Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DP to stay off work tomorrow to look after his brother

167 replies

lenorchik · 09/03/2023 17:08

My DPs brother (20) is currently staying with us, he's been here since Monday as MIL is away and he can't be left alone as he has ASD and isn't independent.

I don't have a problem with him staying here, the only issue is someone has to be with him all the time.

DP has been doing most of his care and he's booked annual leave for this week and next, however he's now been asked to go in tomorrow to cover for someone else.

I have plans to take DS to my sisters tomorrow which would mean i’d also have to take BIL. I have cared for him before at MILs when DP went out to the shops, but that was only for about an hour.

I'm also not sure what ill do if he gets overwhelmed as earlier DS picked up an item which is BILs but he found it on the floor, and BIL snatched it from DS so DS started crying and BIL got overwhelmed and DP had to take him out

WIBU to ask DP to not go into work tomorrow?

OP posts:
BrutusMcDogface · 10/03/2023 10:39

What? Why can’t you take your son to your sister’s on a day when your partner is there? It’s one day out of two weeks that he has off work?

toomuchlaundry · 10/03/2023 10:38

What about work putting on him @Guis23? He's on annual leave. What if OP was working today, would she have to have the day off so she could look after BIL so her partner could go into work even though he is meant to be on annual leave.

AllOfThemWitches · 10/03/2023 10:38

Noonesperfect · 10/03/2023 10:31

Yes I agree, it's very sad how ableist Mumsnet can be Confused

Unsurprising though, it always goes like this.

AllOfThemWitches · 10/03/2023 10:37

Viviennemary · 10/03/2023 10:28

I don't think he should go in if he is on annual leave. That is quite cheeky of them to interrupt his annual leave.

Agree. Work is not the be all and end all.

maddening · 10/03/2023 10:36

Dh needs to tell work it is not possible to come in. It isn't an emergency, they need to solve for their own staffing issues.

ClaireEclair · 10/03/2023 10:36

Your partner’s work should be more organised. If someone is on Annual Leave they should not be asked to work at all.

Guis23 · 10/03/2023 10:34

MelchiorsMistress · 09/03/2023 17:16

Your DH is caring for his brother, someone he has no real responsibility towards and he’s just doing it to be a good human. I’d support him as much as you can tbh, so unless there’s something urgent you need to be at your sisters for tomorrow, just go a different day.

Exactly. What matters more ? Putting your DH in an awkward position at work - or your visit to see your sister. If I was your DH I would be very miffed with you.

TomeTome · 10/03/2023 10:33

OP was asking if she should say no to the request to mind her BIL. So she obviously could if she wanted to.

In some ways I think it’s good this has happened (and I do wonder if MIL is trying to see if they’re really up to it or she should make other plans). It sounds like @lenorchik thought she was up to it but isn’t really. So I think you probably need to have a long chat with dp, OP. Then he can decide what he wants his future to look like.

Noonesperfect · 10/03/2023 10:31

AllOfThemWitches · 10/03/2023 10:05

As if mumsnet's view of living with disabilities is so awful that you can't even say 'hey, it's not necessarily all bad!' without someone jumping on you. 😆

Yes I agree, it's very sad how ableist Mumsnet can be Confused

CornishGem1975 · 10/03/2023 10:30

Guis23 · 10/03/2023 10:21

Change your visit to your sister. Your DH has already done plenty.

Agree. I don't think he's being unreasonable at all.

Viviennemary · 10/03/2023 10:28

I don't think he should go in if he is on annual leave. That is quite cheeky of them to interrupt his annual leave.

billy1966 · 10/03/2023 10:27

Thelondonone · 10/03/2023 06:14

This will sound harsh but it’s also not yours or your dis’s fault your bill is not well. I would think very hard about agreeing for my husbands brother to live with us, possibly until we die. It’s not something I could do. Mil needs to access care she and bil are entitled to. It’s really kind of your husband but is it fair on you and your son? You may have to be cruel to be kind and maybe now is when you start. If I had a child that needed care I wouldn’t expect my other child to do it.

