Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask school to not let DD choose friends for this?

162 replies

FallFallPleaseDont · 09/03/2023 13:43

DD is 8, Y4.

She has a medical condition which means when it’s cold, or damp or she has a mild cold she has to stay inside in the warm or she can’t walk due to the pain or if she falls she could seriously damage her legs.

This is all documented in an EHCP and in the schools own Individual Education Plan (which runs alongside the EHCP and basically tells the school day to day whose doing what and when).

Obviously, the last few months due to it being winter it’s been extremely cold, or very wet. Some days she goes to lunchtime clubs but these don’t run everyday so on days when she can’t go on the playground without a club she’s allowed to choose up to 2 other children from the class to stay inside with her – the teacher encourages her to choose different children each time but theres only around 5 children in the class she considers a friend, so those 5 children are rotated between in either different pairings or 1 at a time – although often those children volunteer themselves to stay inside (which I don’t blame them for when it’s freezing outside!).

Others in the class have caught onto this, and when it’s been very cold have been asking DD to choose them. I am fine with this as is the teacher who has encouraged DD to branch out with friends but she always wants one of these 5 whether she chooses someone else from the class or not – these are not necessarily the 5 children she sits with at school but ones a relative of hers (from her dad’s side) and the rest are various friends who she does out of school activities and goes the parties of.

Some of the parents whose DC don’t get regularly chosen by DD have also caught onto it, and have tried to become friends with me/DD and when that’s not worked, they’re now saying that DD “is the teachers favourite” and that everyone should be given the same chance to be inside and they will say it loudly as they walk passed us or ask their child loudly “So who did the teachers favourite choose to stay in with her today?” It’s getting awkward for DD and she’s now trying to go outside even when school or I deem it unsafe (I am allowed to email school and say I don’t think the conditions are appropriate for playground time today and they keep her inside).

Obviously if she can be on the playground DD is on it and as we go into spring and summer she’ll be on it more often than she is inside, but she did spend most of Autumn term 2 and all of Spring Term 1 inside, this is a safeguard for both DD and the school because apparently if she has a serious fall or injury when they knew about her condition it’s a legal minefield. So I now want to ask school to stop letting DD chose a friend and instead let those friends volunteer, or ask them to do a rota with the whole class so DDs not allowed but everyone gets a fair chance to be inside.

WIBU to ask this? Or are these other solutions?

This has come up again today as school have called me to say she wants to go out in the snow but they don’t believe she did so kept her inside.

OP posts:
Alicetheowl · 09/03/2023 15:13

reelsetogo90 that's a fair point for your area, but I don't think most of the UK has those sort of conditions-we were made to go outside and this was Cornwall! Also I I suspect most of those studies you refer to include going for nice walks or enjoying the countryside, not standing 5 metres from your classroom.

FatGirlSwim · 09/03/2023 15:13

I think your dd should be allowed to choose but if the choosing is causing issues (other children pressuring her), then the teacher should choose. she should be able to spend her break with her friends as everyone else can.

unfortunately though, your dd doesn’t want to share that she has a medical condition and a consequence of that is that other children think it isn’t fair. Similar to a diabetic child being allowed sweets in school etc, it appears unfair if they don’t know the reason. Parents should know better and it doesn’t take a genius to work out that there’s a medical reason.

could you agree something that your dd is happy with - ‘there’s a reason for it but it’s private’ etc although she will probably get asked questions and will need to figure out how to answer. I have an autistic child who doesn’t have to participate in certain things and she hates these questions.

If she’s old enough to decide that she doesn’t want others to know then she’s probably old enough to be involved in working out how to navigate it. You could also ask the teacher’s advice as they may have dealt with similar before.

saraclara · 09/03/2023 15:08

If the parents and the rest of DD's classmates don't know that she has a disability, then of course they're going to question why she gets to stay in on cold wet days when other kids don't. No wonder they think it's favouritism.

I'd suggest a chat with your DD to explain this to her, and point out the downside of her wanting to keep it to herself. She shouldn't have to tell others but in this scenario she can't really have it both ways.

FallFallPleaseDont · 09/03/2023 15:06

FixTheBone · 09/03/2023 14:48

Use the flip-side of the argument....

If your DD chooses someone - how would they feel if they had to stay inside with her even if they wanted to go out? That should be where the differentiating line lies.

I agree that nobody else should need to know why this arrangement exists, other than it does. And they're CFs for even asking.

@FixTheBone And to add to this, some lunchtimes DD is sent to inside clubs, like Lego, or Craft or board games etc to ease the burden on TAs/Friends. These only run on 3 lunchtimes a week and DD can pick if she goes or not and gets to pick which club as well as some lunchtimes theres 2 or 3 to choose (theres 1 she likes more than the others though).

