Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Student finance and UC

61 replies

Wingingit202122 · 10/03/2023 07:14

Need some balanced opinions here!
Single parent of 3 and I have just started a undergrad degree course at University. Just had my Universal Credit statement come through and they are deducting all of my student finance from my monthly payment (Gone from £1300 to £600) as they class it as an income
Im pretty p’d off to say the least for 2 reasons

  1. I was only being deducted £280 a month when I was working and making more money a month than the student finance pays
  2. STUDENT FINANCE IS A LOAN! We have to pay the student finance back WITH INTEREST so I am majorly p’d at effectively having to pay it back twice. (Once through UC deduction and again back to SF)
OP posts:
Ylvamoon · 10/03/2023 09:01

Why can you lend money to buy a car/house and still get UC/Carers allowance, but take out a loan for education and you can't

You won't get housing benefit / UC to pay off your mortgage.

And buying a car via a bank/ credit institution loan isn't the same as getting a government loan for student living. The nature of the loan is different, the T&C's are very different and the way you pay it back is very different.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 10/03/2023 08:55

Ponoka7 · 10/03/2023 08:36

That doesn't necessarily apply to housing benefit, which is now lumped in with UC. They can end up worse off. For smaller courses the funding much beyond the course costs aren't covered The new style UC isn't just for job seekers, it's an overall benefit. Not getting that benefit means that you aren't automatically entitled to other add ons. As asked why is student finance the only loan that stops the payment of benefits? You haven't had extra income because you have to pay it back. Why can you lend money to buy a car/house and still get UC/Carers allowance, but take out a loan for education and you can't?

UC is a benefit used mostly to prop up your earnings and I would assume (not that I agree witht this) that it would be the opinion of HMRC that if you have the time to do a degree you have the time to work more hours.

Also any student finance counts as non taxable income therefore is fully deductible, £ for £, from you UC claim.

Babyroobs · 10/03/2023 08:41

Ponoka7 · 10/03/2023 08:36

That doesn't necessarily apply to housing benefit, which is now lumped in with UC. They can end up worse off. For smaller courses the funding much beyond the course costs aren't covered The new style UC isn't just for job seekers, it's an overall benefit. Not getting that benefit means that you aren't automatically entitled to other add ons. As asked why is student finance the only loan that stops the payment of benefits? You haven't had extra income because you have to pay it back. Why can you lend money to buy a car/house and still get UC/Carers allowance, but take out a loan for education and you can't?

If people are not eligible for a student maintenance loan then they wouldn't have anything deducted ? Your post doesn't make sense at all ?

Babyroobs · 10/03/2023 08:40

Ponoka7 · 10/03/2023 08:36

That doesn't necessarily apply to housing benefit, which is now lumped in with UC. They can end up worse off. For smaller courses the funding much beyond the course costs aren't covered The new style UC isn't just for job seekers, it's an overall benefit. Not getting that benefit means that you aren't automatically entitled to other add ons. As asked why is student finance the only loan that stops the payment of benefits? You haven't had extra income because you have to pay it back. Why can you lend money to buy a car/house and still get UC/Carers allowance, but take out a loan for education and you can't?

Because if you are taking a loan to buy a car, then you buy the care- you don't have the loan available to you to live off each month ?

Ponoka7 · 10/03/2023 08:36

Babyroobs · 10/03/2023 08:13

That is my point - people can still afford them as they are no worse off by claiming student loan than claiming UC. It's not like they are facing a sudden drop in income that makes them at a disadvantage ?

That doesn't necessarily apply to housing benefit, which is now lumped in with UC. They can end up worse off. For smaller courses the funding much beyond the course costs aren't covered The new style UC isn't just for job seekers, it's an overall benefit. Not getting that benefit means that you aren't automatically entitled to other add ons. As asked why is student finance the only loan that stops the payment of benefits? You haven't had extra income because you have to pay it back. Why can you lend money to buy a car/house and still get UC/Carers allowance, but take out a loan for education and you can't?

