Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be a SAHP to pre-schoolers if you were financially independent?

267 replies

Kitchenette · 10/03/2023 08:20

Not super-rich but say you had enough capital to pay yourself an income for life equal to your full time earnings.

I’m always interested in SAHP threads on here and the various very reasonable objections people raise to it- that you’re making yourself vulnerable financially while also putting too great a strain on the paid working partner. But say we took money out of it- would you prefer to stay at home or go to work? For the purposes of the poll it’s a binary choice (of course IRL the best answer for many of us would be to work PT).

YABU- I would prefer to be in paid employment
YANBU- I would prefer to be a SAHP

Me- I’ve had periods of SAHM, FT and PT work since my children were born. Binary choice with pre-school children and no money worries-I’d be at home, no question.

OP posts:
Botw1 · 10/03/2023 13:30

No.

I love my career. Not going back to it post kids never even entered my head. I'm not sure why it would, it certainly didn't enter their dad's

Im also not a single parent. I didn't have kids alone and had no intention of being the default parent or the pcg. We had kids with the intention of being equal parents

Ive always spent lots if quality time with my kids. I don't see the need to be with them 24/7. It is possible to love spending time with your kids and want a balance of doing other things.

Ive never seen not working as the ideal. I'm not sure why anyone does.

Would anyone ask the question in the op of men?

What do you think the answer would be?

Awumminnscotland · 10/03/2023 13:28

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the user.

Ooh Thank you! 😊 Most of the time I don't feel wise! These threads are good for reflecting on your choices whilst hearing very different views and choices.

roundcork · 10/03/2023 13:21

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the user.

SofiaSoFar · 10/03/2023 13:13

SnowAndFrostOutside · 10/03/2023 09:57

I like working so I'll keep working. But if a person is financially stable and don't need to work, I can see why a lot won't.

I think it depends what you mean by 'financially stable', though. If that stability means reliance upon your partner then that's no good, in my opinion.

A couple of my friends could not wait to stop working - it was pretty much their 'career' goal: do something until a man comes along who can support you, have children with them, then make sure never to work again. It backfired quite spectacularly for one of them (who's convinced she wasn't to blame for not seeing what might go wrong with that plan.)

I do think it's the not having to make the effort to go out to work that incentivises some people rather than particularly wanting to look after DCs.

Awumminnscotland · 10/03/2023 12:35

I gave up a good career, which I did alot of qualifications for, to be a SAHM. I was so invested in my work I can't see me having been able to meet my child's needs as well.
I'm 52 with a 7 year old. It's the right thing to do for our family, for a variety of reasons including being an adoptive family with additional needs which are invisible to others so are not seen as a reason to be at home. I am constantly judged and still asked 6 years in when I'm going back to work.
We're not rich, but we can enjoy luxuries when we want. We don't go on expensive holidays sometimes no holidays. We live a simple life. Husband works a lot from home. He was willing to be the parent at home, but as is often the case, he is the higher earner, so it made sense.
Our perspective is that we chose to have our child, she benefits greatly from having me available, and the flexibility and lack of stress that comes from me not working. We are lucky to be able to do this but went into family life with the intention that we have a parent at home if needed.
As for the role model thing. We speak about my previous work, different types of families that have different needs and priorities. She won't grow up ignorant of life choices people can make.
If I was in my thirties, I likely would not have given up work and wouldn't have been in a position to do so.
This is 100% the right thing for us but that doesn't mean I don't question my decision often,especially now she's at school. But the needs are still there and I am happy to focus on her for the next few years.
People need to make their own decisions for their family. That's it really.

KievsOutTheOven · 10/03/2023 12:32

Dacadactyl · 10/03/2023 11:51

@KievsOutTheOven it's funny really because I did have plans of a big career if I'm honest. Also, my DH would've stayed at home to support that if id wanted it enough, but i guess i mustnt have wanted it as much as i thought.

I didn't intend to have DD so young either, but when she came along I just couldn't imagine leaving her with anyone else. Like, i physcially wouldnt have been able to do it. That is probably to do with my upbringing though.

My mum was 35 when she had me (her first), so it's not like young parenthood runs in our family.

Of my high school friends, 5 out of 8 of us have children. I find it very interesting to think around the choices I've made tbh.

As do I! Even things like choosing a partner and the impact that has on the trajectory of your life. I have a “good” partner, but what would have happened if I chose a different, but equally good, partner?

And all the tiny, seemingly inconsequential decisions - are they really inconsequential? For example, if I hadn’t chose to go to the party I went to when I met my partner, I wouldn’t have the same life I do now.

It is a mindfuck!

Tumbleweed101 · 10/03/2023 12:32

Yes.

