Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be a SAHP to pre-schoolers if you were financially independent?

267 replies

Kitchenette · 10/03/2023 08:20

Not super-rich but say you had enough capital to pay yourself an income for life equal to your full time earnings.

I’m always interested in SAHP threads on here and the various very reasonable objections people raise to it- that you’re making yourself vulnerable financially while also putting too great a strain on the paid working partner. But say we took money out of it- would you prefer to stay at home or go to work? For the purposes of the poll it’s a binary choice (of course IRL the best answer for many of us would be to work PT).

YABU- I would prefer to be in paid employment
YANBU- I would prefer to be a SAHP

Me- I’ve had periods of SAHM, FT and PT work since my children were born. Binary choice with pre-school children and no money worries-I’d be at home, no question.

OP posts:
FlyingCherries · 10/03/2023 11:34

I basically was a SAHM (did some freelance work when they were asleep) when they were toddlers and younger and I’d do it again, definitely. It is hard work and I think they benefit from a bit of childcare once they’re about 2, but I wouldn’t have wanted to miss out on those years. They were full of joy. Now my youngest has started school, I’m not sure if I would just stay at home if I could. It’s nice to have the mental stimulation of work and I don’t like housework. I work part-time, which is a good compromise at this age I think.

Dacadactyl · 10/03/2023 11:30

To add...none of my friends or relatives have ever been a FT SAHM.

Dacadactyl · 10/03/2023 11:29

KievsOutTheOven · 10/03/2023 11:00

I don’t know - I did actually start training as a vet so similar type of career; and I knew even before that I wanted kids. I kind of feel most (or at least many) people know by that age if they want kids or not. I met my partner at 21 when I was still at uni and pretty early on I knew I wanted kids with him, even though we didn’t have kids for quite a while after that.

I think the belief in gender based roles probably starts in childhood, to be honest, as I find people who were brought up in families with less traditional roles are less likely to bring their own families up traditionally. My dad was very hands on for his generation (and is still a really hands-on papa to my own kids) and my mum worked more hours than he did. So to me, it’s not particularly unusual that my male partner is the primary parent and works part time.

Only 2 out of 4 of my generation actually have kids, and we are all in our 30s. My daughter swears she won’t ever have kids, and I believe her. She wants to be a scientist.

I 100% agree that I am a product of my environment, my mum was a SAHM and so was my MIL. My dad was hands on though and he was the one who took us to our extracurricular after school.

I remember my nan (also a SAHM) telling me she suggested she go back to work in the 1960s and my grandad was mortally offended by it.

If i hadnt been brought up the way i was, I may well be off working for NASA now 😂It's a weird one really, but I do agree with you.

I'm 37 and all my uni friends have kids now (most had then late 20s, early 30s). I had my first straight after graduating at 21. Most of my (similar age) cousins have kids now too. My DHs similar age cousins are about half and half kids/no kids.

Fifi0000 · 10/03/2023 11:27

It depends on the career mine you can dive in and out. Some you cannot without taking a substantial hit. I think there's always a chance of divorce and the courts favour clean breaks so spousal maintenance is very unlikely. I would never be a SAHM for a long time you are basically gambling that your DH won't leave you. If independently wealthy that's fine if you are depending on DHs money don't do it.

AliceTheeCamel · 10/03/2023 11:26

No way could I be a SAHP. Not sure what I expected before having DC, but it turns out I hate baking/craft/playgrounds/role play/soft play etc. Happy to outsource that to people who are trained in it. I love my DC to pieces and we have so much fun at evenings and weekends, it takes the pressure off knowing they are with other children doing activities the support their development in the daytime.

minipie · 10/03/2023 11:26

I’d choose work. As long as it was an interesting job, and wasn’t such long hours that I hardly saw my DC. 9-5 3 days a week would be ideal. Unfortunately such jobs are rare in my field.

dinkydragon · 10/03/2023 11:25

Yes I chose being a sahm anyway regardless of finances. They're only little once and I went back ft initially and hardly saw my dc. I decided to take a short break from work even though I was massively career focussed and it's only when I stayed at home I realised what I was missing out on. I know it's not for everyone but I thought working was for me until I actually stayed at home long enough to adjust to being a sahm.
And I loved it so much. Unfortunately I'm now working pt but I'd love to go back to being a sahm.
I also found it really nice to support homework and having a daily chit chat to and from school with dc just lovely. I get that's not for everyone but I've noticed the dc at my dc school who have sahp definitely are ahead in their school work whether or not that's just a coincidence I'm not sure but I don't think so. As for what would you do I loved meeting up with other sahp I joined a golf club, volunteered. Ahhh sigh!!

