Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What % of your income from work do you spend because of work?

454 replies

verdantverdure · 09/03/2023 16:21

AIBU to ask you what percentage of your income from working you spend because you are working?

A younger family member has asked me to cast an eye over her sums and it looks to me like she can't afford to go back to work after maternity leave.

Once you add up nursery and the commute, she's already running at a loss even before she buys new work clothes to fit her post pregnancy figure and current norms at her workplace.

Not including convenience foods such as pre chopped veg or a bought in lasagne etc so she can get dinner on the table soon after she gets home, or takeaways for the nights she's too shattered to do that.

A cleaner do her weekends can be family time not housework time?

Treats to cheer her up because life is a bit of a grind?

Stuff like hair, make up and nails so she looks "groomed" at work?

What about you?

What percentage of your income from working do you spend because you are working?

OP posts:
BadNomad · 10/03/2023 15:43

It sounds like she needs a job closer to home then. Or are you going to say now the cost of her commute is only a tiny fraction of that total cost?

verdantverdure · 10/03/2023 15:41

@Ilikepinacoladass

Childcare and the commute will cost over £4k a month.

No need to tell us, but in your own mind, subtract £4000 from your take home pay this month and see how much you have left.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 10/03/2023 15:38

Or skip the occasional nail job and blow dry and have a takeaway instead. Same re: cleaner. Prioritise.

Childcare and the commute use up her entire take home pay @BadNomad

She won't be able to afford any of that.

OP posts:
Ilikepinacoladass · 10/03/2023 15:38

verdantverdure · 10/03/2023 15:20

So to summarise,

Her choices are:

1.	Take a couple of years off and materially damage her career and pension. 

2.	Be a financial drain on the family finances for a couple of years because childcare and commuting costs eat up more than her take home pay, plus they won’t even be able to afford takeaways or a cleaner to make things easier. 

Does that sound about right?

I still don't see how she'll be actively making a loss, if she is earning above minimum wage.

Ah yeh.. I haven't had a takeaway or nails done in about 3 years as can't afford it. These things aren't a right or even necessary

verdantverdure · 10/03/2023 15:37

It is @ShadowPuppets.

OP posts:
ShadowPuppets · 10/03/2023 15:32

43%, which is literally just my commuting costs and my proportional percentage of the childcare (we pool all income but earn 60/40 so I've calculated it proportionally).

Of course there's other incidental costs like clothes, lunches etc but I haven't included them because they're (arguably) a choice. This is literally just the costs of getting me there and having someone look after our children while I'm there.

Mortgage + commuting + childcare is 72% of our income before you factor in any other bills, food, clothes for 2 children. That's on a (just) 6 figure household income. It's completely fucking insane.

BadNomad · 10/03/2023 15:31

verdantverdure · 10/03/2023 15:20

So to summarise,

Her choices are:

1.	Take a couple of years off and materially damage her career and pension. 

2.	Be a financial drain on the family finances for a couple of years because childcare and commuting costs eat up more than her take home pay, plus they won’t even be able to afford takeaways or a cleaner to make things easier. 

Does that sound about right?

Or skip the occasional nail job and blow dry and have a takeaway instead. Same re: cleaner. Prioritise.

verdantverdure · 10/03/2023 15:23

Artemisty · 10/03/2023 15:19

No sorry that's not the maths
I'm saying that if you have the type of job which means you have the expendable income for a weekly blow dry then you must be paid quite well.

Not quite well enough to cover £4k per month on commute and childcare.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 10/03/2023 15:20

So to summarise,

Her choices are:

1.	Take a couple of years off and materially damage her career and pension. 

2.	Be a financial drain on the family finances for a couple of years because childcare and commuting costs eat up more than her take home pay, plus they won’t even be able to afford takeaways or a cleaner to make things easier. 

Does that sound about right?

OP posts:
Artemisty · 10/03/2023 15:19

No sorry that's not the maths
I'm saying that if you have the type of job which means you have the expendable income for a weekly blow dry then you must be paid quite well.

verdantverdure · 10/03/2023 14:34

Artemisty · 10/03/2023 13:02

This thread is wild.
Chopping veg takes minutes and there are plenty of quick and very easy meals you can make instead of a takeaway.

