Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be a SAHP to pre-schoolers if you were financially independent?

267 replies

Kitchenette · 10/03/2023 08:20

Not super-rich but say you had enough capital to pay yourself an income for life equal to your full time earnings.

I’m always interested in SAHP threads on here and the various very reasonable objections people raise to it- that you’re making yourself vulnerable financially while also putting too great a strain on the paid working partner. But say we took money out of it- would you prefer to stay at home or go to work? For the purposes of the poll it’s a binary choice (of course IRL the best answer for many of us would be to work PT).

YABU- I would prefer to be in paid employment
YANBU- I would prefer to be a SAHP

Me- I’ve had periods of SAHM, FT and PT work since my children were born. Binary choice with pre-school children and no money worries-I’d be at home, no question.

OP posts:
Botw1 · 11/03/2023 13:19

@musos

I didn't say it was wrong.

I don't believe men or women have a free choice regardless of what they earn and I also don't believe its a coincidence you think men 'feel differently'

My kids dad doesnt feel differently about them than I do.

musos · 11/03/2023 13:05

That's up to men, Botw1. If men want to be a SAHD and they can afford it - then they should do that. It may be that women and men feel differently about such things. Just because men may be less inclined to do something, that shouldn't mean it is 'wrong.'

Botw1 · 11/03/2023 12:57

@musos

I haven't said that

I think you're mixing me up with someone else.

How many men with the luxury of choosing to be a sahd do so?

Changechangechanging · 11/03/2023 12:55

I was a SAHM when my ex walked out leaving me pregnant with a toddler and a preschooler. It took years to claw my way back and I have concerns about my long term financial security if I live past my early-mid 70s. I wouldn’t stay at home knowing what I k ow now, no.

musos · 11/03/2023 12:52

Botw1 - it's not really about being dependent on 'income' as such. I meant a level of family assets / wealth that would enable that type of choice.

musos · 11/03/2023 12:43

Botw1 - You were saying that women should work (not SAH) to be a positive role model and to ensure better wealth / health for their children.

I am saying many children with long-term SAHMs (mums with the luxury of CHOOSING not to work again - which is what the thread is about) are, by correlation, likely to be in the high-net worth demographics that have the best opportunities / wealth / health outcomes regardless.

As I said, it's not about whether women (or men) work or SAH. It's how much choice they have in the matter.

Being a good role model is obviously not about whether you work or not! You could work all hours, part-time or SAH and still be a crap role model to your kids, depending on your personality. In parenting, as in general life, I'd say it's not what you do, it's how you do it.

Botw1 · 11/03/2023 12:32

@musos

Do women in the top 1% have a free choice?

Either they are dependent on a man's income or their own

Both of which come with expectations

Botw1 · 11/03/2023 12:31

@musos

Sorry, what logic of mine are you responding to?

None of your comments seem relevant to mine

musos · 11/03/2023 12:07

The top 1% of families are obviously statistical outliers in terms of families per se. But the top 1% of families are NOT statistical outliers if we are talking about long-term SAHMs - or women who have the free choice not to work again (which I thought was the whole point of this thread). The top 1% or whatever of net worth families is precisely where you will find a very high-proportion of SAHMs.

tiggergoesbounce · 11/03/2023 11:59

Firstly, it doesn’t have to be a “professional career”
No, how does working 3 months out of 14 years help your daughter to be in a professional career.??? Thats what im asking you

The statistics don’t break it down to job type. The statistics show that working mums are more likely to have working daughters, and their daughters are more likely to be higher earners. The scope of the study doesn’t explore why

No, the scope of the study is ridiculous.i can't believe you can't see that given my explanation twice, that it's a small study with no real parameter.

however I would argue that it would be unusual for the only period of a mothers employment to be three months within the first year of their child’s life; especially since most working mums would be on maternity leave for most of the first year

But your evidence is suggesting a couple of months in any profession, for any salary, at any age of the child increases the chances of a daughter to be in professional role. I cant take the findings of a study like that seriously. Its tosh.
And you still havent answered how you think that can be a credible study?

