Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be a SAHP to pre-schoolers if you were financially independent?

267 replies

Kitchenette · 10/03/2023 08:20

Not super-rich but say you had enough capital to pay yourself an income for life equal to your full time earnings.

I’m always interested in SAHP threads on here and the various very reasonable objections people raise to it- that you’re making yourself vulnerable financially while also putting too great a strain on the paid working partner. But say we took money out of it- would you prefer to stay at home or go to work? For the purposes of the poll it’s a binary choice (of course IRL the best answer for many of us would be to work PT).

YABU- I would prefer to be in paid employment
YANBU- I would prefer to be a SAHP

Me- I’ve had periods of SAHM, FT and PT work since my children were born. Binary choice with pre-school children and no money worries-I’d be at home, no question.

OP posts:
KievsOutTheOven · 11/03/2023 00:21

tiggergoesbounce · 10/03/2023 23:45

You completely missed the point of the study
No, I havent interpreted the point I read the actually study and what it was seen to "prove". And lt was nonsense and if anything proved it was irrelevant on the outcome how much a woman worked. But I've shown that below.

The mere act of the mother going out to work and having work aspirations is beneficial, even if the mother does not have a well-paying job/career

You may believe that it is more beneficial for you, your family and your kids and thats a very valid opinion, just dont cite tosh to try and prove it or combat other tosh.

Others believe that being at home and spending all that time with their child is more beneficial as you can instil a good work ethic in your kids and be a SAHP.

What credentials do you have, which means you are qualified to cite academic literature as “tosh”?

Common sense, the ability to read and dechipher said acedemic literature and objectivity.
Just because it has a certain name put to it doesn't mean they are always correct. You need to be able see past that sometimes.

“No, I havent interpreted the point I read the actually study and what it was seen to "prove". And lt was nonsense and if anything proved it was irrelevant on the outcome how much a woman worked. But I've shown that below.”

I'm not sure if this is riddled with typos or not but it makes no sense.

“You may believe that it is more beneficial for you, your family and your kids and thats a very valid opinion, just dont cite tosh to try and prove it or combat other tosh.

Others believe that being at home and spending all that time with their child is more beneficial as you can instil a good work ethic in your kids and be a SAHP”

Its not tosh. It’s a peer reviewed study. They tracked the outcomes of real people and found that female offspring of working mother were more likely to work than those of SAHM’s; and those who did work were more likely to earn more than working daughters of SAHM’s. The data is there and it’s real. It’s a fact.

“Common sense, the ability to read and dechipher said acedemic literature and objectivity.
Just because it has a certain name put to it doesn't mean they are always correct. You need to be able see past that sometimes.”

Again, there is factual data there to back up their findings. I’d be interested for you to show me peer reviewed literature which disproves it.

MeinKraft · 10/03/2023 23:55

Botw1 · 10/03/2023 20:07

@Kitchenette

Wny should the govt fund women (or anyone) to not work?

Mothers going to work full time is an incredibly modern invention. One parent should be paid enough to be able to support their family, perhaps with a small contribution from the other parent.

Housenoob · 10/03/2023 23:54

I'd be a SAHM no question. But I'd still put them in nursery once or twice a week because I think being exposed to that structure/atmosphere is hugely important. And also I'd need that day or two as a break from going mental, even if it's just to catch up with housework etc.

Mariposista · 10/03/2023 23:48

I would rather sit on a cactus. 🌵 and stay sat on it for decades.

MeinKraft · 10/03/2023 23:47

I don't think there are any wrong choices. Working 2-3 days a week is probably the sweet spot though.

tiggergoesbounce · 10/03/2023 23:45

You completely missed the point of the study
No, I havent interpreted the point I read the actually study and what it was seen to "prove". And lt was nonsense and if anything proved it was irrelevant on the outcome how much a woman worked. But I've shown that below.

The mere act of the mother going out to work and having work aspirations is beneficial, even if the mother does not have a well-paying job/career

You may believe that it is more beneficial for you, your family and your kids and thats a very valid opinion, just dont cite tosh to try and prove it or combat other tosh.

Others believe that being at home and spending all that time with their child is more beneficial as you can instil a good work ethic in your kids and be a SAHP.

What credentials do you have, which means you are qualified to cite academic literature as “tosh”?

Common sense, the ability to read and dechipher said acedemic literature and objectivity.
Just because it has a certain name put to it doesn't mean they are always correct. You need to be able see past that sometimes.