I'm also wondering what industry still has women going for weekly blow dries and nail appointments that apparently don't pay well enough to mean that childcare and commuting fees = a loss.

If without a child you've got the spare cash to throw on a weekly blow dry, you're well paid enough to get childcare.

I'm not sure I'm following your maths.

If someone can afford a weekly blow dry they can afford weekly childcare?

How much is a blow dry? £30?

How much is childcare for a week? A bit more than £30?

OP posts:
Artemisty · 10/03/2023 13:02

This thread is wild.
Chopping veg takes minutes and there are plenty of quick and very easy meals you can make instead of a takeaway.

I'm also wondering what industry still has women going for weekly blow dries and nail appointments that apparently don't pay well enough to mean that childcare and commuting fees = a loss.

If without a child you've got the spare cash to throw on a weekly blow dry, you're well paid enough to get childcare.

BrieAndChilli · 10/03/2023 12:22

Once you add up nursery and the commute, she's already running at a loss even before she buys new work clothes to fit her post pregnancy figure and current norms at her workplace. the commute is something that most people consider before taking a job. For some a long expensive commute is worth it for the salary or the experience. Others actively choose a job closer to home. Most workplaces are now smart casual so lots of people wear clothes they wear out of work anyway.
Not including convenience foods such as pre chopped veg or a bought in lasagne etc so she can get dinner on the table soon after she gets home, or takeaways for the nights she's too shattered to do that. This is a luxury if you can afford it - the rest of us batch cook and freeze, use th eslow cooker or have 'quick' nights like something on toast etc. cant be bothered nights are for something out the freezer. I wouldnt add this into the cost of working as there are cheaper options.
A cleaner do her weekends can be family time not housework time? again this is a luxury, i would say far more people just do cleaning in the evenings/weekends than have a cleaner and there are plenty of people who dont work who still have a cleaner!
Treats to cheer her up because life is a bit of a grind? again a luxury and you dont have to be working to buy treats!
Stuff like hair, make up and nails so she looks "groomed" at work? again hair/make-up is something most people do regardless of whether working or not! i have never had my nails done so to me thats a luxury choice not a necessity.
Lunches plenty of people take a sandwich or tin of soup from home so no extra cost cos you would still eat if at home!

Really the only costs from the above that are not a luxury or a choice are childcare and commute. Commute is a choice although not as easy if you have no choice to move etc so really childcare is the only totally unaviodable cost.

I chose a workplace that was 5 minute drive away to enable me to do school drop off etc. I often wear jeans and a jumper to work which are all things I wear out of work, even the dresses I wear I would wear on weekends on the right occasion. I take lunch in with me most of the time and I am lucky that work often buy us lunch and treats. I have my hair done once or twice a year and would do that regardless, no nails and just basic makeup i would wear anyway. My kids are teens so no childcare but when they were babies my and DH worked opposite shifts to negate that cost. No cleaner so just clean as I go and DH also does his share. Cooking is either me or DH or teen DD who loves to cook so getting a child into cooking at an early age pays off later!! Treats are bought regardless!
So actually work doesnt really cost me anything that I wouldnt still spend if I didnt work and actually probably saves me money as I have no tiem to go to the shops and spend on random stuff!!

VariationsonaTheme · 10/03/2023 11:14

If the figures don’t make sense for her to go back then that’s the decision they make, like millions of other families who’ve done the same whilst the children are pre-school. However, she’s the one taking on all the risks by doing so - no job if her DH up and leaves/dies/made redundant, no pension, loss of experience/promotions in her work role etc. Even if as as a family they’re no better off financially it may be worth having both jobs just so those risks are spread across both adults.

Ilikepinacoladass · 10/03/2023 10:52

verdantverdure · 09/03/2023 17:39

Didn't I already say in the OP that childcare and the commute would already have her working at a loss.