Absolutely this.

Having someone for a weekend in no way compares to full-time responsibility.

Your MIL sounds quite selfish in that she is insisting your partner and you sacrifice your future to be 24/7 care for your BIL.

The enormity of the ask and presumption for you to never so much as be able to go out for a few hours, without finding care, is really huge.

How do you think that will impact your child and his future.

Your MIL should be availing of respite to help prepare your BIL for the fact respite will very likely be a part of his life, as will a care facility.

You sound like a very kind woman but very naive to what you are being presumed to take on.

Every school run?
Every match?
Every party?

Not a single moment not managing his brother and his challenges?

I have an old school friend who's older sister had a very very slight learning disability.
She was never allowed to leave the house without her sister in tow.
It made life tough for her, friendships very tough.
Not a walk to the shop could she do without her sister who was 3 years older.

Her sister was both a bit bossy and demanding and the whole family revolved around her.

My school friend told me once that there was indeed a clear expectation that her sister would live with her forever, and her parents went on and on about it.

She told me it wasn't happening and she was leaving once she qualified.

She took a job two hours away the minute she qualified as an accountant, even though she had her pick of jobs in the city.

Her parents were stunned and angry.
But she was gone.
She met and married two hours away too.

Her sister and parents got on with it as they had to make another plan.

Unlike your BIL she actually was capable of living independently and she has her own apartment in a little community with a warden, close to her parents and lives her life very happily I believe.

My old school friend whom I haven't seen in years was put in an awful position and her childhood was absolutely blighted by never being allowed a moment to herself witout factoring in her sister.

Be very careful about what you casually agree to.

This situation today will be your future 24/7...constant compromise and negotiation.

You can support your partner without agreeing to this 24/7.

Wishing you well.

Lefteyetwitch · 10/03/2023 10:22

LongLostTeacher · 10/03/2023 08:25

Why is it down to you to ask DP not to go to work? Has DP tried looking after DS and BIL on his own? It sounds like a big ask. DP should have told work no straight off the bat without you needing to worry about how to manage both dependants.

I agree with others that what your MIL is proposing for the future is unfair. It will be so limiting for you and your DS. Again, it should be DP starting to sort this out now.

If he has made a commitment between him and his family then he will have to tell work no.

GrumpyPanda · 10/03/2023 10:22

MrsSkylerWhite · 10/03/2023 10:14

I’d help out and go to my sister another day.
Must be pretty important if they’ve asked him to come in during scheduled leave.

OP said "DPs work isn't urgent, they just want him to cover for someone off sick which they ask him to do quite a lot when he's on annual leave." Her DP is letting other people walk all over him, and she has to bear the burden. Not acceptable.

toomuchlaundry · 10/03/2023 10:21

@TomeTome they both work, how do they care for someone 24/7? DH is only able to care for BIL whilst MIL is away because he has taken annual leave, and even that hasn't worked out as planned. Are you expecting him to give up his job when MIL is no longer able to care for BIL?

What happens if BIL can't cope around their DC, do you expect OP and DC to move out so BIL can live with his brother?

I think it is incredibly selfish to expect a relative to take on 24/7 care of someone

Guis23 · 10/03/2023 10:21

Change your visit to your sister. Your DH has already done plenty.

Brefugee · 10/03/2023 10:16

Part of that is doing his best for his brother.

but he isn't. He is going to work (I guess, OP hasn't been back) when he really ought not to. So DP's job has priority over his brother and his partner (and her sister) and the people being inconvenienced by that (OP and sister) haven't been consulted.

As for siblings should look after each other? Meh. Some might want to. Some might be guilted into it. And that is shit. I have always been very clear with my DH and my own family that i am not up for caring responsibilities in the long term for anyone (except my DH if necessary) and that i am not a selfless caring person so there is no need to try to guilt trip me. So we all know where we are (and i don't expect anyone, not even DH if he doesn't feel up to it) to care for me.

I do, however, ask people before i dump on them. Especially when i know they have plans

MrsSkylerWhite · 10/03/2023 10:14

I’d help out and go to my sister another day.
Must be pretty important if they’ve asked him to come in during scheduled leave.

