP posts:
Corah5 · 10/03/2023 12:34

Exercise makes you fit. It does not help you lose weight. When you exercise your body compensates by reducing its energy expenditure in other ways. I have always had much more success by dieting and not exercising.

Oakorn · 10/03/2023 12:31

Read the first five words of your post.

Now, watch shows like Biggest Loser and see how many plateau or even gain in the second week. You can increase the water held in your muscles by up to 10lb when you start to exercise, reducing your food volume intake can slow your digestion so more food sits inside you for longer… there are many reasons. It’s temporary. You’ll still be losing fat even if you’re not losing weight and, when your body adjusts to the change, the weight will fall off.

MaireadMcSweeney · 10/03/2023 12:29

You HAVE lost weight
how much did you expect to lose in 2 weeks?

BIWI · 10/03/2023 12:27

vix3rd · 10/03/2023 11:09

A nutritionist that my husband works with wrote this diet down for him.

I think you're not eating enough.

JFC that's a terrible diet. All that processed stuff! How on earth do nutritionists get away with that?

thisplaceisweird · 10/03/2023 12:27

Give it time. Your body doesn't WANT to lose weight (for survival reasons) and makes it hard, mentally and physically. Stick with it, but make it more achievable if you need to. It'll take months to start seeing real progress.

Dinopawus · 10/03/2023 12:22

vix3rd · 10/03/2023 11:09

A nutritionist that my husband works with wrote this diet down for him.

I think you're not eating enough.

There's quite a lot of processed food there. Cheese strings, jar of chilli sauce, low fat yogurts, crisps...

That looks like an out of date low fat diet and the evidence is now that it is sugar that should be avoided and not fat.

And while I wouldn't wish to cast aspersions on your DH's well meaning colleague, I'm also mindful that not everyone who calls themself a nutritionist is qualified.

TheHouseNextDoor · 10/03/2023 12:17

I'm in my 40's. Changed my eating habits in the new year. I don't weigh myself so don't know how much I've lost but I've gone from an 18 to a 14.

I don't typically eat breakfast but have breakfast at lunch time. Berries, yogart and nuts.
Dinner is meat and salad or meat and veg. I will occasionally eat some chocolate.

I don't exercise at all (disabled).

Dinopawus · 10/03/2023 12:14

I'm old, short and have a desk job.

With light exercise my maintenance calories are around 1650 a day. To lose weight at a pound a week I would need to exist on1150 calories for the duration.

As this didn't appeal, I have taken a slow and steady approach instead. I aim for around 1400 calories and try to do some exercise every day so that I have a deficit of around 300 calories a day. A year on and I'm 8 (nearly 9) kilos down.

It's not an approach that will give me a beach body in 6 weeks, but for me it's working and more importantly its sustainable. I'm not constantly hungry or missing out on anything. Instead I'm doing the boring things; making healthy choices, avoiding processed food, eating lots of vegetables with meals, fewer carbs and not much sugar at all. I've had to be patient and realistic about progress - but honestly it's working well for me.

AutisticLegoLover · 10/03/2023 12:01

I eat mainly carbs. I'm losing weight steadily. I've upped my protein but I'm only having around 64g a day. According to the British Heart Foundation the average woman needs 45g per day or 0.75g per kg of body weight. So I'd need 42.65g per day. I'm obsessed with 0% fat Greek yogurt and berries and that's where most of my protein comes from along with chia seeds and berries. Lots of weight loss enthusiasts seem obsessed with low carbs, high fat and high protein. Balance is more important for sustained lifestyle changes. I suspect those on high fat diets will end up with high cholesterol and heart disease later in life.

rookiemere · 10/03/2023 12:00

I have had success in losing a reasonable amount over the past 6 weeks by doing a modified keto. I've basically cut out all bread, potatoes etc and sugar including fruit.

In the mornings I have a couple of scrambled eggs with smoked salmon, or if I'm going into work I'll make up a pot with full fat greek yoghurt, some protein powder ( chocolate flavoured) chia seeds and a bit of peanut butter or almond butter.

Lunch is usually chicken based and dinner is whatever the family is having minus the carbs. Tesco do cauliflower rice that is a reasonable substitute for rice.

I have allowed myself a few treats - Aldi do a chocolate protein mousse that is HUGE and has 20g of protein and only 150 calories, also there are billionaire flavoured Bounce bars that are around 170 cals but have 10g protein.

If I go out I just have say battered fish with salad and peas instead of chips.

I'm finding it reasonably easy to stick to because it's clear what I can and can't eat. I have been eating a few too many nuts and cheese recently, so I'll need to pull back on that, but actually I've found with eating so much protein I rarely get ravenously hungry these days.

VapeVamp12 · 10/03/2023 11:56

I've recently for the first time in my life, lost weight without really dieting - well, I don't feel like I'm dieting.