I don't really see how this is possible. She needs to look into the 20% tax free childcare scheme, potentially a childminder instead of nursery, and if commuting costs are insane maybe a job nearer home or one where she can WFH part of the time.

DivorcingEU · 10/03/2023 10:29

If she stays home now she saves on short term costs. Considerable costs, for sure, but they're short term. Children go to school eventually. It will mean that as a family despite her working, they'll have a reduced income.

BUT

If she doesn't go to work, and you say she likes her career, then how likely is it that she'll renter the workplace in 5 years on the same income she gets now? That's assuming she'd have no career progression/salary increase in 5 years.

What's the difference between the income she'd be on in 10 years if she stays home until nursery costs aren't a factor and if she goes to work, takes the short term financial hit but continues building her career, future earning potential, pension and no doubt, actual salary increases in that time?

As for her DH working away, if she stays home, she'll ACTIVELY be facilitating his career progression. He's 50% responsible for his children. What's his plan for his children when he works away? Right now he cannot do his job if he doesn't have wifey at home looking after the children. If she stays home for the benefit of the short term costs on the family and to the benefit of the long term advancements if his career, what's his plan to make sure she doesn't have a hole in her pension contributions? What's his plan for when she does want to return to work and needs to devote extra time and energy rebuilding her career??

This is about a lot more then blow dries and nail bars.

bluechameleon · 10/03/2023 10:07

My travel is pretty pricey - about a 6th of my take home pay. Half of childcare costs is about a 10th. I don't buy many clothes. I then spend maybe a 20th of my pay on resources for work (teacher). I take a packed lunch and hot drinks are free.

garlictwist · 10/03/2023 08:11

I walk to work and take my own lunch so no expenses there. I've probably bought the odd outfit I wouldn't have bought otherwise, but my work is very casual so most people just wear jeans and trainers.

PhoenixAuntie · 10/03/2023 08:09

I’m past that stage as are my friends but working kept us with a hand in the workplace and our pensions going. One friend was very much in the minus figures as she had three children. We are all in our fifties now and there have been three divorces in my group of long term friends. One of them was a SAHP and she is now financially totally f*ed as she took about 13 years out of the workplace.

ChildcareIsBroken · 10/03/2023 08:00

Right now we'd be better off if I didn't work, but it's good to thing about the long term gain. Luckily we can afford for me to continue working - ridiculous, I know. The nursery fees and other expenses are more than my take home salary, although pension contributions make that figure look better.
I also wouldn't want to be SAHM. Kudos to all the full time parents out there, it's hard work.

ThinWomansBrain · 10/03/2023 07:59

about 3.5% - most of that because I chose to rent an office & do hybrid working a couple of days a week.
I'd still eat lunch if i wasn't working, and as a PP has said, still have hair cuts, get my nails done, so don't consider anything other than travel and cost of my office and travel a 'cost of working'.
I suppose professional membership and CPD - another 1% maybe.

Ilikepinacoladass · 10/03/2023 07:55

Do SAHPs not eat lunch? Lol.

I think the bigger question is does she actually want to go back to work? It's not just financial benefits. I enjoy going to work and having the break from DS. But everyone is different?

It's clearly in the long term and most probably short going going to be beneficial financially to go back. Seems like it would be used as quite a lame excuse for not going back.

fishonabicycle · 10/03/2023 07:52

Just fuel (job is 7 miles away) and clothes as and when. Other stuff like make up I would buy anyway. Food is just whatever I would cook if I was at home - unless you both work really long hours you don't need convenience food.

Whataretheodds · 10/03/2023 07:49

verdantverdure · 09/03/2023 16:49

But neither of them incur nursery costs if she doesn't go back to work.

It only comes off the bottom line of their family finances then.

If it's coming off the bottom line of their family accounting, then put both their incomes (including pension contributions, and NI) on the top and expenses that are incurred on the bottom.

By all means look at the net position.

Bluesheep8 · 10/03/2023 07:46

I don't understand why things like haircuts and lunch are factored in as being necessary because of working. Wouldn't those things happen anyway?

Swipe left for the next trending thread