”But there are millions of women who see this and know this is exactly what they dont want to, and they ensure they do not end up in that situation and go the complete opposite. How much do you need to work ? How many hours qualify you to be producing this successful child?”

The statistics show you are not correct. Could you please cite a study which shows this? Statistically, working mothers are more likely to raise working daughters. It’s a fact. Just because “millions” of people (across the world?) don’t fit that statistic doesn’t mean it isn’t true

I have already told you that i dont believe any study can prove what is better for a child between a SAHP and WOHP. It's a personal benefit to a particular family.

Your study doesn't show that. Im sure you can find more credible studies to try and back up your claims but as previously stated, anyone can find a study to try to validate their opinion if they feel the need to.
Again you havent answered

how many hours you think a mother has to work for it to promote their daughters to a professional role in later life.

”No, i disagree these days. I think, thankfully, women have more choice now over how they want to live their lives. Alot realise they dont have to follow what was before them and can break the norms of before and they can do whats best for them and their families (those luckily enough to have a choice”

“alot” (lol) of people, including you, may disagree. But the numbers don’t. Again, statistically working mums are more likely to raise high earning daughters who work. Do you understand how statistics work?

Yes, i do. Do you understand what your evidenced study is supposed to be proving. You dont seem to be accepting that you can not have such a vast scope and feel.it proves anything. It doesn't. Its a small scope study, with no real paramaters so proves nothing really.

”So you are saying, you believe the amount of hours worked by a mother helps define the success of their daughter??? .”

Yes, I do believe there would be a correlation, I believe it would show a bell curve of distribution (as almost everything does) and I do think that perhaps, mothers working an excessive number of hours may also have a negative impact on their daughters, with “peak” earnings lying somewhere between part and full time. It would certainly be interesting to plot though

So if you are part time then, your child will be less succssful, but if you work too much it will have a negstive effect. So you think it's right us women should be judged like this ?? The pressure of just that perfect balance to raise that well-balanced, successful child. Its nonsense, the more you buy into it thr more you help create a worse environment for women.

“Im not sure you are truly in touch with the norm of working mums, most working mums are not out their working to afford private education and tutors.

Yes, working mums will obviously bring in an income but their are many, many, many SAHM who have high earning husbands, so the household income would be more than 2 average incomes.”

I know quite a bit about working mums, thank you, given that I am one 😂 no, most working mums are not working to afford private education or tutors, but increasing the household earnings certainly makes it EASIER to afford those things

Yes, so why make it as a point if it's not a valid point for the majority paying for education??

Of course, only if you need that other income to make things easier. If you dont need the other income and the household can afford all this anyway.

You are unwittingly proving my point though - many, many SAHM’s are relying on their husbands for survival

How have i proved that?? 🤣

And that is dangerous, as it can lead to them not being able to leave unhappy relationships

Of course it can. 50% of marriages fail. And women stay in relationships they absolutely shouldn't, noone is disputing the risks from that perspective. Its the other tosh you are trying to justify in your "study "that im disagreeing with, because its a nonsense study. But most SAHM know the risks, plan for it or accept its a risk they are willing to take.

not something I’d want for my daughter
My part time salary is more than the average full time salary in the UK, for the record

That is absolutely fabulous, you should be very proud of yourself for that. As should your daughter. And that pride in yourself should be enough for you.
You shouldn't need to try to drag others down to raise yourself up.
You can quite happily have different views and opinions without attempting to pull others down. Just enjoy your choices.

KievsOutTheOven · 11/03/2023 11:54

musos · 11/03/2023 11:34

KievsOutTheOven - What you are talking about, in terms of children's outcomes, is wealth.

Yes, 'statistically' children from lower-income households - which would obviously be even lower-income households if the mum is not working - may be less likely to become higher-earners themselves. This will not only be because the mum is not working - it's the entire environment they grow up in.