Vegrocks · 10/03/2023 08:30

I am very much hoping your degree doesn’t involve finances (or anything related to numbers)

or requires any kind of research

Babyroobs · 10/03/2023 08:18

Sarahcoggles · 10/03/2023 08:15

Also the thing that makes a student loan unique is that it's a government loan, with very generous Ts&Cs, so it's not the same as a normal loan (which obviously wouldn't affect your UC)

Yes absolutely. And realistically many don't start paying back their student loan for years until they meet the earnings threshold.

Babyroobs · 10/03/2023 08:17

Sarahcoggles · 10/03/2023 08:14

Isn't UC in lieu of earnings, for people who haven't got a job, but are presumably looking for a job? But if you're a student you can't get a job because you're studying. So instead you get a government loan.
I can't think of a situation in which someone would get both? Otherwise all students would claim UC as well as their loan wouldn't they?

Yes exactly and it's likely op will continue to get a significant amount of Uc still as she has 3 kids. Someone who is disabled would be able to still get UC, a young person who is single and disabled would likely still get some UC. Child maintenance is also not counted or deducted from UC in any way so many lone parents would also have that on top and yes I appreciate not all get it but many do.

Sarahcoggles · 10/03/2023 08:15

Also the thing that makes a student loan unique is that it's a government loan, with very generous Ts&Cs, so it's not the same as a normal loan (which obviously wouldn't affect your UC)

Babyroobs · 10/03/2023 08:15

Ponoka7 · 10/03/2023 08:10

It isn't fair. If you were getting a loan for any other purpose, it wouldn't be counted for income, so why a loan for education?
Up until the late 2000's there were lots of free courses for mature students to do, up to degree level, now they have to be paid for and these rules effect all 19+ year olds.

@Babyroobs , there are lots of careers which benefit from mature students, groups such as LP, the disabled, care leavers etc, such as Nursing and SW. Education choices shouldn't just be for those who can afford them. You've got to look at the overall benefit to society of people being able to increase their earnings and further their education, as well as the experience they bring to the organisations they go into.

And disabled students can still continue to get a significant amount of UC whilst studying especially if getting PIP and the LCWRA element of UC.

Sarahcoggles · 10/03/2023 08:14

Isn't UC in lieu of earnings, for people who haven't got a job, but are presumably looking for a job? But if you're a student you can't get a job because you're studying. So instead you get a government loan.
I can't think of a situation in which someone would get both? Otherwise all students would claim UC as well as their loan wouldn't they?

Babyroobs · 10/03/2023 08:13

Ponoka7 · 10/03/2023 08:10

It isn't fair. If you were getting a loan for any other purpose, it wouldn't be counted for income, so why a loan for education?
Up until the late 2000's there were lots of free courses for mature students to do, up to degree level, now they have to be paid for and these rules effect all 19+ year olds.

@Babyroobs , there are lots of careers which benefit from mature students, groups such as LP, the disabled, care leavers etc, such as Nursing and SW. Education choices shouldn't just be for those who can afford them. You've got to look at the overall benefit to society of people being able to increase their earnings and further their education, as well as the experience they bring to the organisations they go into.

That is my point - people can still afford them as they are no worse off by claiming student loan than claiming UC. It's not like they are facing a sudden drop in income that makes them at a disadvantage ?

Ponoka7 · 10/03/2023 08:10

It isn't fair. If you were getting a loan for any other purpose, it wouldn't be counted for income, so why a loan for education?
Up until the late 2000's there were lots of free courses for mature students to do, up to degree level, now they have to be paid for and these rules effect all 19+ year olds.

@Babyroobs , there are lots of careers which benefit from mature students, groups such as LP, the disabled, care leavers etc, such as Nursing and SW. Education choices shouldn't just be for those who can afford them. You've got to look at the overall benefit to society of people being able to increase their earnings and further their education, as well as the experience they bring to the organisations they go into.

Ylvamoon · 10/03/2023 08:08

Your Student Maintenance Loan is paid to you for living expenses.

So yes, why do you think it shouldn't be deducted from your UC?