Corah5 · 10/03/2023 12:30

I would prefer to work and have my kids in high quality childcare. Unfortunately that wasn’t an option that was available to me. Childcare is super expensive and ate up virtually all of my salary, and it was still shitty low quality group childcare with poorly educated staff in an old school building.

I thought why am I working for pretty much £0 while leaving my kids with people who have no brains and don’t really care about them? So I became a SAHM until they started school. If I was rich I would totally have hired a high quality nanny and kept working.

Raindancer411 · 10/03/2023 12:28

I have been a SAHM for both of mine but it has been tight living on one wage. We just worked out if I had of gone back to work, I would have only just made enough for childcare, so rather than paying someone else, we decided I would just do it.

My DH is very much it's our money, so if I did want anything, he wouldn't say no, but I am looking forward to being able to get back to some sort of PT job for some pin money for myself at some point.

SockQueen · 10/03/2023 12:22

Twizbe · 10/03/2023 10:13

@SockQueen sorry but I just have to say this. SAHPs are capable of using their brains as well.

I love history and am an avid reader of non fiction books.

I volunteer and gained a qualification through that volunteering.

Just because I'm not working it doesn't mean I have no interests or pursuits outside of my children.

Of course, I didn't mean to imply that SAHPs aren't capable of using their brains!

But my job requires a lot of technical knowledge and skills which have taken me time to develop. I enjoy it and it is an important part of who I am. Co-ordinating a schedule of baby/toddler groups, and singing Wind the Bobbin Up 400 times did not give me the same stimulation.

You've obviously found your ways to keep your mind active, which is great (I could never have read much in the toddler years as someone was always interrupting me) - but for me, doing my job is that way, with the added bonus of getting paid for it.

Dumbo18 · 10/03/2023 12:22

If I was financially stable I’d stay at home but still send the kids to nursery for a few hours a day 😂 best of both worlds!

DrMeredithGrey2023 · 10/03/2023 12:20

I have a job, not a career.

If I didn't have to work, I wouldn't.

roundcork · 10/03/2023 12:16

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the user.

NameChangeForThisBear · 10/03/2023 11:55

I chose YABU - but only because my DD’s childminder is amazing, and gives her so much more opportunity to do different things and socialise than I’d ever be able to give as a SAHM.

I found it really difficult to make mum friends because of the sheer amount of small talk that’s required in new connections (I have other friends, we just don’t have to spend months on meaningless chit-chat because we already know each other), and because I don’t have friends who have kids in her age group, she doesn’t have any peers through me.

In contrast, my DD’s childminder always has a wide range of group and social activities for the kids, who are lovely together (childminder has a full-time assistant, so they can have 6) … plus she does loads of professional development stuff for herself so she’s get plenty of expertise through experience but has always got fresh ideas too. DD gets to do loads of things she’d never get to do here. The childminder is lovely and supportive to the children and their parents alike, and she’s all-round a brilliant pre-school childcare professional.

I have Asperger’s syndrome, so I’m extremely good at the things I’m good at (one of which is my work), including many aspects of parenting - but I’m never going to be able to be a social butterfly and “fit in”, especially with groups of other women. I’ve learnt throughout my life that making an effort to be part of a group that’s not based on a shared interest usually ends in tears for me, so I just don’t bother trying any more.

The early years are so important, and I wanted DD to have the best possible time, and that wasn’t going to be stuck at home with me. We have lovely times together in the evenings and at weekends, and thanks to me not being a SAHM, she gets to have lovely times all day every day too! 😊(And of course, I get to go to work and do what I’m good at, so I’m happier too, which makes me much better for DD to be around!)

DelurkingAJ · 10/03/2023 11:52

I was on my knees by the end of maternity leave. Bored, strung out and generally desperate for adult company. DH on the other hand would have adored being a SAHP. So it utterly depends on the person. For me, I’m a better mother because I work. (I shiver with dread at the thought of my own, utterly wonderful, Mum as a SAHM).

NotLactoseFree · 10/03/2023 11:51

Why are the only choices SAHM or working? If I was financially independent, I'd stop working in a heart beat. But Im not sure I'd call myself a SAHM, even when the kids were little as I'd never have been willing to do that as my main activity.

As a working parent, and often also as a SAHP, the biggest challenge is no time for yourself. If I was independently wealthy, that's the greatest gift I could give myself - time. I'd probably ALSO spend more time doing things with and for my children than I do currently as a working parent, but that would just be ONE aspect of how I'd change my life.

Dacadactyl · 10/03/2023 11:51

@KievsOutTheOven it's funny really because I did have plans of a big career if I'm honest. Also, my DH would've stayed at home to support that if id wanted it enough, but i guess i mustnt have wanted it as much as i thought.

I didn't intend to have DD so young either, but when she came along I just couldn't imagine leaving her with anyone else. Like, i physcially wouldnt have been able to do it. That is probably to do with my upbringing though.