The majority of families these days fall somewhere in the 'squeezed middle' - families who need two incomes for the lifestyle they perceive to be reasonable. There will be obvious pros and cons to this, which could be summarised as time v money.

But if you are talking about SAHMs specifically, it stands to reason that families with (long-term) SAHMs tend will not to be found in the 'squeezed middle.' I'm talking about women who don't need to work well beyond the pre/school years.

However, there are the women in families with a net worth in the top 1% and you will find that there is a disproportionate amount of SAHMs in this demographic. They are not financially vulnerable due to significant family assets. Many of these are what you might call 'tiger mums' in high extremely achieving families. Families who push for the very best schools and want to facilitate the very best opportunities / extra-curricular for their kids. Imagine how much energy you would have to put into supporting your kids education, without the pressures and time-commitment of a full-time career. This is why these women SAH. They have the money - they want to make it count! Is it any wonder, that children from wealthy families with SAHMs who focus on every aspect of their education and god knows what besides, are more likely to be 'successful' themselves?

of course - but the top 1% are statistical outliers. What I said and what you said are not mutually exclusive. The study is not “tosh” but of course, there are exceptions.

musos · 11/03/2023 11:44

I am responding to your logic Botw1. It makes no sense to me because It's not about whether women work or not. It's more about WHY they work / don't work - how much choice for they have in the matter. Same as with anyone else. A good mum is a happy mum and that's all kids need.

Botw1 · 11/03/2023 11:39

@Thepeopleversuswork

Or my personal favourite

Of course I would be a sahm. I love my children and want to raise them myself 😂

@musos

'
Sweeping statements about SAHMs are nonsensical.'

So are sweeping statements about working mums

You can't claim posters are being defensive and then be defensive yourself

musos · 11/03/2023 11:34

KievsOutTheOven - What you are talking about, in terms of children's outcomes, is wealth.

Yes, 'statistically' children from lower-income households - which would obviously be even lower-income households if the mum is not working - may be less likely to become higher-earners themselves. This will not only be because the mum is not working - it's the entire environment they grow up in.

The majority of families these days fall somewhere in the 'squeezed middle' - families who need two incomes for the lifestyle they perceive to be reasonable. There will be obvious pros and cons to this, which could be summarised as time v money.

But if you are talking about SAHMs specifically, it stands to reason that families with (long-term) SAHMs tend will not to be found in the 'squeezed middle.' I'm talking about women who don't need to work well beyond the pre/school years.

However, there are the women in families with a net worth in the top 1% and you will find that there is a disproportionate amount of SAHMs in this demographic. They are not financially vulnerable due to significant family assets. Many of these are what you might call 'tiger mums' in high extremely achieving families. Families who push for the very best schools and want to facilitate the very best opportunities / extra-curricular for their kids. Imagine how much energy you would have to put into supporting your kids education, without the pressures and time-commitment of a full-time career. This is why these women SAH. They have the money - they want to make it count! Is it any wonder, that children from wealthy families with SAHMs who focus on every aspect of their education and god knows what besides, are more likely to be 'successful' themselves?

converseandjeans · 11/03/2023 11:09

I had to go back when mine were 4 months & 6 months & would have preferred to stay home with them.

Lots of SAHM say they are busier than if they were at work. I think it depends which job you do. Surely if they really thought working would be easier they would do that?

I don't think all women love being with children so I guess there should be something in between where there is cheap and affordable childcare so babies & toddlers can go a couple of half days. The only people I know who have done this are those with well paid husbands or single parents who get some government funded hours free.

musos · 11/03/2023 11:02

Thepeopleversuswork - I can totally understand why you would feel defensive as a single mum. But really, hypothesising about the impact of SAHMs, or the impact of childcare, is a dead-end road because every child is different, every family is different, every woman is different and every job is different. Sweeping statements about SAHMs are nonsensical. Nobody is qualified to pontificate about anyone else's family set up ( as long as there are no child protection issues of course).

