Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel unsafe when cyclists use pavements illegally?

141 replies

BridgeWalkingVideo · 09/03/2023 23:34

Looking for constructive advice and views on how to handle cyclists illegally using one of the two pavements on a busy road across a bridge in London.

The video at the link below (8 mins) was taken when I walked across the bridge on the narrower 'no cycling' pavement at about 9am on Monday.

In the video there are several instances of potentially hazardous moments, and some reckless behaviour at the end (the cyclist going too fast and nearly ending up in the road). My experience of walking across this bridge on that side is that this is all too common, and cyclists should not be using that pavement.

Cyclists do continue to use this 'no cycling' pavement (in part because the signage at the start and end is confusing), but should be dismounting and crossing the road to use the pavement on the other side of the road (which is marked as shared) or indeed the road itself (but I quite understand why cyclists would prefer not to use the road at that point). I believe the 'no cycling' restriction was brought into effect in 2021 (both pavements were shared use before that).

I do also have a video (not uploaded yet) from walking across the bridge on the other side (the shared side), which to be honest despite being slightly wider is still not great (it also having a bus stop narrowing the pavement being one reason).

So which pavement should I as a pedestrian use? The narrower pavement for pedestrians that cyclists use illegally but where I would be safer if the rules were followed, or the wider shared pavement where it might be safe if everyone rode with due care and attention? Or should I just get the bus across the bridge? 😕

And what about people with mobility issues or sensory impairments that will be more at risk? Am I being unreasonable to think that these instances of a shared pedestrian-cycle space (one legal, one illegal) are inherently unsafe, or does the 'no cycling' side need to be enforced so that the design works as intended?

Would it be unreasonable of me to ask cyclists to stop cycling on the 'no cycling' pavement?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
purpledalmation · 10/03/2023 09:41

As a pedestrian it wouldn't bother me. There's enough space for pedestrians to move near the wall and for the cyclist to go nearer the road. If it was 3 deep with walkers then the cyclist needs to dismount and push the bike. When I cycle I always go on our local pavements as there are rarely any pedestrians. When I seen one I stop and get off The roads with potholes and drain holes are lethal to a cyclists.

Blossomtoes · 10/03/2023 09:39

LakieLady · 10/03/2023 09:34

Has it been confirmed that it's a shared use path now? In the early reports, no-one seemed to know for sure.

I'm very uncomfortable with sharing a footpath with cyclists, unless it's really wide and there's a pedestrian only section.

I don't know if there's a minimum width for shared use, but there should be imo.

Here you go. All taken on the shared path in Huntingdon on Saturday.

To feel unsafe when cyclists use pavements illegally?
To feel unsafe when cyclists use pavements illegally?
To feel unsafe when cyclists use pavements illegally?
To feel unsafe when cyclists use pavements illegally?
QueefQueen80s · 10/03/2023 09:39

They are everywhere now.. Leeds city centre is full of deliveroo riders on the highstreet and paths

LakieLady · 10/03/2023 09:34

AlannaOfTrebond · 10/03/2023 09:15

From the video footage I've seen the cyclist was barely moving at walking pace when Auriol Grey pushed her. It was also a shared use path so the cyclist had every right to be there.

Even if neither of those were true and there was a cyclist speeding on a pedestrian only path pushing them into moving traffic is still not the answer.

Has it been confirmed that it's a shared use path now? In the early reports, no-one seemed to know for sure.

I'm very uncomfortable with sharing a footpath with cyclists, unless it's really wide and there's a pedestrian only section.

I don't know if there's a minimum width for shared use, but there should be imo.

LakieLady · 10/03/2023 09:31

YANBU, OP.

My high street has a section, a few hundred yards long, where the pavement is very narrow. Part of that section coincides with a bottleneck where the traffic is controlled by 3-way lights and only one direction of traffic can proceed at a time. There's a bend towards one end of the one-way section, so visibility is poor at that point.

Twice now I've been walking along the narrow pavement and encountered a cyclist who's taken to the pavement to avoid waiting at the lights. The first time, the cyclist rounded the bend and almost slammed into me, stopped about about a foot away, and called me a cunt for having the audacity to be walking along the pavement. The second one had the decency to cycle down the kerb into the road instead of into me, and merely called me a stupid cow.

I think it's very unsafe, and both events shook me up a bit. I can quite understand why the lady who pushed that cyclist into the road lashed out in shock.

SinnerBoy · 10/03/2023 09:28

RotundBeagle · Today 00:48

It's a tough one because it doesn't look like there's enough room for them on the road. Cars are almost touching the kerb.

