Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think I'm not on the class WhatsApp because of DS's SN?

113 replies

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 07:06

DC1 (Yr6) has ASD. He doesn't really have any friends (there's one boy who will chat with him if no one else is around to see, will call for him to play on the Switch if he has no other plans) and is mostly left alone at school. He hasn't been bullied since Yr2. He is never invited to other people's houses, people decline invites to us, has never been invited to a birthday party etc etc. He is not violent, noisy, over-active, obnoxious or anything, he is simply far more childish than his peers and has unusual interests. At break times he plays with the younger children. Most parents are quite stand-offish at parent's events, some resent that DC1 is allowed to use a computer for some work and has a TA for a few lessons a week.

DC2 (Yr5) has many friends and a truly lovely class, and I know I could call pretty much anyone on the class list if I needed help in an emergency. The parents from Yr 6 who do talk to me are those who either also have a sibling in Yr 5 or whose Yr6 child is in a sports team with DC2.

There is a class WhatsApp for Yr5, started by the parents rep and running since Yr3, where random messages about homework and gifts for the teacher pop up. Most recently the return time from the combined Yr5&Yr6 residential. Teacher called first parent on the class list to let them know and parent posted to the WhatsApp chat.

DC1 didn't go on the residential. I find it hard to believe the teacher wrote an email whilst on the coach back and added all 25 other parents individually rather than use the Yr6 mailing list. Especially as he knew DC2 was on the trip. I also don't really believe the parents followed the telephone list and didn't call me because most didn't know DC1 wasn't going. I therefore suspect that there is a class WhatsApp also for Yr6 to which I am not invited.

However, there could be another explanation as to how all the other parents were notified. And the class has the same teacher for two years so there hasn't been a need for a whole group message about an end of year gift yet. Although come to think of there was an issue at the end of Yr4 for the class gift.

YABU - you're overthinking and being paranoid, of course there's no WhatsApp group.
YANBU - probably there is.

OP posts:
LookItsMeAgain · 10/03/2023 09:40

My advice would be to email the school secretary because they clearly have a system in place (the phone tree) and ask them to liaise with the parent rep for your older son's class to ensure that all parents/guardians are included on the class WhatsApp group, so that any notification gets circulated to ALL parents/guardians at all times. Then it is up to the parent/guardian whether the message relates to their child or not.

zingally · 10/03/2023 09:39

Maybe I'm mis-reading, but if your DC1 didn't go on the trip anyway, why did you need a notification about it?

Is it likely that this is less about a whatsapp group, and more about the fact that your DC1, and you by proxy, have had a fairly miserable primary school experience? Especially when seen in contrast with DC2s experience.

And what's with the negative talk around the one boy he is friendly with?

He talks to him at school, but...
He calls for him at home, but...
Maybe try a little harder to encourage the friendship?

But for what its worth, Year 6 is nearly over. It's 4 months. Put these people, and all the associated petty drama out of your head, and concentrate on getting your DC over the finish line and start looking ahead to secondary.

BrutusMcDogface · 10/03/2023 09:36

HMTheQueenMuffin · 10/03/2023 07:10

I would flat out ask if there is one and ask to be put on it. It might simply be an oversight.

Actually, I probably need to ask to be on ours. I am not on it (resisted for both DCs for a good 3 years now) after the great Wtsapp blowup scandal of 2018 where one mother photo dumped pics of her DD winning a swimming comp on it and another called her a cunt.

😂😂😂 brilliant! I mute the WhatsApp parent groups and check them every now and then.

I think you’re being a little paranoid, op. I agree you should ask outright.

MeridianB · 10/03/2023 09:35

I'm really sad to read how your son is treated - and how parents ignore you. Is it worth exploring meet-ups or time with the Y5 kids for him if he prefers their company?

At our school they are red hot on data protection and the school office sends an email at the start of the year with the number for the WA group, which parents can then choose to join or not. I'd just check with school office and ask them to contact the rep to add you.

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 09:27

@VictorStrand most parents were surprised to see him at the pick-up point. Ergo most didn't know he didn't go. So unless the original message of the telephone list was "coach will be back early at 1545, don't call Always, her DS didn't go"...

OP posts:
redskylight · 10/03/2023 09:27

In this day and age it seems very odd that the school's method of communication is to get parents to ring down a list, rather than using emails or text messages (or DC's school does both).

I wouldn't assume there is a class WhatsApp group though - this is the sort of information that gets passed round by word of mouth. And do some of the children have their own phones?

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 09:24

Can school secretary contact you?
The secretary only works Mon & Wed mornings.

