Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be a SAHP to pre-schoolers if you were financially independent?

267 replies

Kitchenette · 10/03/2023 08:20

Not super-rich but say you had enough capital to pay yourself an income for life equal to your full time earnings.

I’m always interested in SAHP threads on here and the various very reasonable objections people raise to it- that you’re making yourself vulnerable financially while also putting too great a strain on the paid working partner. But say we took money out of it- would you prefer to stay at home or go to work? For the purposes of the poll it’s a binary choice (of course IRL the best answer for many of us would be to work PT).

YABU- I would prefer to be in paid employment
YANBU- I would prefer to be a SAHP

Me- I’ve had periods of SAHM, FT and PT work since my children were born. Binary choice with pre-school children and no money worries-I’d be at home, no question.

OP posts:
Botw1 · 11/03/2023 09:50

I can only find research on parents with lower incomes having a directly negative affect on outcomes for children

But that's not to say sahd partners aren't higher earners

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 11/03/2023 09:47

Botw1 · 11/03/2023 09:29

@MissTrip82

think the more interesting experiment would be raising women to expect they’d fund themselves throughout their lives

Exactly

I hope it would also include raising boys to expect to do their equal share of unpaid caring labour.

KievsOutTheOven · 11/03/2023 09:45

Botw1 · 11/03/2023 09:28

@KievsOutTheOven

The same study shows boys earning potential /employment isn't influenced by having a working mum but their attitudes are.

They are more likely to be a more equal parent/believe in equality

hbswk.hbs.edu/item/kids-of-working-moms-grow-into-happy-adults

I know it will be dismissed as tosh but that's what the study showed

Yeah, I saw that - I was wondering specifically about the earning potential of sons of SAHD’s though. I reckon research would probably show they are less likely to be high earners?

My mum worked full-time and my dad worked part-time when I was growing up; and that’s now exactly what happens in my family (although I’m temporarily also part time but with a full-time contract) so I definitely do see the study results playing out in my own family. I hope my son is as hands on as my partner and my own dad!

Botw1 · 11/03/2023 09:29

@MissTrip82

think the more interesting experiment would be raising women to expect they’d fund themselves throughout their lives

Exactly

Botw1 · 11/03/2023 09:28

@KievsOutTheOven

The same study shows boys earning potential /employment isn't influenced by having a working mum but their attitudes are.

They are more likely to be a more equal parent/believe in equality

hbswk.hbs.edu/item/kids-of-working-moms-grow-into-happy-adults

I know it will be dismissed as tosh but that's what the study showed

MissTrip82 · 11/03/2023 09:23

No. I enjoy my work. It’s meaningful and of value. It takes 15 or so years to be qualified.

it’s not unusual to me to have two incomes because I come from a working class family in which women have always worked - it was simply impossible not to do so. The middle-class invention of a stay at home parent was a status symbol that was only dreamt up a few hundred years ago.

I think the more interesting experiment would be raising women to expect they’d fund themselves throughout their lives. I’m always surprised by how many women post who worked for a decade or more before having children but never decided to get any qualifications or improve their ability to support themselves.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 11/03/2023 09:21

I wouldn't have chosen it. Part time work felt like the optimum balance. We could've lived off one income actually, though I realise this is very different from independent wealth.

Also I think DH and I would probably have chosen 1 x FT and 1 x SAHP over 2 x FT, while we're on the general topic. Neither of us has ever been keen on the idea of both being full time with kids.

Bunnycat101 · 11/03/2023 09:16

So I find this quite interesting because I don’t think I would but I wouldn’t do my current job. My husband earns enough that I could have chosen to be a sahm but haven’t. There have been times that the juggle has been so hard but I have had intellectual stimulation and I think mine have genuinely benefited from nursery from about 2.

so…. With unlimited money, I would be at home with them until 2 and then whatever I was doing would look to do some nursery from that age while making sure I was also doing something for me whether that be study, volunteering etc. school she actually feels the killer when working. I would love to be around more to pop in for all of the random assemblies, do more with the PTA etc, do play dates after school etc.

KievsOutTheOven · 11/03/2023 09:10

tiggergoesbounce · 11/03/2023 07:45

@KievsOutTheOven my phone is not letting me quote but in anwer to you. I will break down my explanation for you to understand. It may be in bits though.

I have not "interpreted" the study to miss the point. I read the actually study, and i have previously copied exactly what it stated from a relatively small number of people.

It stated it made no difference if a mother worked a couple of months in 14 years or 60 hours a week across 14 years, it was of benefit to the child.
How can you take that seriously to prove anything?

You believe, if me working 3 months when my child is say one years old, that makes a massive difference to their professional outcome in later life?? (Tosh)

Can you explain how you think this would make a difference?

It also states the role is irrelevant and the pay is irrelevant, so from that, i would think volunteering would have the same outcome.

I have actually already explained this, several times on this thread, and actually, other SAHM’s have agreed with me.

