Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cannot lose weight. AIBU to not know where I’m going wrong?

135 replies

Firehouse1 · 10/03/2023 09:43

For the last two weeks I’ve eaten less than 1200 calories (tracked in my fitness pal). Food is weighed or in defined portions.

typical day:
-breakfast: low fat yogurt or cereal bar
-lunch: ryvita and extra light Philly x4 and a piece of fruit/yogurt
-dinner: ham salad or a weight watchers ready meal or pasta/veg/chopped tomatoes or steamed cod/broccoli and rice or salmon/mixed green salad/rice

no snacks/a banana if I feel really hungry/one square of chocolate a few times which I added to my food tracker

zero alcohol and no fizzy drinks. I’ve just been a couple of teas and water. I’m pretty bad at drinking water though and it’s one area I’m working on.

exercise; I’ve just hired a personal trainer so just getting started with that. Only find a few sessions. I also cycle. At the weekend I walked over 10k steps each day.

I’ve lost a grand total of 1.5lb. Honestly I’ve had more weight loss after a poo 🤣

what the hell? What am I doing wrong? Too much carbs? Not enough protein?

Im 39 and hate that I just cannot get out of the obese category. I’m very short and weigh 78kg.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hydrangeatea · 13/03/2023 12:43

That's great - pretty much what I said in my first post then about giving it time.

You just need to be patient, stick to it and allow your body to give up the fat when it is ready. Weight loss not linear and no-one elses body will behave as yours does.

Firehouse1 · 13/03/2023 08:19

Ok I thought I’d come back to update. Jumped on scales today and I’m 76.2kg which I believe has put me in the 11 stone bracket. And I’m one day before period when I’m typically at my heaviest and eat the most crap. It’s going in right direction!

I’ve upped my protein and swapped my usual yogurt for Greek yogurt and fruit in morning.

OP posts:
YerAWizardHarry01 · 12/03/2023 07:32

open.spotify.com/episode/3ctZOPNNEz5wEDP8SsBJW8?si=sqmWUBILTp-_nxRZzANgxA&app_destination=copy-link

This podcast is unreal, body fat is very different to body weight

Catspyjamas17 · 12/03/2023 06:03

TurnipSurprise · 11/03/2023 16:53

@Catspyjamas17 I am short and fairly light, If I don't move all day I wouldn't even burn 1200 sadly.

Yes, but the poster giving the example was 5'8". What @Hydrangeatea said.

Hydrangeatea · 11/03/2023 17:40

Anotherparkingthread · 10/03/2023 20:36

I'm 5ft 8 and if I don't exercise 1200 calories is maintenance for me. Im just over 9 stone. So you don't have to be tiny to not burn many calories.

People massively over estimate what they need to eat.

When I first started dieting it took 4 weeks before I shifted a single lb. Cutting alcohol really really helped. I then stopped drinking anything except black coffee and herbal tea without sugar. I find I don't stay full unless I eat high fibre foods. White carbs like bread and pasta aren't great for you at all if you eat those.

You will lose weight if you stick at it, it's just much slower than most people expect.

There is no BMR calculator out there that correlates 5'8" and 9 stone with a daily calorie level of 1200 at TDEE or even BMR.

BMR is Base Metabolic Rate which is literally your body surviving, it would be like you sitting on the sofa or lying in bed all day. Even at 60 years old a 5'8" 9 stone female would need 1,226 to 1356 calories just to lie in bed all day (different amounts for different calculators) which I guess you don't? TDEE would usually take you up to needing about 1500 to 1700 calories a day so think this "theory" is probably wrong. TDEE is general daily movement i.e. washing, walking around the house, housework, eating etc and doesn't include for additional exercise calories.

GerronBuzanDoThaWomwok · 11/03/2023 17:07

Portion size? Try eating off a smaller side plate, more protein and veg, less fat and dairy.

TurnipSurprise · 11/03/2023 16:53

@Catspyjamas17 I am short and fairly light, If I don't move all day I wouldn't even burn 1200 sadly.

Catspyjamas17 · 11/03/2023 07:08

Anotherparkingthread · 10/03/2023 20:36

I'm 5ft 8 and if I don't exercise 1200 calories is maintenance for me. Im just over 9 stone. So you don't have to be tiny to not burn many calories.