TomeTome · 10/03/2023 10:12

toomuchlaundry · 10/03/2023 08:45

@TomeTome the OP has said the MIL has refused to consider assisted living or respite care, so assume that is available. It is selfish to assume a sibling will take on the care of another sibling, especially when as in those case it is likely to be the partner of the sibling taking on most of the caring responsibilities. What happens if OP’s work can no longer be WFH. Will she gave to give up her job to care for BIL

No it actually says that the man’s full time carer and parent doesn’t think respite or assisted living is suitable for him. She probably has a better idea than OP or posters on MN. It’s a BIG assumption to think that suitable accommodation is available. A huge number of the most visible (and by that I mean school age high functioning children who have parents/teachers/paediatricians) are not receiving even basic education and healthcare. It doesn’t take a genius to imagine that if your needs are higher and you are less visible provision might be hard to find and suitable provision impossible.
I’m not sure why it’s selfish to expect siblings to care for each other. I personally would care for any of mine if they needed me. I’m not sure what the point of being alive is if you can’t look after the people you love. But it’s this brother who has said he will care for his brother. His dp can say she won’t help but I’d think less of her for it. Her dp sounds like just the sort of person you’d want to be with. Part of that is doing his best for his brother.

GrumpyPanda · 10/03/2023 10:10

TomeTome · 10/03/2023 08:39

Personally I’d rearrange a meet up with my sister for another day. It’s no different than if dh was looking after his young nephew and then got called into work.

All discussions about future living arrangements and MILs “selfishness” are completely inappropriate since none of us knows the young man or what is available to him locally.

You do realize "got called into work" isn't equivalent to God's voice out of the burning bush? OP has made it clear their request isn't about an emergence, just their convenience.

AllOfThemWitches · 10/03/2023 10:05

As if mumsnet's view of living with disabilities is so awful that you can't even say 'hey, it's not necessarily all bad!' without someone jumping on you. 😆

AllOfThemWitches · 10/03/2023 10:03

Brefugee · 10/03/2023 10:00

He's asked her, she doesn't have to say yes? I ask my partner to help me out sometimes, he's not obligated to do anything for me.

there is nothing in the OP to indicate he has asked her, only that he's been called into work. And OP wants to know if she should ask him not to. So it looks as though he has agreed to work, even though he is off to care for his brother, and now she's landed with caring for someone she's not confident she can care for properly. Nobody has asked her.

I agree that the most BU is MIL. But DP is not covering himself with glory here either (not even with his employer who apparently uses him as default cover whether he's available or not)

Well just to clarify, obviously I think DP should say no to work and would be a pushover otherwise.

Brefugee · 10/03/2023 10:00

He's asked her, she doesn't have to say yes? I ask my partner to help me out sometimes, he's not obligated to do anything for me.

there is nothing in the OP to indicate he has asked her, only that he's been called into work. And OP wants to know if she should ask him not to. So it looks as though he has agreed to work, even though he is off to care for his brother, and now she's landed with caring for someone she's not confident she can care for properly. Nobody has asked her.

I agree that the most BU is MIL. But DP is not covering himself with glory here either (not even with his employer who apparently uses him as default cover whether he's available or not)

AllOfThemWitches · 10/03/2023 09:57

MarieRoseMarie · 10/03/2023 09:54

OP is asking for help. You are dismissing her concerns, dismissing broader issues and trying to shut down anyone giving her any advice.

If you love your life as a carer so much then it shouldn’t bother you if the OP thinks hard about whether to sign up for a life of unpaid care work.

but like I said, misery loves company…

If you're so confident that you're right, feel free to quote me. You won't find anything that actually backs up what you're saying.

AllOfThemWitches · 10/03/2023 09:56

If you love your life as a carer so much then it shouldn’t bother you if the OP thinks hard about whether to sign up for a life of unpaid care work.

Again where did I say she shouldn't think hard? Youre actually outright lying and speculating about a complete stranger. I think if anyone has an issue here, it's you.