If you grow up in a house where the mother prioritises spending time at home with the children and keeping a home over a career, that becomes your “norm”

If you grow up in a house where the division of labour in the house (childcare and cleaning) is even, and the woman prioritises working outside the house in some way (even part-time) then that becomes your “norm”

If you are brought up in a happy household (of either kind) you will likely want to repeat your own upbringing with your own children. There are likely to be equal numbers of happy households in each of the above camps.

It would be interesting to see if boys of SAHD’s were more likely to earn less, actually! And it would be interesting to see someone graph the number of hours worked by mums (or salaries earned by mums) with the salaries of their daughter. I’d imagine they’d find a direct correlation.

Some of this is not exactly rocket science to draw out conclusions from:

  • working mums are likely to bring more money into a household overall than a household with only one income; therefore they may be able to afford their child to attend private school/live in an area with better schools/afford tutors
  • working mums may be more likely to be degree educated and be “career orientated” than stay at home mums ((www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/05/07/opting-out-about-10-of-highly-educated-moms-are-staying-at-home/) - it’s well documented that children of degree educated parents are more likely to go to uni than children of parents without degrees - and it’s also well documented that those who have degrees are more likely to become higher earners than those who don’t have a degree.
  • working mums may be able to afford more activities and extra curricular activities for their children; such as sports and instruments; and these are also correlated with higher academic success. Higher scene of success is correlated with higher earning potential. (files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1208711.pdf )

I don’t think that being a SAHM is necessary bad for girls - there are undoubted benefits to having a parent at home. However, I would not want my daughter to be a SAHP unless she was independently wealthy enough to not rely on her partners salary to do so; as I believe it makes women vulnerable and have to stay in unhappy relationships.

If you read back a few pages you’ll see me discuss this at length with a SAHM who agrees with me.

And it’s not at all a dig at SAHM’s. However, statistically speaking my daughter is more likely to earn more money now than if I stayed at home. It’s a fact. Does it mean she’s happier? Not necessarily. Will she be wealthy? Maybe, maybe not, but there is more chance she will be. And, sad as it may be, this means she’s more likely to have a longer, healthier life.

Botw1 · 11/03/2023 09:06

@ilovemyspace

I have children. I have a maternal bond. I even, gasp, love and raise my children.

I still manage to be fully committed to my career and think its absolutely worth while

Does your oh think his career / job is more important and worthwhile than loving and raising his children?

Botw1 · 11/03/2023 09:02

@MeinKraft

I don't think women working full time is a modern invention at all

Women have always worked. I also can't think of any reason why in a 2 person family only 1 of them should work

What is a modern (and sexist) invention is that the parenting ideal involves women sacrificing everything to martyr themselves to their children and the idea that children need to be indulged and entertained and supervised 24/7 until 18 years old.

It's not my ideal and I don't agree it's 1 the govt should fund

Theelephantinthecastle · 11/03/2023 07:59

I think it's interesting to look at what really wealthy women do - people like Pippa Middleton. They don't typically choose to work in a "proper" career but neither are they changing every nappy. They usually have a nanny and a creative or other intellectual interest outside the home.

I enjoy my career and I wouldn't want to be home full time but if I had millions in the bank, I would probably do what they do.

tiggergoesbounce · 11/03/2023 07:51

@KievsOutTheOven
Oh and no i wont be going off to try and find data to try and make a whole load of women feel bad for their choices.
And as i dont believe you can generalise and its a personal case if it's better to have a SAHP or not, i wouldn't post something i don't believe.

There are lots of examples posted on the (millions) of different discussions about that.

tiggergoesbounce · 11/03/2023 07:45

@KievsOutTheOven my phone is not letting me quote but in anwer to you. I will break down my explanation for you to understand. It may be in bits though.

I have not "interpreted" the study to miss the point. I read the actually study, and i have previously copied exactly what it stated from a relatively small number of people.

It stated it made no difference if a mother worked a couple of months in 14 years or 60 hours a week across 14 years, it was of benefit to the child.
How can you take that seriously to prove anything?

You believe, if me working 3 months when my child is say one years old, that makes a massive difference to their professional outcome in later life?? (Tosh)

Can you explain how you think this would make a difference?

It also states the role is irrelevant and the pay is irrelevant, so from that, i would think volunteering would have the same outcome.

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 11/03/2023 07:21

I would be bored out of my mind if I wouldn’t have work

Oblomov23 · 11/03/2023 02:49

I too don't understand what you are asking or what the point is.
On some threads people say they would still work. Would I? I'm not sure. I worked part time while ds's in primary. I like my job. If I won huge millions on lottery and had my time again would I work? Probably not, I could find plenty to do to enjoy and fill my time. Plus I'd probably buy a couple of businesses to ensure future income, so I'd have a tiny amount of work making sure that all ran nicely.
But your question is pointless and doesn't majesty sense for most peoples RL situation.

NumberTheory · 11/03/2023 01:50

Depending on how independently wealthy I was, my preference would be:

  • Not working, but nanny to do the grunt work of parenting while I swanned around.
  • Working, with nanny, to do the grunt work
  • Shared care with DH, both working part time.
  • SAHM
  • Working, nursery to look after DC while I worked.