@Mortimercat & @inappropriateraspberry I got the message about the coach return through the Yr 5 parents WhatsApp group.

There were no emails or texts from teachers.

I was idly wondering how all the Yr 6 parents found out when the coach would be back.

OP posts:
VictorStrand · 10/03/2023 09:23

Why would you not assume that Y6 used the 'call the next parent' process but didn't call you because your DS wasn't on the trip?

Maybe it's different in your school but we have had years where there is a WhatsApp group and years where they don't have one. Even when there is one, not all parents are on it.

Fifi0000 · 10/03/2023 09:22

I can't believe the school are contacting over WhatsApp what about the GDPR regulations? If DD is late getting back from residential I receive an email and telephone call from the office. The bus crashed one time (minor) and the school rang me imagine how much more parents would get into a tizz if they found out over WhatsApp ? I've never felt a need to get involved in all that , DD gets invited to parties and she hands me the letters. The school should be contacting you and there's no need for a school whatsapp at a certain age.

sjxoxo · 10/03/2023 09:18

We also live abroad and tbh I think the culture can be so different that many responses here wouldn’t really make any sense to the (native) parents’ or teacher. I would approach the teacher directly and say is there a way she can communicate directly with you or with everyone as the current system isn’t working and WhatsApp isn’t sufficient to pass on official info. Can school secretary contact you? WhatsApp is too informal for this sort of info imo. It can be hard if you are living in another culture where communication is challenging, even if there’s no language barrier there is still difficulties in accessing information like others would be able to. Which country are you in? I would approach the school directly if I were you xxx

Mortimercat · 10/03/2023 09:18

inappropriateraspberry · 10/03/2023 07:51

I'm a little lost from your OP. Did you not get the message at all, or are the teachers aware you're not on the WhatsApp groups and emailed you but you think they wouldn't have emailed everyone else?
If the latter, they could have a group email set up for each year with the other recipients addresses hidden for privacy/security.

A little lost. I am absolutely baffled as to what OP means - other than she does seem to think there is a huge conspiracy somewhere.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 10/03/2023 09:14

I don't really know any other parents at my sons school and we got to the whatsapp group in a convoluted way via a local facebook group, then a class facebook group, then a whatsapp. If I didn't use facebook I would never have ended up on it tbh.

I should probably make a bit more of an effort with the other mums as he is only 5 at the moment but will probably want to do stuff with friends in the future. Food for thought. My son is also 'young' for his year with suspected ADHD.

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 09:11

Is tour child leaving the school at the end of year six?
yes. All will go to technically the same secondary, although it is split across two buildings, and essentially run as two separate schools.

OP posts:
Fifi0000 · 10/03/2023 09:05

Do schools really have a class WhatsApp? My DDs school doesn't and I wouldn't be bothered if I wasn't invited. In year 5/6 the kids bring you the letters updates and I get an email once a week from them. It's really not needed and I don't think my DD would be happy she gets embarrassed. I think this age the parents start pulling back naturally from schools as more parents work full time and the DC generally become more independent. I wouldn't get upset about it.

ZeldaB · 10/03/2023 09:05

I’d be surprised if there was no wattsapp group at all for your year. But you may not have been excluded maliciously.

Is tour child leaving the school at the end of year six? If so I’d just leave it all alone, but if you are stuck with these people next year maybe the nicest parent if there is a wattsapp group and to add you.

Lwrenagain · 10/03/2023 09:05

HMTheQueenMuffin · 10/03/2023 07:10

I would flat out ask if there is one and ask to be put on it. It might simply be an oversight.

Actually, I probably need to ask to be on ours. I am not on it (resisted for both DCs for a good 3 years now) after the great Wtsapp blowup scandal of 2018 where one mother photo dumped pics of her DD winning a swimming comp on it and another called her a cunt.

This really cheered me up 😂😂😂

Justalittlebitduckling · 10/03/2023 09:04

I’m a school governor and there’s been a lot of drama on class WhatsApp groups, including negative comments about particular children and their behaviour. Bad enough that it went all the way up to governors to deal with. Tricky because the school don’t have any power to deal with them, because they’re completely separate from the school but they can affect the dynamics on the playground.

coffeeisthebest · 10/03/2023 09:02

Hi OP, in your title you asked if you are not on the WhatsApp group because of your child's special needs. This isn't what you are asking though, this appears to be solely about you and some pretty hefty assumptions being made about other parents. Maybe take a breather, have a conversation directly with another year 6 parent and ask if there is a WhatsApp group, and try not to make sweeping generalisations because one parent said their kid would like to use a laptop in class.