People massively over estimate what they need to eat.

When I first started dieting it took 4 weeks before I shifted a single lb. Cutting alcohol really really helped. I then stopped drinking anything except black coffee and herbal tea without sugar. I find I don't stay full unless I eat high fibre foods. White carbs like bread and pasta aren't great for you at all if you eat those.

You will lose weight if you stick at it, it's just much slower than most people expect.

I'd rather be overweight than survive on 1200 calories a day for the rest of my life. I burn up 2500 calories most days, most of us would burn 1500 at least even if we didn't move all day.

lljkk · 10/03/2023 21:34

ok, so 1.5 lbs is 3500 + 1700 calorie deficit. 5200 over 14 days, or ~300kcal/day.

If OP needs 1500 to maintain & is eating 1200/day, that difference is 300/day.

So that's close to exactly right, isn't it?

JudgeRudy · 10/03/2023 21:15

MrsJBaptiste · 10/03/2023 19:56

Exercise makes you fit. It does not help you lose weight

Well it definitely helps me lose weight. I WFH and barely burn 1500 calories on non gym days but at least 500 more when I've been running & spinning (luckily I can go 4-5 times week)

It's definitely calories in V calories out for me so I try and stick to 1500 a day and only eat between 12-8pm. It's still a slow process as I'm not in my 30s anymore but it's keeps me in check 👍

I think what you're saying is you can't outrun a bad diet. If youre overweight I'd say at least 75% of weight loss will be through taking in less calories and a relatively small amount through increased activity. The benefits of being activie though impact so much on our physical health and psychological wellbeing that I'd always recommend a 2 pronged approach

JudgeRudy · 10/03/2023 21:10

Have you considered that actually by reducing your calorie intake you have mostly stopped yourself getting fatter. Let's say in the last 2 or 3 years you've put on almost a stone a year, that's just over a 1lb a month. Now you're not doing that and you're actually loosing weight. 1.5 lbs per fortnight . In a year you will have lost the 2.5/3 stone.
You need to be realistic and start considering a change of mindset. You said you were quite short. It might be that 1200 is close to your maintenance load, so the amount of calories you need to not gain or loose weight. As your weight decreases you might plateau. You're going to find more inventive meals than that. A lifestyle change needs to last a lifetime.
Great you're thinking about exercing too. Don't get too worked up on what ghe scales say. You may well loose fat but gain muscle.

TurnipSurprise · 10/03/2023 21:09

You have had lots of great advice around foods but I wanted to point our two things, the first has already been mentioned, when you start new exercise your body retains water to protect the muscles.

The second thing is that weight fluctuates through your cycle. I can gain 5lbs the week before my period.

Keep being consistent and the results will follow. 1lb a week is good progress and sustainable.

You do need to eat more than you currently are. Protein is important but I disagree with sitting out carbs. You find a diet that you can stick to whatever it may be but the key is consistency.

Ontobetterthings · 10/03/2023 20:44

Intermittent fasting works a treat

Anotherparkingthread · 10/03/2023 20:36

I'm 5ft 8 and if I don't exercise 1200 calories is maintenance for me. Im just over 9 stone. So you don't have to be tiny to not burn many calories.

People massively over estimate what they need to eat.

When I first started dieting it took 4 weeks before I shifted a single lb. Cutting alcohol really really helped. I then stopped drinking anything except black coffee and herbal tea without sugar. I find I don't stay full unless I eat high fibre foods. White carbs like bread and pasta aren't great for you at all if you eat those.

You will lose weight if you stick at it, it's just much slower than most people expect.

roseslovewater · 10/03/2023 20:36

exercise raises your metabolism so even after you stop you'll be burning more calories the rest of the day. it's definitely worth incorporating!

FrangipaniBlue · 10/03/2023 20:28

Cycling is incredibly efficient.... at using very little energy. I really wouldn't count that as exercise

Eh????

BIWI · 10/03/2023 20:00

Well it definitely helps me lose weight. I WFH and barely burn 1500 calories on non gym days but at least 500 more when I've been running & spinning (luckily I can go 4-5 times week)

Yes, because you're using a lot of calories when you're doing that amount of exercise if you can go that often.

For most people, they don't go that often, and they don't do exercise which is so intensive!