Cherrysherbet · 10/03/2023 11:22

Mine are older now, but I was a SAHM.

I chose to stay home with them.
I would 100%. Make the same choice if I had my time over.

Donnashair · 10/03/2023 11:22

Or my kids are older (one is an adult) I would say no.

I would however, take time out when they were in their teens instead.

Scottishskifun · 10/03/2023 11:19

Not a chance!
My children thrive in nursery settings and the eldest since 2 has formed strong friendships. They both do more things in 1 day at nursery then I could manage in a week at home! Our nursery is 50% minimum outdoors (based on the Scandinavian model and we are north east Scotland so its all year all weather) and they both love it. DS1 spent most of the day on Tuesday outside in the snow at -1 (they can freely go in and out).

I also enjoy having a piece of my life which is for me and I worked my arse off to build my career. I have a colleague who recently came back to work after 5 years off and she admits herself it's a huge uphill battle as she is behind on systems, developments and legislation.

riotlady · 10/03/2023 11:03

I’d work part time, or at least have DC in nursery for a few sessions and do a really engaging volunteer role. I’m not cut out to be with small children 24/7, lockdown showed me that! And once they’re toddlers/pre-school age it’s good for them to have the variety and social interaction of nursery.

KievsOutTheOven · 10/03/2023 11:00

Dacadactyl · 10/03/2023 10:45

Yes, perhaps. Although I think very few 18 year old women going off to med school, or 25 yo women coming out the other side of it, are necessarily thinking about children yet.

Like another poster says "different strokes for different folks" and all that.

I don’t know - I did actually start training as a vet so similar type of career; and I knew even before that I wanted kids. I kind of feel most (or at least many) people know by that age if they want kids or not. I met my partner at 21 when I was still at uni and pretty early on I knew I wanted kids with him, even though we didn’t have kids for quite a while after that.

I think the belief in gender based roles probably starts in childhood, to be honest, as I find people who were brought up in families with less traditional roles are less likely to bring their own families up traditionally. My dad was very hands on for his generation (and is still a really hands-on papa to my own kids) and my mum worked more hours than he did. So to me, it’s not particularly unusual that my male partner is the primary parent and works part time.

Only 2 out of 4 of my generation actually have kids, and we are all in our 30s. My daughter swears she won’t ever have kids, and I believe her. She wants to be a scientist.

Dacadactyl · 10/03/2023 10:45

KievsOutTheOven · 10/03/2023 10:37

But presumably someone who believes in “traditional roles” based on gender wouldn’t study to PhD/surgeon level to then become a SAHP, given that it would take so long (and cost so much) to train to that level that most women would only afford a relatively short career before biological time would be ticking so to speak.

I don’t think many female surgeons who plan on having children believe in gender based roles, so it’s probably irrelevant.

I’ve always been pretty career driven (not to surgeon level but I do have a “professional” job) and always knew I wanted kids but not to rely on full-time nursery, so finding a partner who was willing and able to take at least some of the career sacrifice was important to me.

Yes, perhaps. Although I think very few 18 year old women going off to med school, or 25 yo women coming out the other side of it, are necessarily thinking about children yet.

Like another poster says "different strokes for different folks" and all that.

Thinkbiglittleone · 10/03/2023 10:43

YADNBU, Yes, I stayed a home with our DS. It was priceless to us.
But different strokes for different folks.

KievsOutTheOven · 10/03/2023 10:37

Dacadactyl · 10/03/2023 10:22

Yeah I know, but that wouldn't be for me either. Primarily because I don't think he'd do as good a job as me at it!

Aside from this, I do have quite a "traditional role mindset". Although if the options were DC in a nursery/childminder or with DH, I'd go with DH every time.

But presumably someone who believes in “traditional roles” based on gender wouldn’t study to PhD/surgeon level to then become a SAHP, given that it would take so long (and cost so much) to train to that level that most women would only afford a relatively short career before biological time would be ticking so to speak.

I don’t think many female surgeons who plan on having children believe in gender based roles, so it’s probably irrelevant.

I’ve always been pretty career driven (not to surgeon level but I do have a “professional” job) and always knew I wanted kids but not to rely on full-time nursery, so finding a partner who was willing and able to take at least some of the career sacrifice was important to me.