I was quite unwell for a few weeks last summer which saw me not eating properly. It completely changed my relationship with food and now I only eat when I am properly hungry. I've lost 1 stone 4 pounds since christmas and about 3 stone since last summer.

Some days I actually won't eat anything (other than a bit of coffee and water) until about 2pm because that is when I get hungry. Also not adhering to Breakfast Lunch and Dinner because thats what we have always done. I don't eat dinner 2-3 times a week now. Usually when I've had a bigger meal earlier in the day.

Hydrangeatea · 10/03/2023 11:51

Firehouse1 · 10/03/2023 10:45

Thanks all! It’s 100% my crap diet. Just need to try to find some interesting ways to eat protein now.

Ive always been very drawn to carbs (obviously) but I realise that isn’t the best.

Not 100% true actually.

Whilst eating good nutritious food is better for you and getting a good amount of protein will help you feel full and satisfied, you can still have carbs and lose weight. Not ideal to eat sugary white processed carbs but if you fancy a slice of cake now and then have it. The key to long term weight loss and keeping it off is not to restrict yourself too much, it shouldn't be a chore or something you can only tolerate short term otherwise you will just yo yo.

I had whatever I wanted when I lost my 3 stone, cake, icecream, chocolate, crisps you name it. What I didn't have is any alcohol, that was the only restriction I put on myself because it seemed such wasted calories, but other than that I had what I wanted.

I soon realised that for 1800 calories a day I would feel pretty crap and hungry if I just ate crap so I did have good quality food, protein, veggies, salad etc but if I wanted to swap an omelette for a cream egg one day I did!

Don't make it too hard, don't cut too many calories or too many food groups, keep it sustainable and you will stick at it longer term.

DoulaBriaAI · 10/03/2023 11:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ThatsNiceVeryNice · 10/03/2023 11:33

You HAVE lost weight, just slowly. I'd carry on but try and up your protein. When I need to loose weight I only loose a pound a week and aim for a bit over 1200 calories. Slow and steady is good.

People hate 'processed crap' but I think you can use ready meals effectively if you are dieting. Choose the better healthy eating type ones. They can be high in protein and it's easy to have everything portioned out for you.

What about a slim fast shake for breakfast. Make sure they are cold. There is a good amount of protein in them.

Cocolatte24 · 10/03/2023 11:33

Firehouse1 · 10/03/2023 09:43

For the last two weeks I’ve eaten less than 1200 calories (tracked in my fitness pal). Food is weighed or in defined portions.

typical day:
-breakfast: low fat yogurt or cereal bar
-lunch: ryvita and extra light Philly x4 and a piece of fruit/yogurt
-dinner: ham salad or a weight watchers ready meal or pasta/veg/chopped tomatoes or steamed cod/broccoli and rice or salmon/mixed green salad/rice

no snacks/a banana if I feel really hungry/one square of chocolate a few times which I added to my food tracker

zero alcohol and no fizzy drinks. I’ve just been a couple of teas and water. I’m pretty bad at drinking water though and it’s one area I’m working on.

exercise; I’ve just hired a personal trainer so just getting started with that. Only find a few sessions. I also cycle. At the weekend I walked over 10k steps each day.

I’ve lost a grand total of 1.5lb. Honestly I’ve had more weight loss after a poo 🤣

what the hell? What am I doing wrong? Too much carbs? Not enough protein?

Im 39 and hate that I just cannot get out of the obese category. I’m very short and weigh 78kg.

Do this for a few months continuously, not weeks, and then come back to us. Nothing happens overnight

Jellifulfruit · 10/03/2023 11:29

Dacadactyl · 10/03/2023 09:46

Id eat some more protein in your shoes. I also think you may need to up your calorie intake somewhat, less than 1200 calories is too few in my opinion. I think that should be more minimum. Good luck.

Yeah 1200 cals seems too low, especially when exercising/doing 10k steps a day. Your body needs fuel. You might be having too little calories and your body clinging onto it and storing it straight as fat as it’s not getting enough

Baystard · 10/03/2023 11:27

Firehouse1 · 10/03/2023 10:48

Well here’s a wake up call… so I looked at MFP and my tracker and my daily average is as follows
54g of protein
150g of carbs

If you are trying to reduce your carbs and increase protein you should look at foods like full fat greek yogurt, cheese, meat, fish (especially oily fish like salmon, tuna, mackerel) and cut out processed carbs and most fruit (which nowadays is very sugary). Est as many different types of veg as you can. If your carbs come from vegetables (excluding potatoes) then you get fibre and vitamins/minerals. Fat is good for us too and the uptake of some vitamins is better if you have fat with them, adding olive oil or butter to veg is a good idea.

My dinner tonight will be pork chops with vegetable & feta traybake (tomato, pepper, onion, courgette, aubergine, broccoli, chopped black olives and chunks of feta chopped, doused in olive oil and roasted for 45 mins).

Justalittlebitduckling · 10/03/2023 11:17

Firehouse1 · 10/03/2023 09:57

Thanks all.

will carry on and up the protein and up the water. Less processed crap too.