Justalittlebitduckling · 10/03/2023 09:01

I would just send a message to the Year 5 group saying, hi please could someone add me to the year 6 group. Thanks. (If there’s other parents with DC in both year groups).

ProposedWarning · 10/03/2023 08:55

OP I would just ask directly. Mention your other child’s class has one and you just wanted to check. In a relaxed curious way rather than upset manner.

I don’t have a child with SEN or know anyone in that position. But I can believe these stories and I am so disappointed at the ostracising going on. As if these families don’t have enough going on. Who blanks a family because their child has extra needs?? Just awful. I have nothing useful to add but I am really sorry this is happening to people.

HikingforScenery · 10/03/2023 08:55

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 07:06

DC1 (Yr6) has ASD. He doesn't really have any friends (there's one boy who will chat with him if no one else is around to see, will call for him to play on the Switch if he has no other plans) and is mostly left alone at school. He hasn't been bullied since Yr2. He is never invited to other people's houses, people decline invites to us, has never been invited to a birthday party etc etc. He is not violent, noisy, over-active, obnoxious or anything, he is simply far more childish than his peers and has unusual interests. At break times he plays with the younger children. Most parents are quite stand-offish at parent's events, some resent that DC1 is allowed to use a computer for some work and has a TA for a few lessons a week.

DC2 (Yr5) has many friends and a truly lovely class, and I know I could call pretty much anyone on the class list if I needed help in an emergency. The parents from Yr 6 who do talk to me are those who either also have a sibling in Yr 5 or whose Yr6 child is in a sports team with DC2.

There is a class WhatsApp for Yr5, started by the parents rep and running since Yr3, where random messages about homework and gifts for the teacher pop up. Most recently the return time from the combined Yr5&Yr6 residential. Teacher called first parent on the class list to let them know and parent posted to the WhatsApp chat.

DC1 didn't go on the residential. I find it hard to believe the teacher wrote an email whilst on the coach back and added all 25 other parents individually rather than use the Yr6 mailing list. Especially as he knew DC2 was on the trip. I also don't really believe the parents followed the telephone list and didn't call me because most didn't know DC1 wasn't going. I therefore suspect that there is a class WhatsApp also for Yr6 to which I am not invited.

However, there could be another explanation as to how all the other parents were notified. And the class has the same teacher for two years so there hasn't been a need for a whole group message about an end of year gift yet. Although come to think of there was an issue at the end of Yr4 for the class gift.

YABU - you're overthinking and being paranoid, of course there's no WhatsApp group.
YANBU - probably there is.

It’s very likely there is one and you’re not on it because of your DS’s SEN.
Are you missing out on anything by not being on there?

AlwaysTheOutsider · 10/03/2023 08:51

😂😂
There were 45 kids at the start of the residential.
DS was the only one who didn't go, this wasn't widely advertised as DS didn't want the other children asking questions as to why he wasn't going.

There was no "residential update" group from the teachers. My other child was there.

I accept I may well be being paranoid.

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 10/03/2023 08:45

I would expect they had a group for the residential. We got messages all the way through when ours were on residential.

"Every single child slept at least 8 hours and has got up joyfully and loved eating a huge breakfast. They are now super excited on their way to their first activity. Head"*

They were irritating enough when you had a child on the residential. I would imagine if you didn't, particularly if you were feeling a little upset because they didn't, it would have been worse. I'd totally expect them to have a separate group for the residential.

*Other than the fact it was unlikely that every one of 120 children did this, one of dd's friends said a couple of week later. "we didn't go to sleep before 2am any night and our room was next to the head's. On the last night he stormed in at 4am and shouted that if we weren't quiet and go to sleep then we weren't coming to the disco that evening."
I showed her the text and she gave an indignant gasp and said "he lied!" 🤣🤣

donttellmehesalive · 10/03/2023 08:44

I really do think it's unlikely that you were intentionally excluded from a parent WhatsApp group.

I mean, which parents would think 'I'll set up a class group for lost jumpers and so on, but not that parent, that one with the kid who gets extra support, she can fuck off.'

donttellmehesalive · 10/03/2023 08:42

If school policy is to pass a message to the first person on a telephone list, and for the message to filter down the list, maybe that is how the trip message for Y6 was passed on.

I know Year 5 have a WhatsApp group and that the message was posted there by a parent (possibly in addition to the telephone list) but that doesn't mean that Year 6 did it the same way.

I think it's more likely that there isn't a WhatsApp group than you were left out because your child has SEN.

I also think you sound paranoid about jealousy/resentment of the provision he receives. A parent might comment that they wish their child had more support, or could use a laptop, or whatever it is, but that doesn't mean they're angry enough to exclude you as that child's parent from a WhatsApp group.