Lcb123 · 11/03/2023 10:55

My preference would be 2-3 days work and the rest at home. I think it’s good for kids to get used to being looked after by others from young age on those days

KievsOutTheOven · 11/03/2023 10:51

tiggergoesbounce · 11/03/2023 10:14

I have actually already explained this, several times on this thread, and actually, other SAHM’s have agreed with me

No, you actually haven't. You have not answered my question, which relates to the research you cited as relevant.

How is working out of the home for 3 months when a child is, say, 1 years old? How does that help form their professional career ??

If you grow up in a house where the mother prioritises spending time at home with the children and keeping a home over a career, that becomes your “norm”

But there are millions of women who see this and know this is exactly what they dont want to, and they ensure they do not end up in that situation and go the complete opposite. How much do you need to work ? How many hours qualify you to be producing this successful child?

If you grow up in a house where the division of labour in the house (childcare and cleaning) is even, and the woman prioritises working outside the house in some way (even part-time) then that becomes your “norm”

The study you provided shown that out of the small group they used, working women still did nearly double the chores a man did when they were both working full time, so that doesn't show that it is showing our young women anything. You can be a SAHP and still divide chores, the DH can still pull his fair share of weight with a SAHM there. As most i know do.

If you are brought up in a happy household (of either kind) you will likely want to repeat your own upbringing with your own children. There are likely to be equal numbers of happy households in each of the above camps

No, i disagree these days. I think, thankfully, women have more choice now over how they want to live their lives. Alot realise they dont have to follow what was before them and can break the norms of before and they can do whats best for them and their families (those luckily enough to have a choice)

And it would be interesting to see someone graph the number of hours worked by mums (or salaries earned by mums) with the salaries of their daughter. I’d imagine they’d find a direct correlation

So you are saying, you believe the amount of hours worked by a mother helps define the success of their daughter??? .

Some of this is not exactly rocket science to draw out conclusions from:

working mums are likely to bring more money into a household overall than a household with only one income; therefore they may be able to afford their child to attend private school/live in an area with better schools/afford tutors

Im not sure you are truly in touch with the norm of working mums, most working mums are not out their working to afford private education and tutors.

Yes, working mums will obviously bring in an income but their are many, many, many SAHM who have high earning husbands, so the household income would be more than 2 average incomes.

working mums may be more likely to be degree educated and be “career orientated” than stay at home mums (( www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/05/07/opting-out-about-10-of-highly-educated-moms-are-staying-at-home/) - it’s well documented that children of degree educated parents are more likely to go to uni than children of parents without degrees - and it’s also well documented that those who have degrees are more likely to become higher earners than those who don’t have a degree

working mums may be able to afford more activities and extra curricular activities for their children; such as sports and instruments; and these are also correlated with higher academic success. Higher scene of success is correlated with higher earning potential. ( files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1208711.pdf )

Yes, a household with a lot of money for extra curricular activitues im sure would help broaden a childs horizon but again this is just about money and income. Not mother working specific.
Your examples are just proving the child of an educated household with disposable income is more likely to do better, we all know this. So in those circumstances by your theory of examples here , all you need is money to be successful.

I don’t think that being a SAHM is necessary bad for girls - there are undoubted benefits to having a parent at home. However, I would not want my daughter to be a SAHP unless she was independently wealthy enough to not rely on her partners salary to do so; as I believe it makes women vulnerable and have to stay in unhappy relationships

Haha, isnt "necessarily" Confused Of course it isnt, for the right SAHM. A SAHM can instil exactly the same as a working mum into their kids the same as a working mum can have exactly the same "bond" with a child as a SAHM (as other mothers rave on about)

If you read back a few pages you’ll see me discuss this at length with a SAHM who agrees with me

I dont doubt you will have some that agree and some that dont, thats life and its great we all have an opinion, judgment how ever is very unhealthy and for women to drag eachother down for their choices is a disgrace.