OP posts:
Guis23 · 09/03/2023 15:03

Totally she should have her friends.

FallFallPleaseDont · 09/03/2023 15:02

Alicetheowl · 09/03/2023 14:51

I've never understood this obsession with children being outside in Winter. Yes, there are some who want to run about/play football/let off steam but most just seem to stand about chatting. Standing up on a boring piece of tarmac. In 5 degrees. Workers don't do this on their breaks. Families who are having a chat don't insist they all go into the garden or stand in the street in the cold. By all means let the children who want to run around go out but let the others socialise normally ,inside. Like normal people. I used to love a wet playtime!!

@Alicetheowl The problem is staffing, there's 3 classes per year here, teacher has to have her break, and there's only so many TAs especially after infants/KS1. Here there's only 2 fulltime TAs and 2 parttime TAs who work with KS2/juniors. 2 TAs can't supervise potentially 90 children in 3 classrooms inside, so the majority have to go outside.

The TA/Supervisor is funded by DDs EHCP which is why she's the exception to the rule.

OP posts:
FallFallPleaseDont · 09/03/2023 14:59

FixTheBone · 09/03/2023 14:48

Use the flip-side of the argument....

If your DD chooses someone - how would they feel if they had to stay inside with her even if they wanted to go out? That should be where the differentiating line lies.

I agree that nobody else should need to know why this arrangement exists, other than it does. And they're CFs for even asking.

@FixTheBone No child is forced to stay inside, if they are asked and they say they want to go out DD picks someone else.

OP posts:
Nowhereelsetogo90 · 09/03/2023 14:57

@Alicetheowl I think it depends where you live. I’m in Northern Scotland and for nearly half the year the kids come to school in the dark and leave school in the just-about dark. Fresh air and light even just for fifteen minutes a day is surely better than going from darkness to inside and back again. There’s loads of studies that show the positive impact of being outdoors on children and on mental health.

Alicetheowl · 09/03/2023 14:51

I've never understood this obsession with children being outside in Winter. Yes, there are some who want to run about/play football/let off steam but most just seem to stand about chatting. Standing up on a boring piece of tarmac. In 5 degrees. Workers don't do this on their breaks. Families who are having a chat don't insist they all go into the garden or stand in the street in the cold. By all means let the children who want to run around go out but let the others socialise normally ,inside. Like normal people. I used to love a wet playtime!!

lailamaria · 09/03/2023 14:50

listen i was the kid who had to stay inside, i don't understand why the medical condition is so secretive, just let the other kids know that her body's not healthy and the cold makes it worse

Thisismeyeah · 09/03/2023 14:48

Choconut · 09/03/2023 14:43

I think the teachers needs to explain to the parents that there is a 'specific reason' why dd needs to stay in and that she chooses friends to stay with and it is not down to not liking the weather, favouritism or anything like that.

That way she doesn't need to say it's medical if your daughter doesn't want that, but the parents know there is a genuine reason.

This!

FixTheBone · 09/03/2023 14:48

Use the flip-side of the argument....

If your DD chooses someone - how would they feel if they had to stay inside with her even if they wanted to go out? That should be where the differentiating line lies.

I agree that nobody else should need to know why this arrangement exists, other than it does. And they're CFs for even asking.

Thisismeyeah · 09/03/2023 14:46

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 09/03/2023 14:40

You could get the teacher to discuss equity v equality - equality is you all get the same, equity is everyone gets what they need. I use the wearing of glasses with my 11 year old pupils - if I take X’s glasses off them it keeps you all the same but is it fair? Might provoke some thought without discussing your DD directly.

But the other kids are clueless they dont know there is a reason for them to stay inside and OP has madebit clear to the school she doesn't want anyone to know.

LookItsMeAgain · 09/03/2023 14:46

Could you agree with your DD that between her, the teachers and you, you're gong to work on the wording of a note that will go out to all the pupils/parents in her class but keep it generic. The note would be asking parents to either agree or decline from allowing their daughter be added to the list of students who might be called upon to sit in.

In the same way I might receive a note saying that there is a pupil in my son's class that might have an allergy, and to not bring X, Y or Z into the school, that unless I actually brought X, Y or Z into the school I'll never know who the note is about. (I'm not conflating an allergy with your daughter's condition, just probably clumsily trying to explain my train of thought here)

This would require some work but something like this:
"The school has been made aware of a pupil in our student body who for medical reasons cannot do A or B. As such, we are asking for your permission to allow your child's name be added to a list of 'helper' students who may be called upon to sit with the pupil on occasion. We will only add your child's name to the list if we hear back from you. The date for replies to be received would be X day of Y month."