WelshWondergirl · 10/03/2023 23:36

I ADORED being at home with mine - and have managed to raise two well adjusted and happy young people.
I don't have a career now though - just a part time job I don't much like. So at nearly 50 I realise that I did sacrifice something for them.

Doggydooda · 10/03/2023 23:35

I would have gone absolutely mental with boredom if stuck at home every day with my children ..love them to bits but I need adult company and conversation to stay sane !

KievsOutTheOven · 10/03/2023 23:34

tiggergoesbounce · 10/03/2023 23:27

And what is your basis for deciding if a study - carried out by one of the largest academic institutions in the world - is “tosh” or not?

It credibility in content amongst one of the things, but my deciphering of tosh or not in general is not the debate here. I have told you twice now why i dont think the one you posted is credible.

If you actually read my posts properly you’d see I don’t actually care; I only cited the study as a rebuttal to the pp who was throwing shade on working mothers

I have read your posts properly and replied accordingly if you check back.
Stating that you have replied to a post, you felt unfair on a huge group of women by citing one that was unfair on another group of women - crazy really.

“credibility in content” - something is not discredited just because you disagree with it. You can’t claim something is “gosh” just because you don’t like it.

Ans no, it wasn’t being “unfair” - I provided a peer reviewed article that directly disproved the pp.

It is proven that there is a correlation with higher earnings among daughters of women who work in any capacity. Is this true or not? Statistically speaking?

Feetupteashot · 10/03/2023 23:27

Always want to work even if part time. Got two girls and think that it is important.

tiggergoesbounce · 10/03/2023 23:27

And what is your basis for deciding if a study - carried out by one of the largest academic institutions in the world - is “tosh” or not?

It credibility in content amongst one of the things, but my deciphering of tosh or not in general is not the debate here. I have told you twice now why i dont think the one you posted is credible.

If you actually read my posts properly you’d see I don’t actually care; I only cited the study as a rebuttal to the pp who was throwing shade on working mothers

I have read your posts properly and replied accordingly if you check back.
Stating that you have replied to a post, you felt unfair on a huge group of women by citing one that was unfair on another group of women - crazy really.

KievsOutTheOven · 10/03/2023 23:25

tiggergoesbounce · 10/03/2023 23:21

The earlier posters mummy blogger “study” even said that the most impact was during the parents first year; and is assuming the use of “daycare” rather than more individualised care like a family member, nanny, or so on. And given that the vast majority of British working mothers take close to a year off for maternity leave; again it’s largely irrelevant

But the "study" you cited was drawn on some of the information collated from 20 years ago.
It was also drawn stating that it classed a working mum as someone who worked a 60 hour week the same as a woman who worked a couple of months of one year of a childs life up until the age of 14, the same. It stated it had no relevance to earnings, status or job role. Tosh.

You completely missed the point of the study. The mere act of the mother going out to work and having work aspirations is beneficial, even if the mother does not have a well-paying job/career. They are ALL beneficial.

What credentials do you have which means you are qualified to cite academic literature as “tosh”?

tiggergoesbounce · 10/03/2023 23:21

The earlier posters mummy blogger “study” even said that the most impact was during the parents first year; and is assuming the use of “daycare” rather than more individualised care like a family member, nanny, or so on. And given that the vast majority of British working mothers take close to a year off for maternity leave; again it’s largely irrelevant

But the "study" you cited was drawn on some of the information collated from 20 years ago.
It was also drawn stating that it classed a working mum as someone who worked a 60 hour week the same as a woman who worked a couple of months of one year of a childs life up until the age of 14, the same. It stated it had no relevance to earnings, status or job role. Tosh.

KievsOutTheOven · 10/03/2023 23:18

tiggergoesbounce · 10/03/2023 23:13

With all due respect, are all studies a “pile of tosh” to you?

Not all,No. But the ones i see cited on here are, yes. And the other ones i have seen cited to try and "prove" which is better SAHP or WOHP, yes, all tosh.

And what is your basis for deciding if a study - carried out by one of the largest academic institutions in the world - is “tosh” or not?

If you actually read my posts properly you’d see I don’t actually care; I only cited the study as a rebuttal to the pp who was throwing shade on working mothers.

tiggergoesbounce · 10/03/2023 23:13

With all due respect, are all studies a “pile of tosh” to you?

Not all,No. But the ones i see cited on here are, yes. And the other ones i have seen cited to try and "prove" which is better SAHP or WOHP, yes, all tosh.

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/03/2023 22:53

Work.

It's more than finances for me. I worked hard to get to where I am in my career, I love what I do and it's good for my mental health.