My mum was 35 when she had me (her first), so it's not like young parenthood runs in our family.

Of my high school friends, 5 out of 8 of us have children. I find it very interesting to think around the choices I've made tbh.

KievsOutTheOven · 10/03/2023 11:45

Dacadactyl · 10/03/2023 11:30

To add...none of my friends or relatives have ever been a FT SAHM.

None of my close circle have; but my friends are all similarly career driven - most of us work full-time, some are fortunate enough to have family help; others use childcare.
Going back to my school friends though; lots of them are SAHP’s - although they have always been less career driven and probably wouldn’t have benefitted much financially from working whilst they had small kids; due to their earning potential. Again; they never really aimed to have a big career or anything and their aspirations were to raise children.

Simonjt · 10/03/2023 11:44

No, it isn’t something either of us would want, we both believe children seeing their parents working and earning a living sets a good example to them. I wouldn’t want them to give up a career they had earned, so that isn’t something I would model at home.

GoBackToTheLibraryWhereYouBelong · 10/03/2023 11:43

Twizbe · 10/03/2023 10:13

@SockQueen sorry but I just have to say this. SAHPs are capable of using their brains as well.

I love history and am an avid reader of non fiction books.

I volunteer and gained a qualification through that volunteering.

Just because I'm not working it doesn't mean I have no interests or pursuits outside of my children.

I agree with this. I dislike the trope that clever women are just too good for boring old babies and simply must get back to their important, stimulating job and adult conversation.

I'm as clever as anyone and I find babies and small children absolutely fascinating and more than worth my time and effort. They develop so fast you can almost see their brains forming new connections, processing, computing, learning. It's incredible. I'll never forget my baby looking at the sky, looking at me, thinking for a moment and then tentatively saying his first word, "Birds", looking at me for a response. It came out as "Bds", and I grinned, and he grinned back and repeated, "Bds, bds." That is a tiny moment - one of so many - that exists now only in my memory and no, I don't think I'd have been better off in an office having an adult conversation about reports or politics or the weather.

And that is not to say it was all sunshine and roses. Of course it wasn't. But I just think it is wrong to say that babies are boring and it's just shit and vomit and crying and sleeping and you must be some sort of dullard if you spend a couple of years on it.

We were pretty skint when I was a SAHM, but I thought, and still think, it's an important enough job to be worth it.

NewShoes · 10/03/2023 11:43

’Can of course be done’?! Not by many many families I’m afraid! We would be unable to survive if we both went part time. Please don’t be so judgemental.

Whattheladybird · 10/03/2023 11:39

Parenting the first two times I was happy to go back to work.

Third time round, had the money and security been equal, then yes I’d have been at home.

KievsOutTheOven · 10/03/2023 11:39

Dacadactyl · 10/03/2023 11:29

I 100% agree that I am a product of my environment, my mum was a SAHM and so was my MIL. My dad was hands on though and he was the one who took us to our extracurricular after school.

I remember my nan (also a SAHM) telling me she suggested she go back to work in the 1960s and my grandad was mortally offended by it.

If i hadnt been brought up the way i was, I may well be off working for NASA now 😂It's a weird one really, but I do agree with you.

I'm 37 and all my uni friends have kids now (most had then late 20s, early 30s). I had my first straight after graduating at 21. Most of my (similar age) cousins have kids now too. My DHs similar age cousins are about half and half kids/no kids.

I think there is a noticeable shift in attitudes to having children in general. My mum and I had our first kid within 2 weeks of the same age; she was considered an older mum and I considered myself a really young mum (we were both 26).

Weirdly my parents actually were “traditional” in their outlook and did but into traditional gender roles; but their life just didn’t play out that way. And that definitely changed the trajectory of my life. Which is pretty strange to think about, actually.

We do get really bizarre comments often about how “good” my partner is for doing housework, cooking dinners, etc, when nobody would think twice about any of it had he been a woman - and nobody ever comments positively about my achievements in the workplace, my salary etc. The bar for men in society is so low that anything above nothing is praised.

TheKeatingFive · 10/03/2023 11:36

No, but I would go part time for sure.

Busybusybusydoingnothing · 10/03/2023 11:35

I left a professional career to be a SAHM and I wouldn't change a thing. DH had a successful business, I took a small wage from that to feel like I had my 'own money'. DS went to nursery from 2yo for two mornings a week. We had a nice lifestyle that didn't change when I stopped working full time. The stress and rushing about that I imagine comes with having children and working full time just didn't make me want to go back to work and I am glad I didn't. Very fortunate but I get that it wouldn't do for everyone. DS now grown up and I work PT from home. Paid my NI annually so no loss there but do wish I'd sorted a better pension for all those years.

Swipe left for the next trending thread