I think k I need to up my daily activity. It’s tough as I’m desk based and is a struggle to get even 10k steps.

Maybe a big hike or a swim at the weekend, if the weather clears up?

Harp1977 · 10/03/2023 11:11

You are an inch taller then I am but the same weight I was when I started a diet. I am working with a trained nutritionist. I am consistently losing as is my husband.
I don't really calorie count but do count protein 75 gm a day .
I drink 2 litres of water (or green tea/peppermint or fruit tea)

Yesterday I had
A glass of warm water
A cup of herbal tea
400ml protein smoothie (very early start and tend to make bad choices so it works for me)

Snack
Poached egg
Slice of soda bread

Lunch
Homemade chicken and veg soup

Snack
3 corncakes
2 tablespoons hummus

Dinner
1/2 plate mix veg and salad
Salmon fillet
Lemon and mint Couscous

Snack
Smoked turkey slice
Slice Cheese

I avoid tea and coffee as I know I would reach for the nice stuff then.

I buy the flavoured rice cakes and have them with a dip as it makes it more interesting and stops me reaching for crisps.
Keep interesting snacks handy low cal high protein. Baby bel/ individual wrapped cheese are easy to throw in a hand bag. Nuts are good even an apple and some cheese which is my go to on the go snack.
I got an American style 40 oz stainless steel cup and I drink my tea/water from that as it stays warm and I keep topping it up.
So far in 4 weeks I have lost 1 stone. I don't feel hungry but a warning ⚠️⚠️⚠️ I spent the first week running to the loo all day 🤣

I also try to eat every 3 hrs at the moment so I don't get hungry.
Good luck it is not an easy journey but you will get there

MoggyMittens23 · 10/03/2023 11:09

If this is mainly about your health then your diet needs changing as some PP have said.

Switch to wholemeal bread, rice and pasta if you can. Have walnuts and good quality dark chocolate as a snack if you fancy something sweet. berries, yoghurt, mixed seeds and manuka honey is a good breakfast, or peanut butter on wholemeal with a banana on top.
Lunch - soba or wholewheat noodles with stir fry veg, or maybe a quick dahl type dish. or even chickpeas, tuna and sweetcorn mixed up as a last minute nothing-in type meal! Try to pad meals out with good grains, lentils, pearl barley etc. Dinner, maybe salmon or chicken, sweet potato and veg (white sweet potato is delicious) or turkey sausage casserole (tinned tomatoes, beans, onion, garlic, whatever veg you have in, stock)

You must be hungry and miserable from what you are eating, it doesn't sound very fulfilling. Maybe forget the calories for now and focus on putting into your body some really good nutritious things, you deserve it! Keep up the working out but feed your body what it needs too

vix3rd · 10/03/2023 11:09

A nutritionist that my husband works with wrote this diet down for him.

I think you're not eating enough.

Cannot lose weight. AIBU to not know where I’m going wrong?
Cannot lose weight. AIBU to not know where I’m going wrong?
Karcher · 10/03/2023 11:08

swedex · 10/03/2023 11:04

Fasting try to stop eating at 7pm don't eat until the very earliest 7am the next morning

More protein

Cut out the sugar and reduce the processed foods including bread and the low fat spreads if it's got more than 3 ingredients and you wouldn't be able to recreate it in the kitchen from scratch then don't eat it!

I definitely agree with this. I adhered to these rules as well. 👍

swedex · 10/03/2023 11:04

Fasting try to stop eating at 7pm don't eat until the very earliest 7am the next morning

More protein

Cut out the sugar and reduce the processed foods including bread and the low fat spreads if it's got more than 3 ingredients and you wouldn't be able to recreate it in the kitchen from scratch then don't eat it!

Dixiechickonhols · 10/03/2023 11:04

Agree your protein is far too low. Have more Chicken/fish/tuna. I also like babybel light or eat lean cheese as a snack.

trusttheprocess23 · 10/03/2023 11:01

Hi OP,

My initial thought is that you need to adapt a new lifestyle, find something that's sustainable. 1200 kcal a day is not sustainable. It's too little in my opinion. And, as others have said, increase the protein intake.

I'm a similar weight as you, but tallish (5'9). I'm a size 10-12. I'm almost 53yo and do weights 3 times a week (with help from a PT) and a cardio based sport (in a club). I changed my lifestyle a little bit over 18 months ago and it is a slow process - but it works. Whilst I'm not really loosing much weight now, I'm changing my body composition and shape and that's what I want. What do you want?

I eat at least 100g protein every day but generally around 140-150g (my goal). I'm on 1800kcal a day at the moment but plan to increase it.

Also, BMI in itself (I assume that is what you're looking at) doesn't tell you the whole picture. Your body fat % is also important.

Sustainable weightloss doesn't happen overnight, but if you make the right adjustments and don't give up, change will happen.

Good luck!

Swipe left for the next trending thread