And it’s not at all a dig at SAHM’s.
However, statistically speaking my daughter is more likely to earn more money now than if I stayed at home. It’s a fact. Does it mean she’s happier? Not necessarily. Will she be wealthy? Maybe, maybe not, but there is more chance she will be. And, sad as it may be, this means she’s more likely to have a longer, healthier life
.

Of course its not a dig at SAHM as that would be vile.
(Yes as your study shows, 3 months at the local shop and your daugher will be a high earner Confused)

The best way to get a well-balanced, kind, successful, happy child is by having well-balanced, kind, happy, and fulfilled parents(who aren't sinking financially). And that comes in many different forms. The sooner all women realise this, the better and stop pitting each other against each other, the better.

“No, you actually haven't. You have not answered my question, which relates to the research you cited as relevant.

How is working out of the home for 3 months when a child is, say, 1 years old? How does that help form their professional career ??”

Firstly, it doesn’t have to be a “professional career” - the statistics don’t break it down to job type. The statistics show that working mums are more likely to have working daughters, and their daughters are more likely to be higher earners. The scope of the study doesn’t explore why, however I would argue that it would be unusual for the only period of a mothers employment to be three months within the first year of their child’s life; especially since most working mums would be on maternity leave for most of the first year.

”But there are millions of women who see this and know this is exactly what they dont want to, and they ensure they do not end up in that situation and go the complete opposite. How much do you need to work ? How many hours qualify you to be producing this successful child?”

The statistics show you are not correct. Could you please cite a study which shows this? Statistically, working mothers are more likely to raise working daughters. It’s a fact. Just because “millions” of people (across the world?) don’t fit that statistic doesn’t mean it isn’t true.

”No, i disagree these days. I think, thankfully, women have more choice now over how they want to live their lives. Alot realise they dont have to follow what was before them and can break the norms of before and they can do whats best for them and their families (those luckily enough to have a choice”

“alot” (lol) of people, including you, may disagree. But the numbers don’t. Again, statistically working mums are more likely to raise high earning daughters who work. Do you understand how statistics work?

”So you are saying, you believe the amount of hours worked by a mother helps define the success of their daughter??? .”

Yes, I do believe there would be a correlation, I believe it would show a bell curve of distribution (as almost everything does) and I do think that perhaps, mothers working an excessive number of hours may also have a negative impact on their daughters, with “peak” earnings lying somewhere between part and full time. It would certainly be interesting to plot though!

“Im not sure you are truly in touch with the norm of working mums, most working mums are not out their working to afford private education and tutors.

Yes, working mums will obviously bring in an income but their are many, many, many SAHM who have high earning husbands, so the household income would be more than 2 average incomes.”

I know quite a bit about working mums, thank you, given that I am one 😂 no, most working mums are not working to afford private education or tutors, but increasing the household earnings certainly makes it EASIER to afford those things.

You are unwittingly proving my point though - many, many SAHM’s are relying on their husbands for survival. And that is dangerous, as it can lead to them not being able to leave unhappy relationships. Not something I’d want for my daughter. My part time salary is more than the average full time salary in the UK, for the record.

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/03/2023 10:51

@musos

The reason why people are defensive, on both sides of this debate, is precisely because most women don't have a choice. They either have to work or can't work because work doesn't make financial sense for their family. In most scenarios there is sound logic for women doing what they do with respect to work and childcare but also a strong undercurrent of emotional guilt which inclines them to justify what they do.

When you have a decision that impacts your children's welfare (arguably the most important thing in women's lives) forced on you by economic and social structures you can't control it's extremely emotionally triggering.

When research is produced that appears either to justify your case or refute it you tend to want to jump on it. I know I have done this. And although this particular study seems robust enough to me, the bottom line is that there isn't really a settled consensus about the impact of childcare on children. In more than 40 years of handwringing over this no one has produced any definitive evidence that working mothers are overall bad for children. There are nuances and special cases and extremes. But there's been no silver bullet study that shows the children of working mums underachieve at school or are more likely to suffer mental illness etc. The body of evidence just isn't there to make this case.

