Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disastrous holiday let - AIBU?

165 replies

ivygem · 09/03/2023 18:23

Sorry this is long! Just don’t want to drip feed later on. Basically I’m trying to get some perspective please after a disastrous weekend away for a big birthday (mums not mine).

Myself, DH and DD stayed in a fairly large holiday let at the weekend with around 6 other family members including my sister and her new baby. It was a oldish farmhouse that had gone through some redesign etc. over the years in a semi remote farm location. The place was booked by my sister but paid in full by my mum at her request.

My DH and DD left on Sunday due to school and work commitments and I stayed on. Her room was next to ours and I stripped the bed and tidied it out after she left at around 6pm.

On our final night, on my mums actual birthday, I awoke to a loud noise next door (in my DD’s ex room) that sounded like someone was using the shower at around 2am. After some blearly eyed tossing and turning thinking I was delirious I finally investigated and discovered a huge flood in the room coming from the en suite and I immediately ran off to get help. As I went to wake others I discovered a similar noise downstairs - and unsurprisingly found water pouring from the kitchen ceiling. It was actually a shocking amount of damage in a short time with the floor of the large kitchen swimming in about an inch of water. I immediately tried phoning the number left in the ‘house manual’ left by the owners - it was out of date and not in use. My sister then had to search her phone for the number in the booking. Luckily someone answered and they informed us someone would be with us fairly quickly. While we were waiting the electricity tripped and needless to say we were all terrified. My sister packed up her room in case we had to leave (she had the new baby) and we all followed suit. After waiting a while for everything to be brought to some sort of order (the person that was sent spent some time drying out the kitchen with blankets and towels) we were told ‘it was fine’ and we could stay. At this point it was nearly 4am and we were exhausted so we agreed to get some rest and all went to sleep fully clothed, all half terrified that we would need to leave. We awoke early the next morning ans found the electrics downstairs still off and the central heating off. We also found several items that had been damaged including some baby items that upset my sister (think sentimental value not monetary). It was a pretty grim scene. We packed up fairly quickly, with my mum hanging about to speak to someone. No one came or called so she left eventually. We have since contacted the owners to discuss what happened and to talk about what compensation we should expect. We heard nothing so contacted the booking company directly and unsurprisingly my sister received an odd phone call from the owner later the next evening - where they outlined personal mental health issues(?) and suggested we could book in the future at another of their 12 properties for a reduced fee…

Here’s the issue. Myself and others, my mum included, feel given the nature of what happened my mum should pursue a full refund for our whole stay. Other family members feel that’s too much and perhaps she should go after a partial refund, move on ans organise something else at a later date.

A part of me wants to forget the whole ordeal but it was pretty traumatic and I feel like my mum deserves a proper birthday.

AIBU?

YABU - forget it - persuade mum to move on and take a partial refund/ what’s offered. It’s a small business/act of god, these things happen.
YANBU - this is mental - full refund.

Thanks for sticking with it!

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 09/03/2023 19:14

EmmaDilemma5 · 09/03/2023 19:06

YABVU to expect compensation; what a strange response to a very difficult and costly problem for someone else.

Have some compassion. You enjoyed the vast majority of your stay. Be thankful it wasn't a flood in your own home and move on.

What? This isn't a mate who's let her stay for nothing. This is a business transaction. She didn't recieve the service she paid for. She IS entitled to a refund at least for what she didn't get and maybe rounded up as goodwill. She didn't get a full night's sleep on the last night and they had no heating or proper lighting even when they left. They did however have a few days of fair use and presumably a nice birthday celebration.

Twillow · 09/03/2023 19:14

YABU as the incident occured on your final night - partial refund is perfectly acceptable.

NannyGythaOgg · 09/03/2023 19:12

I would expect a 50% reduction if it was a 3 night stay or 2 nights reduction if it was any longer.

Feelinglikeihadaboringnight · 09/03/2023 19:12

I would expect any personal items that are damaged should be covered in the owners insurance, but you need to check the contract.

You mentioned the electrics went out, did a qualified electrician visit before you were told it was ok to stay. I think not from what you’ve said. In which case you should not have been told to stay as that’s a dangerous situation.

I would mention this to the owners and request at the very least a refund for on3 day and one night. A refund for the day as you got no sleep.

BrutusMcDogface · 09/03/2023 19:11

I opened the thread imagining illness and accidents and stuff. I’m sorry you experienced this but yabu to want a full refund. I agree that you should be more compassionate towards the owner. I do hope they’ve updated the contact details, though.

Guis23 · 09/03/2023 19:11

cardibach · 09/03/2023 19:06

They didn’t ‘wake up in water’ though.
land in what way is a pipe burst/accidental leak the fault of the owner so that you would never want to have anyth8 g further to do with them?

Okay. Went down to find water coming through the ceiling and all over the kitchen floor.

I don't know the details or whether it was a burst pipe.
But I wouldn't stay at any of their properties no. It would just put me off.

juliettesmother · 09/03/2023 19:10

FortofPud · 09/03/2023 19:06

I can definitely see why a sudden flood in the middle of the night in a holiday let (that at this point you're worried is your fault) would be stressful, especially when it's pitch black because the electricity has gone out and you're having to figure what to do in a half asleep state. I wouldn't say you are making a fuss at all!

I would want a refund for that night onwards but not for before. To be honest I'd be relieved the owner wasn't trying to pin the blame on me, I think that would be the focus of my panic.