Something along the lines of the above would allow a list to be created and then perhaps two days a week, one of the names might be asked along with one of your DD's friends. Also, it would randomise who gets to sit with your DD when needed.

It's not divulging what the medical condition is. Would getting something like that out to the students/parent body be something that your DD would be comfortable with?

Comefromaway · 09/03/2023 14:44

You'd have to be pretty stupid to not realise that the reason your dd is allowed to stay inside is due to a medical condition of some sort.

She absolutely SHOULD be able to choose which friend accompanies her.

deveronvalley · 09/03/2023 14:43

Your post was sounding all perfectly normal until the bit about the parents??!! They sound awful!! My son was 'chosen' occasionally by a child who needed to stay in for whatever reason and it was fine to be chosen or not chosen. I'm amazed these parents care that much about the weather?! Bizarre! Maybe they should get their kids some decent winter clothes and stop nosing into other people's business! I've never heard of people being weird about this situation before. Definitely don't cave into this unpleasant behaviour!

Choconut · 09/03/2023 14:43

I think the teachers needs to explain to the parents that there is a 'specific reason' why dd needs to stay in and that she chooses friends to stay with and it is not down to not liking the weather, favouritism or anything like that.

That way she doesn't need to say it's medical if your daughter doesn't want that, but the parents know there is a genuine reason.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 09/03/2023 14:40

You could get the teacher to discuss equity v equality - equality is you all get the same, equity is everyone gets what they need. I use the wearing of glasses with my 11 year old pupils - if I take X’s glasses off them it keeps you all the same but is it fair? Might provoke some thought without discussing your DD directly.

Thisismeyeah · 09/03/2023 14:39

I do think you would be best to make the class aware there is a medical condition which requires xyz to stay inside. They dont have to say what or explain. If you dont people will jump to conclusions and cast judgements. Its not really discrimination due to a medical condition though as they dont know about it.

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 09/03/2023 14:39

I’d reply in very short words to those parents if it’s being done in front of you! How immature and pathetic!

FallFallPleaseDont · 09/03/2023 14:33

Thisismeyeah · 09/03/2023 14:27

I may have missunderstood but I thought that only the 5 close friends are aware of any disability and it is not those 5 that are being malicious? Its is other children in the class who are not aware of any medical conditions?

@Thisismeyeah Only the 5 children in her friendship group are aware that theres a medical reason for her staying inside, only 1 of those children (a relative) is aware of the full reason. Those parents are fine with me and DD and all agreed to let their child be chosen by DD.

The ones being malicious are the parents of the children who aren't DDs friends who think their child should be chosen to stay in with DD because it's not fair that DD stays inside when it's cold/wet. Those parents and children do not know why DD stays inside so to them it looks like DD is favoured by the teacher.

OP posts:
2bazookas · 09/03/2023 14:32

Some of the parents whose DC don’t get regularly chosen by DD have also caught onto it, and have tried to become friends with me/DD and when that’s not worked, they’re now saying that DD “is the teachers favourite” and that everyone should be given the same chance to be inside and they will say it loudly as they walk passed us or ask their child loudly “So who did the teachers favourite choose to stay in with her today?”

  In your shoes, I'd expand  those parents  medical and social education PDQ.
Thisismeyeah · 09/03/2023 14:31

FallFallPleaseDont · 09/03/2023 14:17

@Thisismeyeah She has been encouraged by both me and the teacher to choose other children other than her friends, but sometimes she doesn't want to or she chooses another child alongside one of her friends.

The friends parents are all aware and could have opted their child out of the rota as well. Most children are only out one or two breaks/lunches a week (there's 2 playtimes and a lunchtime play per day so 10 playtimes and 5 lunchtimes).

This is confusing. So are people making comments who are aware of any illness/medical condition? If so thats bad. If they dont know however they probably get their kids moaning that xyz stayed in today they never get picked.

lailamaria · 09/03/2023 14:29

of course she should be allowed to choose why should she be forced to hang out with kids she doesn't necessarily like in the name of 'fairness'

Thisismeyeah · 09/03/2023 14:27

Mariposa26 · 09/03/2023 14:22

This is absolutely horrible behaviour by the parents! You should tell the school they are enabling disability discrimination by allowing parents to make such comments. Your poor DD having to deal with nastiness like that from grown adults.
As an aside I think she should be allowed to pick her own friend, she’s already missing out on going outside to play. The behaviour from parents is what should be dealt with.

I may have missunderstood but I thought that only the 5 close friends are aware of any disability and it is not those 5 that are being malicious? Its is other children in the class who are not aware of any medical conditions?

Swipe left for the next trending thread