Ragwort · 10/03/2023 10:24

I was a SAHM for 12 years - not exactly financially 'independent' but no financial worries, I had a great lifestyle .. lots of hobbies, volunteering etc. For much of that time my DS (an only DC) was at nursery/school so I had plenty of time to myself and was never bored.
But don't underestimate the long term effect on your career ... it was very difficult to get back into the career I had, certainly nowhere near the salary level I was at years ago. I am working (part time by choice) in an industry I love but earning barely more than NMW whereas I was fortunate enough to earn a good salary, company car, associated perks etc before.
I am well aware that my comfortable lifestyle relies on the financial contribution my DH has made ... Blush and if we separated I would not be in a strong position. Looking back, it's not a decision I would recommend.

Dacadactyl · 10/03/2023 10:22

KievsOutTheOven · 10/03/2023 10:10

There is always the option to have your partner at home; particularly if you are a high earner yourself. Or both to work part time, rather than one parent giving up their career completely.

Yeah I know, but that wouldn't be for me either. Primarily because I don't think he'd do as good a job as me at it!

Aside from this, I do have quite a "traditional role mindset". Although if the options were DC in a nursery/childminder or with DH, I'd go with DH every time.

lazycats · 10/03/2023 10:16

I mean, sure, I suppose so? Most people don't enjoy their jobs enough to do them beyond necessary income.

Appleblum · 10/03/2023 10:13

I am a sahm. Used to send my kids to nursery for 2 or 3 half days a week when they were around 2.5 years old. I think it was a good balance, they got to spend lots of time with me and also enjoyed their time at nursery.

Twizbe · 10/03/2023 10:13

@SockQueen sorry but I just have to say this. SAHPs are capable of using their brains as well.

I love history and am an avid reader of non fiction books.

I volunteer and gained a qualification through that volunteering.

Just because I'm not working it doesn't mean I have no interests or pursuits outside of my children.

KievsOutTheOven · 10/03/2023 10:10

Dacadactyl · 10/03/2023 09:57

I'd be a SAHM because I think that's what's best for the kids until they are of school age.

I was a SAHM for many years and wasn't financially independent when I did it. I looked at it as being my FT job and poured my absolute heart and soul into it.

I do think there is some truth to what another poster said about careers....if id got a PhD or was a brain surgeon, it would've been a more difficult decision to give up work. But I actually wonder whether motherhood would've been for me in those circumstances, because I know I wouldn't have wanted anyone else looking after the kids. So, if I didn't feel able to give up my job, then I'm not sure id have had kids IYSWIM.

There is always the option to have your partner at home; particularly if you are a high earner yourself. Or both to work part time, rather than one parent giving up their career completely.

pawsandponies · 10/03/2023 10:09

I have some passive earnings probably not quite a full time wage especially in the area I live. I am a SAHM although I do use a nursery two days a week.

I would work part time if I could find something that would work well for me and my family, but at the moment it works well that I am on hand as my husband runs a business and his hours can vary.

I think it would be really hard if you didn't ever get a break though, and my husband is very very hands on.

SavBlancTonight · 10/03/2023 10:01

Neither. If I had no financial worries and young children, I guess I would technically be a SAHM, but I absolutely would still have childcare in place. I have never had any desire to spend 24/7 looking after my children.

Now that my children are at school, if money allowed, I'd quite happily be a SAHM. I have no problem being default parent, doing all the planning and organising etc (frankly, I do most of that already) and I'd be happy yo take the lead on post-school childcare/activities etc (which I don't currently do mostly). But I'd just love to have more time for me that isn't about family or work.

prettygreenteacup · 10/03/2023 09:58

Nope. Maternity leave both times drove me crackers and impacted my mental health. Both kids are in school now, I'm also a single parent and work full time. Life is busy but it's still better for my wellbeing to work! I adore my DC but was utterly bored on mat leave. I don't find my whole week being defined by motherhood and parenting fulfilling. Kind of wish I was the sort of mum who loved it, but weekends solo parenting is enough for me now 😂 I go back to work for a break!

Dacadactyl · 10/03/2023 09:57

I'd be a SAHM because I think that's what's best for the kids until they are of school age.

I was a SAHM for many years and wasn't financially independent when I did it. I looked at it as being my FT job and poured my absolute heart and soul into it.

I do think there is some truth to what another poster said about careers....if id got a PhD or was a brain surgeon, it would've been a more difficult decision to give up work. But I actually wonder whether motherhood would've been for me in those circumstances, because I know I wouldn't have wanted anyone else looking after the kids. So, if I didn't feel able to give up my job, then I'm not sure id have had kids IYSWIM.

Swipe left for the next trending thread