And? It's against the law to cycle on a footpath.

www.highwaycodeuk.co.uk/rules-for-cyclists.html

64
You MUST NOT cycle on a pavement.
Laws HA 1835 sect 72 & R(S)A 1984, sect 129

Blossomtoes · 10/03/2023 09:23

ReformedWaywardTeen · 10/03/2023 08:54

I think that's rubbish. The cyclist took a risk by cycling at speed along a pavement. She knew the road was busy yet she would have expected pedestrians to walk in it to avoid her.
By your reckoning, Auriol should have stepped off the pavement and been killed because cyclists are so much more important

You can think what you like. It’s a shared path and Grey’s actions caused a death. The facts are indisputable.

AlannaOfTrebond · 10/03/2023 09:15

ReformedWaywardTeen · 10/03/2023 08:54

I think that's rubbish. The cyclist took a risk by cycling at speed along a pavement. She knew the road was busy yet she would have expected pedestrians to walk in it to avoid her.
By your reckoning, Auriol should have stepped off the pavement and been killed because cyclists are so much more important

From the video footage I've seen the cyclist was barely moving at walking pace when Auriol Grey pushed her. It was also a shared use path so the cyclist had every right to be there.

Even if neither of those were true and there was a cyclist speeding on a pedestrian only path pushing them into moving traffic is still not the answer.

SoupDragon · 10/03/2023 08:58

I'm sick of entitled cyclists on the pavement near me. I had one insist that it was a "shared path" only last night. It isn't, it's a pavement with absolutely no signs to indicate it might be a shared path.

Pavements are for pedestrians.

Cyclists get pissed off with pedestrians in cycle lanes/cycle sections of a shared path but some think they should be able to cycle in a pedestrian only area.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 10/03/2023 08:54

Blossomtoes · 10/03/2023 07:54

What happened to Auriol Grey? She caused someone’s death, ffs.

I think that's rubbish. The cyclist took a risk by cycling at speed along a pavement. She knew the road was busy yet she would have expected pedestrians to walk in it to avoid her.
By your reckoning, Auriol should have stepped off the pavement and been killed because cyclists are so much more important

Frauhubert · 10/03/2023 08:51

@BridgeWalkingVideo as Hammersmith bridge is under repair and closed to any motor traffic, the cyclists can’t ride on the road, so have to use the footpath but they must absolutely dismount and it’s plastered everywhere, and wardens are ‘enforcing’ it. foot traffic on the bridge is one way. Still people ignore it…

MichelleScarn · 10/03/2023 08:47

RNLD1981 · 10/03/2023 07:52

Protect ourselves by killing them?! AG deserves her sentence

Absolutely! The frightening entitlement and self-righteousness of some posters and support of Auriol Grey and her role in Celia Ward's death is disturbing.

hettie · 10/03/2023 08:45

Well it sounds tricky to think how you alone could impact change. You could join one of the London cycling campaign groups? Most of them push for designated clear cycling lanes. Some cyclists and pedestrians and car drivers are just unthinking and selfish, but the cycle lane signage is often confusing and the routes often randomly peter out/merge. That's before you even get into desinated shared pavement use (which in my experience merely seems to give certain people a licence to yell at me or 'jump out' in front or chuck stuff at me 🤷‍♀️)
You could try traffic police or local council but I don't think you'll get any traction as most public services are understaffed and only dealing with critical stuff (which unless there has been a fatality they won't class this as). Like many things in the UK at the moment....

BridgeWalkingVideo · 10/03/2023 08:45

@Squamata it is interesting that some people find the situations shown in the video hazardous or reckless cycling and some don't. The cyclist in black, if you look closely, was inches away from being snagged by the van while at the pedestrian crossing. Extremely dangerous and would have impacted the pedestrian next to him as well (a few seconds later, the same cyclist is seen having crossed the pedestrian crossing while the traffic lights were still green - he was clearly in a real hurry that morning).

As regards filming being weird, it does help to have actual examples to discuss. As far as I am aware, it is still legal to film and take photographs in public places in this country. 🙄

@Frauhubert that is terrible that cyclists ignore wardens telling them to dismount! But it sounds like a good idea. Maybe I should ask Kensington and Fulham Council (I think that's the one for Hammersmith Bridge) why wardens were put in - maybe they were advised to do that following an accident?

@Augend23 thank you for the signage suggestions. Those signs are a lot clearer!

