Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think I'm not on the class WhatsApp because of DS's SN?

113 replies

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 07:06

DC1 (Yr6) has ASD. He doesn't really have any friends (there's one boy who will chat with him if no one else is around to see, will call for him to play on the Switch if he has no other plans) and is mostly left alone at school. He hasn't been bullied since Yr2. He is never invited to other people's houses, people decline invites to us, has never been invited to a birthday party etc etc. He is not violent, noisy, over-active, obnoxious or anything, he is simply far more childish than his peers and has unusual interests. At break times he plays with the younger children. Most parents are quite stand-offish at parent's events, some resent that DC1 is allowed to use a computer for some work and has a TA for a few lessons a week.

DC2 (Yr5) has many friends and a truly lovely class, and I know I could call pretty much anyone on the class list if I needed help in an emergency. The parents from Yr 6 who do talk to me are those who either also have a sibling in Yr 5 or whose Yr6 child is in a sports team with DC2.

There is a class WhatsApp for Yr5, started by the parents rep and running since Yr3, where random messages about homework and gifts for the teacher pop up. Most recently the return time from the combined Yr5&Yr6 residential. Teacher called first parent on the class list to let them know and parent posted to the WhatsApp chat.

DC1 didn't go on the residential. I find it hard to believe the teacher wrote an email whilst on the coach back and added all 25 other parents individually rather than use the Yr6 mailing list. Especially as he knew DC2 was on the trip. I also don't really believe the parents followed the telephone list and didn't call me because most didn't know DC1 wasn't going. I therefore suspect that there is a class WhatsApp also for Yr6 to which I am not invited.

However, there could be another explanation as to how all the other parents were notified. And the class has the same teacher for two years so there hasn't been a need for a whole group message about an end of year gift yet. Although come to think of there was an issue at the end of Yr4 for the class gift.

YABU - you're overthinking and being paranoid, of course there's no WhatsApp group.
YANBU - probably there is.

OP posts:
WolfFoxHare · 10/03/2023 08:38

Vegrocks · 10/03/2023 07:52

So this mother confronted you and said she and others thought it was unfair your child used the computer?

Why are you being so aggressive with the OP? Is it so unbelievable that one or more parents might be left off the WhatsApp, accidentally or others?! I don’t understand why you’re so convinced she’s wrong, and taking such a hostile tone? Maybe calm down a bit?

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 08:37

@Vegrocks actually I never said that. I said DC2 has lots of friends.

OP posts:
Spanglemum · 10/03/2023 08:36

The OP says that she's not in the UK so things about the phone lists etc are different. I have children with ADHD and ASD and you do get excluded. They good thing is once they go to secondary schools you don't have to deal with other parents any more.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 10/03/2023 08:32

OP yanbu, I’m sorry though because it’s a sucky feeling.

@vegrocks lay off. If you and your kid have never experienced any sort of discrimination with their adhd then you’re lucky. You’ve proven well enough that you don’t think discrimination exists and you’re wrong about that.

Vegrocks · 10/03/2023 08:29

Op

You say you have friends in this class (those with children in your other child’s class).

Surely they would have told you OR you could… ask??

Huntzberger · 10/03/2023 08:26

It's a horrible feeling isn't it. I'm in a similar position except I know full well there's a group because my neighbour, who has a child in the same year as mine and I suppose can't so easily avoid me, sometimes reads bits of it to me.

I'll say 'have you heard about xyz?' And she'll pull out her phone and say 'oh yes, we were talking about that on the mums' group chat...' while I wonder how you get through life without realising how hurtful you're being.

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 08:21

PS I am aware how ridiculous that sounds!

OP posts:
Pasithean · 10/03/2023 08:20

DIL refuses to be on any WhatsApp etc due to bullying on there by parents. Fuckem if they don’t want to include your kid. It’s their loss.

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 08:20

Our school website lists the staff and their roles - so it shows which classes have a class at and which TAs provide individual SEN support.
At one point (last year) they actually listed on their website X. Yyyyyy Role: T.A. Yr 5. D.C. where D.C. were DC's initials. I was not amused....

I am debating. To ask or not to ask. To wait and see about leavers' stuff / teacher gifts. I was hoping it would be a resounding YABU. So now I don't know if I want to know.

OP posts:
underneaththeash · 10/03/2023 08:17

GPDR wouldn't allow the teacher to be on a what's app group, it's not something official comms can go through.

There probably a what's app group though. But, he's in year 6 and going to finish soon, so is it really worth getting concerned about it now, especially when he socialised with the younger children anyway.

Vegrocks · 10/03/2023 08:08

The parents from Yr 6 who do talk to me are those who either also have a sibling in Yr 5 or whose Yr6 child is in a sports team with DC2.

can you not ask any of the above?

Soontobe60 · 10/03/2023 08:08

Vegrocks · 10/03/2023 08:01

How on earth do you know all this? At my school it’s very private re which children have extra support and the extent of that

I’m pretty sure it would be obvious that a child inA wheelchair has TA support. As for the other info, the OP hasn’t said she knows which children have support, just that there IS support provided. Our school website lists the staff and their roles - so it shows which classes have a class at and which TAs provide individual SEN support.

LesserBohemians · 10/03/2023 08:06

HubertTheGoat · 10/03/2023 07:38

It's perhaps different as we don't get phone lists here, but I've never known anyone to be in charge of a WA group. It's everyone's own responsibility to ask someone to add them to the group if they want to be on it.

I also find the idea of teachers still using telephone trees bizarre! I wouldn't trust everyone on the list to do as asked. Do they not just have a program so they can just text all parents?