MrsJBaptiste · 10/03/2023 19:56

Exercise makes you fit. It does not help you lose weight

Well it definitely helps me lose weight. I WFH and barely burn 1500 calories on non gym days but at least 500 more when I've been running & spinning (luckily I can go 4-5 times week)

It's definitely calories in V calories out for me so I try and stick to 1500 a day and only eat between 12-8pm. It's still a slow process as I'm not in my 30s anymore but it's keeps me in check 👍

PrinceYakimov · 10/03/2023 19:26

Weight loss sometimes plateaus for no obvious reason - or it can be linked to where you are in your monthly cycle. I find that it takes a couple of weeks to get going. But you're not doing badly at all.

That said I think you probably need to be more active - 10,000 steps is not very much if you are only doing it at the weekend (to be considered 'lightly active' you need to do the equivalent of 5000-7500 steps a day).

As others have said, you may find it more sustainable to up your activity if you increase the amount you eat. I've done the constant low calorie thing, and I just got too tired to exercise. Doing 5:2, where you eat your maintenance calories on 5 days and 500-800 calories on the other 2 days, allows you to incorporate more exercise into the week. It might not mean you lose any more quickly, but it's less miserable and you can get fitter at the same time.

And yes to increasing protein and fats.

Hydrangeatea · 10/03/2023 18:39

Firehouse1 · 10/03/2023 13:15

@FrostyFifi

im a person that has all the gear and no idea! I have a peloton so I’m doing that 1x weekly at moment (30 minutes cycle)

I am meeting with trainer to do weights (squats, rows, arm exercises with the weights etc.) press-ups. We finish with a bit of cardio - boxing. Total time is 1 hour.

then one day a week I’m recreating the PT session on my own. Strength and a bit of cardio.

so 3 x a week of concentrated exercise

When I was actively losing weight I would Peloton 5-7 times a week. Are you a member of UK Ladies Peloton on Facebook.

Dinopawus · 10/03/2023 17:48

PelicanWings · 10/03/2023 16:58

I'm 47, 5ft5 and weigh 10 stone. I was 11 stone 3 months ago and lost it by having one day a week where I only ate about 600 calories. That's it.
I ate whatever I wanted the other days, drank alcohol. I.also don't do any exercise, like at all. Never have. If I stop the 600 calorie day then I.maintain. my weight. Honestly, you can work out all you want but it's about calories. Also, as a pp said, starvation mode is a myth. If you reduce calories, you'll lose weight, its that simple.

That's an interesting approach - I seem to remember reading / hearing something about how limiting calories for a short period then eating sensibly can help to reset your metabolic set point. I'd imagine its more sustainable and less miserable doing it that way.

PelicanWings · 10/03/2023 16:58

I'm 47, 5ft5 and weigh 10 stone. I was 11 stone 3 months ago and lost it by having one day a week where I only ate about 600 calories. That's it.
I ate whatever I wanted the other days, drank alcohol. I.also don't do any exercise, like at all. Never have. If I stop the 600 calorie day then I.maintain. my weight. Honestly, you can work out all you want but it's about calories. Also, as a pp said, starvation mode is a myth. If you reduce calories, you'll lose weight, its that simple.

roseslovewater · 10/03/2023 16:45

try to leave longer before you have breakfast, it will give your body a chance to burn more fat. Even cut down to eating twice a day (late lunch / dinner). Stop with the snacks - they raise your blood sugar cutting out your fat loss ability. If you drink tea drink it black (same with coffee). The milk in tea or coffee again raises blood sugar. It will give you a better chance of weight loss.

Beneficialchampion2 · 10/03/2023 16:42

1.5 pounds is real to a calorie deficit of 5100 calories.

Your diet is fine, so is your exercise. 1.5lb a week is pretty sustainable.

Keep plugging away, nothing is wrong.

Magnoliafarm · 10/03/2023 16:27

I actually think this is a really decent weight loss in only 2 weeks! A bag of sugar weighs a pound, go pick one up and feel how heavy that is, it's hefty! Well done! Do the maths and see how much weight you will lose in 6 months or 1 year at this rate, it might surprise you. And think about how long it took to gain the weight in the first place, it was probably slower than that

Swipe left for the next trending thread