OP posts:
Frauhubert · 10/03/2023 08:35

Those who say op is getting worked up don’t have to cross a bridge like this twice a day. I sympathise as i cross Hammersmith bridge every day, sometimes 4times and i feel like it’s torture every time. That bridge is only open to pedestrians and cyclists have to dismount as it’s too narrow but about 50% are still ok their bikes trying to overtake pedestrians. There are wardens on both sides of the bridge telling cyclists to get off. They still don’t.

Augend23 · 10/03/2023 08:31

BridgeWalkingVideo · 10/03/2023 07:26

Thank you for the advice so far.

I am looking into where best to report/campaign about this. I am sure others feel the same way and am wondering where to look for that (local papers)? The bridge (Kew Bridge) is between two London boroughs (in the video I am walking from the Hounslow side to the Richmond side, from Brentford to Kew Green). I think as it is a Red Route, TfL also have some responsibility as well, but that the bridge itself is the responsibility of the Borough of Richmond-upon-Thames.

The junction before the bridge on the Hounslow (Brentford side) is the start of the (notorious locally and in Chiswick) cycling infrastructure for the C9 cycling superhighway, which is another story entirely. This may explain the lack of joined-up thinking and lack of clarity over the design for the bridge and how to join the two systems. Sorry, I feel a diagram is needed! (Well, a map at least.) I am less familiar with the cycling infrastructure and extent of shared pavements in Kew.

@RotundBeagle my understanding is that the bridge was widened from 3 lanes to 4 to reduce traffic congestion (though still an issue as seen in video), and this accounts both for the lack of road space for cyclists and one pavement being narrower than the other.

@Augend23 my understanding is that the pavement is shared for about 2-3 metres after the sign you screenshotted up to the pedestrian traffic lights (the ones that the too-fast cyclist screeched to a halt at coming the other way). There are two 'no cycling' signs from that point onwards, both of which I show in the video (one at head height by the traffic lights, mounted/turned at an angle) and one on the bridge itself (higher up but clearly visible after passing the bus stop). Did you see those signs when watching the video (I am not being sarky here, genuinely interested if people are failing to see, or not understanding those signs)?

The bizarre thing is that coming from the Hounslow (Brentford) side, there is no signage at all facing that way on this end of the bridge (there is on the other side, the eastern shared pavement). Shockingly bad design. Are you even allowed to put up signs facing one way only?

To those saying I shouldn't get worked up about this, it only takes a small mis-step, or people trying to move out around each other, especially someone not familiar with the area, for a really nasty accident, especially if near the kerb when the traffic is moving fast and not stationary, and especially since the pavement was narrowed in 2021. It is an accident waiting to happen.

There are some cyclists I have seen who stop at the traffic lights and cross to use the pavement on the other side. While this may be because they intended to cross anyway further up, I wish all cyclists were considerate enough to do this and didn't ignore the very visible 'no cycling' signs (can someone screenshot that?).

I do appreciate the cyclists that go slowly, but my heart is in my mouth when less experienced cyclists wobble past near the kerb, or the less considerate cyclists rush past too fast without thought for pedestrians that may move out unexpectedly. If there was an accident, I believe the cyclists would be more liable if cycling on a marked 'no cycling' pavement?

Apologies, I was lazy and skipped through the video until the bit with the cyclists being difficult at the end, and missed the signs. I got too bored watching an 8 minute long video of mainly just pavement and traffic. Serves me right for commenting without the full information.

I think I can safely say I wouldn't have known they were there if I was a cyclist going across the bridge in the direction you were walking. The cyclist seen earlier in your video going in the opposite direction should have at least clicked the second sign (the one closer to the middle of the bridge). I don't think it's reasonable to think anyone would have seen the one near the pedestrian crossing.

Honestly I try and avoid shared paths for this reason amongst many others. I find it nightmare to try and make sure I'm not cycling illegally in them because they vanish and reappear with impunity.

If I wanted to make that bridge clear I would put a written explanation "cyclists dismount or rejoin carriageway for example" or even one of the little bollard signs at the end (as they can't end up pointing in the wrong direction). If you were a non cycling road user on a two way road and there was a sign facing the opposite direction on the opposite side of the carriageway (which is what is the case here for the cycle signs) you wouldn't assume they were meant for you. I find signs like those attached the clearest.

If we actually cared about green transport they could switch this road so that 2/4 of the lanes were cycle/bus lanes and the other two were for traffic, thus avoiding the conflict with pedestrians and facilitating faster, safer travel for the cyclists and better service for the buses.

To feel unsafe when cyclists use pavements illegally?
Cantstaystuckforever · 10/03/2023 08:19

NumberTheory · 10/03/2023 07:17

You might just as well say we can mix traffic with pedestrians if motorists were more tolerant of people on foot.