The last seems most exhausting and I probably wouldn’t do it if I was independently wealthy enough to not be worried about maintaining my earning power.

ChildcareIsBroken · 11/03/2023 01:47

I voted YABU because I wouldn't enjoy being SAHM full time. So out of the two options, I'd choose work. But I'm lucky I work remotely so that saves me almost 15 hours commute.
My ideal scenario would be both me and husband work part time, say 3 days a week, children are in childcare for 4 days, so we're free to do whatever we want for a day. Then 3 days weekend together.
When I was on mat leave with my first I thought I wouldn't want to work afterwards, but I decided to wait and see. Turns out it gave me the right balance. My children are thriving and I'm happy and we're still really close.

KievsOutTheOven · 11/03/2023 00:45

SouthLondonMum22 · 11/03/2023 00:38

I'd also like to see a more generous leave for fathers too. I feel like a reason why the mother can often become the 'go to' parent even if she isn't a SAHM is because it is easy for that to happen if she takes the whole year off.

Yeah. I’m lucky that my partner took off nearly as long as I did; a combo of paternity leave, holidays, unpaid leave, and shared parental leave. We were only able to do this as we were ttc for quite a while so had a chance to save.

Maybe a way to do it would be to pay 50% of each parents normal salary for 18 months, and allow the parents to decide who gets what. So they can take 9m together, they can take 6m together and mum take a further 6, they can do 9 each, or whatever. Given our crippling issues with a declining working population and an increasing aging population; we need to do something.

ilovemyspace · 11/03/2023 00:43

@OheeOheeOh I wouldn't, I spent far too many years at uni/training to do my job to just have children and sit at home all day. I wonder how many people who answer yes have left successful careers to be a SAHM? The ones I know didn't have a career to leave, they just married well and live off their husband's. If they hadn't they'd be working in a minimum wage job somewhere. I think that's the thing here, if you don't have a career but have money of course you'll stay at home. If you have a career you worked hard to achieve you'll be less likely to leave it to be a SAHM.
The way you've phrased this it sounds a bit simplistic and patronising.
Do you actually have children? And, therefore, have you felt a maternal bond?
Do you consider having a career to be more important and worthwhile than loving and raising children?
No problem if you do - just don't be patronising about women who want to stay at home and look after the children they've decided to have,

SouthLondonMum22 · 11/03/2023 00:38

KievsOutTheOven · 11/03/2023 00:30

That being said I do think statutory maternity leave should be more generous, to allow mothers on a higher income to afford to take the whole year off. I think it should be more proportionate to your own salary (and therefore how much tax you contribute) rather than a flat fee. My maternity pay was less than 1/4 of my gross pay, and I only got 13 weeks at 90% of my pay from my employer.

I'd also like to see a more generous leave for fathers too. I feel like a reason why the mother can often become the 'go to' parent even if she isn't a SAHM is because it is easy for that to happen if she takes the whole year off.

motherofqilins · 11/03/2023 00:32

If it was at all possible yes I would. This is because it would be the right choice for my family and our circumstances.

I am a trained nursery worker so am confident in the early years being able to provide the same care and activities they would have gotten at a nursery. I would still make the effort to sign up to enough age appropriate activities so they get to play with children their age.

If I could still afford it once they go to school I would choose to still be a SAHP so I could be active in their school volunteering where possible so I can play a active role of their education and also plan lessons/activities to do outside of school. That is what my mother did and I do think it benefitted me greatly and is something I would like to provide for my children.

KievsOutTheOven · 11/03/2023 00:30

SouthLondonMum22 · 11/03/2023 00:23

It's a good thing that mothers now have more choices and are able to go to work. Paying mothers to stay at home (because of course it would be majority mothers) would be a step backwards.

If someone wants to be a SAHP, they shouldn't expect the government to fund it for them.

That being said I do think statutory maternity leave should be more generous, to allow mothers on a higher income to afford to take the whole year off. I think it should be more proportionate to your own salary (and therefore how much tax you contribute) rather than a flat fee. My maternity pay was less than 1/4 of my gross pay, and I only got 13 weeks at 90% of my pay from my employer.

KievsOutTheOven · 11/03/2023 00:25

MeinKraft · 10/03/2023 23:55

Mothers going to work full time is an incredibly modern invention. One parent should be paid enough to be able to support their family, perhaps with a small contribution from the other parent.

Yes, and mothers being able to leave unhappy marriages without leaving themselves destitute is also a modern invention. Being a SAHP leaves one person vulnerable (regardless of whether it is the mother or father) unless you are very proactive in taking steps to protect yourself, or independently wealthy.

SouthLondonMum22 · 11/03/2023 00:23

MeinKraft · 10/03/2023 23:55

Mothers going to work full time is an incredibly modern invention. One parent should be paid enough to be able to support their family, perhaps with a small contribution from the other parent.

It's a good thing that mothers now have more choices and are able to go to work. Paying mothers to stay at home (because of course it would be majority mothers) would be a step backwards.

If someone wants to be a SAHP, they shouldn't expect the government to fund it for them.