This. In the UK and Irish schools DS has attended, the school is extremely clear on the fact that class WhatsApp groups are not school lists, and school will never communicate via them, any disputes etc are not a school issue.

I only discovered DS’s first English school had a class WhatsApp during the nativity play in Year 2, when the mothers of his classmates were posting on it on either side of me. I just asked to be added. I think I hadn’t been added because I was one of the two WOH mothers in a class of 27, was foreign, and wasn’t much liked — it was easy to overlook me, or ‘overlook’ me. I didn’t take it personally. It was that kind of environment.

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 08:06

I know that because DS's TA has e.g. asked him to bring his homework (he didn't hand in on time) to reception on Tuesday as he'll be with L, and DS has told me.
The floating TA is listed on both DC1 and DC2's timetable, this year and previous years, and I know parents with DC in lower years whose younger DC love it when TA is in class => TA spends roughly same amount of time in each class. Everyone knows about child in wheelchair (and rallied round when she was having treatment which paralysed her) plus her she has a sibling in each of my DC's classes so I randomly chatted to her mum when we were the only parents of older DC still doing pick up.

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 10/03/2023 08:05

Vegrocks · 10/03/2023 07:53

And your son is the only child that is ND? And the only child that requires any extra support?

Unlikely

No it’s not. Most classes will have a range of children with SEN, but not to the point that they have 1-1 TA support through an EHCP, or use tech regularly. In my current school, which is 2 form entry, we have 10 children with EHCPs, 5 of whom have 1-1 support. My previous school had 1 EHCP and no TAs in any of the KS2 classes - they shared a TA every morning.

tourdefrance · 10/03/2023 08:04

DS1 also has ASD. I discovered there was a class WhatsApp a matter of weeks before he left Y6 (several years ago). I was added when I asked. We had been quite a social group from Reception onwards and I had the numbers of several of the mums.

I’m pretty certain there was a WhatsApp for DS2’s class as well. He also has ASD but more obviously so. The only mum friends I had in his year group were ones with older siblings in DS1’s year or a couple from nursery. Friends is an exaggeration tbh.

DS2 is in y8 now and I’m not in touch with a single one of the mums (or dads) I saw almost daily (except for Covid) for 10 years at the school gate. Having a kid or kids with SN is bloody lonely.

yanbu

Vegrocks · 10/03/2023 08:03

The parents from Yr 6 who do talk to me are those who either also have a sibling in Yr 5 or whose Yr6 child is in a sports team with DC2.

Ask them 🤷‍♀️

Soontobe60 · 10/03/2023 08:02

Vegrocks · 10/03/2023 07:47

So a mother (shit stirrer) told you that some parents resent your son using the computer? And you have just accepted that as fact

Oh believe me, this does not surprise me. Many parents will ask me if their little dear can use a computer “Joe” does because their offspring thinks it’s unfair that they’ve got to use a pencil to write. I even had this from 1 parent when the child using the computer had cerebral palsy and could only use 1 arm!

Vegrocks · 10/03/2023 08:01

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 07:59

@Vegrocks There are three children in the school with whom the TA works 1:1.
There is another "floating" TA who sits in on 4 lessons a week with each class and e.g. takes a group to work with. One child in the school has a personal TA (rather than educational) to help with personal care, picking up books etc as she is in a wheelchair.

How on earth do you know all this? At my school it’s very private re which children have extra support and the extent of that

Prettypaisleyslippers · 10/03/2023 08:01

Teachers don’t use the year group WhatsApp in my school. Ask to be added? Mine is helpful for reminders

Vegrocks · 10/03/2023 08:00

My son has adhd

I am not gas lighting

but quite clearly there was a separate group. The op wasn’t invited. Because it wasn’t relevant to her

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 07:59

@Vegrocks There are three children in the school with whom the TA works 1:1.
There is another "floating" TA who sits in on 4 lessons a week with each class and e.g. takes a group to work with. One child in the school has a personal TA (rather than educational) to help with personal care, picking up books etc as she is in a wheelchair.

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 10/03/2023 07:58

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 07:32

She would not contact the first person on the telephone list and trust that it would be posted. I think they'd text or email every Y6 parent but elect to remove you because it would be poor taste as your son didn't go.

No, that's not how it works. The telephone list is in two columns. If the teacher has an urgent message to communicate she calls the first two parents on each column, who call the next etc and the last two on each column have to call the teacher and confirm the message is delivered!

My DC2 was also on the trip and her teacher definitely didn't email or text every parent. She called the first on the list who immediately posted on the parent only WhatsApp rather than run through the telephone list. Also DC1's teacher knew DC2 was on the coach with him so I would need to know when they were back anyway. Can't see him creating extra work for himself for no real reason.

@Shinyandnew1 polite chit-chat with one parent at the supermarket when she mentioned that she and a couple of others think it's unfair DS gets to use a computer sometimes and their DC would like to use one too...

If we did this in any school I have taught in we would be in big trouble! It’s incredibly unprofessional to expect messages from a teacher to parents to be delivered 2nd, 3rd, 4th hand. We use a texting app in which we send messages that go to all parents, and we would NEVER divulge contact details to other parents. We do t even give out class name lists for Christmas cards anymore. Massive GDPR fail.

Shinyandnew1 · 10/03/2023 07:57

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 07:50

Well yes. She was pretty clear that she finds it unfair that her DS isn't also allowed to. So yes, I took that as a fact.

Goodness, well isn’t she forthcoming with her views.

Vegrocks · 10/03/2023 07:57

You have friends in this class (the ones that have children in your other child’s class).

ask them about the underground watsapp group (and don’t be surprised if you see a look of confusion cross their face!)

Swipe left for the next trending thread