Even when tolerant, motor vehicles are so much heavier than cyclists that the chance of serious injury or death in an accidental collision is significant. And cyclists and motorists don’t move at the same speed, so shared lanes don’t work well there either.

Shared car and cycle lanes slow down traffic, true. Except that car driving - unlike cycling or walking - is extremely environmentally damaging, it also takes up far more space. In the London area this is taken in, public transport provision is very good, and most journeys are short.

Better to encourage cycling (on the road), pedestrians on the pavement, and encourage the vast majority of cars to get off it. Some people need to drive for work, a very small percentage due to disabilities or unavoidably awful commutes, but not most.

Squamata · 10/03/2023 08:19

And that pavement is wide enough to be shared use imho

Squamata · 10/03/2023 08:19

I find it a bit weird that go around filming in pavements tbh.

Those cyclists were being careful, slowing down, making eye contact, giving way to oncomers. The one in black at the end was a bit faster. If they all stopped to dismount at the corner it would arguably be more hazardous as they'd create an obstacle and cyclists on the shared bit could knock into them.

The problem is that cycling infrastructure is so abysmal, it's given two seconds' thought by car-oriented planners and next to no funds. So the easiest thing to do is say 'cyclists dismount here' rather than create a bike path by taking space away from cars or building better facilities like a separate bike bridge here.

Cyclists are vulnerable and have to make constant assessments of both what the road layout tells them to do and what is actually safest, which are not always the same thing. Cyclists don't want to knock into you any more than you want them to, chances are the cyclist would be the one to go under a truck rather than you due to speed.

lookluv · 10/03/2023 08:17

There is plenty of space for the cyclists on the road - they queue like the cars do. The right to filter if possible does not mean get on the pavement and scare the most vulnerable.

Yes the new highway code puts pedestrians as more protected before cyclists!

Giveaschitt · 10/03/2023 08:11

I felt more worried by the people walking along looking at their phones and nearly colliding with people coming the other way than I did by the cyclists tbh!

Blossomtoes · 10/03/2023 07:54

What happened to Auriol Grey? She caused someone’s death, ffs.

RNLD1981 · 10/03/2023 07:52

ReformedWaywardTeen · 10/03/2023 07:47

Cyclists are a menace and after what happened to Auriol Grey we can't even protect ourselves from their reckless behaviour.

The police won't act as a minor crime and councils do nothing either.

Frankly I've said for years that cyclists need to be registered, licenced and have a numbered plate as motorbikes do as do mopeds. Cyclists know they can behave as they wish with no penalty.

Protect ourselves by killing them?! AG deserves her sentence

ReformedWaywardTeen · 10/03/2023 07:47

Cyclists are a menace and after what happened to Auriol Grey we can't even protect ourselves from their reckless behaviour.

The police won't act as a minor crime and councils do nothing either.

Frankly I've said for years that cyclists need to be registered, licenced and have a numbered plate as motorbikes do as do mopeds. Cyclists know they can behave as they wish with no penalty.

GasPanic · 10/03/2023 07:40

Cantseethewoodforthetree · 10/03/2023 06:01

i cannot play the clip so have not seen the example. I think the nation needs to decide if we want to encourage cycling or not. We cannot go at this in a half hearted manner. If doesn’t work. So scrap the shared pavements, convert one lane of traffic into a properly segregated cycle path and make the road one way. Yes this could cause total chaos for traffic. Yes that could mean a massive round trip for cars, but we are either serious about green transport or not. The sheer amount of illiterate people that read the thread about the poor cyclist who died and said ‘she shouldn’t have been on the pavement’ shows how poorly the terrible cycle infrastructure we have is understood. It’s not working currently. Look at Amsterdam. Look at Paris. It is possible to remove motor vehicles from town and city streets. You just have to have local authorities who want to properly commit to green policies.

The issue is we do want to encourage cycling.

The question is whether we want to do that at the expense of pedestrian safety.

In my mind cars should give way to motorcyclists and cyclists, who in turn should give way to pedestrians. But the second part of that hierarchy tends to be missed out in the encouragement of cycling and the green agenda.

Roads are shared use for cars and cyclists and many cyclists seem happy to slate car drivers when they behave irresponsibly but then behave irresponsibly themselves when in shared use with pedestrians. There is less comeback for cyclists because there is no license or consequence for most of the more minor bad behaviours like speeding or weaving dangerously.

The only real way around this is to make sure that cyclists are aware of their responsibility to behave with caution in shared areas with pedestrians and that they are made to feel the full consequences of their actions when they don't.