Sorry it was a crap holiday, but personally I'd focus on the 'thank goodness it wasn't worse' angle.

This

tothelefttotheleft · 09/03/2023 19:10

ivygem · 09/03/2023 18:49

See this is why I knew I shouldn’t have bothered putting this on here. Thanks everyone. I’ll delete this now and wobble my head as instructed.

People love a pile on.

I can imagine how scary it was.

Motorcycleemptyness · 09/03/2023 19:08

Also you might want to look up ‘disaster’ and ‘terrified’ in the dictionary, OP. You’re using them wrong and they make you look like a grabby bastard.

Mañanarama · 09/03/2023 19:07

You were woken at 2am, went back to bed at 4am, and the next morning found some stuff had got wet. And you want a full refund?

How many days/nights were you all there having a lovely time before this terrifying experience happened?

Motorcycleemptyness · 09/03/2023 19:06

Prime candidate for piss taking on the mumsnet madness page, this one.

cardibach · 09/03/2023 19:06

Guis23 · 09/03/2023 19:01

Some harsh comments on here. I wouldn't want to wake up in water and with no electrics on a weekend away.

Whatever caused what sounds like a pipe bursting we do not know.

I would not be tempted to stay at another of the owners properties after that experience.

Did your mum take out holiday insurance ?

They didn’t ‘wake up in water’ though.
land in what way is a pipe burst/accidental leak the fault of the owner so that you would never want to have anyth8 g further to do with them?

FortofPud · 09/03/2023 19:06

I can definitely see why a sudden flood in the middle of the night in a holiday let (that at this point you're worried is your fault) would be stressful, especially when it's pitch black because the electricity has gone out and you're having to figure what to do in a half asleep state. I wouldn't say you are making a fuss at all!

I would want a refund for that night onwards but not for before. To be honest I'd be relieved the owner wasn't trying to pin the blame on me, I think that would be the focus of my panic.

Sorry it was a crap holiday, but personally I'd focus on the 'thank goodness it wasn't worse' angle.

HolidayLetter · 09/03/2023 19:06

I would offer a partial refund, a massive apology for something that couldn't have been foreseen, and a 'goodwill gesture' of a reduced-price stay in future. However, it is remiss of the owner not to provide up to date contact info, and if it had been my property, I would have been there at 4AM rather going via an agent (I would regard that as part of my job). I'd also think that "terrified" was OTT and I'd be pissed off about having to be nice about it, though I'd be nice about it all the same.

EmmaDilemma5 · 09/03/2023 19:06

YABVU to expect compensation; what a strange response to a very difficult and costly problem for someone else.

Have some compassion. You enjoyed the vast majority of your stay. Be thankful it wasn't a flood in your own home and move on.

JudgeRudy · 09/03/2023 19:06

whatadayforadaydream · 09/03/2023 18:48

Also curious about all these high value baby items ruined by normal tap water….

Hi value to her. Could be a favorite book, a photo, a musical Teddy, a mobile....essentially anything that's not designed to get wet.

Nousernamesleftatall · 09/03/2023 19:05

Refund for a final night only if one of your party didn't cause it.

RandomUsernameHere · 09/03/2023 19:02

I think a refund for the final night would be fair, so a third of the cost if you were there for 3 nights.

Defaultsettings · 09/03/2023 19:01

This happened in my own home last year. I’m still living in the mess because my insurance company are still sorting things out.
I’ve made less fuss than the OP

Guis23 · 09/03/2023 19:01

Some harsh comments on here. I wouldn't want to wake up in water and with no electrics on a weekend away.

Whatever caused what sounds like a pipe bursting we do not know.

I would not be tempted to stay at another of the owners properties after that experience.

Did your mum take out holiday insurance ?

BlueHeelers · 09/03/2023 18:57

I think it’s pretty scary to be in an unknown property in the middle of the night which had a major flood! Especially as the electric downstairs had already tripped.

oh yes, because the zombie apocalypse followed by the attack of the vampires was going to happen.

Jimboscott0115 · 09/03/2023 18:56

Ok so I think getting a refund for the final night is fair, it was ruined after all. However, it's all a bit hysterical, you had a flood which is one of those things that in a lot of instances, noone can help as a pipe blew or something - it was hardly terrifying, overly stressful or traumatic as you're saying here, it was just a bit of a shit way to end your holiday.

So you're not unreasonable asking for a partial refund, you are unreasonable if you want a full one and you're definitely unreasonable for how traumatic and frightening you found a situation which wasn't that big a deal - albeit was a pain in the backside for everyone involved.

JuneBridie · 09/03/2023 18:56

I’m beginning to think someone in mnhq is posting these ridiculous threads, loads of nonsense about train seats and being “terrified” for absolutely nothing.

Kitchenette · 09/03/2023 18:56

Your reaction was a bit OTT.

I think 50% refund would be more than reasonable if it was one night of a long weekend. I wouldn't be happy with no refund and money off another stay.

BlueHeelers · 09/03/2023 18:55

Traumatic?!

That’s a bit OTT. These things happen, especially in old houses.

It sounds as though the owner wasn’t particularly helpful or on the ball about clearing up, but what would you have done if it had been your own home? Would you have expected the whole thing to be cleared up within 8 hours?

There are safety considerations in terms of water and electricity. And so on. You sound as though you’re hyping up the water leak so as to get a full refund. One third would be fair, given it was a weekend booking.