DS is 3 months and I've recently returned to work. I already feel much more like 'me' as opposed to just 'DS mum'.

KievsOutTheOven · 10/03/2023 22:48

tiggergoesbounce · 10/03/2023 22:33

There is a massive difference though - I cited a peer reviewed study carried out by a well recognised education institution, and they cited a mummy blogger

There really isnt. You cited a flawed and nonsense study that was steered to prove their narrative and she cited someone elses opinion that was steered to prove their narraitve.
There are other studies that suggest the same as the blogger, again by people steering their narrative. All a load of tosh.

With all due respect, are all studies a “pile of tosh” to you?

The earlier posters mummy blogger “study” even said that the most impact was during the parents first year; and is assuming the use of “daycare” rather than more individualised care like a family member, nanny, or so on. And given that the vast majority of British working mothers take close to a year off for maternity leave; again it’s largely irrelevant.

MrsRandom123 · 10/03/2023 22:45

Never claimed anything*

MrsRandom123 · 10/03/2023 22:45

OheeOheeOh · 10/03/2023 19:04

Do you really think you are a sahm if your kids are in high school? Will you still be a sahm when they are at uni 🤣?

Yip still a sahm. No school care needed, no breakfast clubs, no grandparents collecting the kids and giving them their dinner or playing taxi taking them to numerous clubs.

It’s completely different to being a sahm parent when they were babies and when i never got a break. This way i can do the shopping during the day, keep the house tidy, help out at school events and trips as well as go to the gym or for coffee. The “me time” is owed after the years of it being constant.

You can call me whatever you like if you have a problem with sahm. Lady of leisure? Lazy bitch? I couldn’t care less. worked hard for a career that i’ve sacrificed (for various reasons) but we’ve claimed anything & my husband works hard, earning a decent wage to support us and & it still works as we’re all happy.

If or when i chose i to return to employment it will be because it’s the right thing for me & not because someone somewhere has an issue with me being “unemployed” whilst my kids are at school 🙄

bellamountain · 10/03/2023 22:43

If money were no object then definitely. Once those few years are gone, they're gone forever.

Dustpot · 10/03/2023 22:40

I have a healthy passive income and I'm a sahm to one baby and a Reception age DD. My days are pretty busy, the baby doesn't nap consistently and I like to keep her busy with activities so I'm out of the house every morning, going to baby classes. Loads to do with babies and schoolkids around here, including theatre and concerts designed for under 5s, so I'd regret missing out on taking them if I were working. I don't stay at home and organise my own activities for her - there are loads of private classes for messy play, gym, music etc. You just pay and turn up and don't have to tidy up the mess.

I love taking both DDs out during school holidays- exploring new places and also just trips out near us in London. Other working mums around here have nannies who take their kids to similar things - but I genuinely enjoy going with them rather than seeing it as a chore for someone else to do, so I'd feel sad to not be doing it even if my DC weren't missing out.

I have no plans to return to work. I know the children won't need me as much when they're older, but then I'd see their school hours as time to fill with my own hobbies and sports, not time in an office. The only downside is that there's a bit of stigma to being a sahm, or people will simply assume you work. I do run a limited company which is really just a hobby - if I need to do "work talk" to fit in socially then I mention that. I don't talk about my side income at all to anyone so people just assume that DH is the only earner (my income actually brings in more than his salary).

tiggergoesbounce · 10/03/2023 22:38

And I was only doing it to disprove her crock of shit claims, I don’t actually care what anyone else does, but I do care about judgemental people who share blog posts as “research” to try to put others down

So you wanted to reduce the judgement placed on women by promoting another study/research that judges and pulls down a massive amount of women.

Its good you don't care what others do. The more women stop dragging each other down for their choices, the better.

MooseBreath · 10/03/2023 22:37

I would love to be a SAHP with no financial difficulty. I would put DC in nursery twice per week though so that I could have time to do jobs around the house and take a bit of time for myself.

tiggergoesbounce · 10/03/2023 22:33

There is a massive difference though - I cited a peer reviewed study carried out by a well recognised education institution, and they cited a mummy blogger

There really isnt. You cited a flawed and nonsense study that was steered to prove their narrative and she cited someone elses opinion that was steered to prove their narraitve.
There are other studies that suggest the same as the blogger, again by people steering their narrative. All a load of tosh.

WeAreBorg · 10/03/2023 22:10

I am exceptionally lazy and I think getting paid for staying at home doing very little sounds great! Count me in as a yes and please arrange this for me asap