Otherwise every student over 18 would be entitled to a full amount of UC ....

Vegrocks · 10/03/2023 08:05

Wingingit202122 · 10/03/2023 07:47

Actually no-one, Student finance, UC or any online calculator can tell you what will be deducted from the SF until AFTER you apply. So no, I had no idea this much would be deducted

Of course you could

it is very straightforward the deductions

Babyroobs · 10/03/2023 08:05

Wingingit202122 · 10/03/2023 08:03

Of course it is paying it back twice. For the next 3 yrs my student finance is deducted from my UC on a monthly basis of over £700 so that’s over £25000 from my SF entitlement
Once I graduate SF will want me to start repaying my loan and being 29 I am pretty sure I will have repaid most, if not all, of it

How are you paying it back twice ? UD is free money in the first place ! Student loan is being taken off that and then you repay the student loan later ( maybe ).

Wingingit202122 · 10/03/2023 08:03

Swiftswatch · 10/03/2023 07:45

You aren’t paying it back twice though, that implies you would be unconditionally eligible for UC regardless.
SF is counted as income, if you have other sources of income you don’t need the same support from the state.

Of course it is paying it back twice. For the next 3 yrs my student finance is deducted from my UC on a monthly basis of over £700 so that’s over £25000 from my SF entitlement
Once I graduate SF will want me to start repaying my loan and being 29 I am pretty sure I will have repaid most, if not all, of it

OP posts:
IhearyouClemFandango · 10/03/2023 08:01

But you're not paying it back twice. UC isn't yours in the first place, so they're not taking it from you, just not giving it to you as you have another income source.

Babyroobs · 10/03/2023 08:00

Wingingit202122 · 10/03/2023 07:58

Where does it say on their website that they deduct the whole amount every month? When I was working it was 55p deducted for every £ earned so why would anyone think it was now £ for £?

UC is designed to encourage people to work, that is why earnings are deducted at a taper rate of 55p in the pound. Student loan is not earned income so is deducted pound for pound as are private pensions, state pensions etc.

Wingingit202122 · 10/03/2023 07:58

gogohmm · 10/03/2023 07:53

@Wingingit202122

The fact that uc takes student finance into account is on the student finance and universal credit websites!

Where does it say on their website that they deduct the whole amount every month? When I was working it was 55p deducted for every £ earned so why would anyone think it was now £ for £?

OP posts:
Wingingit202122 · 10/03/2023 07:55

coffeetofunction · 10/03/2023 07:51

I can understand your frustration. I'm hoping to start an undergraduate in September and I'm already worried about how I will manage. My eldest will be doing an additional year at college before uni so I will be supporting him as well. I know I'll have to work in addition to full time uni and placements. Good luck with the degree OP

All i can advise is to start putting some savings away now! Good luck with it all x

OP posts:
Wingingit202122 · 10/03/2023 07:54

Swiftswatch · 10/03/2023 07:49

I imagine it’s also because you’re viewing the SF as the per month equivalent but it’s paid in one chunk for the term which is why the deduction is higher now.

It’s UC who have divided it into monthly amounts so therefore i will be having the same deduction every month for the next 3 yrs. They will even deduct it over summer when i’m not actually studying

OP posts:
gogohmm · 10/03/2023 07:53

@Wingingit202122

The fact that uc takes student finance into account is on the student finance and universal credit websites!

Wingingit202122 · 10/03/2023 07:52

megletthesecond · 10/03/2023 07:44

It's really unfair and prevents single parents improving their earning prospects.

Exactly! There have been many on my course who have already withdrawn (started in jan) as they can’t afford to actually continue. I know it’s for the best to stay on but in reality it’s going to be a hard 3 yrs

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 10/03/2023 07:52

megletthesecond · 10/03/2023 07:44

It's really unfair and prevents single parents improving their earning prospects.

Why does it prevent people improving their earning potential ? no-one ends up worse off my claiming student finance instead of UC, you would get roughly the same amount overall, but just paying some of it back later.

Swipe left for the next trending thread