From my perspective: I'm a single parent and I have always had to work. There's never been any question of me taking time out to look after my child. I do bring bias to the table here and I will acknowledge that, but I can also see many women who remain at home with their children lead extremely productive lives and are good role models. And working parents owe it to SAHMs not to belittle them to shore up their own position.

But when people pop up onto chat threads and say "daycare is bad for children, end of", or "there should only be one breadwinner" or "I don't understand people who have children just to leave them in childcare", then hell yes I get defensive. Because some random on the internet is judging the way I support my child, based on no proper evidence, when I have no choice in the matter. And I will continue to get defensive about this. Sorry if it's a derail, but you asked.

musos · 11/03/2023 10:22

So much defensiveness on this thread. Some people need to ask themselves exactly WHO they are repeatedly trying to convince. It very much reads as if they are trying to convince themselves, to be honest. As for "the evidence" - you can find evidence to support any inclination.

As if a "good role model" is dependent on going to work or not. If you are working and miserable, is that a good role model? If you are a SAHM and miserable, is that a good role model?

Surely a good role model is a decent person? Not how many hours you work ffs.

tiggergoesbounce · 11/03/2023 10:14

I have actually already explained this, several times on this thread, and actually, other SAHM’s have agreed with me

No, you actually haven't. You have not answered my question, which relates to the research you cited as relevant.

How is working out of the home for 3 months when a child is, say, 1 years old? How does that help form their professional career ??

If you grow up in a house where the mother prioritises spending time at home with the children and keeping a home over a career, that becomes your “norm”

But there are millions of women who see this and know this is exactly what they dont want to, and they ensure they do not end up in that situation and go the complete opposite. How much do you need to work ? How many hours qualify you to be producing this successful child?

If you grow up in a house where the division of labour in the house (childcare and cleaning) is even, and the woman prioritises working outside the house in some way (even part-time) then that becomes your “norm”

The study you provided shown that out of the small group they used, working women still did nearly double the chores a man did when they were both working full time, so that doesn't show that it is showing our young women anything. You can be a SAHP and still divide chores, the DH can still pull his fair share of weight with a SAHM there. As most i know do.

If you are brought up in a happy household (of either kind) you will likely want to repeat your own upbringing with your own children. There are likely to be equal numbers of happy households in each of the above camps

No, i disagree these days. I think, thankfully, women have more choice now over how they want to live their lives. Alot realise they dont have to follow what was before them and can break the norms of before and they can do whats best for them and their families (those luckily enough to have a choice)

And it would be interesting to see someone graph the number of hours worked by mums (or salaries earned by mums) with the salaries of their daughter. I’d imagine they’d find a direct correlation

So you are saying, you believe the amount of hours worked by a mother helps define the success of their daughter??? .

Some of this is not exactly rocket science to draw out conclusions from:

working mums are likely to bring more money into a household overall than a household with only one income; therefore they may be able to afford their child to attend private school/live in an area with better schools/afford tutors

Im not sure you are truly in touch with the norm of working mums, most working mums are not out their working to afford private education and tutors.

Yes, working mums will obviously bring in an income but their are many, many, many SAHM who have high earning husbands, so the household income would be more than 2 average incomes.

working mums may be more likely to be degree educated and be “career orientated” than stay at home mums (( www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/05/07/opting-out-about-10-of-highly-educated-moms-are-staying-at-home/) - it’s well documented that children of degree educated parents are more likely to go to uni than children of parents without degrees - and it’s also well documented that those who have degrees are more likely to become higher earners than those who don’t have a degree

working mums may be able to afford more activities and extra curricular activities for their children; such as sports and instruments; and these are also correlated with higher academic success. Higher scene of success is correlated with higher earning potential. ( files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1208711.pdf )

Yes, a household with a lot of money for extra curricular activitues im sure would help broaden a childs horizon but again this is just about money and income. Not mother working specific.
Your examples are just proving the child of an educated household with disposable income is more likely to do better, we all know this. So in those circumstances by your theory of examples here , all you need is money to be successful.

I don’t think that being a SAHM is necessary bad for girls - there are undoubted benefits to having a parent at home. However, I would not want my daughter to be a SAHP unless she was independently wealthy enough to not rely on her partners salary to do so; as I believe it makes women vulnerable and have to stay in unhappy relationships

Haha, isnt "necessarily" Confused Of course it isnt, for the right SAHM. A SAHM can instil exactly the same as a working mum into their kids the same as a working mum can have exactly the same "bond" with a child as a SAHM (as other mothers rave on about)

If you read back a few pages you’ll see me discuss this at length with a SAHM who agrees with me

I dont doubt you will have some that agree and some that dont, thats life and its great we all have an opinion, judgment how ever is very unhealthy and for women to drag eachother down for their choices is a disgrace.

And it’s not at all a dig at SAHM’s.
However, statistically speaking my daughter is more likely to earn more money now than if I stayed at home. It’s a fact. Does it mean she’s happier? Not necessarily. Will she be wealthy? Maybe, maybe not, but there is more chance she will be. And, sad as it may be, this means she’s more likely to have a longer, healthier life
.

Of course its not a dig at SAHM as that would be vile.
(Yes as your study shows, 3 months at the local shop and your daugher will be a high earner Confused)

The best way to get a well-balanced, kind, successful, happy child is by having well-balanced, kind, happy, and fulfilled parents(who aren't sinking financially). And that comes in many different forms. The sooner all women realise this, the better and stop pitting each other against each other, the better.

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/03/2023 10:06

@MeinKraft

Mothers going to work full time is an incredibly modern invention. One parent should be paid enough to be able to support their family, perhaps with a small contribution from the other parent.

Where to start: firstly the premise is inaccurate. Throughout most of history women, with the exception of wealthy women, worked because they had to. It's only really a 30-40 year period after the end of WW2 when it became normalised for middle class women not to work. If anything the situation we are in now, where more women work than don't work, is more regression to normal than the 1950s model of a FT breadwinner and FT housewife.

Also you say one parent "should" be paid enough: who decides who "should" be paid anything? This is a factor of the economic situation of the day and the current one dictates that, certainly in large cities, few households can sustain having one breadwinner.

Finally, and most importantly: the key problem with having one parent support the whole family is that the whole family is then dependent on that one parent. If that one parent dies, or gets bored and runs off with another woman or just dicks around and doesn't pull his weight then the whole family gets dragged under by this. (And this is deliberately gendered because it is usually a man). It's a huge financial gamble for the dependent person.

The central question is whether any marginal, short-term benefits to children from having a parent at home FT outweigh the benefits to the whole family of the woman having financial security and greater authority within the household. And that's before you get onto the benefits being argued here about whether a working mother is a better role model than a SAHM.

Personally I think the benefits of having a woman work vastly outweigh those of having a woman at home for a couple more years when the children are small. I realise that there are plenty of very good reasons why women choose to remain at home and that is absolutely their choice.

But arguing that all families "should" be set up with a single breadwinner structure as if it was an open and shut case and the argument had been one is pretty specious.

AuntMarch · 11/03/2023 09:58

I would love to stay at home. To be able to do all the household stuff while he was at preschool so I could actually enjoy him when he's home would be a dream.

KievsOutTheOven · 11/03/2023 09:56

Botw1 · 11/03/2023 09:50

I can only find research on parents with lower incomes having a directly negative affect on outcomes for children

But that's not to say sahd partners aren't higher earners

I’d imagine most partners of SAHD’s would be higher earners - when my partner became a SAHD I earned more than him (although he got a very generous redundancy package so although he was a SAHD; we had significant savings to live off too)

Botw1 · 11/03/2023 09:50

@BashirWithTheGoodBeard

Absolutely

Swipe left for the next trending thread